The Debate over German POWs in Soviet Hands WW2

AtoZ Heritage
50 followers
7 Video Views·Oct 16, 2022
The Debate over German POWs in Soviet Hands WW2
In my recent video on the Soviet prisoners of war in German hands, we saw the horrors
inflicted on Soviet POWs, and the death of well over three million souls through deliberate
neglect or outright murder. With some minor variants, the sources I used for that video
were more or less in agreement. In this video, there is no agreement. In fact, there's
so little agreement that even the question of whether we can agree over the fact that
there isn't an agreement is up for debate.
What we can definitely say though, is that the German and Soviet statistics are both
awful, and are used by various authors to push their particular narratives. This is
why we should probably avoid statistics when it comes to things like history or economics.
But since we're already here, and nothing warms the heart on a lovely summer's evening,
more than calculating death statistics, let's dust off the old abacus and start making math
teachers around the world cry.
According to German sources, 3,155,000 German soldiers became captives in the Soviet Union.
Some have said it was higher than that, going as high as 4 million. But claims that high
seem to have been guesses in the immediate post-war period, so we can probably dismiss
them. In 1947, the ever-trustworthy Molotov stated that over one million German prisoners
had already been sent home, and another 900,000 remained in Soviet custody. This was upsetting.
Because the Germans in the 1950's believed, or hoped, that more Germans had been taken
prisoner than that. So they assumed that the remaining one or two million missing men must
have been killed in Soviet captivity by the Soviets.
Later, when the Soviet archives opened in the 1980's, Soviet statistics confirmed
that roughly 2,389,000 German prisoners had been taken by the Soviets during the course
of World War Two. They revealed that, for once, Molotov was telling the truth. So basically
either 2,389,000 or 3,155,000 German prisoners of war had been taken, and the higher amounts
are actually missing soldiers assumed to have been taken prisoner rather than killed in
action. Even the 3,155,000 figure may be too high, and it seems that the German civilians
in the post-war era really hoped that fewer Germans had died than had actually died.
The numbers of those missing after all repatriations had taken place was around 1.3 million, suggesting
that actual losses were much higher than the official figures. So the evidence here suggests
that German casualties on the Eastern Front are probably understated. As we've seen
in previous videos on the tank numbers and so on, the oh-so-efficient German record-keeping
wasn't oh-so-efficient after all. In fact, they often seemed to downplay their losses,
just like most sides did in World War Two. As an example of this poor record-keeping,
we don't even know how many German soldiers there were with Rommel in Africa during Operation
Crusader. And that was roughly 120,000 men. We don't even know if the Afrika Division
was even called the Afrika Division or not. And that's the name of a division. If we
don't know that, what chance have we got in figuring out the actual number of men on
the Eastern Front, let alone how many men were captured during the confusion of combat?
The point I'm making here is that both German and Soviet record-keeping standards are poor
to say the least. A lot of people will say that the Soviet statistics are not trustworthy,
and gladly swallow whatever numbers the German Third Reich made up. No, both sides are as
bad as each other, and are completely untrustworthy. Because of this, the number of men who made
it to the battlefield is incalculable, and that's before we even attempt to figure
out how many troops or tanks were lost, and in what manner they were lost. So the bottom
line is this, the numbers are bogus to begin with, and so it's no wonder there's debate
going on about this.
What we can say however, is that most of the German prisoners seem to have been taken later
in the war, if not in the final months of the conflict. During Operation Barbarossa,
just 30,000 German soldiers ended up as prisoners of war in the Soviet Union. This makes sense
considering they were on the offensive, which was largely a success at the beginning at
least. Both German and Soviet records indicate that a significant portion of German prisoners
taken in 1941 and 1942 were either shot, or just simply did not survive. For example,
180 German soldiers were shot by Soviet troops at Broniki on the 30th of June 1941. Soviet
records indicate that 90 to 95% of German prisoners taken in 1941-42 did not survive
for various reasons.
But Bellamy also says that this does not seem to have been the Soviet High Command's intention.
The Germans captured a number of documents which showed that the Red Army Command was
trying to stop the killing of prisoners, which of course confirms that it was happening.
To cut the long story short, by 1942, the Soviet High Command had managed to get a grip
on their men, and stop them from executing German prisoners of war. It seems that they
did this for economic reasons. German prisoners could work in the gulags, and their labour
was seen as valuable, at least by 1943. Many German prisoners ended up constructing a major
railway between the Volga and Siberia, and actually got paid for the work, although their
guards seemed to have pocketed a lot of the money. Conditions in the gulags were especially
poor at first, and the Soviet authorities appeared to be badly organized, which makes
sense since they hadn't expected the sudden German attack, and hadn't prepared for a
sudden influx of German prisoners of war. The situation improved over time, although
they worked between 10 and 12 hours a day, and got 600 grams of bread and some potato
soup, and maybe some meat and vegetables now and then. They were not conditions designed
deliberately to exterminate the occupants of the camps, for the labour power of prisoners
was needed to rebuild the Soviet economy. Despite what some Marxists in the comments
of my videos have claimed, that they were in fact nice holiday camps, the gulags weren't
lovely places to be. That said, the conditions were certainly not like those that Soviet
prisoners suffered in German camps, as discussed in the other video.
There were, in fact, deaths in the gulags. Shock and horror. The numbers I've seen
for the death of German prisoners in Soviet custody are 356,000, 360,000, 363,000, 450,600
and 459,000. Again, the numbers are based on bogus records, which means, yeah, there's
discrepancies.
And just to be as generous as I possibly can be to the German sources, Rudiger Obermann's
went even higher. His number of 363,000 is the confirmed number of German deaths in Soviet
hands. But he says that another 700,000 missing prisoners could have been killed too. He has
said the figure could be as high as one million German prisoner-of-war deaths in the Soviet
Union.
Okay, but this is clearly speculation. The fact that there's 700,000 missing German
soldiers in the first place indicates that the German records aren't accurate. It even
suggests that German casualties during the battles are understated, which was also the
same conclusion Overy comes to as we mentioned earlier. It's also playing to the idea going
around in the 1950s that lots more German soldiers survived the war and were just in
Soviet captivity than they actually did. The only evidence we seem to have for this 700,000
figure is the unreliable and understated German casualty records, and the hopes of the friends
and relatives of missing German soldiers.
So, while it's clear that they were killed by the Red Army, that doesn't mean they
were killed when they were taken prisoner. It could be that they were killed in combat,
and then simply not recorded as such by either side, hence the discrepancy. Therefore, unless
more evidence comes along which definitely proves that they all died in the gulags or
something, then it would be wrong to conclude that they even became prisoners of war in
the first place. However, we're not going to rule it out completely, since there's
a chance it could be true. So what we're going to do now is take both the German and
Soviet figures for German POWs, and compare them to the number of prisoners who are supposed
to have been killed in Soviet captivity. Again, the numbers are bogus, so the calculations
we're about to make are essentially pointless. But we're going to do them anyway for the
fun of it.
And there's plenty of evidence that they are bogus, as demonstrated by the ever-so-Keynesian
Cambridge History of the Second World War, Volume 1. This exquisite tome uses the high
number for German captured, 3,155,000, and a low number for the number of deaths in Soviet
hands, 360,000. It then concludes that there was a death rate for German prisoners of war
This is incorrect, because 13.9% of 3,155,000 is 438,545, not 360,000. So yeah, not only
have I shown previously that Cambridge's economic history contradicts itself, but Cambridge
also can't do basic math.
So yes, we are calculating made-up numbers. However, since they're all we've got,
why not mess around with them? Therefore we're going to put the number of German prisoners
of war who fell into Soviet hands at the top. The German 3.15 million, 3.06 million which
is Overmans' specific number, and the Soviet 2.38 million. And we're going to list the
author's numbers at the side. Overmans gets additional numbers because he's a bit special.
So now we're going to calculate the percentages. Ignoring the Overmans over and above the Call
of Duty number for a moment, the percentage number of German prisoners of war who died
in Soviet hands is somewhere between 11 and 20%, with a lot of the numbers at roughly
11.5 or 14.5%. Oh and I forgot to add an extra column for Cambridge's 2 plus 2 is 5, so
I'll just add that in now. I'd love to say that their number was actually the average
between two of the other numbers, and thus they were just being clever, but no, they
screwed up. But this range is actually broader than what most of the authors say, so if I
highlight which number the author favours, we can narrow the range down even further.
And we have Overy off to a good start with his 14.90, Cambridge off to the side having
difficulties, Overmans first bringing up the rear at 11.86, whilst Glantz and Haus
reaching an 18.86 coming in first. But Fritz has fallen at the final hurdle and failed
to cross the finish line. Fritz doesn't state which of the 3.15 or the 2.3 million
numbers he prefers, and so had to be put down and turned into sausages.
Therefore, we can conclude that, well, nothing. But I'm going to suggest that the number
of German POW deaths is low. Probably around 14.5% of the total, and more likely to be
360,000 or 450,000 in total. Even if it was the massive 1 million that Overmans speculates,
this pales in comparison to the 3.3 million Soviet POWs who died in the German camps.
Even the highest percentage of 41.85, which even Overmans himself does not use, does not
compete with a death rate percentage of 58% for Soviet prisoners in German camps. And
the likelihood of it being that is much lower, since 14.5% seems to be a more reasonable
figure. But I'm actually going to suggest that the 14.5% is also too high. Why? Because
of Stalingrad. Glantz says that Rokossovsky's official figure for the number of Axis soldiers
captured at Stalingrad was 91,000, while Paulus's was 107,800. He notes that Rokossovsky's
estimate does not include men taken prisoner prior to the 30th of January, which was around
16,000, making it closer to Paulus's guess. The NKVD numbers are similar to Paulus's
figure as well, so roughly 108,000 Axis troops were captured at Stalingrad. Of these, only
around 5,000 made it back to Germany. Doing some quick math, that's a survival rate
of 4.63%, which means the death rate for Stalingrad prisoners was 95.37%. Why? Because they were
slowly starved in their pocket for months prior to capture. We have reports of men in
the 6th Army starving to death inside the pocket, so of course they were near death
already as the pocket collapsed. And according to Beevor, just 5% of the senior officers
taken prisoner at Stalingrad, and 55% of the junior officers perished, compared to over
95% of the lower ranks. Why? Well, he says it's because of the privileged treatment
that the officers received in Soviet custody. I'd say it was because of the privileged
treatment that the officers received in German hands. The officers got priority of food in
the pocket, and weren't running around fighting all the time like the lower ranks were.
When prisoners were registered before departure, many put down agricultural labourer as their
profession in the hope of being sent to a farm. Or because they're hungry. And on
the same pages, Beevor does say the prisoners received bread and fish. So again, they weren't
deliberately starved by the Soviets. More likely, they were starved before capture,
and then died as a result, which is the conclusion I came to in my 6th Army's rations at Stalingrad
video. So the Stalingrad death ratio is 95.37%, which is atypical compared to every percentage
we've looked at in this video.
Stalingrad is a special case. The death rate was higher because the German soldiers were
starved before they surrendered, and probably died because of that, not through harsh treatment
in Soviet hands. Thus, since Stalingrad's death ratio is super high, through no fault
of the Red Army, then that means that all our percentages here are wrong. They are too
high. Stalingrad makes the percentages go higher than they would otherwise be. So we
need to recalculate and take out the Stalingrad numbers to get a more accurate assessment
of how the typical German prisoner would fare had he fallen into Soviet hands.
And here we are. The death percentage for non-Stalingrad German prisoners who were captured
by the Soviets. 11.5% seems to be about right, although it could be 8.5 or 15.4 as well.
Either way, much lower than the 58% of Soviet prisoners of war in German camps. Even if
you went with the super-high Obermann's 2 figure of 39.33%, the Germans were treated
better in Soviet custody than Soviet prisoners were in German custody. And interestingly,
the Axis Allied numbers are somewhat similar. A further 1,097,000 were captured from the
nationalities fighting at Germany's side, of whom 162,000 died. That's a death percentage
rate of 14.76%. Again, much lower than the 58% suffered by Soviet prisoners of war, and
lower than the 95% of my brain cells which were lost as I watched part of Hitler The
Greatest Story Never Told recently. Seriously, how anyone could sit through that rubbish
without their brains melting out their ears is beyond me. If you want me to review it
at some point in the future, vote in the poll.
So can we come to any conclusions here? Well, it's probably fair to say that the German
prisoner of war survival chance was much higher than that of Soviet prisoners of war in German
hands. And that was because the Soviets didn't have a deliberate starvation policy, unlike
the Germans. Conditions weren't great for either side, but Soviet prisoners in German
camps definitely had it worse overall. What we can definitely say is that statistics aren't
reliable, and that all the numbers are made up, so the points don't matter. That's
right, the points don't matter, just like your feelings when I say, no, I won't just
stick to tanks. We sometimes have to use statistics, but we should avoid them, especially when
it comes to things like macroeconomics or military statistics. If we do use them, we
should assume they're not accurate and could be subject to change or dismissal. What's
more useful is a convergence of evidence and a logical interpretation of history. If you
have a contradiction in history, it's most likely an indication of a distortion of history.
And big statistics are always contradictory.
Thanks for watching, bye for now.
