Making SQUEAKY Cheese CURDS From Scratch

Best Comfort Food
50 followers
14 Video Views·Oct 16, 2022
Welcome friends, today I'm going to try and make squeaky cheese curds.
This is something that I really love to eat
and sadly you can't really find it anymore where we live
in Toronto. It's just not something that you see a lot of. So I'm
starting out with whole milk. This is pasteurized but
non-homogenized so you see the separation between the
cream and the milk here in the jar. This isn't something that you can get at
the grocery store here. I had to search this out. It is available
just a little bit more difficult to find and the cream
is essentially a plug at the top of the
of the bottle. So I'm going to pour all of this into
this pot. Now making cheese, I've never done it before. I've made ricotta
and you can see those videos elsewhere on the channel,
but I've never made cheddar cheese or cheddar cheese curds.
So this will be a little bit new for me and part of it
part of the whole process is, I want to hold a little bit of milk back,
part of the whole process is keeping everything
at a certain temperature. You need to control the temperature
very tightly. So I've set up essentially a bain-marie or a double boiler.
This pot has some water in the bottom and it also has some rings at the bottom
to hold this pot off of the bottom. I'm going to heat the water and try to
keep it at a constant temperature so that
the process works as it's supposed to and we'll see how that works out.
I know a lot of people will say in the comments, why don't you use
a sous vide machine and I've got them and I can definitely do that.
I think the problem is a lot of people out there don't have them
and let's find a solution that is easily accessible for anyone who wants to try
this recipe. So I've got the milk and the cream now
in this pot and so I'm going to stick this pot
inside this pot and we need to bring the milk up to the temperature that is
currently flashing on the screen. I'm not going to say a lot of the times and
temperatures just because it's confusing and I don't
want to get myself confused. So temperature probe into the milk
and we'll keep an eye on that and when it comes up to the temperature we'll
move on to the next step. I've got to tell you this
milk that I got, I've never used it before, so it's
non-homogenized 5% whole milk and it's pretty crazy. So this stuff
here, it's almost right out of the jug, it's
almost butter. Let's see if I can get a taste.
That's amazing, absolutely amazing. I'm looking forward to these cheese
curds. Okay we're pretty much at the right
temperature. You want to bring this up to 91 degrees Fahrenheit. I'm at 90 and
I'm going to say that's a win. So the next step is to sprinkle on this
cheese culture and I will link to the cheese culture down below
so that you can get the right one. In my research there are
four or five different cheese cultures that are listed as the right
one to make this. So I'll link to the one that I used and I'll also
try to remember to put in all the other ones. So you want to sprinkle this
on and then we're going to let it sit for about five minutes to bloom and
then we're going to give it a stir. We're going to stir it in to make sure
that it's fully incorporated. Then we're going to put a lid on it and
we're going to maintain that 90 or 91 degrees Fahrenheit for 40
minutes. Okay so it's almost been 40 minutes. I
have two containers of water in front of me.
They're both 60 mils of water and in the first one I want to dissolve
calcium. I get this stuff for my home brewery and it changes the
water chemistry. You can also find it in grocery stores,
in bulk food stores. It's fairly easy to come across.
If you do pickling you're probably using it already and it often goes by the name
pickle crisp, but before you just go and use pickle
crisp make sure that it's only calcium. In the next one I'm going to
dissolve some rennet. This is liquid rennet.
Now the reason we're dissolving both of these in water is
you don't want to just dump them straight into the milk.
You want to have them partially dissolved so that it's
fully dissolved when you put it in there. So
give them both a stir and make sure they are
good. Okay so I did pretty well maintaining the temperature.
A little bit of fluctuation, not a whole lot. So next up
we just want to stir this and make sure that we've got
even temperature inside. Then we want to pour in the calcium.
Now you want to pour it off the spoon just so that it doesn't all land in
the same place and then stir it in. I read a bunch of
different things about stirring it in. Some people say stir up and down like
this with a flat spoon. Now if you have a flat slotted spoon
like I do that will work really well. Other people said just to stir it
and make sure that it gets stirred in and don't really worry too much
about how you're stirring it. So there we go.
Now this one is the rennet and we want to do pretty much exactly the same thing.
Pour it make sure it gets everywhere
and then stir it in. Now once this is stirred
in we're going to set the timer for another 40 minutes and we're going to
continue maintaining around 91 degrees Fahrenheit.
During that time it should set up completely.
Okay lid on timer set. Okay time is up.
Now what we need to do is check and see if
the curd is set. So what you're supposed to do apparently is make a small little
slit and then put your knife in and pick it
up and if it's clean, which it definitely looks like it's
clean, your curd is set. We can move on to the next step which is
to cut the curd. Now there's a very special contraption for
cutting curd. It kind of looks like X's and O's and you
stick it in and swirl it around and it cuts the curd perfectly.
If you have a curd cutter in your kitchen that's great, I don't. I'm just
going to use a knife and so I'm going to very carefully
cut it in a pattern and then cut on a diagonal
and see if we can get this curd cut to the right
shape and size. The idea is you don't want to cut the curd too small
and you don't want to cut it too large. Now we put the lid on for five minutes
and let the curds heal. Okay so now we start to stir
the curds gently. Look at them, they look pretty cool.
Okay so over the next half hour I'm going to
stir this gently and constantly and you need to raise the temperature
over this 30 minute period and you can't raise it too quickly.
Everybody says if you raise it too quickly there's something about the
acidity that develops and it makes it sour, you
So you need to gently heat it and over 30 minutes bring it up to 102 degrees
Fahrenheit. So this next bit is a little bit
tricky. Not only do I have to stand here
stirring, I have to mind the temperature very carefully.
Let's see what happens. Okay so the timer went off and I've got to 101
degrees Fahrenheit which I think is pretty good.
I didn't overshoot. So now I continue stirring
and we go another 40-45 minutes holding this temperature
and you don't have to stir quite as much at this point. I've
seen people say that you need to stir constantly and other people say
if you stir every 15 minutes or so just give it a gentle stir
you'll be okay. So I'm gonna sort of split the difference and maybe every
five minutes give it a nice gentle stir. Oh and there we go we have
hit 102. So you can see the curds have changed
significantly from what they looked like before.
They've gotten smaller and tighter. The whey is more
pronounced. So we'll just keep stirring and maintain
that temperature. Okay so there's the timer. Now this is
what it looks like. The curds have gotten smaller,
much smaller and they're still distinct. So here's the deal.
Now I would say the advice of a lot of the recipes of stirring every 15 minutes
is probably wrong. You want to stir more often.
What I found was after the first 15 minutes they started to clump together
and they were stuck together. Everything that I read did say that
you want the curd to be loose in this liquid. You
don't want it to clump together yet at this point.
So I would stir every five minutes or gently stir for the whole time period.
Now we do want to let this rest for 15 minutes at this point. You want it
to settle to the bottom and you want it to start to clump together
before we move on to the next thing which is draining it into a colander.
Okay so I'm just going to pull the cheesecloth over top here
and we are going to let this sit and drain for about 15 minutes.
But I'm going to move it into this bowl
because I want to put the whey back in the original pot,
put it back in the bain-marie and raise the temperature to 115 degrees Fahrenheit.
Okay so this next step is called cheddaring. It's the whole reason cheddar
cheese gets its name. What's going to happen
now is I've got the curds in this basket covered in cheesecloth over top of the
warm whey and the whey is going to heat and steam
just a little bit and the curds are going to drain.
Now four times over the next hour so every 15 minutes
I'm going to pull the curds out and put them on the cutting board and I'm going
to cut them in half, turn one half on top of the other and
then put it back over the pot, cover it and let it
to continue draining. The idea is over this time period
more of the whey is going to drain out of the curds
making them drier and squeakier.
Okay cutting and folding and cutting and folding and
squeezing. So I did squeeze these while they were resting in there and I
think that if you put a plate on top of some weight you would squeeze out even
more of the whey and some of the methods said
to do that some of them said not to do it. If the
objective is to get most of the whey out I would squeeze it or put something
heavy on top of it during that process that we just went through.
Now we need to cut it into curds. I've been in a cheese factory where they
cut the curds and they use a machine and it shreds it.
It's almost a machine like a rototiller for a garden
and it shreds it into uneven pieces. We're not going to get that here.
So I'm just going to cut it and I'm going to chop it up
into smaller chunks that will be the curds.
And relax yes I know blue is not the color of cutting board
for cheese but you know it's the one I could find.
Okay the next thing you want to do is throw them into a container with a lid
on a scale because you want to weigh the curds. You want to know how much you've
got here to determine how much salt to put in.
We have 515 grams so we need five grams of salt.
Oh 5.2 that'll do. Okay so sprinkle the salt
in put the lid on and give it a shake. The idea here is that you want the salt
to get all over every piece of curd and that's it. We'll let it sit for
about a half an hour or so and then we'll give it a taste.
What have you been doing all day you've been at this for hours? All day
squeaky cheese curds. When I say all day it was like
like nine hours of work. Yeah like you got up
early and started this and now it's nine hours that's not a lot of cheese.
No it's not a lot of cheese. Nine hours and like
like $40 worth of milk. So I can hear the squeaky from here that's
good. They're very squeaky.
That's a really good cheese curd. Yeah. Did you make some fresh bread to go with
it? No. So this will ripen over 12 hours
and so 12 hours from now it will taste it will have a more rounded flavor
okay and it will still squeak. 24 hours from now the squeak will be completely
gone because the squeak is caused by
proteins long chains of proteins and the lactic acid in the in the cheese
will break up those proteins and it will no longer squeak. Good for you Mr.
Chemistry. So 24 hours from now it'll be... I feel
like we need to do a taste again then in 12 hours. So tomorrow morning when I come
out I'll taste again and I'll report back.
Yeah you'll be on your own. Sorry. But at this point you can put that in a bag
stick it by the counter. Yeah. Sell it six hours for now.
It'll be good to go. So I have a question though.
It took you nine hours. Yeah. For what we had. Yeah.
Would it take you the same nine hours if you were making three times as much? Oh
no. Yes it would. It would. So that the time
doesn't get any longer. Okay. With more volume. Okay. But how are we
going to eat this in the next 24 hours? That's a lot of cheese.
I think I can get through it. Good for you. I think I can get through it. So
if you were going to make poutine, this is the curd that you need. This is
and you cannot buy it at the grocery store here.
Because by the time it gets to the grocery store here it's cheddar. Yeah.
It's cheddar. So the squeak is gone. People are gonna ask
how to store this. On the counter. Don't put it in the fridge and consume it
within 24 hours. Everything's fine. Oh which is why it's so great to just get
it from the corner store. Oh what is that? What is that?
Le Faire Est Ketchup? Yes. Yes. Le Faire Est Ketchup? Oh yeah.
Everything's ketchup. Everything's good. Yep. Okay.
So one more. I'll see you in 12 hours. I'll just put the lid on and go.
Okay so here we are 14 or 15 hours later and we're gonna give this another go.
Now let's see what happened. Still super squeaky
and the flavors deepened. They've ripened.
There is a much better depth of flavor after 14 hours on the counter.
So I would say then with this experience
these cheese curds would be good to eat as soon as you've made them.
They are better to eat 12 to 14 hours later.
So I guess the final question is, is it worth it?
If you live somewhere that you cannot get squeaky cheese curds,
you can't get cheddar cheese curds, then yes
it is worth it to give this a shot. It's also worth it if you're on an
exploration of food and you really want to better understand
how food gets from, and specifically cheese,
gets from the cow to the grocery store. This will give you an insight in the
entire process and I think that's important
to try these things to know whether you want to do it yourself
or if you want to buy better quality at the grocery store because you discover
that what you've been buying is maybe not that great. So
give it a try if you want. Thanks for stopping by.
See you again soon.
