What On Earth Is Going On In The Chinese Super League?

ThinkGeek
27 followers
1 Video View·Oct 19, 2022
The Chinese Super League has sought to present itself as the great emerging power within the
world of football over the last four or five years, just as China itself has become the world's
great emerging power over the last four or five decades. One of the teams at the forefront of
this footballing great leap forward has been Jiangsu Suning FC, backed by one of the powerhouses
of China's enormous retail industry, who also own current Serie A league leaders Inter Milan.
Ranked as China's fourth wealthiest club by Forbes, Jiangsu won promotion to China's top
for the first time during the professional era in 2008, and they haven't been relegated since.
Having won the Chinese FA Cup in 2015, the club got their hands on the most prestigious trophy
of the lot, the Chinese Super League title, for the first time less than three months ago,
defeating eight-time Chinese Super League champions Guangzhou Evergrande across a
two-legged playoff final in front of a limited crowd in Suzhou. The scorer of what proved to
be Jiangsu's winning goal was one Alex Teixeira, perhaps the most landmark Chinese Super League
signing to date. There had been many big money arrivals to the Chinese Super League before
Teixeira joined Jiangsu in 2016, Rubinho, Paulinho, and Tim Cahill to name a few,
but they were all to a certain extent on the decline. Teixeira most certainly was not,
having just enjoyed an awe-inspiring half-season at Shakhtar Donetsk, where he had bagged 22 goals
in 15 league games at the halfway stage in the 2015-16 campaign. There was concrete interest
from Liverpool, under new boss Jurgen Klopp, who had lodged an official bid, yet Teixeira chose to
join Jiangsu instead. His €15m arrival briefly made him the league's most expensive signing,
breaking the record for the third time in just 10 days, but it isn't the only occasion
in which Jiangsu's suing splashed the cash. Alongside Teixeira, the club signed his
compatriots Ramirez from Chelsea and former Man City striker Joe. They later appointed
former England boss Fabio Capello, and in 2019, they came mightily close to securing
the signature of Gareth Bale in a move from Real Madrid. It would be fair to say that for the last
few years at least, Jiangsu haven't messed about when it comes to their finances, and their maiden
league title in 2020 seemed like their crowning achievement. You could say that it came as a
surprise then, just a few days ago, when the club put out a post on WeChat, China's largest app,
which functions like a combination of WhatsApp and Facebook, stating that they had seized all
operations. That includes Jiangsu Suning Ladies Football Club, who are themselves two-time Chinese
Women's Super League champions, as well as the men's club. And yet, to those who are familiar
with the inner workings of China's tumultuous top flight, and the government's rocky relationship
with the world's most popular sport, this news is somehow simultaneously shocking,
but not at all surprising. China's footballing project goes far beyond Jiangsu Suning,
and so too does China's footballing crisis, which is the subject of today's video. So forget about
football in Europe or the Americas for a moment, switch off from any existential dread surrounding
the state of the planet, and join me on a journey exploring the chaos surrounding the machinations of
the beautiful game, in a country where this website is banned. In 2014, Chinese President
Xi Jinping set out his government's three-point plan for Chinese football. They did so in the
of a series of policy papers, but the three targets outlined by China's new leader were for
China to have 300 million children playing football regularly by 2020. That's almost six times the
total population of England right there, which they managed to achieve. The next step is to have a
Chinese national team, which is on par with East Asia's current powerhouses of South Korea and Japan
by 2030. So, a team that can regularly qualify for the World Cup finals. And lastly, for China to
become one of world football's ultimate superpowers by 2050. Good enough to beat any other national
team, and competing to win the World Cup. The Chinese Super League was to become a central
pillar of these plans, with a strong domestic top flight considered to be integral in growing the
popularity of the sport, promoting investment, and creating a clear pathway for China's future
generation of footballers into a competitive league. In the year before Xi Jinping came to
almost no one outside of Asia had any reason to know anything about Chinese football. It was a
country where teams sometimes went on pre-season tours. That was about it. Though the league did
have foreign players pre-2012, few were big names. And even in China itself, the league was best
associated with scandal and corruption, rather than footballing prowess. China got its first
major professional football league in 1994, the GAA League, which just so happened to coincide with
the introduction of the five-day working week, and increased time and resources for weekend
leisure activities among the nation's city-dwelling growing middle classes. You see, football has
always been popular in China. The ancient Chinese game of Cuju is often cited as the earliest form
of association football, and was recognized as such by disgraced former FIFA president,
Sepp Blatter. Football in its codified modern-day form would arrive in China a few thousand years
later via Britain, but China were at one time Asia's strongest national team. Before China's
communist revolution, civil war, and the ascent to power of Chairman Mao, China released Asian
powerhouses. Particularly during the 1920s, considered to be the nation's golden era,
China dominated the football discipline at the Far Eastern Games, spearheaded by Li Weitong,
a native of British Hong Kong, who is considered to be one of the finest Asian footballers of all
time to this day. Following the success of the CCP in taking control of China though, or post-World
War II, depending upon how you wish to frame it, China has consistently been one of world football's
great underachievers. There is a common complaint among football fans in China, represented by the
slogan, 11 from 1.3 billion, begging the question of how a nation of so many, who care about football
so much, can consistently be so useless when it comes to the sport. Every leader of the CCP since
Mao, and including the revolutionary, who actually played football himself as a goalkeeper during his
college days, has sought to rectify this anomaly. China has become the dominant force at the Olympic
Games, but they have only ever qualified for one World Cup in 2002, where they lost every game and
failed to score a single goal. The GIA League made a bright start, sponsored by Marlboro, the cigarette
brand, for the first five years of its existence, and attracting an average attendance of over 17,000
fans in the league's first season. By the early 2000s, the league was faltering though, and support
was dwindling. China's FA did away with the GIA League and launched the Chinese Super League in
2004, but the switch up failed to have the desired impact. Interest in the league diminished following
the relaunch, and foreign and domestic audiences largely considered the league to be something of
a farce. Corruption is a long-standing issue in China, and the nation's new league was thought
to be riddled with it. There were allegations of illegal betting and match-fixing, frequent
instances of violence among the small number of supporters who still attended games, and instances
of racism towards foreign players, and particularly towards black players. In many respects, this was
the state of play when Xi Jinping became China's new dictator. Immediately, changes were made. You
may recall that it was in 2012, the year Xi took office, that the likes of Didier Drogba and
Nick Sanelka signed for Chinese Super League outfit Shanghai Xinhua, Drogba signing fresh off
the back of just having won the UEFA Champions League with Chelsea. They weren't the only ones
though, there was also Frederic Kanute, Yakubu, and World Cup winning manager Marcello Lippi,
among others. Meanwhile, Dario Konka's arrival at Guangzhou Evergrande was said to put him among
the 20 highest paid footballers on the entire planet. It is a trend which has continued ever
since, accelerated by the CCP's plans outlined in 2014, which came in light of some of China's
worst international performances yet. In the men's game, I should clarify. China failed to qualify for
the 2014 World Cup, and that was followed by a humiliating 5-1 defeat to a very young Thailand
team in 2013. That defeat prompted considerable anger among supporters, which spilt over into
riots in the streets, and caused for the Chinese FA's president to resign. They got their wish,
as Yun Weiman was eventually booted out and replaced by former table tennis player
Chai Zhenhua. Results didn't improve though. In 2016, supporters took to the streets once
again after the national team lost 1-0 to war-torn Syria in a 2018 World Cup qualifier.
The Syria team weren't even able to train or play in Syria at the time, due to the country's
ongoing civil war. Clearly, this was a challenge of epic proportions. Xi Jinping is a man with epic
resources and power at his disposal though. A valid claim could be made for Xi being the
most powerful individual on the planet, as evidenced by the recent disappearance
of Alibaba founder Jack Ma for a number of months before he was shown in a clip
from China's state media following the tech entrepreneur having made a number of critical
comments about the CCP. Ma is the 3rd richest person in China, and the 20th richest person
in the world. If he can be silenced, anyone can. So when Xi Jinping said he wanted to see
investment in football, he got it, and not just from the state. Following the outlining of Xi's
plans in 2014, some of China's wealthiest individuals and companies began pouring
their money into football at home and abroad. Jack Ma's own business Alibaba owns 40%
of the CSL's most successful club, Guangzhou Evergrande, now known simply as Guangzhou.
Real estate giant Greenland Group owns Shanghai Shenhe, the Cinebo Group owns Beijing Guan,
and Dalian Wander Group owns Dalian Pro. I could really go on. Overseas, we have seen a wave of
Chinese cash flood into European clubs. Three Premier League teams, Southampton, West Bromwich
Albion and Wolverhampton Wanderers, are all majority owned by Chinese businesses or billionaires.
Meanwhile, Chinese investment company Citigroup acquired a 14% stake in Manchester City in 2015,
which prompted Xi Jinping to pay the club a visit that same year whilst on a state visit
to the United Kingdom. It doesn't take a genius to figure out that perhaps not all of these
billionaires are passionate about football and that some of them may just be caught in favour
with Xi. In fact, it has even been theorised that Xi's own love of the sport may just be a facade.
Football is the global sport and is reportedly seen by the CCP as a gateway into foreign markets,
a potential source of national pride, a platform to build a wider sports,
leisure and entertainment industry around for China's grown middle class,
and a way for China to earn greater international recognition and respect.
Whether Xi's love of the game is genuine or not, all of these factors are likely to have played a
key role in the prioritising of the sport over numerous other issues. However, cracks are
emerging in Xi's plan, which brings us back to Jiangsu Suning, who actually renamed themselves
as just Jiangsu shortly before the revelations emerged. Jiangsu are, or were, owned by Suning
Appliance Group, who are 20% shareholders of Suning.com Limited. Suning.com is one of
China's largest retailers with over 20 billion US dollars in annual revenue, and following their
success in the retail space, the company branched out into one or two other businesses like streaming
and marketing. Now they are looking to strip back from other industries though, having just sold 23%
of their assets, which the company says is a long-term strategy so they are able to maintain
a laser-like focus on their core retail business. Ending their investment in Jiangsu FC and the
club's associated women's team is thought to be part of this streamlining, and having tried to
find an investor for six months, Suning Appliance Group finally pulled the plug just a few days ago,
and the teams seized all operations. But why would one of China's largest companies, and one of
China's wealthiest individuals, who is a former politician himself, have wanted out of a team
that just won the Chinese Super League? And why wasn't there another business or billionaire just
waiting to step in and fulfill a lifelong dream of owning a football club, or at least trying to
court favor with China's supreme leader? Well, one reason might be that owning a Chinese football club
isn't a very profitable business. In order to attract players, clubs have had to offer foreign
players eye-watering contracts, whilst revenues haven't risen as hoped. As of the end of last
season, 11 of the world's 30 highest paid footballers played their club football in China,
each earning between 280,000 and 575,000 pounds a week. No Premier League player comes close to
earning as much as the likes of Oscar, Hulk, and Paulinho reportedly do, yet the league's total
revenue remains dwarfed by the Premier League, and is roughly on par with the Championship.
Meanwhile, average attendance is peaked back in 2016. There are one or two suggestions that Xi and
the CCP, already scaling back investment in football, have been disappointed by the lack
of impact that they have seen since outlining those initial plans in 2014. If Xi starts to
lose interest, then so too will China's businesses and billionaires, many of whom likely never had
the growth of football in China as their main priority. This could have significant knock-on
effects for football worldwide, and in some respects it already has. Suning.com, the company
Jiangsu's former owners were shareholders of, also owned PPTV, a streaming service, who have
the rights to broadcast the Chinese Super League, the UEFA Champions League, the Bundesliga, and more
in China. PPTV also previously had the rights to broadcast the Premier League in China, in a deal
worth more than 500 million pounds on an annual basis. That made it the Premier League's most
lucrative overseas TV deal, but in September, the Premier League pulled the plug on PPTV's rights
to broadcast over an unpaid 160 million pound payment. Given the struggles with COVID, the loss
of this income came as a significant blow to Premier League teams. PPTV also ended their
broadcasting agreement with La Liga in 2020, and suspended broadcasting of both the FA Cup and
even Serie A in February 2021. I say even Serie A, because Suning.com also, sort of, kind of,
own Inter Milan, who currently top the Serie A table. Inter are owned by Suning Holdings Group,
which belongs to Suning.com founder, and the company's largest shareholder, Zhang Xindong,
though Suning Holdings Group is technically a separate entity to Suning.com, and is the private
investment arm of Xindong's business. The likes of Southampton and West Brom, both Chinese-owned,
have scaled back spending in recent years, and to a lesser extent, so too have Wolves, particularly
in terms of their plans surrounding the redevelopment of Molineux. There is not yet
any suggestion that Suning will pull all funding from Inter, as they have done with Jingsu. That
would be pretty reckless, given that Inter are currently top of the Serie A table, and have
significant commercial potential in their own right, regardless of Xi's updated outlook on
football, though Suning have been seeking external investment in the club for the last six months.
It is a precarious situation, both at home and abroad, for Chinese-owned football clubs.
One Chinese Super League team was dissolved in 2020, and there are already two who have bitten
the dust in 2021, prior to the start of next season, including the reigning league champions.
Inside China, the league still has a reputation for corruption, and the quality of China's
domestic players has barely improved. Outside China, players are likely to start treating a
move to the Chinese Super League with even more suspicion, if they cannot be sure that
contract promises will be fulfilled, and that owners are in it for the long haul.
The fallout of all this is rarely yet to develop though. Whether Xi and the CCP have really given
up on football, or at least to what extent, remains to be seen. China's president may not
have to answer at the ballot box, he is in essence a president for life should he wish,
but he still wants to be popular. The CCP have tied themselves to China's footballing project
in a fashion that is difficult to reverse. They announced their 2014 targets with such bravado,
that football loving Chinese citizens are holding them to them as promises.
The bond is so strong that when China's national team fails, fans blame politicians and Xi as much
if not more than they blame the managers or players, who are written off as simply not
being good enough, rather than actively having done anything wrong. In many respects then,
I have made this video a what is likely to be a seminal moment in the history of the Chinese game.
Right now, the league appears to be in chaos. I haven't even had time to mention Shandong Luneng
getting kicked out of the Asian Champions League. And there appears to be a real threat of state,
individual and businesses all pulling their investment from football clubs at home and
abroad. But on the flip side, failure to see through his plans, or at least be perceived to
have done so, would be politically very damaging to a man who doesn't like to be disliked.
So watch this space, because the next 12 months may determine whether China are
world champions by 2050, or whether they're still losing to Syria, Uzbekistan and Iraq.
Thank you all for watching today's video. Before I leave you, I just wanted to tell you about Zheng
Xi, who made his debut for China during the same year in which the country qualified for their only
World Cup, in 2002. You may remember Xi from his time in Britain, where he played for Charlton
Athletic and Celtic. Here he is with then Prime Minister Gordon Brown and Manchester United player
Dong Fangzhu back in 2008. Well, Xi is now 40 years old, and he still captains China's biggest club,
Guangzhou, and he is still a full international. I'm not sure whether that says more about the
state of the Chinese Super League and the Chinese national team, or about the longevity of the
former championship midfielder. I suspect it is a bit of both, but I just found that quite
interesting, so I thought I'd share it with all of you. Thank you as ever for tuning in. I hope
you enjoyed today's video, whether you're watching via a VPN in China or elsewhere. Go ahead and hit
the like button if you enjoyed today's video, feel free to let me know your thoughts down below in
the comments, and make sure to subscribe to HITC7s, and click the little notification bell
to ensure that you never miss an upload. You can also find me on Twitter or Instagram,
via the username at HITC7s, should you wish to do so.
