Jesus and Buddha- Offical Film (inter-faith-dialogue 101)

Healthy Life
199 followers
31 Video Views·Oct 23, 2022
Directed by John Ankele
[HIGHLY RECOMMENDED]
Trailer plus segment from the documentary opens up dialogue for understanding the other first, before endeavoring to be understood. This is a way to educate oneself on views that may be opposite of their own, and at the same time, not hold those of different views in judgement. As Thomas Merton was quoted in saying, "Where the theologians argue and debate, we mystics speak the same language."
Coppyright: Paul Siddall
Buddha has enabled me to see things about Jesus
that I never would have been able to see without Buddha.
When I start finding what I believe
is true in other religions, of course,
it doesn't remain in my head.
It touches my whole being, my heart, my practice.
And I start adopting that religion to some extent.
The words of Jesus that we must die to our very self,
when we first hear that, it sounds
almost impossible or cruel.
It's only later we realize that it is mercy itself.
Because the self that we cling to doesn't exist.
It is a construction of the human mind.
Emptiness is this really vortex of life energy
where everything is interconnected
and everything comes out of it.
So emptiness is your wide openness
to see whatever is coming to you in this life.
Ah, wow, this is new.
How interesting.
That is emptiness.
Autama became Buddha because he woke up.
Jesus became Christ because he woke up
to the divine spirit that was given to him in his very being.
Karl Rahner said, to say that Jesus is divine
means that Jesus realized the full potential of what
it means to be human.
Even if I don't see it again, nor ever feel it, I know it is.
And that if once it hailed me, it ever does.
For me, Zazen is prayer.
To come into the presence of mystery
and sit with attention, and attention, reverence,
gratitude, need not be spoken.
We don't have to use the words.
What would I do with words?
Would I try to remind God of something God forgot?
When you can really be mindful of this present moment
and recognizing that its depth, its mystery,
is deeper than any thought you have,
that any feeling that you have.
It's hard to find words for this.
That's when you feel that you are held,
that you are sustained, that what you really are
is deeper than what you think you are
or than anything anybody says you are.
It's deeper.
And that reality is the Christ spirit.
That reality is our Buddha nature.
That's who I really am.
Jesus came to experience the reality of the spirit,
a power of love that calls us to have a particular concern
for people who have been pushed aside by the powers that
be, for the marginalized, the oppressed.
This, I think, is central to the experience of Holy Mystery
as we experience that Holy Mystery
through the teachings of Jesus.
We participate in the mystery of Christ.
Paul said, you are free in Christ,
free of this old binding sin of self-centeredness and pride.
Then you live in the vision of love and kingdom of God,
which is peace of equals, where justice is flowing.
When Jesus said, I am the truth, I understand Him to mean,
wherever there is truth, there is Jesus.
So when we seek the truth, we are seeking Jesus.
Or the Buddha would say, we are seeking the Buddha.
Once a student asked the teacher, who is the Buddha?
And the teacher said, you are you.
Never mind about the Buddha.
Don't speak to someone else.
Don't imagine a Buddha out there and start
speaking to that Buddha.
Just look deeply into yourself.
Has enabled me to see things about Jesus
that I never would have been able to see without Buddha.
When I start finding what I believe
is true in other religions, of course,
it doesn't remain in my head.
It touches my whole being, my heart, my practice.
And I start adopting that religion to some extent.
I am nurtured by two different religious traditions.
My Christian practice and beliefs
and my Buddhist practice and beliefs.
And both of them, now they're different.
That's what makes it so interesting.
That's what makes it exciting and fruitful.
My interest in Buddhism actually goes way back
to when I was 13, 14 years old and I
decided that I wanted to become a missionary priest
in the Catholic Church.
The beginning of a long process, I
went to the seminary through all 14 years
and was ordained a priest.
But my primary motivation in the beginning
was since I loved all these wonderful Buddhist people,
I felt I had to convert them to Jesus
because otherwise they're in big trouble.
Their eternal salvation is at stake.
But as I then began to actually study Buddhism,
and even more so as I began to meet Buddhists and enter
into dialogue with Buddhists, my more academic interest
in Buddhism led to a decision to start practicing.
Happily, I'm married to a Buddhist.
Kathy and I do a lot of talking and exploring
and sitting together, and that has been extremely enriching.
Buddhism helped me discover how I might more deeply experience
the reality of God.
This was in the Buddhist insistence
that truth, they don't use the word God,
but that truth, ultimate reality, the way things are,
is to be found within myself and within this world.
In other words, what I call God is not an entity out there
that has to step into my life.
Buddhism stresses or affirms that truth
is that which we find within this world.
It just answered so many difficulties
I had with what is oftentimes an exaggerated Christian teaching
and talking about God as if God is this supreme entity out
there, this infinite father being, this super person.
And that's why Buddha didn't want to talk about God.
Because to talk too much about God,
that distracted you, you looking out there
rather than looking into yourself.
And so that was a tremendous help.
When I was in Japan as a young Jesuit,
I was teaching English and baseball.
And we had a championship team there
with the high school and the middle school boys
in Rokko High School in Kobe.
When I entered the Jesuits, I was simply Catholic.
I never thought of being interested in Buddhism.
The Second Vatican Council changed everything
for Catholics.
The Jesuits following the council
urged us not merely to tolerate other religions,
but to admire them and to promote the good that they
have, because there's good in every religion.
And our job was to find out what was good, all that was good,
and promote it, promote it even as different
from our own understanding of the truth.
And finally, more than that, to practice
the truth of the other, to walk in their shoes,
because only if we walk in their shoes
do we really understand them or can appreciate them.
I found out that many Jesuits were interested in Buddhism,
especially Zen Buddhism.
They introduced me to Yamada Roshi of Kamakura,
who knew about us.
His son went to one of our high schools,
and he was very open to us.
And he welcomed me into his zendo,
which was another great gift, because I really knew nothing.
But the personality of Yamada Roshi touched me deeply.
And I can't explain that either, why this man,
just when he walked into the zendo, touched me so deeply.
I had the feeling that this is it.
I read later Thomas Merton said when he encountered Zen
Buddhism, he said, I don't know what it means yet,
but this is it.
I guess it was the reasonableness of Zen,
the sanity of it, and the compassionate lifestyle
that it presented was very appealing to me.
Appealing is almost a command in my spirit,
that this should be followed also.
I studied with Mayasumi Roshi for a semester
of my sabbatical in Los Angeles.
And then I met Glassman Roshi, who at that time
was his heir apparent.
So Glassman Roshi then became my teacher.
He was really wonderful to me in every way.
When the time came, he wanted me to be a teacher.
There were many Buddhists who were upset by this,
because I was Catholic and Jesuit.
Glassman said to them, are we one or are we not?
And they said, well, he's not even a priest.
He's not a Zen priest.
And Glassman said, he is a priest.
We have to ordain him again.
What is this about?
And so he faced down some serious opposition.
So we properly understood in that this Zen practice
does not interfere with anyone's faith.
It's not about faith at all.
Zen is beyond yes or no about God.
Zen is a skill, perhaps like learning to play the piano.
And faith need not enter into it.
It can.
It can enrich a faith.
If a person is deeply practicing his own faith,
Zen can enrich it.
But for those who have no faith, that's
perfectly all right, too, from a Zen point of view.
We opened the possibility of people being themselves,
whatever that is, without judging them.
This young monk went into the mountains to find a teacher.
To find a teacher, meaning to find life itself.
And deep in the mountains, he heard a voice.
The Japanese call this hearing the voice of the cuckoo.
Something called him deep in his own nature,
in his own mind and heart.
And the voice said, all things are impermanent.
And the young man was deeply touched by this.
In other words, he heard it because he was silent,
because his search was thorough.
He heard the teaching, all things are impermanent.
I was born and raised in a third generation Christian family
in Korea, Presbyterian family.
So I went to church every morning and every Sunday.
But my encounter with Buddhism actually
started with my personal struggle.
At the time, I was going through my divorce.
And I didn't know what to do about this.
So much suffering, I don't know whether I do it or not.
I was teaching women and religion
in Cambridge at the time.
Then one day, I walk home.
I discover this Korean temple in the middle of a central square
in Cambridge.
So I walk in, and they have a meditation instruction.
So I sat, and I learned meditation instruction
because I need to do something for my suffering.
Then I went on my very first interview with the Zen master.
So he asked me, why are you here?
So I said, oh, I'm suffering.
All my melodramatic stories about I love this man so much,
but he become a religious fundamentalist.
What can I do?
And maybe I have to leave.
So I pour out all my suffering, expecting his empathy.
Then Zen master looked at me in a very quiet spirit
and asked me, so?
I said, I told you all this suffering story,
and your question is so?
So I was kind of angry inside.
I felt, this Zen master doesn't know psychology 101
and pastoral counseling 101.
He heard this story of suffering.
He need to give us some comfort.
But he said, so?
So I was kind of dumbfounded.
Then after a little bit of silence, he asked me,
you know, it's very interesting.
The first noble truth of Buddhism is life is suffering.
Everybody is suffering.
And you just think you are the only one
who are suffering in this world.
So why do you think you are so special?
The first question, first gonghan,
Zen master Sung San asked me was, who are you?
Then he said, if you don't know that answer,
go to the Dharma room and sit and meditate.
Just ask this question, who am I?
Who am I?
And get the answer.
And if you get the answer, come back to me to report.
And until that time, you just sit down and ask, who am I?
You breathe in, who am I?
And breathe out, don't know.
Who am I?
Don't know.
That's all you need to do.
Then he said, you will find that answer.
And you will find your true self.
Then you will not suffer anymore.
So many years passed with this question, who am I?
Really?
I don't know.
So that was the beginning of my journey.
Keep this don't know mind.
But in the beginning, this don't know
gave me kind of anxiety.
It's like your bottom fall apart.
And if really I don't know the ground of my being,
really what am I?
So it gives me kind of an uneasy feeling.
But with practice over the year, I
started to learn how to be relaxed, how to be,
just to be in that big don't know with trust.
In that trust, everything is possible.
So when my don't know becomes bigger and bigger,
my freedom and also my peace and acceptance
is getting bigger and bigger.
So Zen Master Sung San really gave me
the wonderful first gongwan, first question,
who are you and don't know?
There's a classic story in Zen of a student coming
to the teacher and saying that he
is bound by his bad actions of the past.
Could the teacher free him?
And the teacher said, well, go out and find
this self that you feel is bound by your bad actions.
The student finally says, well, I can't find that self.
And the teacher says, there I have unbound you.
The words of Jesus that we must die to our very self,
when we first hear that, it sounds
almost impossible or cruel.
It's only later we realize that it is mercy itself.
Because the self that we cling to doesn't exist.
It is a construction of the human mind.
And it's necessary to put that down
in order to enter the fullness of reality
where Christ is found, from the Catholic point of view.
From the Buddhist point of view, of course,
it's necessary to transcend your own mental conceptions
of the self to reach something else.
And that's what the effort in Zazen,
in the Zen hall and Zen meditation is doing,
is trying to de-center the self to get
us to cease from repeating patterns of thought
that we've become accustomed to and that we identify
with our very self.
The Buddhist has to free himself of his Buddhist self.
The Christian has to free himself
from his Christian self, to the extent
that these are constructs of the mind.
Yamada Roshi said that to me when I was sitting with him.
He said, I'm not trying to make you a Buddhist.
I'm trying to empty you in imitation of your Lord Jesus
Christ, to empty themselves.
So Yamada went right to the heart of Christianity.
But the goal is not to just repeat Christian dogmas
or attend Christian services, but to recognize and activate
the oneness you have with Christ.
And Christ emptied himself.
So the path to Christ that Yamada Roshi was saying
is very similar to the path to the Buddha, self-emptying.
It is very difficult for young Western students
to understand emptiness.
So as soon as I talk about emptiness,
they think emptiness is psychological emptiness.
So they have a big hole here in their heart,
or they feel lonely.
They feel unloved and meaninglessness,
or sometimes nihilistic.
And just something is not there they need to feel in.
They think emptiness is that, very negative way.
But Buddhist emptiness is not that.
Buddhist emptiness is in a way, it
is a fullness, so I always like what Thich Nhat Hanh said.
Empty of what?
That is important.
Empty of this solid, unchanging, fixed self, fixed nature.
So emptiness is this really vortex of life energy,
where everything is interconnected,
and everything comes out of it.
So emptiness is your wide openness
to see whatever is coming to you in this life.
Ah, wow, this is new.
How interesting.
That is emptiness.
Ladies and gentlemen, in this true self,
there is eternal happiness.
In this true self, there is a great freedom
that is devoid of all obstructions.
You will become one body with the whole human race,
and one household with all sentient beings
and insentient beings throughout the entire world.
The ultimate concern of Buddhism is enlightenment,
waking up to the fact that all is profoundly interrelated,
that nothing exists unto itself, that nothing
has its own individual or individualized being,
but that we are all part of an interconnected reality that
is an interconnected reality that is vital, alive,
and that functions primarily through compassion,
or what Christians would call love.
Prajna, wisdom, that is the growing awareness
that I am not just this individual substantial being,
but I am more.
I am, in Christian language, I am part of spirit, spirit
that I see in Jesus Christ.
But that is my true identity, not my individual self.
And that gives me, or can give me,
a deep peace in experiencing that I
feel this connectedness with.
And that means a compassion and love for all sentient beings.
So taking these Buddhist teachings,
I went back to the Bible, looking
at some of the central teachings or symbols of my Christianity.
And one of them that just leapt out
was one of the primary symbols that we Christians use for God
is spirit, spiritus, pneuma, ruach.
This means that God is spirit.
And what is spirit?
Spirit is that which animates.
Spirit is that which fills us, which moves in ways in which we
can never truly, truly perceive or forecast.
And so the symbol of spirit, from my Christian tradition,
became alive with meaning, not just for my head,
but for my prayer, for my meditation,
to feel or to imagine the ultimate God
as this interconnecting spirit, this beautiful,
I mean, this interconnecting spirit.
There are very few definitions of God in the New Testament.
In fact, maybe there's only two or three where it says God is.
And those instances, they come from the writings
attributed to John.
God is love.
God is spirit.
Those are the two, love and spirit.
Well, love is the compassionate energy
of the interconnecting spirit.
And so you see, this is where God is no longer
an entity out there.
But Buddhism has helped me.
And I'm not saying that Buddhism is the only way to discover
this, certainly not.
But Buddhism is a way of helping Christians to perhaps
to come to a deeper and, I would say,
more personal, more mystical, more mystical experience
of God.
More and more, I feel my Christian notion
of God as love and my Buddhist notion of don't know.
They come together, almost like a love meets wisdom.
This big don't know beyond all concept and all name and forms.
If we really trust this don't know mind, in that don't know,
everything is possible.
It's like, actually, we don't know
what is the best for our life, whether what
we think it is necessary for us to be happy and to be wholesome.
We need to have this and this and this.
That's what we think.
Maybe it's not what we really need
to have an enlightened life.
So this don't know mind taught me radical humility.
You really don't know.
So whatever needs arise around you,
you respond freely with open heart
without clinging to your old, unchanging self.
Christian notion of being in Christ and Buddhist notion
of no self and true self have something in common.
You are free from this binding ego,
then open to receive love of God and open
to act as a good Christian disciple or a good bodhisattva.
My favorite words from Christian tradition
actually came from so-called Gnostic Gospel,
Gospel of Thomas.
There, Jesus talks about salvation.
Jesus said, if you bring out what is within you,
what is within you will save you.
But if you cannot bring out what is within you,
what is within you will destroy you.
So whenever I heard that message of Jesus,
I feel, yes, that's what is within you is true self,
our true self, which is not bounding to either our sin
or this unchanging, solid illusion of a self.
Gautama became Buddha because he woke up.
Jesus, the son of Mary, became Christ, the son of God,
because he woke up to the divine spirit
that was given to him in his very being.
Karl Rahner said, to say that Jesus is divine
means that Jesus realized the full potential
of what it means to be human.
What it means to be human is to wake up to,
to be open to the spirit of God that is given to us,
that is given to us by God in our very beings.
When we are created, when we come forth,
we already are human beings endowed with God's spirit,
sustained by God's spirit.
Our problem is we don't know it.
We don't trust it.
Maybe we've grown up in situations
where that has just become so obscure.
And Jesus or Buddha can help us realize it.
But when we realize it,
it's not just something that is up here.
It's a realization that becomes energy, transformative,
or what Christians call grace.
Grace is not something from outside.
Grace is the very presence of God within us,
enlightening us, humanizing us.
The greater our humanity,
then the greater capacity we have to receive God's grace
in Christian theological terms.
Teilhard says the fire of heaven
has to come down on something.
We're expected to do our part in developing our human nature,
even though that, too, is a grace.
So every step forward we take to develop our nature,
you know, God's grace is there to meet us,
to enliven us, to enrich it.
To become one with yourself,
to see the breadth of the self,
or the light of the self, or the beauty of the self,
is then to recognize the breadth and the beauty
and the light of Christ, because we are not separate.
It is Christ growing within us in all that we do.
We can think of Christ in a relational sense,
that Christ is another whom we love or serve
or something like that.
But it is also very Catholic to see that Christ is not other.
I am not simply a friend of Christ,
but I am Christ himself.
Do you not know what St. Paul says?
You are the body of Christ.
You are Christ himself.
And the other is Christ himself.
It's that unity of Christ with the world
and with each one of us that is an intimacy of identity,
not just relationship, but identity.
So everyone we meet, as the Irish prayer says, is Christ.
St. Paul writes to the Galatian community.
He says, it is no longer I who live,
but Christ who lives in me and as me.
Paul is saying, I'm not living.
It's Christ who's living, however, in me.
Buddhism is helping me to comprehend
that that brings me to a different understanding
of Paul Knitter.
When you can really be mindful of this present moment
and recognizing that its depth, its mystery,
is deeper than any thought you have,
any feeling that you have, it's hard to find words for this.
That's when you feel that you are held,
that you are sustained, that what you really are
is deeper than what you think you are
or than anything anybody says you are.
It's deeper, and that reality is the Christ spirit.
That reality is our Buddha nature.
That's who I really am.
Buddhists say, if you can really be mindful of this moment,
it will provide all that you need.
That's the power.
That's the beauty, because when you are mindful
of your thinking and you don't let your thinking
define what is real in this moment,
my thought that I am, you know,
I'm thinking that I'm afraid.
I'm thinking that I'm inadequate.
I'm thinking that, I mean, or I feel I'm angry.
When I'm aware of my anger, when I'm aware of my fear,
and I say that's my feeling,
that's not what is real in this moment,
what is really real, the thoughts that I have
and the feelings that I have of despondency,
of inadequacy, of meaninglessness, be aware of them.
Let them be.
Don't fight them.
I mean, because so often in the past,
I say, oh, I shouldn't be feeling this way.
Well, damn it, I do feel this way.
This is what, accept that.
There's a certain kind of letting go,
which includes acceptance.
You know, you accept the fact of what you're feeling
and then you let it go, but first you have to accept it.
There is something that can be almost miraculous
about that.
When we sit well, all our sins, if you will,
or our limitations disappear like frost or snow.
They just vanish because this moment
is the only moment that truly exists.
The past is memory, the future is speculation.
Sit right now, work right now, serve right now, do it well.
As we get older, we realize our limitations,
they can almost crush us, you know,
and we realize the difficulty of change,
even for the better, but it is not good Zen practice
to become obsessed with the idea of growth
or change or enlightenment.
That can just make us sick.
We must accept ourselves as we are in this moment.
Accept the light that we have even if we don't see it
and be grateful for it and grateful for the gifts of others
who can teach us.
Don't tie ourselves in a knot trying to improve ourselves.
That just puts the emphasis back on the self
instead of the moment, you know.
For me, Zazen is prayer.
To come into the presence of mystery
and sit with attention, you know, physical attention too,
I mean, physical attention in the presence
of ultimate truth.
To sit with reverence for that truth
and gratitude for the experience itself is prayer.
I mean, attention, reverence, gratitude need not be spoken.
We don't have to use the words.
What would I do with words?
Would I try to remind God of something God forgot?
Would I beseech God to pay attention to someone else
as if God was not paying attention?
Being fully in the present moment is
when joyful situation arise, you become joyful.
And very painful situation arise and you feel pain.
And something sad appears, you are sad.
And something really fantastic appears,
you are totally surprised.
So you are like a very fresh child in a way
to see everything for the first time.
It's like falling in love with life
as if every moment is your first love.
So that is the present moment.
But I didn't know it when I was younger
because I have big dreams and big ambitions
and I wanted so much in life and I want this, I want that.
And then so much want always bring so much suffering.
So there are moment in my life,
I had a really dark night of soul.
I walked into that valley.
And sometimes, you know, I got so depressed.
It is unbearable.
And that moment, I learned how to be in present moment
from my psychotherapist and from my great Buddhist teachers.
Present moment, that's all we have.
It's this very moment, only here and only now.
And that is what life is presenting to us.
Every moment, and we miss this, we miss entire life.
I wish I got it 30 years ago, but that is all we have.
But most of us are really, most of the time,
regretting about the past and worrying about future.
But when we really know how to be at the present moment,
then even big suffering is bearable.
So present moment in my very difficult time of life,
it pull me through.
It carry me like a great wind, great love.
My very loving mother take me just this moment.
Next moment, next moment, then you will be fine.
