Heisman Race: CJ Stroud vs Hendon Hooker, is the race over if Hooker beats Georgia? | SNAPS

Sports News
153 followers
7 Video Views·Oct 20, 2022
As we go down some potential college football rabbit holes here on this Tuesday, October 18th,
there is one, Aaron, that I thought was very clear just recently. I mean, I think we did a
segment on this last week and now all of a sudden it's heated up and that is the Heisman discussion
and there's two lead dogs right now and it's the top two rated quarterbacks in the entire country.
It's CJ Stroud and it's Hendon Hooker. Aaron, who has a better chance to win the Heisman trophy?
Is it Stroud or is it Hooker? I think Hendon has the better chance to win the Heisman because we
talk about Heisman moments and he already had the big first blow. I mean, he had the big haymaker
this weekend versus Alabama and you already see that in the odds. I don't know exactly where he
was last week, but right now if you go on FanDuel, he's moved up to plus 440 when it comes to Heisman
and I think he was somewhere in the thousands last week, so it's a significant jump for him.
CJ Stroud is still plus 100 with the odds right now, but I just think there are going to be more
Heisman moment opportunities for Hendon, but that also means that it's going to be a lot
harder for him to overcome that and to win those football games. You look at their schedule,
they're going to have to face, they've already had games versus ranked Florida, LSU,
and obviously the win versus Alabama. You have a chance to win versus Kentucky,
who's a ranked team. The game versus Georgia is going to be another epic game,
similar to what we saw this past weekend, and then possibly facing Alabama again.
Those are three more opportunities, two more against top six, seven teams in the country
to make a statement on the biggest stage in front of the country. So I think he's going
to have more moments to shine. Where you look at that CJ right now, they got the game versus
Penn State, but Penn State, that lost a lot of excitement with the way they just got absolutely
pounded by Michigan. Then you get the game versus Michigan, and then you got Illinois.
Just not as many moments for him, but obviously he's in the lead though. So he doesn't need as
much. Hendon's the one on the backend coming in right now, trying to essentially upset what we
all thought was going to happen. The inevitable of CJ Stroud and the crazy stats of Ohio State
quarterbacks, my man's going to win it all. But if Hendon plays like he's been playing
and you get Cedric Tillman back, and you win versus Kentucky, you win versus Georgia,
and I don't even think you have to win versus Alabama. I think if you make the game versus
Alabama competitive, I would say Hendon's going to win the Heisman. I think it all
is going to be on the line in Athens on November 5th. If he plays well and they beat the Dawgs,
I think Hendon is going to win the Heisman. I understand everything you're saying,
but from where I sit today, I feel like CJ Stroud remains the better choice for Heisman,
but not maybe for the reason that I did last week. The reason why we started to discuss this,
why I thought it was clearly still Stroud, it was just based in the volume of the numbers.
Now, obviously that's before Hendon Hooker goes out and throws for five more touchdowns to add to
his own, but more so than that, Stroud seemed to just have a pretty significant advantage.
Now, I'm not so sure. I look at the numbers today. Again, they're very similar. They throw
for the same amount of yards. It's 10.9 yards per attempt to 10.7 yards per attempt. Like I said,
they're both completing 70% of their passes. They're the two highest rated quarterbacks
in the entire country. I've accepted that the numbers may be more equal and you're like,
well, okay, T-Bowl, then why is it Stroud if Hendon Hooker has all this opportunity?
And to me, it's still Stroud because I think the bottom line is that the winner
must win their conference and make the playoff to win the Heisman. That's what I'm saying. That's
the only part we disagree on. Like I agree with you, Hooker's path is such that if he actually
wins the SEC championship, it's not even close. I think that he ends up actually kind of pulling
away from Stroud. If he loses though, and Stroud wins, and let's say Stroud does very well in those
obviously, I guess the context matters here, but if Stroud's going to the playoffs and for a second
year in a row, he's sitting there at 40 plus touchdowns, all these other things and Hendon
lost in the SEC championship, although Hendon has a better story and Tennessee's probably a bit more
of the fan favorite. I feel like CJ Stroud takes home that award both for the team success and
maybe even for the overall volume over the past kind of two years, which shouldn't count, but I
think sometimes does in these conversations. So I still think it's CJ Stroud, but mainly just
because the path is easy, right? Because again, if you lose, I think Hooker is eliminated,
but if not, if Hooker wins, he wins in a landslide. I just think right now there's a lot of voters
that still vote when the regular season's done with, and I think once you get through that SEC
schedule and what Tennessee's going through, I think a lot of them will say he's the Heisman.
I don't care what happens. We know it's not easy to win, to beat a team twice in a season. We all
know that. It is a hard, hard test, especially when that team's Alabama. So I think it would be
unfair of us to say, hey, Hendon Hooker, go beat Nick Saban twice in order to win a Heisman after
you've already been Alabama, who is ranked in the top two. After you went to Athens and beat the
one team in the country in Georgia, the defending national championship champions. Oh, and once
again, now let's go beat Alabama for a second time in a matter of two months. That's unfair.
CJ doesn't have to go that route. Once they beat Michigan, I know Illinois is playing well this
year. I get that, but if they win the game versus Michigan, which is at home, they're going to win
that game and it is a much easier task. I think you have to look at the situation that that football
team is going to be put in and Tennessee is not as good of a football team in general,
perception-wise, than Ohio State is. Let's talk about importance of a player on a football team.
You take CJ Stroud away from Ohio State, that's still a very good football team and a team that
still can compete to win in the Big Ten. You take Hendon Hooker away from Tennessee,
that's a seven and five football team, maybe six and six football team.
I think all this needs to play into the mind of the voters if they are 12-0 heading into the SEC
championship game versus Alabama. For those listening and want to get some better odds,
I will say, and I brought this up a couple of minutes ago, the way Michigan played,
I talked about it yesterday too in our show, so make sure you go watch that if you missed it.
The way Michigan played and the way they beat Penn State and dominated up front
kind of makes me feel like the game from last year, which they beat Ohio State,
could be very similar this year at the end of the month, at the end of November, excuse me.
So if you want to get some crazy odds, or I guess not super crazy odds, but some bigger odds,
Blake Corham, who is number six right now in rushing yards in the country,
number one with 13 touchdowns in America plus 1,200, they're going to continue to run.
Their schedule gets pretty easy for the next few weeks. Michigan State,
they should dominate Rutgers, Nebraska. I think they take care of business versus Illinois.
And then at Ohio State, if you believe Michigan can beat Ohio State, which I think they can,
and then they would take care of business versus Illinois once again, that is an interesting one.
I brought it up last week, and I'm feeling him even more after that dominant performance
versus Penn State. I mean, if you just want to go for the home run, that's the play.
I think if you just want to go for added value, you've really convinced me on hooker
actually now, Aaron. I'm not someone who will just hold to what I originally thought if I
think somebody had a stronger argument. And I think your argument in playing out this hypothetical
where you would go lose to Alabama in the SEC, I definitely can see the world there
where the voters are still swayed hooker side of the equation. And you're right,
I do think kind of the brand comes into play, importance of the team. And like we said,
sometimes it's not fair to CJ Stroud because he's been unbelievable. But Dwayne Haskins
threw for 50 touchdowns, right? We have seen this with Ohio State before, whereas Tennessee
just has this kind of groundswell of grassroots support right now that is just more likable
narratively. It's like just more enjoyable. Okay, so I stand convinced. I changed my mind.
I said it was CJ Stroud. I think Aaron hit the nail on the head. If hooker beats Georgia,
hooker probably wins the Heisman no matter what happens in the SEC championship.
Nice job, sir. Well done.
