The Surprising Truth About N95 Respirators VS Surgical Mask

Our Lifestyle Travel
30 followers
1 Video View·Oct 27, 2022
So there's definitely a lot of opinions out there
about how effective an N95 respirator is
versus a surgical mask at preventing the wearer
from getting infected with a contagious virus.
So today we're gonna take a look at a four year long study
that followed 2,862 medical workers
working at 137 different medical centers
during peak flu season.
And they gave half the staff N95 respirators
and the other half surgical masks to wear at work
to determine if either of them was even effective
at preventing these workers from contracting the flu.
And if so, which one was most effective?
And I think you're gonna be just as surprised
by the results as I was.
But first let's take a look at what the differences are
between an N95 respirator and a surgical mask.
So according to the CDC,
a respirator is a personal protective device
that is worn on the face or head
and covers at least the nose and mouth.
A respirator is used to reduce the wearer's risk
of inhaling hazardous airborne particles.
An N95 FFR is a type of respirator
which removes particles from the air
that are breathed through it.
These respirators filter out at least 95%
of very small 0.3 micron particles.
And on the same page they say surgical masks
are loose fitting and provide only barrier protection
against droplets including large respiratory particles.
Most face masks do not effectively filter
small particles from the air
and do not prevent leakage around the edge of the mask
when the user inhales.
So an N95 respirator is designed
to create a tight seal for the user
so that most of the air does get filtered
through the respirator and it can filter out
up to 0.3 microns which is small enough
to capture most viruses.
Now surgical masks were actually designed
to prevent the wearer from contaminating
the surrounding area when they cough, sneeze,
breathe or even talk.
They do not filter out small particles
like the N95 respirator does
and they do not create an airtight seal.
This is what's known as leakage
where air can come in from the top
and around the sides of the mask
and just bypass the mask altogether.
So if we go back to that four year long study
you would expect to find that the N95 respirator
is significantly more effective
at preventing the wearer from contracting the flu
but that's not actually what they found.
So this study was published in July of 2019
and it's titled N95 Respirators versus Medical Masks
for Preventing Influenza Among Healthcare Personnel
A Randomized Clinical Trial.
And what they found was out of the 2,862 participants
207 medical workers who wore the N95 respirators to work
and 193 medical workers who instead wore the medical mask
did contract influenza.
So that's 8.2% in the N95 group contracted it
and 7.2% in the medical mask group contracted it.
So that is only a difference of 1% between the two masks.
And this led the authors of the paper to conclude
no significant difference between the effectiveness
of N95 respirators and medical masks
in preventing the laboratory confirmed influenza
amongst participants routinely exposed
to respiratory illness in the workplace.
So pretty surprising results.
And personally two big things stood out to me
when reading through this study.
So first I'm pretty surprised by how high those numbers are
people actually got infected with the flu.
It's 8.2% and 7.2%
and these are trained medical professionals.
But my assumption is that these high numbers
are probably a result of just them being exposed
to this virus on almost a daily basis.
And my guess is that this is probably more of a result
of them not following other best practices
during their shifts.
Such as washing their hands for 20 seconds,
removing their mask properly and not touching their face
and probably less of a result of them
actually inhaling the virus and getting infected that way.
Many viruses can actually live on the surface
of different materials anywhere from a few hours
up to several days depending on the virus
and depending on the surface material.
So according to one study that I found
both influenza A and influenza B viruses
survived 24 to 48 hours on hard non-porous surfaces
such as stainless steel and plastic
but survived for less than eight to 12 hours
on cloth, paper and tissues.
Measurable quantities of influenza A virus
were transferred from stainless steel surfaces
to hands for 24 hours and from tissues to hands
for up to 15 minutes.
Viruses survived on hands for up to five minutes
after transfer from environmental surfaces.
And I also found a different observational study
from the University of South Wales
that found that people unconsciously touched their faces
an average of 23 times per hour.
So with that 8.2% and 7.2% healthcare workers
that did get infected, my assumption would be
that most likely this is how they got infected
and they probably weren't even wearing a mask at the time.
It's very possible that they touched surfaces
that had the virus on it, got it on their hands,
that virus could then live for up to five minutes
on their hands and then they touched their faces
unconsciously and they may have contracted
the viruses that way.
My second big takeaway from this is that it appears
that just having anything covering your mouth and your nose
and that's filtering out those larger particles
and providing that barrier protection against droplets
is almost just as effective as a respirator
that are specifically designed to filter out particles
the size of viruses.
And the so-called leakage that you get
from air seeping in around your surgical mask
may not be as big of a deal
as many people make it out to be.
So my assumption after reading this is that
if you wear just about any kind of cover on your face,
it can have a pretty big impact.
And in fact, on the CDC's website,
they say that if hospitals run out of N95 respirators
and surgical masks, they can use improvised masks.
In setting where face masks are not available,
healthcare professionals might use homemade masks,
example, bandana or scarf for cases of patients
as a last resort.
So even with a bandana, you're probably still getting
that barrier protection against droplets,
including large respiratory particles
that the CDC says that you also get wearing a surgical mask.
And even with a bandana, you're still benefiting
from not being able to touch your face nearly as much,
probably a heck of a lot less than the 23 times per hour
that the one study found.
So what does this all mean for you?
Should you go out right now and buy an N95 respirator
or a surgical mask?
Well, in my non-professional opinion, I'd say no.
After reading the study, it seems like having
that 0.3 micron filter capability is not all that impactful
on whether or not you get infected or not.
It appears that the surgical masks are just as effective.
And according to the CDC, the biggest benefit to these
for the wearer is just that barrier protection
against droplets.
And it seems like you could probably achieve
that barrier protection with some other materials
such as scarves, bandanas, maybe even a T-shirt.
And on another note, we are experiencing an extreme shortage
of respirators and surgical masks right now.
And our country's inventory should really be going
to our medical professionals right now
who are being exposed to this on a daily basis,
rather than a consumer who may possibly be exposed
to it for 15 minutes when they run into a grocery store.
I'll have links to all the studies
that I referenced in this video down below.
And if you wanna see my video breaking down
the recently leaked government report
that says that we may be in this situation
for 18 months or longer, click right here to check that out.
Don't forget to subscribe and hit that bell icon
to get notified every time I upload a new video.
Stay safe and I'll see you guys over here in the next video.
