Ford Ranger Tremor vs Chevy Colorado ZR2 vs SWAMP! Which Midsize Truck is Better Off-Road? - Part 1

Family Auto
135 followers
8 Video Views·Oct 23, 2022
Hi everyone and welcome to the Trucking YouTube channel. Well on my right today is a truck that's
been on the channel a couple of times. That of course is the Chevy Colorado ZR2. It is one of,
if not the best, midsize off-road truck you can buy. But for 2021 Ford has something to say about
it with this truck. That is the Ford Ranger Tremor. And in this video we're going out there onto our
trails, we're going to find the mud, try to get stuck, and answer the big question. Which one
is better off-road? Before we get dirty let's start with the walk around. So under the hood
of the Ranger, and the only engine you can get in the Ranger here in North America,
is a 2.3 liter EcoBoost turbocharged four-cylinder that makes 270 horsepower and 310 pound-feet of
torque sent through a 10-speed automatic transmission. Now when you go for the Ranger
Tremor, first of all the truck gets some styling upgrades. You can see these cool kind of red
nostrils up here in the grille. I do think it comes together to look a little bit tougher than
a standard Ranger. You get that unique grille too. But now let me tell you about the upgrades that
matter. Of course you're getting skid plates underneath, you're getting tow hooks up there
in the front, and then as we roll back the biggest one of course is a set of General Grabber all
terrain tires. Now those tires are 32 inches and they help to get this truck up to 9.7 inches
of ground clearance. Now as we roll back we do have a big set of side steps on our truck today,
and the one thing I like about these steps is they're actually covered in this bed liner type
material. So even though these are kind of hanging down and they are probably going to get in the way
off-road, they are protected so they shouldn't chip or show any of that damage. And then as we
roll around to the back, everything back here is basically standard Ranger. One thing I will
complain about, no damped tailgate on this truck. It's basically the only truck that we've tested
in a while without a damped tailgate. Not sure why Ford doesn't do that. And then like I said,
the bed back here is basically just regular Ranger. Now let's go take a look at the Challenger.
Now let's talk about the ZR2 here. Under the hood we have a 3.6 liter naturally aspirated V6
that makes 308 horsepower and 275 pound-feet of torque. So these are very different engines.
This engine makes more horsepower. The Ranger over there makes more torque. It's going to be
interesting to kind of feel that out when we get on the trail. By the way too, this is an
8-speed automatic, whereas the Ranger is a 10-speed. So for 2021, Chevy redesigned this whole front end
here on the ZR2. They didn't really change any of the running gear, any of the important stuff,
but they definitely made it look tougher, more aggressive. And to my eyeballs, I think the Chevy
is the better looking truck out of the two, but you know what, that's subjective. So why don't
you guys go in the comments right now and tell me which one looks better, ZR2 or Ranger Tremor.
And now let's keep on walking around here. So you get that unique fascia for the approach angle up
there, a full set of skid plates here too, red tow hooks. And then we get to the most important
upgrade, of course, the tires. That is a set of Goodyear Wrangler Duratrax. And these are just
slightly smaller than the tires over there on the Ranger Tremor. They're pretty close, but yes,
the ZR2, they're a little smaller. Now here on our model today, we have the optional rock rails.
These I absolutely love. Those are giving you great protection. They don't get in the way.
And I'm a tall guy. I don't think midsize pickup trucks need running boards. So I love those rock
rails. Now coming back to the back, we do lose the awesome bumper steps that you normally get
on your Colorado or Silverado. And that's to give us this really nice departure angle.
Now, finally, we can take a look at the bed. Tailgate is damped. And this is a standard
Colorado bed, except for, of course, that sport bar up there. It's really just for style. It does
make the truck look cool. Plus you get those lights. However, when you load up tall things
into the bed, it can also get in the way. So that's a decision you got to make whether you'd
rather have the style or the utility out of your bed. Anyways, I think that's basically it for me
talking about these trucks. Let's go out there and drive them. All right, folks, we're getting
ready to head down the hydro line now, and we're going to put Matt to the test. This is your
rematch in this truck. We're back in the ZR2, and I'm going to try not to get miserably stuck.
Guess what, though? No ice today. No ice, just some treacherous mud. Water and mud. Should be
all right. So before we take off, I just want to quickly go over a couple other differences between
the trucks. Here in the Colorado, we have locking differentials in the front and in the rear.
Double lockers, that's nice. Over there in the Ranger, you're only getting a rear locker.
However, when it comes to numbers, the Ranger is actually better. I already told you it has
more ground clearance. It has 30.9 degrees of approach. This truck has 30. That one's kind of
the same, but it has a much better departure angle at 27.1 over there in the Ranger compared to 23
here, and a slightly better breakover angle in the Ranger as well because the wheelbase is two
inches shorter. All that is to say, on paper, the Ranger Tremor looks like the better truck,
but we don't believe what the paper says, so let's hit the trail and go see what happens.
Let's do it. All righty. Okay, I'm going to start her off here in my four auto
and just see how we do. Okay, yeah, fair enough. I mean, I like that this has the auto setting.
There's no auto over there in the Ranger, although the Ranger has drive mode, so we'll see if that
might be able to play with those a little bit. Nope, we're bogging down. Oh, wow. It has brought
me to a complete standstill. Oh, it's because you got your traction on, but it's very slick out here
today, and oh, geez. I mean, you're going to want to go into four high, too, because the auto is
screwing me here. Well, you're stuck a lot sooner than I thought you'd be. A lot sooner than I
wanted to be. Now, to be fair, you had to stop there, and you couldn't carry any momentum through.
There it is. So, see? That's interesting. The four wheel auto is not the same as four wheel.
Having that, you know, dedicated four wheel made a big difference. All right,
it's slick out here today. We are going to make a mess right here. Hold on, hold on tight. Chug
through. Poor camera guy's going to get muddy. No, he's such a dad. Yeah, you might get a little
wet here. Oh, he's good. He's good. Nicely done. Wow. The tires are getting some grip,
but like I said, it is slick out here today. It's like snot. So, in that first section there,
we really bogged down. So, we're going to go ahead and lock that rear. So, we're now four high,
rear locked, and we're entering the deep section. All righty. And we're going to keep some momentum
going this time, because I think that's the number one thing that killed me back there.
Man, it's so slick. You can just feel the whole rear end stepping out.
Okay, come on, buddy. We don't want the tractor to do this. I was going to say,
the tractor's gassed up, right? We don't want the tractor today. That's a big,
gnarly rock there. That's a big rock. That's recently exposed. Oh, yeah. There was some
clearance issues in the rear. It'll hang up there. Okay. All right, Matt. We got it, man.
Here we go. Come on, ZR2. Going for the water. Oh, oh, oh. This does have worse clearance than
the other truck, and it is showing itself. The water feels nice. Come on. Yep, yep. Bow
wave. We got going. And there's usually a rock right about there. Yep. Okay. Yes, yes. We're
going to go a little left here. Yep. There we go. All I can see is sky, and we're out. Okay.
Well, nicely done, ZR2. Wow. A couple ground clearance issues. There's some rocks in that
mud, which are hard to see, but I'm pretty impressed. You and I talked about this before
we drove it. Those rear shock mounts hang down so low, and I think that's what we bumped. Yes,
they do. It sounded like that's what hung up. And I know, despite the ground clearance numbers,
that's definitely one of the things that isn't taken into consideration, I don't think. Yeah,
no, I hear you. And I can show you a shot. There's shock mounts on the Ranger as well,
and they are also slightly lower than the axle, but they're not as egregious as here on the Chevy.
They really hang down. So, Matt, now let's test the hill descent control. I'm not sure how much
you've used these systems, but basically, you hit the button, you take your foot off the brake,
and it's going to let you down this hill nice and slowly. At least that is the idea. Let's start
it here. Yeah, just let it go. It'll catch you. Off the brake. It should catch you. There it is.
There it is. It took a sec, but I think I also feathered the brake a little bit there. Yeah,
that can be it too, but fairly smooth. Didn't like that brake over, though. It gave up on me.
I had to take over again. Oh, interesting. All right. Yeah, it's flashing at me like that. It
doesn't want to run. Back in the water.
Holy cow, though. It is deep. This is like bottom of door deep.
Sweet, Todd. Oh, it doesn't get old coming through. Never.
Nice. Oh, yeah. There's that brake over again, but she's out, man. Dirt tracks, four-wheel drive,
and you know what? You locked up the rear. It feels that much more confident, right? It does.
No spinning. Didn't have to worry about it. Didn't have to think about it. It just made it
through. Nicely done. Okay, Matt. Well, the Chevy made it through pretty well. Yeah. Now we're going
to see how the Ford does, and so you started in four-auto with no systems on. Yeah. We don't have
four-auto here. We only have two or four, so we're going to start in two-wheel drive, rear wheel,
and just see if it gets stuck at the same spot the Chevy gets stuck. That same first little
entry pit. Yeah, and that's definitely a test of tires right there. That's just my parking
sensor. I should probably turn those off. Here. Question is where? Yeah, there we go, because
that's going to be beeping the whole time, and the other key was Matthew went in with a bit of speed,
and then he had to slow down because we were waiting on dad to make sure we got the shot,
so I'm not doing momentum here. I'm creeping. I'm creeping. It's already upset at me,
but it's still going. This is where I stopped. Oh, no. Traction control is not happy. Traction
control is trying to figure it out, and I'm done. All right, but it was actually going okay. Let me
see if I defeat the traction. If I defeat the traction. No, it doesn't matter. All right, so
same conditions. You got caught. If you were coming down this trail without any of your systems on,
and you got caught on a wears, this very small entry pit will bog you down, so it's good to
know that they compare on one level at least. Going to four high. Traction is off. Let's see
if I can just go forward right from here. All right, we're coming at you right now, and yep,
there's all the difference in the world. Just a little bit of four-wheel drive action. Traction's
defeated. This is just four high, and you're just in normal mode. Right, no mud mode. We'll try mud
mode on the way out, maybe. Oh, it is so sloppy. It is. So my first impression from behind the
wheel is this rides almost as nice as the Chevy. I think the Chevy might still be a touch softer
when you're getting in some of these hits, but the suspension here is quite good as well. The
Chevy feels like it eats it up more, whereas this, we're kind of, you're following the terrain. Every
hill I see, we're following it. Whereas the Chevy, it's kind of like, okay, yeah, I can eat that up,
but not bad. Okay, continuing on now. I am going to go ahead and put the truck into mud and ruts
mode, so we're ready. Four high still. And I'm still in four high, and what, should we lock up
the rear end? I locked the rear for this too, so let's give them a fighting chance against each
other. She's all locked up now, and mud and ruts mode. All right. And of course, mud and ruts mode
should change the throttle response a little bit too. Oh, yeah. Nice. No kidding. It actually makes
it really aggressive. The tip in was right there. This is that new rock that I bumped. I was just
about to say. And we cleared it. Clearance. We cleared it. The Ranger's got the clearance,
but it's definitely a harsher ride in here. It's definitely knocking me around a little bit more.
Here we go. Into the pit with the Ranger trimmer. There's that rock. Same one. Same one. So that's,
everything hits that rock though. Okay. Holy cow. Not bad, man. The water. Okay,
now we're coming up to the end of her. No problem. Oh, there was one there. There's
that rock on the tire. Oh, it's the one in the middle. But it's, oh yeah, there was just a rub.
Another skid plate rub there. That's okay. So we hit just about the same amount of rocks,
but at least one or two less. But that front one, I'd be willing to bet that was that shock mount
that we bumped. Because this thing cleared it and this thing, the shock mounts are
below the axle, but not nearly as far down as that Chevy. Well, there you go. I mean,
they both did good. And yeah, those are my takeaways so far. The clearance made a difference.
That mud mode definitely changed up the power bank. In the mud there, you had no hesitation.
Like even in, even with the four low in or the four high in the Chevy, it still was like,
I had to get into it. I had to tell it to go. This thing was like, Nope, Nope. Lots of power.
Yeah, it really, really was. Um, which I was a little surprised that I thought maybe it would
back off your throttle response, but obviously they figure you're going into mud. You need
maximum wheel spin, get the power to the ground. That's pretty cool. All right. Do we have a
downhill ascent control? Yes. So what we have here in the Ranger is called Ford's trail control
system. And this is a good time to use it. So trail control, you don't need to be on a hill.
Trail control is off-road cruise control. Okay. You turn it on. You use the set button here on
your steering wheel to set the speed. So I'm going to set the speed at four kilometers an hour.
Perfect. And now I remove my foot from the brake and the truck does everything else. It's going to
keep me right at four, regardless of the hill in front of you, up, down, doesn't matter. The hill
descent in the Chevy did great until this break over down here. When it felt me level off and
felt a little bit of roll, it just shut off. Because you do level off here. So it obviously
detected it. This is it right here. This shouldn't because this isn't dependent on the hill. See,
look how nice and slow it is. It just held it. It's a little sketch there, right? When it comes
over the top, it kind of lets you go. All right. Not bad. And then the best thing about these
systems is when you need the power, just put your foot into it and off you go. Just ready to go.
Ready to go in the mud. It's so deep. It's the bottom of the door. At least.
And last one. Oh, he's on his way through.
Getting deeper there. It's funny you try to avoid the ruts, but when you slip back in,
then it's more abrupt. Well, Matt, I think these trucks are really similar is one of the takeaways
I'm feeling. They both did good. They both feel capable. The Ranger, I think, did it a little bit
better. You're a little bit more. It's a little more harsh in the cab. We're getting thrown around
a little bit more. I'll give the Chevy that. So for suspension, it's Colorado. But for the
clearance, for the power out of this turbo and for the slightly bigger tires, just I'm a Ranger fan.
Overall confidence in the mud back there. I would say Ranger. Like I didn't I wasn't even driving
and I felt like, yeah, we're not getting stuck. Yeah, we're not getting stuck. Whereas in the
Colorado, I kind of had to I was on the I was on the gas. I was on the brake. I kind of had to
manage it. Now, high speed. I wouldn't. It's not a it's not a comparison. No,
it's got to be bashing my head off the roof. Totally glass. But over there, it eats everything.
Actually, to that vein, Matt, maybe let's rip back to the parking lot and we can talk about
going fast. Let's go for it. First, let's go fast here in the tremor. Now I'm just on my tight trail
so I can only go so quick. And that's a plus for both of these trucks. They're both so right size.
They fit on our trails really well. Now, here in the tremor, there's no doubt that the Fox
suspension is a big step above stock. But when the speeds start to pick up, yeah, it's still kind
of rough. Now, this thing gets hydraulic bump stops as well. So it really doesn't have those
big hits when it bottoms out. But I still would not call it an off road, a high speed off road
truck like I would the Chevy. Now let's go drive that one. And there's no denying it. One of the
things this ZR2 was built to do was go fast. And when the speeds do pick up, this Multimatic
suspension, it just swallows things up on the hydro line when you're going slow. It's also,
you know, quite plush. But when you really pick up your speed and you're smashing through these rocks,
man, this truck does such a nice job. And that is definitely one area where I would take ZR2
over Ranger Tremor. If you live in the desert and you're going really fast all the time,
you probably want to take the Chev. Well, folks, that is kind of it for this video.
These trucks are really well matched up, really similar feeling from behind the wheel.
And you saw them both take on the hydro line. They both did good. So we want to challenge them
further. We're taking them over to the left hook right now, which has probably got deeper mud,
a bit of a steeper hill, more rocks. We're going to really challenge them. But not in this video.
You're going to have to wait until part two comes out to see how these things handle on the left
hook. For now, that's it for this one. So go below, leave us a comment, hit like, hit subscribe,
hit join to become a member of the channel, and then come right back here to Truck King to see how
the rest of this day goes. See ya.
