Jeep Wrangler Rubicon versus Land Rover Defender | 4xOverland

The Explorers
19 followers
25 Video ViewsยทOct 20, 2022
In the world of four-wheel drive, there are two arguably three makes of vehicle that engender
such passion, such love, that they could be almost described as religions.
I'm at the Stony Ridge Off-Road Academy in Natal, South Africa, where I am joined by John Rich.
John is one of South Africa's best respected off-road trainers
and definitely one of the best I've ever worked with.
John is helping me do this comparison test between the Jeep Rubicon and the Land Rover Defender
because he's had far more experience than I have with the Jeep. You've had also a great
deal of experience with Land Rovers. I've had a lot with Land Rovers, not so much with Jeep,
so I thought I'd bring John along to kind of even the playing field. And I don't think there's going
to be a winner or loser in this test. I think it's just going to be a lot of fun discovering
the good, the bad and the ugly of these two vehicles. I think if we leave it at that,
that will make a good film on that. The Wrangler Rubicon is not an SUV. I think it's wrong to call
it an SUV because typically an SUV, they're built to be very good on the open road, long distances
and then a bit of off-road too. Its very design makes that very obvious. It has solid live axles
front and back, long travel coil springs front and back, which means that on road it's not going
to be great but off it, it's going to be wonderful. And it has really good clearance and of course,
transfer gearing. These same words could also accurately describe this vehicle,
the Land Rover Defender, the Defender of the Faith, sometimes regarded as the icon by which
all other 4x4s are measured. And today we're going to see which one is best. Defender
on an open tar road. It's so much a truck and not a car. It's vague, the steering is a little vague,
no more vague than the Jeep. In fact, maybe even more directional than the Jeep.
It's a little bit cramped, it sways around a lot but you must understand that most people that
own Defenders, they have love affairs with them. All of these quirks, all of these characters,
the fact that it rattles quite a bit and the fact that it moves around like a boat
in a light wind on a lake, they get used to it, they accept it. It's not a negative quality
about the vehicle, it's just that the vehicle is full of character. And for a lot of people,
when they climb from an ordinary SUV and they drive a Defender, they shake their heads in wonder
thinking, what on earth are you doing driving this awful car? But it's not awful, it's lovely.
There's a lovely character about a Defender and those who love it will sit day after day after day
in this quite cramped, limited visibility driving position with vague steering,
not terribly good ventilation and love every minute of it. So while I can criticize the
Defender for being this and that, it's actually, given all of that, a lovely vehicle to drive.
These two vehicles, they're so different and yet again, so similar.
This is a driver's car. By that, what I mean is, you're not going to easily fall asleep while
driving a Rubicon because, in fact, the steering is so vague and so non-directional that, well,
you could easily crash before falling asleep. It really is not very good at all. The tyres on this
are stock standard size, so this is what you can expect from a vehicle from the showroom.
Put larger tyres, as many, many Rubicon owners do, they upgrade the suspension, they lift it
and they put larger tyres on it. I can't imagine how terrible the steering will be,
but you can get used to anything, you know, and I think I will probably get used to this as well.
The Jeep has very nice big door handles, but is a bit annoying because the door won't stay
open. It has just a strap, not any kind of system to keep the door open. The interior
is typical American. You sit in the vehicle, not on it, and it's typical that the steering
wheel is very, it's not slanted at all, it's kind of in your face. There is an integral roll cage
which your head nudges, so it's not a spacious interior. The door slam, if you close the door
lightly, it feels a bit flimsy. But if you give it a whack, it's actually quite nice,
quite satisfying. Now, seating. Very good. Excellent seating. There is a nice armrest,
cupholders, and ergonomically really quite nice. In terms of places to put things,
cupholders, maybe sunglasses, actually not very good. Very nice cubby hole,
and yes, that's quite nice up on top there. That works well. Ventilation, round vents in the center
and at the sides. This particular model has plenty of speakers, don't know how many. The
models have different numbers of speakers. But one of the most satisfying parts of the Wrangler
is the removable roof. Although I'm unable to demonstrate that now, because this vehicle has
a roof rack fitted. Right, the fender. Actually a little easier to get into than the Jeep.
And the driving position, well it's more truck-like. The steering wheel is tilted more this
way, and I feel actually it's very similar to the Jeep. It's a little bit crowded, a little
bit compact, there's not a lot of space to move around in. And particularly with Land Rovers,
the door, the door sound is completely unsatisfying to everybody on the planet,
apart from Defender owners that absolutely love it. It has a, it's almost like a signature,
this funny little rattle as you close the door. And I can understand, having owned a Defender,
I can understand that particular very strange appeal. Visibility is very similar to the Jeep.
I have a reasonably small windscreen with a reasonably large side window. So big-boned people,
broad-chested people, find the Defender very cramped. And it's because of the B-pillar here.
And as the vehicle moves around, they thump themselves on the B-pillar. And you'll notice
a lot of Defender drivers drive with their elbows out. It's actually not to look cool,
it's because they don't fit. It's just that much more comfortable leaning forward a little bit
with the elbow out. In terms of places to put things, okay, there's no armrest at all. It has
a center console, but it's too low for an armrest. So there's no armrest at all. Double cup holders
and the center console is actually quite a reasonably sized unit and very useful. And
nowhere really to put anything. I suppose you can put something down there. And up here,
there's a little pocket. So it actually scores very badly in terms of places to put things.
But this is nice. In front of the passenger, grab handle and a nice generous place to put stuff.
I like that. That's actually the best part about the entire dashboard on the Defender.
That's the best bit. Ventilation. There are only the vents in the middle. There are none on the
edges. So if you drive it in very hot climates, this half of you stays quite warm and this half
of you stays nice and cool. And the middle of you is really undecided on whether you're too hot or
too cold. As for passengers on the back seat, a little place to put stuff. And there's a handle
here, which some could say is a little bit tacky because it's just a strap. I actually quite like
it. I actually think it's got character and it's certainly practical. OK, here's a problem with
rear seat passengers. You have the integral roll cage, which is so nice for taking off the roof.
But actually, that's very close to my head. I feel a little bit cramped. The speakers are right here.
So if the radio is on, the back seat passengers are going to get a full blast of audio much more
than the front seat. So I imagine that it's not going to be a great place to be if music's playing
other than having a party. But the seats are quite good in terms of legroom, really quite
generous. But they're very firm. The seats are very firm. And in fact, if I move into the middle,
that's very hard. So I imagine a middle seat passenger long distance is going to grumble and
complain. Not a particularly wide vehicle, but not narrow either. But I imagine that for a long
distance trip, backseat passengers are going to have to be, given its firm suspension, a pretty
hardy lot. Backseat passengers, a little bit easier to get into than the Jeep. I'm sitting very high up
on an extremely firm seat. Now, it has manual windows that only go down to there. So that's
very uncomfortable. And my seating position as a passenger in a Land Rover Defender at the back
is terrible because my eyeline, I'm actually looking at this bit here
to see animals or anything. I've got a stoop. It's claustrophobic. It's uncomfortable. The seats
are quite supportive, but very firm. And the legroom is fair. Not really bad at all. But the
height is a problem. You're so high. And again, you've got the C pillar here, right here against
you. And you're going to be thumping the C pillar all the time. It's right there. So it's not a great
place to spend a long, long time. But in terms of air and space, this feels more airy than the Jeep.
It actually feels like I've got more room to move around in. I am being very critical of the back
seats of these two vehicles. But one has to remember, they're not SUVs. They're not designed
to be really comfortable. That isn't the primary objective in the designs. But what is important
and vital if these vehicles are to be used as overland tourers, is the packing space.
The Jeep's tailgate is a little unusual. Split, but split top bottom. They have a strap, but they
also have a linkage here. So this will stay open if the vehicle is parked on a bit of a slope.
Now, in here, in terms of overlanding, packing lots of stuff, I can see a few problems immediately.
The seat belts are attached directly to the integral roll cage. So if you're now going to
pack stuff here and it's going to push on these belts, your backseat passengers are going to have
a problem. And off-road, when things are moving around, or overland, things are being shaken
around, things are going to fall onto this belt and going to make backseat passengers' lives a
little bit difficult. In terms of space, it's not bad. It's not particularly large. And this very
large speaker here, this kind of thing actually really annoys me. I understand, you know, it's
a subwoofer and you wanted this part of the vehicle. That takes up so much valuable space.
I'm sorry, I need that space. I really do need it for packing my stuff. So this kind of thing
annoys me. This is a personal thing. So for long distance, heavy loads, and a lot carrying lots of
stuff, it doesn't score particularly highly in the back. Right, space in the back. This is where
the Land Rover scores in a massive way over the Jeep. This is a big space. This is probably, my
guess is, the biggest in its class in terms of the amount of space that I've got. The width, there's,
there are no speakers in the way, there are no funny bits of plastic trim to get in my way.
It's pretty square. This is, this drawer system here is aftermarket. It's a big space. The only
limitation really is you have limited access because the door is quite narrow and the vehicle
is of course much wider. So to get stuff in and out of here, this is the old design,
that is the carryover, but in terms of place to put stuff, nothing, or I can't think of anything,
beats a Land Rover Defender 110. No true off-road vehicle has a tight turning radius,
but some are better than others. The Jeep we have on test is the Wrangler Rubicon.
It's the off-road version with built-in traction control and differential locks and lots more
off-road kit besides. It's powered by a 3.6 litre V6 petrol engine and this one has the automatic
gearbox. Now I'm not too sure if this is fair. You see the Land Rover we have here is a near
stock 110. Manual transmission is the full-time four-wheel drive with a lockable centre differential
and the axles have no differential locks, although this model does have Land Rover's own
standard electronic traction control. The Land Rover's transmission consists of a permanent
four-wheel drive with an open or non-progressive centre differential. That means that when it is
unlocked, whatever wheel that has the least resistance will spin. So that vehicle is in
four-wheel drive right now and yet one wheel is rotating and the vehicle is in effect bogged down.
But the Defender has traction control, but the traction control only works left and right,
not front and back as we will now demonstrate. Add some power and the brake-activated traction
control begins to work and the opposite wheel gets power. If we did the same with one of the
rear wheels, exactly the same would happen. For this vehicle to have any proper four-wheel drive
transmission working, one has to lock the centre differential. The locked centre differential
means power goes to both front and back axles. But the Jeep is different. We've put the rollers
under the back wheels because the Jeep has part-time four-wheel drive. We've got the vehicle
on the rollers, we have an open differential here that the wheel with the least resistance
is spinning out at the moment. To get this vehicle off these rollers, I'm going to have to stop him,
we're going to stop the vehicle, engage four-wheel drive, which will engage the
transfer case, so I'll have a 50-50 drive from the front to the back. It's called part-time. Okay,
drive forward and then I've got drive on my front axle and the vehicle easily pulled off the rollers.
Putting the Jeep in four-wheel drive is the equivalent of locking the Land Rover's centre
differential. Like the Defender, this Jeep has brake-activated electronic traction control.
And it's time now to find out how this all works. I'd like to test the downhill hill descent control
of the Wrangler Rubicon and it has some neat bits of kit built into it, not so?
With the hill descent control activated, you select the first gear on that one,
so you'll go to the manual shift. So I'm going to drive. And then just push across towards me.
There you go. C1, yeah? Yes. All right, have you activated the hill descent? The hill descent
control is that button there. That is green light. Green light is on. Okay. Handbrake down and I'm in
four-low. This is the speed they've selected. This is a good speed. You've got total control.
If I apply power now, will it disengage and then re-engage when I took my foot off the accelerator?
But you just override it with the acceleration. The Jeep's hill descent control is brilliant.
At just the right speed, I can slow it further by using the brakes
and if I dab the accelerator, it instantly disengages. It really is nice and slow. Oh,
that's nice. Right now, Land Rover Defender, a little bit simpler. I'm in low range.
Differential is locked and I'm using first gear. Now, I want to make a point here. Yeah.
Inexperienced instructors will say, use engine compression when going down slope. In this slope,
engine compression is not enough. We go too fast and you'll damage the vehicle.
So, in the first section, I'm not using engine compression. I'm using brake, very smooth control
until the point where I can use engine compression safely because if I just rely
on engine compression, it will go down far too fast and damage the car. Am I right? That is
correct. Okay. We're also going to do something slightly different as well. We're going to have
so it's not pulling against the vehicle. I understand that because of the anti-stall device
will prevent us applying proper control on the brakes. We've actually got to disengage
the transmission. That is correct. Yeah. Okay. But I'm in low first. My foot is on the clutch
and if I get into trouble, I can say, okay, let's rely on the engine compression
as my backup. Great. And now I'm going to release it and let it go.
Look, it's more work to do than the Jeep, but it feels equally safe, equally controllable.
The Defender's compression braking is fair. The descent speed on the second half was a little
too fast for me, any steeper and I would have to use brakes all of the way down.
Yeah. When it slid in the cross actual, how did you feel? Oh, fine. I didn't do anything that I,
yeah, absolutely fine. Now let's take it back up again. But which gear to use? One.
And then try and keep it nice and smooth. Yeah. Yeah. She's great. An easy climb. Too easy,
actually. It's time now to test the two vehicles a lot more. That's quite an interesting slope.
I'm going to give us a little bit more of a challenge on the slope. Okay. I'm going to
push it to the left hand side of the slope. All right. Okay. I have a bank to climb. I have
slippery stuff down below. I have a cross axle just on where that rock is up top there. Right.
So it's going to challenge us on the climb. Yeah.
A little bit more challenging descent now. We're going to go hill descent and well,
I'm sorry to say a bit of a non-event again. Yeah. It's very easy to drive, isn't it?
Okay. How's my line doing? Run it from here? Yeah. Right. Pre-flight for the climb. We're
going to make sure that the hill descent control is on because if we roll backwards, it'll catch us.
I want to keep the lines similar for both vehicles.
To keep things on an even footing, I've not used the Rubicon's axle differential locks.
Now the Land Rover up the same slope. Right. Pre-flight on Land Rover is a little bit easier.
We have our center differential locked and we're a low range and we're going up in first.
To me, the Jeep has the clear advantage. While the actions of the two traction controls is similar,
the wheel travel is better on the Jeep and is providing better traction up the slope.
Another consideration is that the Jeep's track or distance between left and right wheels
is quite a bit wider than the Rover's. This means that holes dug by other vehicles
with narrower tracks are not going to affect the Jeep as badly and I think that's what we
are seeing here. What we have done is made other things we can control equal. For example,
the tires they are running are the same and the pressures are the same. I could take a
faster run up this slope, but the point of this is to compare the two vehicles.
Okay, you think I've gone back far enough? Okay, so I'll leave that test to the vehicle's owners.
I'll just reposition my wheels and persevere.
Obviously a soft spot where the back wheel was digging in and was lifting the front up.
So you call it there and then to be able to take off on the hill as you did there, that was good.
Just land another line. Yeah. Now the owners driving their own vehicles with their own
driving styles. I said that the Jeep's wheel travel exceeds that of the Land Rover and that
its wheel track is considerably wider. On this axle twister obstacle, these can be easily seen.
Both vehicles approach and departure angles are among the very best of any 4x4 station wagon
available. The bumper fitted to this Jeep is not an original Jeep front bumper, but as it can be
seen, both vehicles score high points with both approach, breakover and departure angles.
This experiment, this comparison between these two vehicles was one of the most fascinating things
I've done in years with 4x4s. I really didn't know what to expect. If you're one of these
YouTubers that love to go and point fingers, if you think I'm biased one vehicle to the other
just because I'm British, go and watch another channel please. Go away. I'm not interested.
Okay. The idea was to see which vehicle performed better under different circumstances, different
terrains. Now, unfortunately in Natal, they've been having the driest season they've had for
over a decade. So we couldn't do our mud trials. So what I thought I would do is I would
challenge both vehicles in one or two obstacles where we would be able to see some obvious
differences. Mud and water, deep water, it's very, very difficult to see differences. They're both
great off-roaders that, you know, they're the top of the pile. There are few vehicles out there
that are better. So what would we do to really be able to learn something about these two
vehicles? And I think we've achieved that. My conclusion is that when it comes to, there are
two elements of off-roading. One of them is off-road driving, rocks and sand and mud and
all of those, you know, it's great fun driving off-road. And then there's the overlanding. That
is the travel and touring element of off-road driving. And some people do both. Some people
do just one. I do both. These are my conclusions. Off-road, the Jeep is better. It's easier to drive.
The traction control systems of the two vehicles, I think, are very similar.
I don't think one is better than the other. I am excluding, for obvious reasons, the differential
locks that are standard on the Rubicon version of the Jeep because the Land Rover does not have
differential locks. So, and if I look at the two vehicles, oh, it's better. It's easier to drive
off-road. It's better going down because the hill descent control is fantastic. They've tuned it
just, I don't think I've driven any vehicle ever with such a well set up hill descent control as
that Rubicon has. The Land Rover, of course, doesn't have hill descent control. So, we have
to rely on compression braking and sometimes you can't do that because it's just too steep. You
just, you know, you then have to rely on control. You have to rely on grip. You have to rely on the
wheel travel to keep grip as the wheels drop into different troughs down the slope. The Jeep was
better. Okay, now, the Land Rover is a much more old-fashioned design when it comes to this
transmission and so its electronic traction control, even though it's fitted to an old-fashioned
vehicle, actually works very well indeed, as we could see with the climbs. But the Jeep was better
in the climbs. The wheel travel is better and we proved that again after those climbs. We went and
tested it. I wanted to actually see on a set piece of terrain which one's vehicle travel was better
and the Jeep's is considerably better. It would have to be a scientific test to say how much
better, but my impression is a lot better. And that is the main reason why climbing that slope,
it climbed easier. The wheel track is, of course, wider on the Jeep, which meant that we couldn't put
all four wheels on exactly the same terrain with both vehicles. But then, which vehicles are
identical? What vehicles, when you compare one with the other, have exactly the same track,
exactly the same wheelbase? So, the wider wheels track on the Jeep in this situation may have also
been a contributor to making its hill climbing efforts a little easier. As overland vehicles,
there's no comparison to which one is better. The Land Rover is far better. The main reason being,
yes, more packing space. Yes, of course, that helps. You can fit a roof rack onto both of
them. So, at the end of the day, what will be able to carry more stuff? The Land Rover. There's no
comparison. It is a done deal because of its payload. Now, a Land Rover in standard form, I'm
not going to give the figures here because I might get them slightly wrong and then all the YouTubers
go, la la la, give me a hard time. Okay, the Jeep's maximum payload equates to approximately a full
tank of fuel and five adults, and that's it. So, you have to then go and get aftermarket suspension,
springs to increase the payload. You can do that with the Land Rover too. The Land Rover's
payload is very, very good in standard form, and of course, lots of room in the back, and
it's all a matter of functionality and practicality. I'll give you an example.
The Jeep has a relatively small fuel tank and high fuel consumption when compared to the Land
Rover. So, you now need to increase your range. Now, for an overland vehicle, you need 1,000
kilometers, 600 miles minimum. Okay, that's to begin with. So, you need to make sure your vehicle
has got that kind of range, and if you need to carry extra fuel, well, then you can, of course,
in the Land Rover, carry lots of extra fuel because the payload allows for it, and with the Jeep,
it doesn't. So, how do you increase the already limited range on the Jeep? Change the springs
up, but now you can only change the springs so much. The axles themselves have maximum tolerances,
so you can't just go and load, and load, and load, and load, and load. There is a limit.
The limit on the Land Rover far exceeds the limit on the Jeep. So, as an overland long-distance
tourer, and I'm talking about Trans-America, Trans-Africa, you know, crossing Australia,
long-distance stuff, the Land Rover is a clear winner, mainly for that reason.
I asked the other participants in today's test what single unique character makes their vehicle
special for them. It gives you, it provides you a sense of being invincible.
Everything is so well thought out and put together that driving it, no matter where you are,
or where you're going to, it's never an issue. You just use it, and it goes. Everywhere where
you go, and you stop, the guys always come and talk to you, and swap stories out, and
the unique thing about, another unique thing about a Land Rover is you can bolt on anything,
drill holes, and make it like your own personal vehicle, just like you want it.
John, when teaching somebody how to drive a four-wheel drive, what is the single most important
thing that you want them to leave with after they've done one of your courses?
Andrew, thank you. The single most important is for the person to actually understand
what the vehicle is doing. They're all different, so the person comes with
his or their vehicle on that one, and they need to understand their vehicle,
where to place their wheels, and the power from that vehicle. More than just driving the vehicle
and going out there, you need to respect the environment out there, less wheelspin, so the
more they understand their vehicle and truly get to enjoy their vehicle out in the bush,
I think that, to me, is the most important thing.
