Who Has Made the Most Reliable Pickup Over 15 Years? Shocking Results

Bloom tires
39 followers
6 Video Views·Oct 23, 2022
If you want to know what the most dependable pickups have been over the last 15 years,
I have the data for you, and be warned, it just might piss you off.
We're going to get to it coming up right now.
Hello, it's Tim Espinel of Pickup Truck Plus SUV Talk, and my passion is trucks and SUVs.
If you're new to the channel, I've been an automotive journalist for several years now,
and I just love this stuff. It's kind of a weird addiction I have.
But hey, thanks for joining me in this video, and I've seen a lot of new faces,
which is really exciting to me, and I've been coming from a few videos I've put out.
One of them was recently about the Toyota Tacoma, and how unreliable it's been over
a couple of years, and now it's coming back to being more reliable.
Transmission issues, I digress. I'll put the video above. You can watch it there.
But it got me thinking, and some of the comments got me thinking.
A lot of people dish on J.D. Powers. Terrible. Awful company.
But automakers really like having the awards.
And then somebody said, hey, just look at what J.D. Powers has awarded over the years,
and follow the money.
So I did. I can go back as far as 2005, and see model year 2002.
All the way to this last survey result, 2019, which shows model year 2016.
If you don't know about the survey, it is J.D. Powers Vehicle Dependability Survey.
It goes out every year.
They go ahead and collect 80,000 results from truck owners.
And they, really basic questions.
Do you like your truck? Yes, no. You know, not yes, no, excuse me.
Scale of 1 to 5. Scale of 1 to 5 quality. Scale of 1 to 5 problems.
They collect this data together, and they put together into a survey.
And the survey does, puts out all the results.
Now there's more data in that survey than what we see as the public.
And that's what J.D. Powers sells.
That's what they sell to automakers.
So if you're following the money, it's basically automakers buying the report for
insane amount of money.
And all the automakers have been buying the report.
Because it tends to be pretty accurate.
Gives them real information about vehicle dependability,
and what owners are seeing as problems.
And so what we get, is we get the awards.
Who's won what. Who's the best selling truck in, who's, not best selling.
Who's the best quality truck in full size.
Who's the best quality truck in midsize.
And so on and so forth.
What I did, was I went back to all the survey results.
I got a spreadsheet.
I put it all together.
And I also awarded the best brands by pickups.
And I awarded the best midsize.
The best full size.
And the best heavy duty.
And I'm telling you, you're going to comment.
Because it's going to piss you off.
So let me turn on the computer, fire it up.
And I'll show you these results.
Okay, let's go over these survey results.
And again, just to be clear.
I went to J.D. Powers website.
Look through the archives.
And I compiled this list.
Now they do have 2004 survey, 2003 survey.
But 2002 survey results weren't on the website.
I thought about going back and a little bit forth.
But you know, really what I have here.
Is I have 15 years of survey results and model year information.
I think that's good enough.
I think it's going to give you a really good idea.
Of what J.D. Powers awarded over the years.
And we answer that question.
You know, what have they awarded?
Where's the money going?
Let's, let's dig into this.
So looking at 2005 survey year.
Which is the 2002 model.
Again, this is three years of ownership.
You have to own a vehicle three years.
And then they, they, you can respond to a survey that comes out.
Looking at 2002.
We have a mid-sized truck was the Chevy S10.
It was a good truck.
I owned one back in the day.
We have a full-size Cadillac Escalade EXT.
Remember that?
That's the avalanche looking Escalade.
Which is kind of funny.
I haven't seen that or even seen one for years.
I don't think.
And I have it on the list.
Heavy duty truck was a Chevy Silverado 2500.
In 2003, we had the Ford Ranger.
Remember the old Ford Ranger?
That thing was pretty bulletproof, I think.
I don't, I had neighbors own them.
And they were good trucks back in the day.
We have full-size.
We have the Toyota Tundra.
Remember that's a T100 model.
That's the nine-tenths version of a full-size truck.
And heavy duty, we have no award.
Now this surprises people.
But there isn't always an award winner in each category.
Based on the number of problems people have had.
They don't just automatically give somebody the award.
The next best guy.
You have to meet a certain criteria.
That's my understanding of it.
I'm going to say that very clearly.
That's my understanding of it.
2004, we have the Toyota Tacoma.
We have the full-size Toyota Tundra.
And again, we have no award for heavy duty.
2005, we have the Ford Ranger takes back the spot.
Toyota Tundra again is the full-size champ.
And heavy duty, no award again.
2006, we have the Ford Ranger and Toyota Tundra.
Sorry if I repeat myself.
Because this is the same thing for a couple years now.
No award for the heavy duty.
And then we go 2007.
This is interesting.
We have the Honda Ridgeline.
And this is that Ridgeline that was the size of a full-size.
But it was at a...
They rated it as a mid-size as far as what category it was.
It was a weird truck.
But it best...
Most reliable truck was in the 2007 mid-size was Honda Ridgeline.
We have the Toyota Tundra again.
Again, repeating myself.
No award for heavy duty.
2008, we have Toyota Tacoma and Toyota Tundra.
And no heavy duty.
2009, we have Nissan Frontier.
I was a little bit surprised there.
Toyota Tundra.
And then 2010, we have Ford Ranger.
We have GMC Sierra.
Three-quarter ton was the full-size.
Which is interesting that they awarded the full...
The, excuse me, the heavy duty truck to be the full-size truck.
I think there was some confusion at GD Power personally that year.
Okay, I'm looking at 2011 model year.
This is a 2014 survey.
We have mid-size Honda Ridgeline.
We have full-size GMC Sierra 1500.
Heavy duty is Chevy Silverado 2500.
In 2012, we have damn near the same thing.
We have Honda Ridgeline.
GMC Sierra 1500.
GMC Sierra, one ton.
So one ton versus three-quarter ton.
In 2013, we have no award for mid-size.
We have full-size Toyota Tundra.
And we have Chevy Silverado 2500.
Heavy duty.
In 2014, the mid-size champ is the Honda Ridgeline.
Again, but it's Honda Ridgeline.
Full-size Ford F-150.
Heavy duty.
Chevy Silverado three-quarter ton.
2015 model year, we have the Toyota Tacoma was mid-size.
We have Chevy Silverado was the full-size.
And we had heavy duty Ford F-450 dual rear wheel was the heavy duty.
And then looking at 2016, we have the Nissan Frontier,
the Toyota Tundra, and the Chevy Silverado one ton.
So don't worry if you haven't kept track of total numbers yet.
I have it.
We're going to get to that right now.
Okay, while individual model years are interesting.
See who won and kind of look back in time.
I think it's even more interesting to see who got the most awards
over that period of time for vehicle dependability study.
So let's start with heavy duty pickup.
So all those years that they actually awarded a heavy duty pickup award,
the Chevrolet GMC trucks won five awards while Ford won two.
So they dominated that segment.
Looking at full-size pickup in third place was Ford with one award.
Chevy and GMC was in second place with five awards.
And Toyota won nine awards for its full-size pickup,
making it the most dependable of those 15 years.
Midsize pickups was more competitive.
Coming in at number five, we have Chevy and GMC with one award.
We have Nissan.
The Frontier has two awards.
Toyota had only three awards.
It came in number three.
Shocker, shocker.
I know, fire up the keyboards.
We have a tie for first place.
We have Honda and Ford tied with four awards each.
It's kind of interesting to look at a top truck brand who won.
I would make a note right here to say that you have probably noticed by now,
I haven't said Dodge Ram or Ram at all because they haven't won anything.
So they're not missing.
I didn't exclude them.
I wasn't being anti-Ram or anti-Dodge Ram.
They just aren't listed.
But anyway, back to the list.
Top truck brand.
Number five is Nissan with two awards.
Number four was Honda with four awards.
Number three was Ford with five awards.
First place and second place was a tie.
So here you go.
This is going to kind of get you fired up.
Toyota won 12 awards for top truck brand.
And Chevy and GMC won 12 awards as well.
Now you could argue that it's not so great for Chevy and GMC
because they offer a truck in each class versus Toyota doesn't offer a heavy-duty truck.
Or you could say, wow, look how good Toyota did
because they don't offer heavy-duty truck and Chevy won five awards.
Five of those total awards from the heavy-duty segment.
It's an interesting argument.
Make it either way.
And I'm sure you'll let me know below.
Hey, thanks for watching.
Make sure you follow us on Pickup Truck Talk on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram.
Just type in Pickup Truck Talk.
You will find us.
We're there.
Trust me.
I've done it right there.
Hit subscribe for more videos like this.
I do some crazy drives.
I do some unique drives, new products, new trucks, and unique old trucks as well.
You want to make sure you follow those.
Look back.
I got a lot of videos on this channel.
A lot of content people have been eating up.
Make sure you check us out on PickupTruckTalk.com.
Email me at Tim at PickupTruckTalk.com.
I love getting emails.
I'll respond to them.
I read the comments.
Leave hate mail down below.
I love reading that too.
Again, thanks for watching.
I'll see you down the road.
