The Housing Market Crisis of 2022 (Unaffordable Housing Prices)

Ask Your Financial Guru
89 followers
240 Video Views·Oct 22, 2022
So the housing market so far in 2022
is like a 5,000 piece jigsaw puzzle.
Homes are becoming less and less affordable
and some argue that they've already been that way
for quite some time.
According to data from Goldman Sachs,
the monthly median mortgage payment
is up almost 56% year over year.
That means if you're in the market for a new home
just a year ago on the same house,
you would have paid $1,100 for a monthly payment for,
now you're looking at closer
to a 1,700 monthly mortgage payment.
While homes are less affordable,
home prices across the board are still high
compared to the past year
with home prices up around 11% year to date
and up 44% since the pandemic.
The data is also showing
that even with this price appreciation,
the rate at which it's appreciating
is starting to cool off.
That is most attributed
to the crazy environment that we're in.
We have interest rates hitting their largest yearly increase
in the 30-year mortgage rate.
We'll explain what that means today.
We also have inflation running at 8%.
There's a war going on overseas
and gas prices are still at all-time highs.
The stock market remains down 18 to 20% year to date
and the cryptocurrency markets,
well, they're nowhere really to be found
compared to last year.
So many people naturally think
that the housing market is going to crash next,
but in this video,
we're gonna uncover a few factors with data
as to why many experts don't believe
that the housing market will crash.
Cool off, yes, but ultimately crash, no.
It's a puzzling situation,
but by the end of this video,
we're gonna make sense of it in the simplest of terms
and that 5,000 piece puzzle will be complete.
You'll be able to brag to your friends
that you put a puzzle together in one day,
even though the box says two to four years, eh, eh?
You'll have a clear understanding of how we got here,
where the housing market stands today
and what it means for you,
especially if you're in the market for a home like I am.
All right, so make sure you thumbs up the video,
especially if you liked that puzzle joke
and let's talk about how we got here.
So prior to the pandemic,
the 30-year US fixed mortgage rate
was sitting right around the 3.5% interest rate level.
The interest rate is the cost to borrow money from the bank.
Now, if you know nothing about mortgage rates,
3.5% is historically considered low.
If you were to borrow $500,000 on a 30-year fixed mortgage,
your monthly payment on this loan would be $22.45 a month.
At a 7% interest rate, however,
your monthly payment becomes $33.27
or about $1,100 more per month
just on the higher interest rate alone.
Make sure you remember these 3.5% and 7% numbers
because they will be important in just a little bit.
Now, at the onset of the pandemic,
what we had was just some widespread economic panic
among just overall panic in the market
because of the unknown.
And people were hoarding supplies such as toilet paper
and the economy shutting down
meant that money would not be changing hands.
If money stops changing hands,
people would lose their livelihoods and their jobs.
As a direct result of this economic shutdown,
the Federal Reserve and the government
enacted massive stimulus packages into the economy
and they also decreased the federal funds rate.
That rate is the cost for banks
to borrow money from other banks.
So they lowered the federal funds rate
by a total of 1.5% at their meetings
on March 3rd and March 15th of 2020.
These cuts lowered the fed funds rate
to a range of zero to 0.25%.
With rates that low,
that means the cost to borrow money became cheap.
When people can borrow money
and not have to pay any interest on it,
they naturally will just borrow more.
More money allows for the expansion of business
and more spending naturally occurs
because people are willing to make large purchases
with that borrowed money.
This spurs economic activity
and is overall a good thing for most people.
The stock market and asset prices
like real estate go upward.
This is good for a short period of time,
but nothing that great lasts forever.
The other thing going on at this time
was that the Federal Reserve
was buying US Treasuries and mortgage-backed securities.
I can explain more about these in a different video,
but essentially mortgage rates are determined
by the price of mortgage-backed securities,
the prime rate, which is affected by the federal funds rate,
and a whole lot more.
The Fed bought over $1.3 trillion
of mortgage-backed securities
from March of 2020 to March of 2022.
This insane level of buying by the Federal Reserve
drove mortgage-backed securities market to the moon,
leading to record low yields,
which then also resulted in record low mortgage rates.
In July of 2020, mortgage rates fell to below 3%
due to the Fed funds rate change and the purchasing of MBSs,
and ultimately hit lows of around 2.65% in January of 21,
according to this graph.
So homes were cheap to get mortgages for,
and what happens when mortgages are cheap?
Do you know?
Well, the easiest explanation
of how interest rates affect the housing market
is from Investopedia.
Quote, low interest rates
tend to increase demand for property, driving up prices,
while high interest rates generally do the opposite.
Now, notice how I said generally.
This is a foreshadowing for the rest of the video,
so stay tuned.
As of right now in 2022,
because the Fed exited the mortgage-backed securities market
and due to inflation running rampant at 8%
and the fears of the economy going into a recession,
the Federal Reserve has had to act more aggressively.
The Fed and Jerome Powell
decided to raise the federal funds rate
and even made the most aggressive interest rate hikes
since 1994 with a 0.75% hike in one Federal Reserve meeting.
Their main hope is to control inflation,
which seems to be the most pressing economic matter
right now.
By increasing rates,
the Fed is hoping that buying behavior
across the United States slows down,
resulting in less demand for goods in person
and bringing inflation down.
This is best illustrated by a small business example,
so let's pretend that you own a donut shop
and you want to expand that donut shop.
Personally, I'm a glazed donut guy myself,
but if you wanted to offer a full coffee bar
in addition to your donuts,
you need the funds to expand your business.
When interest rates are low,
you might be willing to borrow some money to do that,
especially if the bank is giving you a loan
to the tune of less than 3%.
So you borrow $100,000,
you create a full coffee bar with that $100,000,
and you might have to hire some contractors,
you have to buy coffee machines, coffee beans, et cetera.
All the money that you spent
is going straight into the economy,
and that is increased revenue for the entire supply chain.
If you think interest rates are gonna go up,
you won't pull the trigger right away on a loan,
you might think twice about borrowing that 100K
and you might wait for a better time in the market.
That should lower the overall demand from goods.
So that's the intention of raising interest rates
is to lower overall economic demand of goods
and hopefully lower inflation.
But the increase in the federal funds rate
also meant that mortgage rates
are going to be affected as well.
We're already seeing those mortgage rates
reflected across the board in the housing market.
So according to Freddie Mac, at the beginning of 2022,
the average 30-year mortgage rate was 3.11%.
At its peak in late June, the rate was 5.81%.
Now, higher interest rates
generally decrease demand for property,
thus lowering prices,
but our situation this year in 2022
is a little bit different.
On whether or not the housing market will collapse,
the answer is a little bit more nuanced
than just yes or no.
There's a possibility that the housing market
actually stays decently strong
relative to other investments,
such as stocks, bonds, and commodities.
And one thing most people will agree on
is that the housing market will at least cool down
from where it is right now.
Housing affordability is increasingly becoming
a huge challenge for many families.
So the National Association of Realtors
has a housing affordability index,
and it's currently at lows never seen before,
completely free-falling this year.
In this chart, the lower the number,
the less affordable homes are.
You can see that in January of 2021,
when mortgage rates were at their lows,
affordability was much higher.
But now that chart has completely changed its tune.
In October of 2021, about half of Americans
said that the availability of affordable housing
was a major problem where they live,
a bigger problem than the availability of jobs,
drug addiction, crime, and racism.
In that same survey, 70% of Americans
said young adults today have a harder time
buying a home than their parents' generations did.
This unaffordability, according to data,
is due to limited supply unable to meet rising demand,
resulting in higher prices.
Over the past three years,
home listings are down overall about 54%.
And at the same time,
the prices of sold homes in the United States
has increased by over 45%.
But here's another interesting question.
We know that interest rates are going up,
so that should cool off the demand for homes.
But with the low supply that we're facing,
will that lower demand mean anything for prices?
Let me use another simple example.
Let's say there are 80 farmers
looking for new John Deere tractors,
but there's a problem.
There's only 20 available for sale.
That means there are four farmers in the market
for every one tractor.
Now let's pretend the store selling the tractors
magically makes half the farmers disappear from buying them.
That still leaves 40 farmers for 20 tractors,
a ratio of two to one.
In other words, if home prices are going up
because of high demand,
then raising interest rates
could help bring prices back down
as the cost of borrowing increases.
But if prices are going up primarily
because supply is too tight,
like in our tractor example,
then raising interest rates won't be that impactful.
But there's something I've researched
that may make you think twice.
So a recent study by the Fed
found that the demand played a larger role
in home price appreciation, not supply.
Quote, fluctuations in demand
explain essentially all of the variation in home sales
and 80% of the variation in prices
between 2002 and 2021.
Since new construction typically accounts
for about 15% of supply,
our estimates imply that new construction
would have had to increase by roughly 300%
to absorb the pandemic era surge in demand.
Basically, what they found was that
because housing demand was so incredibly strong,
there was no way increasing supply
could have prevented such massive home price appreciation.
Thus, reducing demand should be the short-term focus
rather than increasing supply.
Plus, increasing supply will take years anyway.
So this can help explain
why the Fed wants to raise their Fed funds rate
because that will indirectly result
in a higher mortgage rate, which can tamper down demand.
As the study from the Fed states, quote,
we estimate that a one percentage point increase
in the mortgage rates lowers housing demand by 10.4%.
So since mortgage rates
have had their largest yearly increase ever,
that should mean that demand
should also have near record declines.
I decided to take a look at the existing home sales
and new home sales in the US
to see if there were any big changes this year.
Both existing and new home sales
have had their largest yearly decrease
since the global financial crisis in 2008.
So clearly, demand is decreasing
and at a pace consistent with the Fed's estimates.
With inflation still so high,
the Federal Reserve is going to continue
to raise interest rates.
In fact, the market is pricing
in four more rate hikes in 2022,
which means that we could be seeing a 7% mortgage rate
by the end of the year.
So remember when I mentioned the 3.5% versus 7% interest rate
at the beginning of this video,
that might actually become a reality for many home buyers
by the end of 2022.
Lastly, why is it possible that the housing market
actually stays decently strong
relative to other investments
like stocks, bonds, and commodities?
The reason is the structurally high demand
and over 10 years of under-building of homes
in the United States.
So this graph on the screen represents under-building
versus over-building of homes in the US.
Anything above the blue line indicates over-building
and anything below the blue line shows under-building.
From around 2001 to 2008,
you can see the number of homes being overbuilt
before the 2008 crisis.
You can see that right before the crisis,
we were building almost two homes
for every one home that we needed.
Now, since that recession,
you can see that from 2009-ish till now,
we have been under-building homes this entire time.
According to realtor.com, there are 45 million millennials
in their first time home buying ages,
and there's a deficit of around 5.24 million homes
through June of 2021, and that number is likely larger now.
So while demand is falling for now,
the long-term need for more housing is still there.
People are just waiting for the market to cool down.
You'll see that many Americans
are back living with their parents,
and the data shows that many people
are choosing to live with their family
because it's more cost-efficient.
So because there is so much long-term demand for housing,
even though the market may cool down
and decline in the short term,
the long-term outlook for housing is still quite positive.
Any decline in mortgage rates and home prices
will bring eager buyers swooping in quickly.
So I'm personally in the market for a starter home,
and I'm sitting on cash waiting to see
if home prices come down in the next six months,
if interest rates continue to go up.
With little demand,
I'm hoping that they do come down a little bit,
or I might just be weighing my options
on investment properties instead.
One thing I did want to mention
was to make sure to check out my free newsletter, Hump Days,
and that's where we cover the market and tech news
twice a week on Wednesdays and Sundays.
I hope that this video was helpful.
Let me know in the comments
what you think of the housing market,
and subscribe to my channel for more videos like these.
I'll also leave up another video at the end,
right here or right here that you might enjoy.
Okay, I'll see you guys in the next one.
Peace.
