J.S. Bach - Cello Suite No. 5 in C Minor, BWV 1011 - A Song of Mourning - Colin Carr

Stories of Music
Stories of Music
129 followers
59 Video Views·Nov 5, 2022

This video is made for those who like JS Bach and Cello. It is also for music lovers seeking deeper understand of JS Bach's emotional landscape.

In the summer of 1720, Bach went on a trip with his employer, Prince Leopold of Anhalt-Cöthen, to Carlsbad. Upon his return, he was grief-stricken to know that his beloved wife, Maria Barbara, passed away and was buried in his absence.

Cello Suite No. 5 in C Minor chronicled his emotional challenges during this time. The heaviness of the notes in the first few movements described the wistful state of mind - remembrance of the love, the children who lost their mother, and the gentle heart that wanted to rise but was pulled down by the sorrow. However, as the movements progressed, one would notice the gradual opening of the heart to the surroundings, though still heavy, started to show more lightness and care.

As with all sorrows, there comes a day when one overcomes it - with forbearance and grace. In the last movement, liveliness edged in - one sees a mind beginning its recovery from the trauma. Sun rises again, hope emerges, and one is prepared for a new chapter in life. In Bach's case, he would be meeting his second wife, who loved him dearly, soon.

It was a journey to the valley of despair and back, and one becomes stronger after it.

This trauma recovery process is illustrated using John Atkinson Grimshaw's paintings in the 19th century - a surprising match with those emotions rendered in Movements 1 to 5. For Movement 6, however, Bach's emotional hue exceeded Grimshaw's repertoire. A more suitable illustration turned out to be Frederic Edwin Church's "Morning in the Tropics".

An alternative rendition of this suite was developed by Milena Cord-to-Krax, performed using Recorder, which portrayed a different emotional landscape. We shall explain this in the next video.

Credits
Video production: Stories of Music

Music Composer: J.S. Bach
Musician: Colin Carr, Music from the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum, Boston (Licensed under CC BY-NC-ND)

Paintings:
All paintings licensed under Public Domain.
1) "Gourock, Near the Clyde Shipping Docks", John Atkinson Grimshaw, British, Romanticism
2) "A Moonlit Lane with Two Lovers by a Gate", John Atkinson Grimshaw, 1873, British, Romanticism
3) "The Lady of Shallot", John Atkinson Grimshaw, 1875, British, Romanticism
4) " A Moonlit Lane", John Atkinson Grimshaw, 1874, British, Romanticism
5) "Boars Lane, Leeds by Lamplight", John Atkinson Grimshaw, British, Romanticism
6) "Morning in the Tropics", Frederic Edwin Church, 1858, American, Luminism