How close were we to nuclear war?

Binkov's Battlegrounds
1.4K followers
2 Video Views·Oct 21, 2022
During the Cold War, the United States and the Soviet Union battled for global dominance.
The main reason they never fought directly was because of their nuclear arsenal.
Both superpowers had thousands of thermonuclear weapons ready to destroy their enemies at a
moment's notice. It is easy to forget how the world almost ended in atomic annihilation.
And not just because of international tensions. Technical glitches, human mistakes,
unfortunate accidents and more all tested the people overseeing the weapons of mass destruction.
But not all of those incidents were equally dangerous.
Throughout this video, we will be using our special atomic annihilation scale
to judge the relative danger of those incidents, with one being the least dangerous one
and five being the edge of full on nuclear apocalypse.
So get ready for an exploration of world war threes that almost happened.
Hey, check out my new look!
Thanks to our sponsor, Established Titles, you can now refer to Commissar Binkov as
Lord. According to historic Scottish custom, that means I'm a landowner.
Here's my official certificate with a crest and one square foot of dedicated land on a
private estate in Eddleston, Scotland. It has a unique plot number so I can easily see its location.
If possible, I can add a lord or lady title to my credit card, plane ticket or dating profile.
But it's no vanity project. It helps preserve the natural woodlands of Scotland
and supports global reforestation. With every order, they plant trees around the world,
with global charities One Tree Planted and Trees for the Future.
The first 200 people purchasing a title pack using my link will be next to my plot,
so maybe we can build our little Binkov kingdom.
It makes for a fun last minute gift. Established Titles is running an early
black friday sale right now. Plus, if you use the code BINKOV, you'll get an additional 10%
off. Go to establishedtitles.com slash binkov and make your friends lords.
In the early decades of the cold war, nuclear deterrence heavily relied on strategic bombers
armed with atom bombs. Since the Soviet Union could attack at any time, the US Air Force
had to have some planes in the air at all times if a retaliatory strike became necessary.
This never-ending air vigilance led to numerous accidents involving nuclear weapons.
In January 1961, a Boeing B-52 Stratofortress broke apart in air near Goldsboro, North Carolina,
dropping two Mark 39 nuclear bombs with a yield of around 4 megatons each.
Fortunately, they remained intact. In a similar incident in January 1962,
another Stratofortress crashed near Savage Mountain in Maryland,
with two nuclear bombs on board. While certainly dramatic,
accidents like these seem minor compared to the possible horrors of nuclear warfare.
Bombs aren't really designed to detonate on their own in a crash.
And even if somehow the crashes resulted in nuclear explosions,
those incidents would not have led to a nuclear war. As nothing even exploded,
those incidents on our atomic annihilation scale count as a one.
Other incidents were slightly more serious. In March 1958, the crew of a Boeing B-47
Stratojet accidentally released a Mark 6 nuclear bomb near Mars Bluff, South Carolina.
With a weight of over 3.5 tons, the device was still dangerous even without its fissile core.
The bomb crashed onto an empty children's treehouse and detonated its conventional explosive.
In January 1968, a Boeing B-52 crashed near the Thule base at Greenland
after its crew cabin caught fire. Conventional explosives inside its four B-28 thermonuclear
bombs detonated, spreading their radioactive material around the vast area of ice and sea.
In a similar incident in January 1966, another Stratofortress crashed near Palomares, Spain.
The bomber plane carried four B-28 nuclear bombs. While two of them remained intact,
conventional explosives within the other two bombs detonated,
spreading radioactive material over a wide area. Despite the effort of cleaning crews,
traces of radioactive contamination remained long after the incident.
Nuclear bombs can be dangerous even without a nuclear explosion.
Detonation of conventional explosives inside the device can spread the radioactive material
over a wide area, acting like a dirty bomb. Surprisingly, incidents like those seem to
have rarely escalated international tensions. At least among superpowers. Because of this,
these accidents still measure no more than a one on our atomic annihilation scale.
So, what merits a two on our scale? Mostly incidents with malfunctioning
early warning systems during peacetime. And there were a lot of those. By the 1950s,
the United States was investing heavily into a sophisticated early warning system that could
alarm its armed forces in a case of a Soviet nuclear attack. Working with their allies in
Canada and Western Europe, they established a series of long-range radar stations monitoring
the movement of air units. This is how North American Aerospace Defense Command, or NORAD,
came to be. The assembled data was then partially analyzed by Semi-Automatic Ground Environment
System, a series of state-of-the-art computers housed in large block houses that could withstand
an explosion. A network of telephones, teleprinters and early modems connected various sites.
However, the more complex the system is, there's a bigger chance of malfunctions.
Especially if the technology is new. In November 1961, Strategic Air Command
headquarters lost contact with NORAD and early warning sites at Alaska, Greenland and Great
Britain. So either the communication with three separate stations failed simultaneously,
or the Soviets were cutting them off to prevent warnings about an upcoming nuclear attack.
In response, B-52 bomber crews were alerted to prepare for a takeoff.
But then a bomber orbiting near the Thule base at Greenland reported there was no attack. It
turned out that their relay station in Colorado overheated and stopped working,
thus cutting off the Strategic Air Command from others.
Malfunctioning equipment caused several alarms in May and June 1980. Displays in command centers
at NORAD, Pentagon and elsewhere began showing a variety of enemy missiles. Personnel soon
realized the alarm was false. Several days later, while the matter was still under investigation,
the same warning happened again. The cause was a worn out computer chip, worth 46 cents.
Astronomical phenomena also played havoc with electronic equipment.
In October 1960, the United States early warning radar at the Thule base
reported that the Soviet Union launched dozens of missiles carrying nuclear bombs.
People at NORAD were skeptical, especially since Nikita Khrushchev, Soviet leader at the time,
was visiting New York. The radar station misinterpreted the moonrise in Norway.
Then the computer banks interpreted the data as an all-out attack.
By the mid-1960s, the effects of solar flares on electronic equipment
were still a relatively novel idea. These are intense bursts of high energy radiation.
A solar flare can disrupt things like radio communication or even power grids.
In May 1967, a powerful flare jammed early warning radar sites in Alaska, Greenland and Britain.
Fortunately, since the 1950s, NORAD had hired scientists to report on solar activity.
They helped diffuse the tension and prevent a retaliatory strike.
Accidents like these may not seem as dramatic as strategic bombers
dropping their nukes over the United States. However, they are in fact more dangerous.
If the soldiers, technicians and engineers don't interpret the incoming data correctly,
the result won't be a single nuclear explosion, but an all-out thermonuclear assault.
On our atomic annihilation scale, such incidents rank as a two.
Sometimes a simple human mistake can cause a serious incident.
In 1979, commanders at NORAD received information from several radar stations
indicating the beginning of a full-scale nuclear attack by the Soviet Union.
As was the procedure, American strategic bombers readied for takeoff,
while crews working on international ballistic missiles went on high alert.
The US president had just about six or so minutes,
the approximate time before the Soviet strike, to order a counterattack.
Unlike in previous cases we talked about, this time it was the early
warning stations that proved that the alarm was false.
So, what caused it? A technician accidentally loaded an operation computer
with a training tape containing a scenario for a large-scale nuclear attack.
Due to the US actually reacting to what they thought was a real threat,
this incident gets a three on our atomic annihilation scale.
We talked a lot about nuclear mishaps involving the United States.
But what about accidents in the Soviet Union? Don't worry, we got you covered.
Reports about similar incidents behind the Iron Curtain are rare.
This isn't due to the Red Army's impeccable record regarding nuclear safety,
but because in the Soviet Union it was considerably easier to cover up embarrassing accidents.
And yet, both the Soviet Union, and later Russia,
came dangerously close to launching a nuclear attack on several occasions.
The early 1980s were a tense period for relations between the US and the USSR.
In September 1983, Lieutenant Colonel Stanislav Petrov
was a duty officer at the Command Center for OCO, the Soviet Nuclear Early Warning System.
When the system reported that Americans launched up to six ICBMs from the continental United States,
procedure demanded Petrov promptly inform his superiors.
Instead, his gut instinct told him this was a false alarm.
It didn't make sense for Americans to commence a nuclear war by launching just six missiles.
In addition, he knew the early warning system was new and barely tested.
Petrov was right. Later investigations showed that the early warning system
mistook a rare alignment of sunlight on high altitude clouds with the high orbits of Soviet
satellites. However, the commanders couldn't reward Petrov without admitting the new system
had flaws. Instead, they reprimanded him for not submitting proper paperwork.
The incidents continued into the post-Cold War era. In 1995, Russian President Boris Yeltsin
activated the nuclear briefcase after radars detected an ICBM launch near Norway.
Russian ballistic missile submarines were on alert. The missile in question was Black
Brand 12, a research rocket with which Norwegians used to study the Northern Lights.
Norwegians informed Russia and other countries about the launch weeks before,
but Russian radar crews never received that information.
As with similar US cases, these incidents rank 2 on our atomic annihilation scale.
They could be dangerous, but there are worse things yet to come.
Until now, we have examined how chance accidents, technological glitches and
airplane crashes could have caused nuclear explosions or even lead to full-scale attacks.
But all these problems get compounded when you account for the human factor.
Case in point, in 1956, Egyptian President Gamal Abdel Nasser nationalized the Suez Canal,
one of the busiest trade routes in the world. On October 29, 1956, Britain, France and Israel
launched a joint attack to take control of the canal. This caused an international uproar.
The Soviet Union threatened to target London and Paris with its missiles, unless the fighting
ceased. There was legitimate fear the Soviets might enter the war on the side of Egypt.
On November 5, 1956, NORAD spotted unidentified planes that were flying over Turkey. Even worse,
a hundred Soviet combat jets were flying over Syria. An English Electric Canberra
plane crashed in the same area. And a Soviet Black Sea fleet was sailing through the Dardanelles,
towards Egypt. It seemed as if the Soviets were getting ready to enter the war.
However, each of these warnings was false. Unidentified airplanes over Turkey turned
out to be a flock of birds. The Canberra bomber had to land due to technical problems.
The Soviet fleet was performing scheduled maneuvers. As for hundred mig planes over Syria,
their number was much smaller. And they were escorting the Syrian president home from Moscow,
a routine procedure. Eventually, what prevented the Suez crisis from escalating further
was that the United States and the Soviet Union successfully pressured France,
Israel and the United Kingdom to abandon their plans.
Even at the best of times, people who operate the nuclear arsenal carry a great responsibility.
And when political tensions escalate to a full-blown international crisis,
they find themselves under enormous pressure. In addition, the response time to a nuclear attack
is short. Less than ten minutes. Combined, all this can understandably lead to frayed nerves
and panic mistakes. This is why events like the Suez crisis weren't a three on our atomic
annihilation scale. In October 1973, another major crisis in the Middle East almost caused
a nuclear war. The Yom Kippur War began when a coalition of Arab states, led by Egypt and Syria,
launched a massive surprise attack on Israel. Attacked from all sides, Israel's existence
was at stake. In response, the country's president, Golda Meir, authorized the armament of
20 kiloton tactical nuclear weapons. These could be delivered either by Jericho ballistic missiles
or Israeli combat jets. The United States quickly sent military aid to Israel, even as the Soviet
Union began sending equipment and armament to Egypt and Syria. As Israelis halted the enemy
offensive and launched a counterattack, Egyptian President Anwar Sadat asked the USSR for direct
military assistance. Such a move by the Soviets would have inevitably escalated the crisis further,
even up to World War III. Based on their intelligence, Americans also worried the
Soviets might be sending tactical nuclear warheads to arm Egypt's Scud missiles. Eventually, however,
the crisis ended thanks to Israeli military victories and the intense US diplomacy between
Egypt, Israel and the Soviet Union. Interestingly, this time weren't as many false alarms as during
the Suez Crisis. The most notable one happened at Kinshol Air Force Base, Michigan, where a
mechanic accidentally triggered an alarm system throughout the entire base, alerting the crews of
strategic bombers. Luckily, the duty officer quickly realized what was happening. The Yom
Kippur War had an international component, as the United States and Soviet Union were arming the
belligerents. Since Israel felt at one point that it was on the brink of defeat, there was a realistic
possibility it might deploy its nuclear arsenal, as a last ditch effort against its enemies. Indeed,
warheads were placed on the delivery systems, waiting in high alert status. Ultimately,
the fact Israel armed its nukes alerted and pressured the US into sending massive and
urgent military aid to Israel. Had Israel used nukes, the USSR might have responded by supporting
Egypt and Syria via nuclear weapons, that could have triggered World War 3. This is why this
crisis warrants a four on our atomic annihilation scale. All this brings us to the ultimate
international crisis of the Cold War. The Cuban Missile Crisis. In 1962, the United States deployed
ICBMs in Italy and Turkey. The Soviet Union matched them by placing their missiles in Cuba,
just 140 kilometers from Florida. In October 1962, Americans responded by ordering a naval blockade,
threatening to either board or sink any Soviet ship approaching Cuba that could be carrying
nuclear missiles. On October 24th, a newly launched Soviet satellite exploded as it entered orbit,
causing some concern at NORAD that the USSR was launching an ICBM attack. The next day,
October 25th, a guard at the Duluth Sector Direction Center saw a figure climbing the
security fence. He shot at it and then activated the sabotage alarm, setting off similar alarms
at all bases in the area. But at Volk Field, Wisconsin, the broken alarm signaled the pilots
to take off in their nuclear-armed F-106 interceptors. Pilots assumed this wasn't a
since they were already on high alert. The command had to send a car to stop the planes
as they were starting down the runway. As for the intruder climbing the wire fence at Duluth,
it was a bear. But the near misses don't stop there. That same day, the Soviets detected an
American U-2 spy plane over Siberia. Commanders ordered the U-2 to retreat from the Soviet airspace,
but not before their MiGs took off to intercept it. The US Air Force sent 102 jets to protect
the spy plane that lost all of its fuel and had to glide towards Alaska. The US jets were to
prevent the Soviet planes from entering US airspace. They carried AIM-26 Falcon air-to-air
missiles with nuclear warheads. While these warheads weren't powerful, their use in combat
could have set a dangerous precedent for future aerial dogfights. On October 26th,
there were two separate test launches of US-made intercontinental ballistic missiles. At the time,
US armed forces were at DEFCON 3. This meant all ICBMs had to carry nuclear warheads,
a procedure Soviets likely knew of. But did they know that these two missiles didn't have
nuclear warheads? The first ICBM was launched from Vanderberg Air Force Base, California.
The second one was launched from Florida. This caused some concern at the radar site in Moorestown,
New Jersey, before they plotted the missile's course and realized it would land in the Pacific
Ocean. Just two days later, on October 28th, the Moorestown radar site caused alarm when its
operators warned NORAD about an imminent nuclear strike near the city of Tampa, Florida. At the
time, the station was running software simulating a missile launch from Cuba. Furthermore, operators
mistook a satellite rising above the horizon for an enemy ICBM. Finally, the other radar station
that would have double-checked Moorestown claims was working on something else. Meanwhile,
a radar station in Laredo mistook a satellite for Soviet ICBMs targeting Georgia.
But possibly the most severe incident during the Cuban Missile Crisis in 1962
involved the Soviet submarine B-59. It belonged to a detachment of diesel-electric submarines
sent by the USSR as part of their naval forces. Pursued by the aircraft carrier USS Randolph
and 11 US destroyers for days, B-59 lost contact with the surface and Moscow.
The US ships began dropping depth charges, attempting to force the submarine to the
surface as it was worried the submarine was breaking the imposed blockade. With no information
regarding the international political situation, the commanding officers aboard B-59 started
arguing about reacting to the depth charges. Captain Valentin Savitsky and the political
officer Ivan Maslennikov wanted to fire a T-5 torpedo armed with a 5-kiloton nuclear warhead
at US ships. But the captain Vasily Arkhipov, who commanded the entire submarine detachment,
opposed them. The situation was desperate since the batteries were running out,
and crew members began losing consciousness due to the lack of oxygen. Ultimately,
Arkhipov convinced Savitsky to surface and re-establish contact with Moscow.
Eventually, B-59 surfaced amid US ships, realized World War III didn't break out,
and altered their course towards the Soviet Union.
Incidents like these brought the world to the brink of World War III. Individually,
most of them weren't that serious, but in the middle of a global political crisis,
these mishaps piled up as people succumbed to pressure. The Cuban Missile Crisis brought the
world dangerously close to total nuclear war. This is why it gets a 5 on our atomic annihilation
scale. Since the detonation of the first atomic device back in 1945, there have been many
incidents involving nuclear technology. Throughout decades of the Cold War and beyond, there were too
many accidents that could have led to countries using atomic weapons to strike first or retaliate.
All the incidents we talked about show that the people operating and maintaining such dangerous
technology are prone to the same weaknesses as everyone else. Training and discipline
can only go so far. As for the technology itself, it is also prone to malfunctions.
The military developed elaborate procedures and system redundancies to remedy these challenges.
As for the deliberate use of nuclear weapons as an intimidation tactic,
that remains a reckless gambit. So called atomic diplomacy can all too easily escalate
beyond the control of those who initiated it and blow up in their faces. For example,
the current military and political events may lead the whole world to a very sensitive situation.
Repeated mentions and vague threats about nuclear weapons usage have already happened.
It's quite conceivable that if the current situation doesn't go the way Russia wants,
and if the Russian government doesn't see a way out, pressured by western governments in
multiple areas, that Russia might actually resort to using tactical nuclear weapons
on the local battlefield. Right now, since that hasn't happened,
Binkov believes we're still at level 4 of our atomic annihilation scale. But if such nukes
are used, then we'd go further than we've ever been on the said scale,
farther than even in the Cuban Missile Crisis. How would the west respond? Would it use its
own tactical nukes? And where would it use from? Those are all questions that perhaps
better remain unanswered.
