WHY PAY MORE?! Apple Magic Keyboard vs Logitech Folio Touch

We Science Too
67 followers
30 Video Views·Oct 21, 2022
If like me, you use an iPad for work
or as a laptop replacement,
you're gonna need a keyboard.
The on-screen keyboard just isn't good enough
for any serious amount of typing.
The question shouldn't really be
whether to buy a keyboard,
it should be which one you're gonna buy.
If you're watching this video,
my guess is that you're interested in one
or both of these options.
So let's break these down,
talk about the good and the bad,
and see which one is the best fit for your iPad.
What's up guys, Sagi here,
and welcome to another Tech Gear Talk.
Today, we're gonna compare the Logitech Folio Touch
for the iPad Air 4 to the Apple Magic Keyboard.
I first got the Magic Keyboard,
used it for about a month,
and then Logitech asked if I would be interested
in reviewing the new Folio Touch.
I did partner with Logitech
and they did send me this keyboard
for my honest and impartial review.
And if you're not new to this channel,
you know that I always keep it real with you guys
and I share my actual user experience.
All right, so let's get to the keyboards.
Both are good options
and there are advantages and disadvantages to each one.
So my goal will be to share my real life experience
so that you can choose based on what's important to you.
The first thing I wanna talk about is the price,
because I think for most people,
this is a pretty significant purchase.
The Apple Magic Keyboard costs 300 bucks
and the Logitech Folio Touch costs 160 bucks.
So it's about half the price.
This is a pretty big difference
and you can actually buy a second generation Apple Pencil
for 130 bucks with the Logitech Folio Touch
and you'll still be at 10 bucks under the Magic Keyboard.
So if we're strictly shopping on price alone,
clearly the Folio Touch comes ahead,
but that's not really how I choose products.
I look at value and price
is really only one part of the equation.
We also know that Apple doesn't sell on price,
they sell on experience.
So let's talk about the typing experience.
And that's something that I sort of ignored
for years of programming.
I just used whatever keyboard I had
and I didn't really give it a second thought.
And then when I started using mechanical keyboards
and noticing how big a difference they made for me,
I started being much more aware
of how the keys feel and sound
and then how that impacts my overall user experience.
So let me open these up
so we can just take a quick look at the orientation here.
I'll just even prop this one up
so that they're kind of similar.
Both boards have backlit keyboards.
So the keys are easy to see even in the dark.
I'm gonna give the Folio Touch a slight edge here
because you can control the brightness level
with dedicated keys.
And we'll get to a lot more
of these shortcut function keys later on.
The keys on both boards have one millimeter of travel,
but the Folio Touch keys feel more like laptop keys.
I definitely prefer typing on them.
They seem to bounce back a little bit more.
And I also like the sound that they make better.
It was a little more clicky and less of a hollow thud
like on the Magic Keyboard.
Now I do have to admit that I'm actually someone
who likes clicky keys
and there's definitely an element of preference there.
So let's do a quick sound test.
All right, back to the feel of typing.
For me, I felt like my hands got fatigued more quickly
on the Magic Keyboard
because there's less feedback from the keys.
So you end up pressing them harder than you need to.
And in addition to that, there are some other reasons
that I'm gonna mention later on in the video.
The key layout on the Folio Touch
is a little over a quarter inch wider
than on the Magic Keyboard.
So it translates to an ever so slightly roomier configuration.
This isn't really a major difference, but it is there.
Now, an area where there is a significant difference
is the actual position of the keys
in relation to the bottom panel.
If you notice, the Magic Keyboard
has about an inch and a half of space at the top.
And then we get to the top row of keys.
The Folio Touch only has about a half an inch.
The reason why this is meaningful
is that the Folio Touch has much more room
for my hands to rest on,
and they're actually being supported by the board.
On the Magic Keyboard, my hands were either off the board
or they're resting right on the edge of the board,
which was not the most comfortable.
Now, when looking at the different places
where I actually type, either at a desk or on couch
or laying in bed,
I liked having this larger wrist rest
pretty much in every situation.
Now, this is a perfect transition into ergonomics
and the different modes and orientations
that each keyboard supports.
But one of the things that I like about the Magic Keyboard
is that because the iPad is floating,
there is tension in these two back joints,
so the keyboard doesn't need any support from the back.
That means that when you're in a tight space,
it's easier to use
because you don't need as much depth to work with.
I also like how thin and sleek this design is.
I have to admit that it looks great,
but it does have some practical drawbacks,
which I'll get to in a minute.
Now, the Folio Touch has a flap on the back,
which is both good and bad.
On the one hand,
it definitely requires more space to work with,
so it could be a limitation.
But on the other hand,
it does offer a lot more angles for the screen
when you're typing, which is a bonus.
With the Magic Keyboard,
there were times when I wanted it to be tilted back
just a little more and I couldn't
because the way the Magic Keyboard is designed
means that it's already top-heavy, right?
Because the iPad itself is heavier than the actual keyboard.
So if you have it on your lap at a slightly downward angle,
you sort of have to keep pressure down on the wrist rest
to keep it from tipping back.
And when you remove your hands,
you have to be careful that it doesn't tip over.
Think that if they made it tilt up any more than this,
it would be a real problem
anytime you weren't on a flat surface,
and that's why they limited it to where it is.
Now, using the Folio Touch on your lap,
you don't run into the tipping issue,
but you will need to have the board closer to you
because this back flap needs to be supported.
Other than typing mode,
the Folio Touch can also be put into viewing mode,
which is sort of like a pyramid.
So it's like that.
And now we have a smaller footprint
that's similar to what we have with the Magic Keyboard,
except that it's better balanced
and it offers more viewing angles.
Now, you can't type in this mode,
but you can use this to view content.
Now, if I push the Folio Touch to the limit in this position,
which is right around there,
then I get to sketch mode, which is great for drawing
or for when I'm using the Apple Pencil in Lightroom
or editing in LumaFusion.
I like having it at this slight angle
rather than flat on the desk
because I don't have to lean over as much
when I'm using the pencil.
Now, this obviously isn't something
that you can do with the Magic Keyboard.
I have seen some people use it like this,
and so technically you can.
I mean, you have the keyboard sort of in front of you.
I'm gonna say that you can, but it's not the best.
But most of the time, what I see people do
is if they want it flat on the desk,
they just take it right off the Magic Keyboard
and they put it down.
Personally, I'd be worried about the camera getting scratched
but I always say that I'm not like
the most careful person with tech,
so that could just be me.
And that brings me to the last mode, which is Read.
And this is where we can flip this down,
flip everything like this,
and now I can use the Folio Touch
like I would a normal tablet and I can use it to read.
That's another thing that you can't do
with the Magic Keyboard.
Again, you can take the iPad out,
but now there's no protection
and we're gonna keep this board
while you're using the iPad.
And is this gonna be next to you when you're done
and you wanna put it back?
So I don't really see that as an ideal solution.
If you're the kind of user who doesn't mind
having the iPad without a case
and you only wanna use the keyboard at your desk
for everything else,
you're fine with just having a naked iPad Air 4,
then the Magic Keyboard is great.
It's much easier to remove the iPad
because it's only held in place by the magnet.
So taking it out and putting it back
on the Magic Keyboard is quicker.
I don't trust myself without some sort of a case,
which means that if I took it out of the Magic Keyboard,
I'd have to put it in another case
and that's just not gonna happen.
And speaking of protecting the iPad,
the Folio Touch is hands down the better option.
Both keyboards protect the front and the back,
but the Folio Touch being thicker
definitely adds another level of protection
with additional padding.
You can see that the camera is inset quite a bit.
So you'd really have to place it on something
that would protrude and fit through that hole
in order for it to get damaged.
The Folio Touch also has a bumper going all the way around.
So the top, bottom and sides of the iPad Air 4 are protected.
Whereas with the Magic Keyboard,
the one side is protected,
but the other side, the top and the bottom are exposed.
And the camera is only slightly
below the surface of the back.
You don't need to worry about the camera getting damaged
on the Magic Keyboard if you put it on a flat surface,
but it is much more exposed than with the Folio Touch.
One of the things I love about the iPad Air 4
is the Apple Pencil 2 compatibility.
It's great that you can just pair
and charge the pencil wirelessly.
And I like the fact that it attaches to the iPad itself.
With the Magic Keyboard, the pencil is exposed.
So when I put it in my bag or take it out,
unless I'm really being careful,
the pencil usually falls out.
With the Folio Touch, there is a magnetic strap
that goes over the Apple Pencil
and snaps onto the back of the case.
So the pencil can still charge, but it won't come loose.
Also because of the bumper,
the pencil is deeper into the case.
So it's more protected.
Now the strap does mean that when you're typing,
you need to flip it over
and let the magnet snap into the back
so that it's not like flopping around like this.
That's something that you don't need to do
with the Magic Keyboard,
but I'll take that extra step
over having to worry about losing my Apple Pencil.
The strap also has a little cutout right there inside of it.
If you wanna use an Apple Pencil alternative
like the Logitech Crayon.
Now, moving on, I wanna talk about the power source.
So both keyboards use the smart connector
to get their power from the iPad Air 4.
So you don't need to worry about charging either one of them.
And again, you don't have to worry
about replacing a battery.
The Magic Keyboard has the advantage here
with a USB-C pass-through on the bottom of the board.
I really like this feature
and I wish that it was available on the Folio Touch
because it allows me to have the charging cable
flat on the desk,
rather than hanging from the side of the iPad Air 4.
It also means that I can charge the iPad
and use another accessory like an external SSD
without using a USB-C hub.
When I use the Folio Touch,
I use a small USB-C hub
so that I can still power the iPad Air 4
and connect an SD card, external SSD,
or even an external monitor.
Now I wanna talk about the trackpads,
which are available with both boards.
Here I had mixed feelings
and depending on how you use your trackpad,
you're gonna like one of these over the other.
The Folio Touch trackpad is bigger than the Magic Keyboard.
It's a tiny bit narrower,
but it is deeper because of the larger wrist rest.
But then I realized that the top of the board
can't be clicked.
It's only as you get about a quarter of the way down
that it starts to click
and you have to press pretty hard.
Now, as you move down, it requires less and less force
and it's perfect as you get closer to the bottom.
On the other hand,
the trackpad on the Magic Keyboard
clicks perfectly everywhere
and it seems to require a little less force,
which is more comfortable to use.
So if you actually like to press your trackpad,
the Magic Keyboard is a better option.
I almost missed this difference
because I don't like clicking the trackpad
and if you saw my 10-day review of the iPad Air 4,
I mentioned that I immediately turned on tap to click
on the Magic Keyboard
because it's how I prefer to use the trackpad.
And because I enabled it before I got the Folio Touch,
I almost didn't notice
that you can't press the top of the trackpad.
And both trackpads fully support gestures,
so you can maximize your productivity.
Both are accurate and responsive
and both contribute to a laptop-like user experience.
If you like actually pressing down on the trackpad,
you're gonna like the trackpad on the Magic Keyboard.
If you're a tap-to-click kind of person like me,
you'll prefer the larger trackpad on the Folio Touch
with a larger and more comfortable wrist rest.
All right, so now I wanna get to this extra row
of shortcut or function keys,
which is something that I really liked
about my slim Folio for my iPad 8.
At the top of the Folio Touch,
you can see an extra row of keys
that quickly performs iPadOS shortcuts
without having to use key combinations.
If you saw my iPad keyboard shortcuts video,
I showed you how to do things
like bring up the spotlight search,
quickly go to the home screen,
and a few other shortcuts like switching between apps
and taking screenshots.
Plus, I covered how you can see
every single shortcut available in every app.
What I absolutely love about the Folio Touch
is that some of those shortcuts
are available with a single dedicated key,
plus we have some features that are not available
using traditional keyboard shortcuts.
So you can go to the home screen,
control the screen brightness,
show or hide the on-screen keyboard,
bring up iPadOS search, control key brightness,
and we also have a full set of media keys
with back, play, pause, forward, mute,
and volume up and down controls.
And then at the end, we have a screen lock key,
which turns the iPad screen on or off.
For me, being able to change the brightness of the screen
or quickly hit the mute button when I get a phone call
without having to interact with the buttons
or with the iPad control center,
those are the types of features
that contribute to a better real-life user experience.
All right, so let's put this whole thing together.
If you want a sleek and minimalistic design
with less moving parts,
you like to press down on your trackpad,
you want USB-C pass-through for charging,
which is really nice,
if you want a smaller footprint when typing,
you often remove the iPad Air 4 from the keyboard
to use it without a case,
and 300 bucks is in your budget,
then the Magic Keyboard sounds like it's a good fit for you.
If you prioritize functionality
with four different modes designed for typing,
sketching, using an Apple Pencil, viewing, and reading,
if you want to better protect your iPad Air 4
and Apple Pencil while at the same time,
you want a better and more comfortable typing experience,
a larger trackpad,
and all of those awesome shortcut function keys at the top,
all for 160 bucks, which is essentially half the price,
then the Logitech Folio Touch is the iPad keyboard for you.
I'm always curious about the types of features
that are deciding factors for you guys.
So please let me know which you like better and why.
And if I miss something that you'd like to know
about each one of these,
again, let me know in the comment section.
It will help me create better reviews
and comparisons for you in the future.
I'll put links in the description
to where you can buy both keyboards
as well as the accessories I mentioned in this video.
I really hope that I was able to give you a good comparison
between the Apple Magic Keyboard
and the Logitech Folio Touch.
If I did, please let me know
by giving this video a thumbs up,
tweet it, share it, and if you haven't yet,
join the community by hitting the subscribe
and notification buttons.
You can always find me on Instagram, Twitter,
and Facebook at Techier Talk.
You know what I always say, buy it nice or buy it twice.
Good luck and see you soon.
