These Are the LEAST (and MOST Safe) New Trucks You Can Buy Today!

Barely a Dent
19 followers
Oct 21, 2022
In this video I'm going to show you all the crash tests and actually rank the five major full-size
halftone trucks in the United States. So let's start with the number five which is a Toyota
Tundra and here on my screen I'm showing you some of the data from IHS. As you can see the truck is
struggling with a small overlap front test on the driver's side and especially on the passenger side
with a poor rating and this is mainly because some of these tests were added after the Toyota
Tundra was designed. So the Toyota Tundra has been redesigned a couple times over the last
12 years or so but the overall chassis and structure of the truck remain mostly the same
although the face and the grille and some of the tech has been changing. So that's a challenge for
the Tundra. The other challenge for the Tundra is the roof strength. It's rated acceptable in this
case and the roof strength test is done in a lab at IHS. It's basically a giant plate that's
pushing down on the a-pillar in the roof section and it's measuring how much force it takes to
actually deflect the roof and in this case Toyota can withstand about 3.94 times its curb weight
and it's not the worst rating actually but closer to the bottom. But really the
main reason why it's in number five is because of that marginal and poor rating in the front
overlap crash tests. The headlights are marginal which is actually not the worst but Toyota
recently added crash prevention tech on the new Tundra so it's actually doing well. It has a
superior crash prevention rating from IHS and they do collision warning system checks and also 15
and 22 mile an hour front collision avoidance and the Tundra has passed those tests.
Moving on to number four and here we have the Nissan Titan. The Titan has been redesigned in
2017 so it's a newer design, newer chassis, newer body so it's doing a little bit better than the
Tundra but still it's at number four and here I'm showing you some of the overall ratings.
It's doing really well actually in front overlap also side and roof strength test. On the roof
strength it's actually can withstand about 4.55 times its curb weight with the overall weight
rating for the roof at 24,857 pounds so it's better than the Tundra by about 3,000 pounds
as far as crash strength on the roof so that's not too bad but Nissan is struggling in one main
area and that is the crash prevention technology and we're I'm not talking about like 360 degree
camera which the Titan has or the blind spot monitoring which the Titan also has but this
is basically front collision warning at slower speeds and actually crash avoidance technology
which combines some of the radar technologies sometimes some of the camera technologies
together. According to IHS the trucks they tested did not have that which kind of brings the truck
way down. In order to get the coveted top safety pick plus rating from IHS you have to have a good
rating in all the crash tests and also the headlight has to be acceptable or good and you
have to have crash prevention technology enabled and actually have a good rating or superior rating
in that category. If you're missing any one of those items including the headlights you cannot
get that top safety pick plus which is really important and Nissan misses the mark just with
that crash prevention technology although it actually has a marginal rating not the poor
rating on the headlights. And at the number three spot are the GM trucks the redesigned 2019 Chevy
Silverado and the GMC Sierra. I'm mainly going to be showing you guys the Silverado truck
although the Sierra basically has the same rating so here's the Silverado on my screen
and here's the Sierra. You might be surprised that the new redesigned Silverado which just was
redesigned for 2019 it's an all-new truck basically has good crash ratings except for one
the small overlap passenger side test which is one of the newest tests and there are a couple
of small issues there and the issues are the structure and safety cage integrity on the
passenger side and during that test and also the lower leg rating so they use test dummies for
crash tests and they measure force for like the head torso and leg areas and according to IHS
for the passenger in the front small overlap test the leg or lower leg and foot area could
be compromised so it has an acceptable doesn't have the best rating there. Roof strength is still
pretty good 4.62 times the curb weight of the truck. Headlight ratings of course is an issue
and I say of course because it's kind of an issue across the board for all the pickup trucks here
and it gets a poor rating in this case and here's what IHS says about the headlight rating for the
GM Silverado and Sierra trucks. Straight away visibility is good but in curves the visibility
is fair for the left but inadequate for the right curves and GM trucks do not have a curve assist
headlights which means the headlights don't actually swivel or change the light pattern
side to side. Number two on the list is the Ford F-150. Once again it's been redesigned several
years ago 2015 the all-aluminum F-150 came on the scene and largely that structure that body
and that frame is still around. Initially when that new truck was rated by IHS it had issues
on the passenger side front crash ratings but they fixed that. They also had some wheel intrusion
on the driver's side issues and they fixed that once again with certain frame components to
protect the passenger compartment of that truck. Once again we're talking about only crew cap
trucks in this case so they have good ratings in basically all of those crash tests. So small
overlap front driver's side and passenger side all good moderate overlap front side roof strength
roof strength for the F-150 is actually one of the best or the best in this group it can withstand
5.85 times its curb weight up to 27,215 pounds of force on that A-pillar. The headlight ratings of
course is what brings this truck down and this is why it's at number two spot here on our list
is because the headlight performance is poor and IHS says this visibility was inadequate on
straightaways and then all four curve tests as well and this includes low and high beams. They
also tested different lights with the Ford Raptor F-150 Raptor and the lights were also rated poorly
in that configuration. They worked a little bit better on the straightaway in the Raptor but
had a lot of issues in their curve tests as far as light pattern but the F-150 of course has the
latest crash mitigation technology and so it's there on the cusp of getting the top safety pick
plus rating but it didn't get it. And at number one is the Ram 1500 and mainly it's at number one
because the 2020 model year that just came out this fall got a small update for the headlight
functionality and it actually pushed them to a better headlight rating to good rating on the
headlights and that allowed this truck to get this coveted rating the top safety pick plus rating. So
let's just go over really quickly what's going on here with the Ram. Obviously it's redesigned
brand new for 2019 before the truck had some crash test issues to say the least and those
issues were partially with the roof strength as well but now the Ram gets good marks across the
board except there's a couple of nicks in the armor. The lower leg area for the small overlap
driver's side test gets a marginal rating and the small overlap passenger test the structure the
cage of the truck gets an acceptable rating not good but once again it has much improved roof
strength rating of good it can withstand up to 4.24 times its curb weight for the roof strength
that's up from 2.97 times for the previous generation of the Ram and the headlights are
good but only there's a catch only for the long horn and limited upper trim levels of the truck
so the picture you see here is the top limited truck and it has those more squinty headlights
but they also have curve assist so the light pattern actually swivels with the steering
also have high beam assist several other trucks on this list also have high beam assist but
that particular headline arrangement with a 2020 model year update is that good rating
these headlights performed well in the straightaway test but not everything was perfect
the light pattern was inadequate on the gradual left turn on the Ram trucks and that's really
what separated it from the Ford and the GM trucks and go back to tfltruck.com for my news views and
real world truck reviews
