Does Planet 9 Really Exist?

Simple Digital
57 followers
8 Video ViewsยทOct 24, 2022
Since Pluto lost its planet status, scientists have not abandoned their attempts to detect
other large objects on the edge of the solar system. After all, there is something beyond
the orbit of Neptune that significantly affects the trajectory and revolution of celestial objects
like asteroids and dwarf planets. And this isn't the kind of something we can detect with telescopes.
Recent research suggests it could be a miniature black hole or even a cluster of dark matter.
In this video, we'll examine the mysterious 9th planet, its properties, size, and whether
it is a planet at all. The question about the existence of the 9th planet became especially
prevalent when scientists closely studied the movements of trans-Neptunian objects
in the Kuiper Belt, an area on the edge of the solar system similar to an asteroid belt.
Astrophysicists Konstantin Batygin and Michael Brown studied six distant objects in the Kuiper
Belt, dwarf planets and planetoids including the dwarf planet Sedna. They found that the
objects followed elliptical orbits pointed in the same direction but moving at different speeds.
This was a rather unexpected discovery and Brown even made this analogy.
This kind of result is if there were a clock with six hands moving at different speeds
but as soon as you look up, all the hands are in the same spot. Brown implied that this type
of event is very unlikely and on top of that, the orbits of these six objects are tilted at
the same angle, about 30 degrees downward in the same direction relative to the plane
of the eight known planets. The chance of this happening is about 0.007%.
The first proposed theory was the presence of certain objects near the borders of the Kuiper
Belt that would affect gravity. Therefore, if that were the case, the mass of the belt should
have been 100 times greater than it is today. Computer simulations using a small planet have
shown that its mass would be insufficient to align objects in this manner. However,
if you run a similar simulation with a massive planet the scale of Uranus or Neptune, the
mathematical model converges and practically duplicates the real-world calculation results.
The work of Batygin and Brown sets limits on the possible mass of the ninth planet,
the location of its orbit, and its position in the sky. According to calculations, the mass of
the planet is 5 to 20 times greater than the mass of Earth and its diameter is 2 to 4 times larger
than our planets. To see this planet directly through a telescope is almost impossible.
It is too far to register in our visible spectrum, so we have to search for it using its faint
infrared glow. However, with a mass of only 5 Earth masses, it wouldn't give off much heat.
Additionally, such a distant planet would revolve around the sun very slowly, so it would be
impossible to detect its movement with observation alone. It's only possible by comparing images
taken at different times and this may take dozens of years. And unfortunately for astrophysicists,
it's most likely that right now the planet is the furthest removed from the sun in the northern
hemisphere of the sky with the radius of its elongated orbit on average in range from 380
to 980 astronomical units. And even all of the data collected so far does not provide a complete
picture of the potential location of the mysterious planet. The search area is approximately
6 to 800 square degrees in the night sky. For reference, the full moon only occupies 0.2 square
degrees in the sky. In an attempt to narrow down the planet's orbit, the researchers compared
simulation results with real Kuiper belt objects. A 4 billion year old model of the solar system was
built. The scientists wanted to understand how the gravitational pull of the largest planets
and the ninth planet could affect the orbits of thousands of objects in the Kuiper belt.
Although Batygin and Brown actually prove the existence of a certain object that influences
the position of other celestial bodies, recent research conducted over the years 2020 to 2022
have cast doubt on the existence of a massive planet. In a relatively recent study from 2021,
critics of the Batygin-Brown theory have discovered about 300 new objects in the region
of the Kuiper belt where the Batygin and Brown theorized the presence of the ninth planet.
Astronomers scanned the better part of the sky with the 20-foot Atacama Space Telescope in Chile
in search of the new planet and spent six years studying 87% of the sky accessible from the
southern hemisphere. Reportedly, a detailed examination of the orbits of objects in
question revealed that every case of orbit synchronization can be explained by known
physics effects except for two celestial bodies. But even these two anomalies are an exception out
300 objects, and in a way they confirm the new theory. Why do discoveries in these orbits not
coincide with Batygin and Brown's predictions? The answer may be that the ninth planet theory
is simply incorrect. However, the nature of the strange behavior of the orbits of some objects
in the farthest reaches of our solar system, hypothesized by some astronomers to be shaped by
an unknown ninth planet, can instead be explained by the combined gravitational force of small
objects orbiting the sun beyond Neptune. The alternative explanation, Planet 9 hypothesis
put forward by researchers, proposes a disk made up of small icy bodies with a combined mass as
much as 10 times that of Earth. When combined with a simplified model of the solar system,
the gravitational forces of the hypothesized disk can account for the unusual orbit architecture
exhibited by some objects at the outer reaches of the solar system. The researchers created a
computer model of the detached TNOs as well as the planets of the solar system and their gravity
and a huge disk of debris past Neptune's orbit. Astrophysicist Antranik Cephelian allows if you
remove Planet 9 from the model and instead allow for lots of small objects scattered across a wide
area, collective attractions between those objects could just as easily account for the
eccentric orbits we see in some TNOs. Earlier attempts to estimate the total mass of objects
beyond Neptune have only added up to around one-tenth the mass of Earth. However, in order
for the TNOs to have the observed orbits and for there to be no Planet 9, the model requires the
combined mass of the Kuiper belt to be between a few to ten times the mass of the Earth. Another
team of scientists used the Infrared Astronomical Satellite, the IRAS, and the Akari Infrared
Telescope to search for the ninth planet. Two surveys were performed and photographed over 20
years apart, giving any hypothetical planet enough time to move to a slightly different part of the
sky. The scientists assumed that any distant planets would be quite close to the equatorial
plane of the sky and then studied the data marking potential planets. They have found over 500
candidates. Judging by the energy distribution of their spectra, most of them have orbital distances
of less than 1,000 astronomical units. This means that most of these objects were either inside or
near a faint nebula. A nebula is a cloud of interstellar gas that's difficult to see with the
naked eye because it emits infrared light or, simply put, heat. It turns out that all the
discovered candidates are not planets at all, but rather echoes of a faint nebula. A large planet,
clusters of small objects, or a glimpse of a distant galaxy, these are perhaps the simplest
explanations for the unusual behavior of trans-Neptunian objects. Scientists asked themselves
a logical question. What kind of object would have enough mass to change the orbits of other celestial
bodies, yet not be visible to us? This prompted theorists to consider a radical hypothesis.
What if the ninth planet is a small black hole that can be detected by theoretical radiation
emitted around its edges, the so-called Hawking radiation? There is a contradiction that relates
to the mass of such an object. Since it is believed that only the most gigantic stars are
large enough to form a black hole, the black holes they would leave behind would have a minimum mass
of around five times greater than the sun's mass. But what if the extreme conditions of the early
universe made it possible for smaller black holes to form? A group of astronomers from Harvard
University planned to start their search for such objects as early as 2023, as part of the Legacy
Survey of Space and Time, the LSST project. To help them find black holes in far corners of the
solar system, astrophysicist Avi Loeb developed a method to search for flares that occur when a
black hole collides with small objects in the Kuiper Belt and the Oort Cloud, a region that
could potentially contain several trillion bodies surrounding our system. The researchers say that
sometimes the objects within the Oort Cloud, such as comets, can interact with lurking black holes,
creating a visible flash of light, possible for Rubin's observatory to detect. Thus,
if scientists could confirm that a small black hole the size of a grapefruit with a mass of 5
to 10 times the mass of Earth orbits the sun, this could provide an answer to one of the greatest
mysteries of modern cosmology, the formation of black holes. However, there is another theory,
most exotic and yet just as deserving as others. What if out there at the edge of the solar system
there's an object made of dark matter? We see evidence of dark matter all around us.
Stars that revolve too fast around the centers of their galaxy. Galaxies that move too fast
within their clusters. A new hypothesis now suggests that most of the dark matter can
concentrate into objects the size of Neptune, the so-called dark matter planets. Although these
planets remain invisible to us, they can create an atmosphere out of helium and hydrogen. And this
can lead to the fact that reaching critical temperatures would trigger nuclear fusion
inside the planets, which would help us discover them. Dark matter forming into planets may explain
why no object with a mass approximately equal to the mass of Neptune has been discovered
in the aforementioned research. Scientists believe that if dark matter planets exist,
they clearly formed when the universe was very young and remained static for billions of years.
In the early universe, the temperature was too high, which prevented the formation of larger
objects. However, dark matter does not interact with ordinary matter nor light and could therefore
freely assemble into such, quote, planets. According to this theory, instead of being
evenly distributed throughout the galaxy, most of the dark matter will be inside these relatively
compact spheres with masses ranging from a mass of an asteroid to the mass of Neptune.
These hypothetical dark matter planets may have first accumulated a layer of helium,
since it was the first chemical element to break away from the plasma state of the early universe,
and later attracted hydrogen gas, creating a dense atmosphere around the helium similar to
the layers of gas around giant planets. What would we see inside a planet like that?
It's hard to say. Submerging into such a planet would be very strange. A bright layer of hydrogen
would be warm since it's gravitationally bound to a dense object. The friction would cause it to glow.
After the layer of hydrogen, we would reach the helium underneath, and as soon as we pass
through the helium, we would see nothing. Absolute emptiness. The core of the dark matter planet would
be completely invisible. You'll find yourself surrounded by a membrane of luminous hydrogen
helium plasma. The flash from the ejection of matter could compete with a supernova in its
brightness. In conclusion, let's address the expediency of the search for the mysterious
ninth planet. Although searches have so far not revealed a single planet at the edge of the solar
system, this does not mean that the search was completely in vain. The ninth planet theory has
sparked an unprecedented surge in research into the Kuiper belt and other trans-Neptunian objects.
The search for planet nine may eventually lead to something even more significant for the scientific
progress. For example, Batygin claims that the discovery of the ninth planet, which seems so
strange to us, would actually make our solar system more like other planetary systems.
We quote, one of the most striking discoveries about other planetary systems was that the most
common type of planet has a mass in the range between the masses of the Earth and Neptune.
Until now, we thought that the solar system is missing exactly this, the most common type
of planet. Maybe, after all, our system is not as unique as we thought.
