Some of the figures I gave for last week's episode of Battlestorm Stalingrad (episode 22, link ) were wrong. Thanks to Anton Joly and Egor Kobiakov, I can reveal what the actual numbers probably were. There's also a Patreon Q&A in here, and I wanted to highlight some other comments too, so be sure to watch the full video.
🔔 Subscribe for more History content: Videos EVERY Monday at 5pm GMT (depending on season, check for British Summer Time).
The MAPs for this series were created by Terri Young, and the thumbnail was created by her too. Check out her website https://www.terriyoungdesigns.co.uk/
This video isn't sponsored. My income comes purely from my Patreons and SubscribeStars, and from YouTube ad revenue. So, if you'd like to support this channel and make these videos possible, please consider becoming a Patreon or SubscribeStar. All supporters who pledge $1 or more will have their names listed in the videos. For $5 or more you can ask questions which I will answer in future Q&A videos (note: I'm behind with the Q&A's right now, and have a lot of research to do to catch up, so there will be a delay in answering questions). There are higher tiers too with additional perks, so check out the links below for more details.
Thank you to my current supporters! You're AWESOME!
- - - - -
📽️ RELATED VIDEO LINKS 📽️
BATTLESTORM STALINGRAD S1/E1 - The 6th Army Strikes! “Why I'm Passionate about HISTORY and What Got Me Into it” Theory 101 - - - -
ABOUT TIK 📝
History isn’t as boring as some people think, and my goal is to get people talking about it. I also want to dispel the myths and distortions that ruin our perception of the past by asking a simple question - “But is this really the case?”. I have a 2:1 Degree in History and a passion for early 20th Century conflicts (mainly WW2). I’m therefore approaching this like I would an academic essay. Lots of sources, quotes, references and so on. Only the truth will do.
This video is discussing events or concepts that are academic, educational and historical in nature. This video is for informational purposes and was created so we may better understand the past and learn from the mistakes others have made.Credit: TIKhistory
A few different things to talk about today, starting with a correction to episode 22 of
my Stalingrad series. And this is the first time I've been tempted to remove one of
my Stalingrad videos and replace it with a fixed version, because I think this was a
major error. It's not like 53 degrees in the sun or something, this is a bit bigger
than that, so let me know what you guys think I should do. But in that video I said that
the Soviets lost 88,000 men on the first day of the 2nd Kotluban Offensive. Many of you
were sceptical, and you were right to be. Your comments prompted me to check again,
and then I discovered that I had made a mistake, and so had David Glantz. Plus, Isaev may have
made a mistake too, although I'm not sure on that one. But let's dive into the details
and figure this all out.
On page 177 of Glantz's second book on Stalingrad, he says, the intense fighting on the 18th
and 19th of September exacted a terrible toll on Moskalenko's army. He then says the casualties
were 88,000 men. And yes, this is where I got my information from first. In fact, Jason
DeMarc uses Glantz's numbers in his Panzerkrieg book, so we're all following the leader
off a cliff here like lemmings. Now, my mistake, and I made this one alone, so I'm holding
my hands up to that. My mistake was that I said the 88,000 men lost were for the first
day of the 2nd Kotluban Offensive, rather than the first two. So yes, I messed the dates
up, and I apologize for being an idiot.
But it gets worse. By going back and checking this, I noticed that Glantz says, see tables
20 and 21, as verification of the numbers. Well, turning to page 178, we see these two
tables. Yes, there was 88,000 men lost during the first two days of the 2nd Kotluban Offensive.
Except, wait a second, this table doesn't say the 18th and 19th of September. It says
the 1st to 20th of September. Well, that's not the 2nd Kotluban Offensive. That's the
first and the early part of the 2nd Kotluban Offensive. So, has Glantz made a mistake here?
He definitely said it was 88,000 men for the first two days of the 2nd Kotluban Offensive,
whereas the date for this table, where he got the numbers from, shows a much larger
period. Now, if you notice, Glantz actually took this information from Isaev. Well, when
Glantz's book was published, Isaev hadn't put his book out in English yet. He now has
it published.
And turning to page 152 of Isaev's book, we have the same two charts. And yes, it does
say the 1st to 20th of September. So this must be confirmation, right? Glantz must have
messed up and carried all the casualties for the first and early part of the 2nd Kotluban
Offensive as having occurred in the first two days of the 2nd Kotluban Offensive, right?
Well, the problem is that Isaev is specifically talking about the 2nd Kotluban Offensive here.
It's in a chapter on the 18th and 19th of September. And, as he's talking about the
2nd Kotluban Offensive, above the second chart, Isaev writes,
"...losses among the rank-and-file of the Stalingrad Front's three armies were also
quite high."
See table. Below the chart, he goes on to say how losses for two of the rifle divisions
during the 2nd Kotluban Offensive were devastating, losing roughly half their men. So, all this
implies that these losses in the chart are only for the 2nd Kotluban Offensive, rather
than the full period of the 1st to 20th of September. So which is it? Could this be
a typo on the chart? Should it have read 18th to 20th of September? Or is this chart for
both the 1st and 2nd Kotluban Offensives? In which case, are the losses for the 1st
Kotluban Offensive, which I have quoted previously, also wrong?
Glantz says on page 55 that the 1st Kotluban Offensive probably resulted in the loss of
about a third of the original 250,000 men that took part, which would be 80,000 casualties
as I said in a previous episode. It looks like a guesstimate though, so maybe this is
also wrong. But then again, this may throw out the numbers even further. The three armies
participating in the 2nd Kotluban Offensive had roughly 195,000 men in their ranks. So,
if they had 250,000 for the 1st Kotluban Offensive, they were down by 55,000 men for the 2nd,
even though they had received reinforcements, which implies even more than 55,000 men were
lost for the 1st. But if it was higher than 55,000 men for the 1st, then the losses for
the 2nd must have been less than 33,000 men, which then doesn't correspond with the events,
because Isaev says that the 308th and 316th Rival Divisions alone lost just under 10,000
men during the first two days of the 2nd Kotluban Offensive. So that would leave only about
23,000 men lost for the rest of the units participating in the offensive, which doesn't
seem right given the fact you have three armies participating in the attack, and a lot of
losses implied in the narrative. Really, this all depends on whether this chart from
Isaev is for the 1st and early part of the 2nd Kotluban Offensive, or just for the first
two days of the 2nd, because if it's for both 1st and 2nd Kotluban, then Zhukov's
attacks were not as deadly for the Soviets as first assumed.
I mean, 88,000 men would still be a terrible loss compared to German casualties of about
5,000 or 6,000 for this period, a ratio of 15 to 1. But clearly, it wouldn't have been
160,000 for a German loss of 5,000 or 6,000, a ratio of 27 to 1. So it's worth verifying
this. I therefore did the only thing I could do in this situation. I contacted Anton Jolly.
Anton Jolly got in touch with Igor Kobyakov, who's provided us with some primary source
documents for the 1st Guards Army. Now, yes, there were two other armies participating
in the 2nd Kotluban Offensive, but the 1st Guards was the main one, so we can get a pretty
decent picture of the numbers from this.
The total strength of Moskalenko's army was 123,882 men, which is what I said in the
series, so that's good. The combat strength was 97,114. And, as Glenn said, not all of
them participated in the attack, so probably 86,000 men and 170 tanks took part on the
first day. The rest probably went in later though. But even still, it should be obvious
that 88,000 men lost is not possible, even if we count the other armies, because 1st
Guards Army took the brunt of the losses, and certainly wouldn't have lost most of
its men. If it sent in 86,000 men and lost the majority of the 88,000 casualties, what
would it have been left with? Like 10,000 men? It's just not possible. Unfortunately,
the recorded losses are not counted daily. Instead, they're listed for the period of
the 18th to the 30th of September, so we can't get more accurate and say how many they lost
on the first day, or the first two days, unfortunately. But the losses for that entire period were
10,376 killed, 32,615 wounded, and 7,661 missing. That's a total of 50,652 for the entire
period of the 18th to 30th of September.
Yes, we've got to take into account the other two armies. So maybe it was 88,000 for
all three armies over this period. Although that still seems a little high, considering
1st Guards Army was the main army taking part. But it could be right, and maybe that's
what Isaev's numbers are about. I actually suspect that Isaev's chart should have read
18th to the 30th of September, rather than 1st to the 20th. Maybe that's the error
here. Either way, it's clearly not 88,000 on the first day, nor the first two days.
It was probably more like 20,000 for the first day or two. And I say that because Isaev does
point out that the two rifle divisions that got routed on the first day or so lost about
half their strength, almost 10,000 men. There was also a lull in the fighting after the
first two days, and then it picked up later again. So it would make sense to lose 20,000
men that first two days, a few more losses in the middle, then the majority of the rest
later, when the attack got ramped up again. So it's still a lot of guys. 20,000 versus
maybe 2,000 Germans for two days. A ratio of about 10 to 1. But not as ridiculously
high as it was originally stated. And just to clarify as well, the tank losses were correct.
About 106 tanks were taken out, out of an original total of 170. So at least I got that
right.
But Igor Kobyakov notes,
"...there is also a document on the results of the offensive. The result is not called
anything other than a failure. Unsatisfactory command of divisional headquarters, shameful
actions of artillery, lack of coordination of actions, etc. etc."
So, while the losses weren't as high as I and others originally stated, the offensive
was still nothing short of a disaster for the Soviets. Again guys, I'm going to recommend
you read Igor Kobyakov's articles, link in the description, and check out Anton Joly's
channel. He's just starting a new series on the Battle of Berlin, which I may be contributing
to audio-wise. So definitely worth subscribing to him there.
Thus, I think it was probably 88,000 casualties for the 1st Kotluban Offensive, and probably
88,000 or less for the 2nd, with the first two days of the 2nd probably resulting in
about 20,000 casualties for the Soviets. So the question is, should I take down my video,
redo those parts, and then re-upload? Or should I just put a note in the description and pin
a comment explaining the issue, and then link into this video, and just hope that people
see those comments? I don't know. On the one hand, I kind of want to keep the error
up, so I can link to this video and clarify it for people, so they can see how mistakes
creep into the narrative and then get addressed by historians, because I wasn't the only
one to make the mistake here. But on the other hand, I also don't want people coming away
with the wrong impression about the 2nd Kotluban Offensive, or the Eastern Front. I'm also
aware that people don't read the description or the pinned comments, so I'm not 100%
confident that people will see the correction. But on the other hand, people may get annoyed
when they see a new video pop up in their feed, only to find that it's an old Battlestorm
video they've already watched and therefore don't really need to listen to. So what
do you guys think? Let me know.
This is probably a good opportunity to highlight a comment I got in Episode 19. I was going
to highlight this comment a while back anyway, but didn't find the right moment to do it.
Now though, making a serious error, I think it's worth highlighting it, because the
wrong thing to do when you make a mistake is refuse to admit it.
Mr Said
I really love that you are so self-critical. More historians slash youtubers, actually
more people in general, should be that way. I imagine you might be too hard on yourself
sometimes, but it really does show in the quality of your work.
I replied,
You're correct that more people should be like this. I respect people who can admit
their own mistakes more than people who pretend they never make them. Too many people think
that admitting their mistakes makes you look a bad person, and that you should guard yourself
from all criticism. That's a poor man's mentality.
And perhaps I am overly self-critical. However, the idea is not to do myself or my work down,
but about improving and getting it right. Only by accepting our flaws can we strive
to overcome them. If I refuse to admit mistakes, as some people do, and I've met those people,
then it's impossible to learn, and it's impossible to grow.
Yeah, there's a little bit of an embarrassment when it comes to making mistakes, and I feel
bad right now for not spotting the errors I've made, or even the errors other people
have made. But I suspect that many people, having watched this video, will see me in
a more positive light now, because they know I'm willing to be open and honest about
my mistakes. This has happened before, and people get frustrated when I do make mistakes
and admit them, because they expect me to be perfect for some reason, which is impossible,
but at least people know I'm genuinely trying to get to the truth. And because the truth
is what is most important, I'd rather be open and honest, admit my mistakes, and have
people trust that I'm telling the truth in the vast majority of times, when I don't
make mistakes, than not admit my mistakes, and then lose the trust of you guys, and then
not be able to tell you the truth, because even if I presented the truth, you'd automatically
think I was lying. And I know some people don't trust anything I say anyway, or anything
any historian says, which is a topic I've been meaning to talk about for a while, and
if I'm honest, it's actually been getting me depressed. It's actually been distracting
me from doing my work, and preventing me from concentrating on my work. Maybe I'll do
a video about it soon, but I am genuinely trying to provide you guys with the truth,
based on the evidence and sources that I have. So, you can choose to believe that or not.
I also need to bring up the fact that the reason I made this mistake that I did with
the dates, and the other mistakes before this, is because I'm exhausted. I'm laughing,
but it's true. Look guys, I've got to be honest, Stalingrad is killing me. Like, it's
killing me. People were joking at the beginning, saying that the Stalingrad series is going
to be Tick's slow descent into insanity. They were right! It feels like I'm fighting
a war of attrition. If it was just the Stalingrad series on its own, I could probably manage
that. Or, if it was the other videos on their own, I could probably cope. But the combination
of Battlestorm and these other videos together at the same time, it's just impossible.
With the older Battlestorms, there was an end. Like, there was a light at the end of
the tunnel. But for Stalingrad, it's never-ending. It's like, it's the longest battle in human
history. And we're only, I think we're like two months into it. It's a seven month
campaign. Right now we're at like 15 hours of content for the Stalingrad series itself,
not including the addendum videos. Concentrating with Stalingrad has made me fall behind. I'm
basically out of ammunition right now. I've been working on things, but I need to do more
reading before I can commit to making videos on those particular topics. Plus there's
an issue I mentioned before that is distracting me, and I've got a couple of difficult Q&A
questions to answer which require a lot of reading. I'm not going to stop doing the
videos, I just need time to catch up. So I may do some shorter videos for the next couple
of weeks. I've got an idea for a video about British grand strategy during the Second
World War. That's going to be a bit like the Poland video I did a while back with the
maps. It won't require references because it's more of a thought experiment, but the
video will only be about 5-10 minutes if that, so I could do that. Or videos on topics that
aren't necessarily about the battles, but let's say, you know, on that problem I mentioned
before. And there's a reaction video I need to do as well. That's going to be a bit longer,
but it'll only take like a day to put it together, so I may as well do that. And it's also something
that's distracting me right now as well, so I want to get that done. It's also related
to the problem I mentioned before. People are going to probably kick off, and I may
lose Patreon support because a couple of weeks of short videos will do that, but I think it's
reached the point where it's necessary. And this isn't burnout by the way. I've had burnout before,
and I just worked straight through it. This is just me getting distracted, falling behind,
and then needing to regroup. So hopefully you guys can let me off a little.
I've also got a Patreon question relating to Stalingrad that I said I would address
in this addendum video, so here it is. Basilikum Nashe said,
I just don't get the attack of the 6th Army. They did a frontal attack from the east and
therefore pushed the Soviets into the city, while on the other hand, the 4th Panzer Army
planned to overrun the south and capture the city by a swift push. That makes no sense at all.
Isn't one laying the focus of 6th Army's attack on the north, therefore luring away Soviet troops
from the centre and maybe even the south, plus freeing up troops from 14th and 3rd Divisions
to strengthen the defence in the north? Two, or even just not attacking on the 7th?
Just wait one day so a combined and prepared strong push would overpower the Soviet defences
far outside of the city of Stalingrad? A way better option? In my opinion, that attack on
the 7th lost Stalingrad. What are your thoughts on that?
So, you're referring to the situation late in Episode 16, where Paulus had the choice of
either helping Wietersheim's forces in the north, who were suffering during the
1st Kotluban Offensive, or marching directly into the city, which is what they did.
You're saying that, by choosing to march into the city, all Paulus did was push Soviet forces
back into the city, rather than surround them, which then would cause problems inside the city.
And also, by marching into the centre, they neglected the Orlovka salient,
which then increased the pressure on Wietersheim in the north.
Your suggestion is that Paulus should have sent Seydlitz's 51st Army Corps to fight at Orlovka,
tackle the north of the city first, then move south to link up with Kempf's forces,
and then surround the Soviet forces outside the city. At least, I think that's what you're saying.
There's a couple of things to note here. The original plan was for 14th Panzer Corps
to strike south into the city, meet up with Kempf at the same time that Seydlitz was marching in.
So this would have done what you're suggesting. It would have surrounded Soviet forces outside
the city for Seydlitz to crush them, or it would have simply overwhelmed Soviet forces in the city
because another three divisions would have struck the city at the beginning, and this would have
been overwhelming in theory. But this plan was thrown out because 14th Panzer Corps got bogged
down at Kotluban. Thus, only two corps were available for the assault on Stalingrad.
In this sense, 1st Kotluban saved the city, sort of. The problem of course is that 14th Panzer
Corps would have had to guard the northern flank anyway, even if the Kotluban Offensives hadn't
happened. Because you can't just leave the northern flank open, and there weren't any
other divisions in the area to take over their front. So, I don't think much of 14th Panzer
Corps would ever have been able to go south, maybe some but not all. So the original idea
of trying to strike from the north and south of Stalingrad and trap the Soviets west of the city
wouldn't have worked, even if Kotluban hadn't happened.
So, then we're left with the two corps that did strike into Stalingrad. And yes,
in theory, Paulus could have shifted forces northwards to attack the Olovka salient,
and this could have relieved pressure on 14th Panzer Corps. It also would have allowed 51st
Army Corps to secure the north before striking south into the city, in much the same way that
48th Panzer Corps did in the south. I think the issue here though, is that Seydlitz and
Kempf's forces were too weak by themselves to actually achieve these separate objectives.
Imagine having to leave 71st Infantry Division in the centre, while the other two divisions
of 51st Army Corps moved north to do this encircling manoeuvre. I don't think this
would have worked. And even if they had reached the city and struck south, and if Kempf had struck
north, these two weak forces wouldn't have been able to achieve their objectives, and I think
Paulus knew this. So what he decided to do was have Seydlitz concentrate in the centre,
hopefully splitting the 62nd Army into two, and then have Kempf and Seydlitz concentrate
in wiping out the southern encirclement first, then concentrate on the northern portion of
Stalingrad. I think Paulus saw that, if he sent the 51st Army Corps to the north,
Kempf and Seydlitz would be separate and unable to work together. So Kempf would have struggled
in the south against Soviet forces that would have been able to shift south against him,
and Seydlitz would have also suffered the same problem later. I think that the only reason Kempf
was able to do so well in the south was because 51st Army Corps was in the centre,
tying down Soviet forces and blocking most of their units from moving south.
If 51st Army Corps had been fighting in the Olovka area, then Kempf probably would have
had to face the brunt of 13th Guards Rifle Division, as well as other reinforcements
coming into Stalingrad. As for not attacking on the 7th, but waiting for a bit before striking
forwards, yeah that may have been an option. But I think Paulus' original idea was to take the
city of Stalingrad on the march. Meaning, march in and seize the city quickly, rather than get
bogged down in fighting for individual positions in a stop-start affair. I think that Paulus
didn't want to stop, because he probably thought that if he did stop, then the Soviets would be
able to dig in, preventing him from marching quickly into the city and seizing it.
We also have to take into account the 1st Kotluban Offensive.
Paulus seems to be spurred into action to relieve pressure on 14th Panzer Corps,
and that's probably why he didn't wait, but attacked on the 7th. He may have also decided
to attack into the city centre and south of the city, rather than the north, to draw Soviet
reinforcements in the 62nd Army away from the north, away from 14th Panzer Corps.
Had Seydlitz gone north, the Soviets may have sent 13th Guards Rifle Division north as well,
increasing pressure on 14th Panzer Corps, rather than relieving it.
Also, as I discussed in the last episode, I think the turning point happened a little
earlier than the 7th. I think it happened on the 2nd or the 3rd of September. But,
you're right that the turning point happened at some time in that first week of September,
rather than happening later when they entered the city. And this just gives me another great
opportunity to highlight a common thread that was in episode 19 of the Stalingrad series. Just look
at how many different perspectives there are, depending on which country you're from.
Big Man Foamy said,
Wow, the way this battle is taught in documentaries and schools,
you would think the Germans simply walked into Stalingrad before getting stopped.
Here we can see that both sides were battered before the Rat War began.
It's mad. Great series.
I replied,
Exactly. That's the myth the Germans built after the war, to say that Hitler was a madman
for not allowing the German generals to win, or the Blitzkrieg to work. In reality,
the Blitzkrieg broke down, and the German generals can't entirely blame Hitler for this.
A lot of it was their fault.
Jan said,
Wow, you have been so lucky to have this topic in school.
The entire WW2 history lesson for us was a one-hour monologue of our teacher.
No comments. I hope this has changed a bit after 35 years now.
I said,
When I was in school, our WW2 lesson was all about the atomic bombs.
It's a story I need to tell one day because it's ridiculous.
Foamy replied,
Honestly, the whole war was basically covered in three days.
Kyna went, invasion of Poland, France fell, Russia invaded,
winter has come, Germans enter Stalingrad, they lose.
D-Day, Germany capitulates.
There was little depth or discussion.
I remember we got shown the infamous charge scene from Enemy at the Gate.
And that was it.
There was no mention of Pearl Harbor, North Africa, the war against Japan in general,
the Italian campaign, or even the Battle of Berlin.
Frederick Bayes confirms it hasn't changed.
Enowent said,
I barely had any 20th century history in school at all. By the looks of it,
the next generation will have even less. It's not a popular subject anymore,
at least over here, which is sad, especially considering how much in today's world
is a consequence of the war and other events that get discussed even less
the fall of the USSR for instance, at least when looking from a western or European perspective.
You know, I think it's sad. And I think the education system is a disaster.
But then again, some people do say they were taught the Second World War in school,
or at least one version of it.
I grew up in Poland, so I was presented with a different narrative
than the one Tick is trying to disprove. Germans were not presented as elite,
but rather as fanatical brutes that pushed their way through weaker Soviet forces.
They were then stopped by heroic defenders who fought desperate last stands to wear
the Germans down while the Soviets built up forces to push them back. The German generals
weren't presented as brilliant tacticians, but rather just brutal extensions of Hitler's will.
Basically, this is the Soviet or Russian perspective, which is pushing the idea that
the Soviets allowed their armies to fall back, while they built up massive counter-attacking
forces to throw the enemy back. It was the plan all along. This isn't true either,
and just shows people get taught different perspectives depending on where they live
and who has influenced them. Enewett replied,
There's a pretty common narrative going around that what defeated the Reich was the Normandy
landings in 1944. Not very common amongst educated people, but quite so amongst laymen,
probably due to Hollywood or something similar. At least here in Scandinavia.
And yes, as I said to Enewett, that's also the narrative I heard too early on. It was
common in the west, during the Cold War, for Normandy and El Alamein to be classed as the
turning points of the war. It was partly due to ignorance of the scale of the conflict in the
East, plus anti-Soviet Union-slash-Cold War propaganda. To Kozlowski I replied,
Given the history of Poland during WW2 and subsequent Cold War era, it's understandable
why you would be taught that. This common thread shows how different perspectives, biases and
agendas can creep into history, and why it's important that we consider all angles before
coming to any conclusions. Kozlowski then shows how it's different in the West.
Mind you, that was just elementary school history lessons and general media portrayal
in books, movies and TV. I moved to Canada around the 8th grade, so then I got my WW2
history lessons from the Canadian perspective, i.e. focus on Dieppe and Normandy. In Poland,
you would not get the hero-worship for German generals like Rommel or Guderian,
and no one really cares about the differences between Wehrmacht or SS. My grandmother's
parents were killed by Wehrmacht, my grandfather's by SS. The thread goes on, but the point is that
depending on which country you're from, you're going to be getting a different perspective on the
events of history, and I think this is why I'm having such trouble trying to convince certain
I've got pro-German viewers dismissing everything I'm saying as propaganda,
saying I'm shilling for the Russians. And I've got others from Russia saying how
biased I am in favour of the Germans. And that's just on this one subject. Across all the other
subjects I've got a multitude of different perspectives and agendas to deal with. I don't
know what to do, because people are learning false narratives in school, or they've read something
in a newspaper or on Wikipedia, or maybe they've read one book on a topic, and then they assume
that everything that goes against that perspective must be wrong and should instantly be dismissed.
We are definitely living in the age of fake news and the age of emotionalism,
rather than the age of logic or reason. This is a time where dismissal and distrust
is the name of the game, and it's frustrating. There's one guy out here right now, a YouTuber,
with a channel and audience of 16,000 people, claiming that TIK's an anti-Semite. There's
another channel where the guys on it state openly that they don't believe me at all,
and they say I'm being deliberately dishonest. And for these people, nothing I say will persuade
them otherwise. Or, at least, that's not how I don't think I can get through to these
people. And these guys aren't trolls necessarily. I think they're just so wrapped up in their
own perspectives that they've closed themselves off from all others' perspectives, and I can't
get through to them. So I'm at a bit of a loss right now on how to get through to people like
that. If anyone has any suggestions, let me know, and I may bring some of your suggestions up
in a future video that I may do on this problem. But anyway, so yeah, thanks guys.
Thanks for watching. Bye for now.