Wilhelm Canaris was the head of the Abwehr, and one of the key members of the Germans resistance movement during WW2. Along with Hans Oster, Ludwig Beck, Paul Thümmel and many others, they plotted and schemed to take down Hitler, or undermine him in his conquest of Europe. But just how effective was the German resistance at stopping Hitler? Let's find out.
🔔 Subscribe for more History content: Videos EVERY Monday at 5pm GMT (depending on season, check for British Summer Time).
This video isn't sponsored. My income comes purely from my Patreons and SubscribeStars, and from YouTube ad revenue. So, if you'd like to support this channel and make these videos possible, please consider becoming a Patreon or SubscribeStar. All supporters who pledge $1 or more will have their names listed in the videos. For $5 or more you can ask questions which I will answer in future Q&A videos (note: I'm behind with the Q&A's right now, and have a lot of research to do to catch up, so there will be a delay in answering questions). There are higher tiers too with additional perks, so check out the links below for more details.
Thank you to my current supporters! You're AWESOME!
- - - - -
📽️ RELATED VIDEO LINKS 📽️
Who saved Hitler? The Munich Crisis & The Oster Conspiracy 1938 the Gleiwitz Incident the SPARK that ignited WW2? MAIN Reason Why Germany Lost WW2 - OIL STALINGRAD S1/E1 - The 6th Army Strikes! Theory 101 - - - -
ABOUT TIK 📝
History isn’t as boring as some people think, and my goal is to get people talking about it. I also want to dispel the myths and distortions that ruin our perception of the past by asking a simple question - “But is this really the case?”. I have a 2:1 Degree in History and a passion for early 20th Century conflicts (mainly WW2). I’m therefore approaching this like I would an academic essay. Lots of sources, quotes, references and so on. Only the truth will do.
This video is discussing events or concepts that are academic, educational and historical in nature. This video is for informational purposes and was created so we may better understand the past and learn from the mistakes others have made.Credit: TIKhistory
The story of the German Resistance is one of missed opportunities, rivalries and death.
It had the potential to stop the war before it even began, and end it once it had. Hitler
could have been removed from power, or even killed, and the downfall of the German Resistance
may have led to the only government-sponsored assassination of a senior National Socialist
So the question today, asked by my Patron, Spectre321, is, how effective was Wilhelm
Canaris and the German Resistance? And did they have an overall effect on the eventual
collapse of the Third Reich? Let's find out.
The only force in the Third Reich with the capability of taking Hitler down was the Wehrmacht.
But not all of it was equal. The Luftwaffe was the newest arm, and was therefore loyal
to Hitler. The navy, with the exception of Canaris, largely kept out of politics. So
it was only really within the German Army that a resistance movement came about, mainly
thanks to its traditional Prussian roots.
Hitler had rejected the old Prussian values and beliefs, had none of the manners, education
or decency that the German generals saw in themselves, and had sacked the head of the
army, Fritsch. He had a secret police force, and promoted street violence, plus was marching
Germany to war. All of this alienated the old generals.
But that doesn't mean that the entire army was against him, or that the resistance was
massive. The army largely stood by and did nothing to stop Hitler, and there are several
reasons why. For one, the rapid rearmament program and expansion had diluted the influence
of the Prussian tradition. Worse, Hitler had basically showered the generals with money,
gifts and estates, bribing them into doing his bidding. The Allies had proven incapable
of standing up to Hitler, which persuaded the generals that Hitler was doing the right
thing. And there are more reasons besides this.
This is why, if we take the Abwehr headed by Canaris, we can see that only a few people
within it were active resistance members. Of the 13,000 officials and clerks working
for the wartime Abwehr, 50 at most could be considered active conspirators, and as a convinced
anti-communist, Canaris would never accept former KPD, SPD or other Marxist activists.
This, by the way, suggests that former members of the KPD, SPD and other Marxist activists
were still around in the Third Reich at this time, which is contrary to the Marxist narrative
that states that they were all thrown into concentration camps. Clearly, that couldn't
be the case if Canaris had the choice of recruiting them, but then decided not to do so.
In fact, there were members of the Abwehr who were fanatical Nazis who believed in what
Hitler was doing. They even conspired against Canaris from late 1942 onwards. So the Abwehr
as a whole cannot be seen as a den for the resistance. And overall, the German resistance
within the military was small, especially in the pre-war and early war phase. It only
really started to grow later, but by then it was too late.
At the heart of the German resistance was Wilhelm Canaris, a conservative from the navy
and a committed anti-Bolshevik. He became head of the German intelligence service, the
Abwehr, in early 1935.
In Spectre's Question, he mentions how Paddy Ashdown, in his book, Nine, Standing Up to
Hitler, which is actually a very entertaining read and a great introduction to the topic,
paints some of these characters in too good of a light, and omits certain facts about
some of the individual's darker backgrounds. This is arguably the case with Canaris.
Canaris was a resistance member. He did fight against Hitler and the regime, but not at
first. Like millions of other Germans, he, Canaris, saw in Hitler a saviour, and an enemy
of the Bolshevism that was his sworn enemy. The extreme anti-Semitism, no doubt given
his later acts to save several Jews, would not have appealed to Canaris, himself a far
from Aryan-looking German. But the Communist Left was still seen by the officer class in
Germany, rightly or wrongly, as the preserve of Bolshevik Jews. Whatever his distance towards
Hitler later in his life, there can be little doubt that at this stage, Canaris was a believer
and, as shall be seen, not above playing the Nazis by appealing to their prejudices, anti-Semitism
included.
His friend Richard Protzer, as well as many historians, say that the Blomberg-Fritz Affair
was the turning point in Canaris' loyalty to the Führer. To keep it simple, Blomberg
was sacked for marrying a lady who had, 17 years previously, posed in naughty pictures
to comply with YouTube's Communist guidelines. She was therefore deemed to be a pro, and
a general shouldn't have married such a strong independent woman like that. So Hitler
got rid of him, and General Fritsch, who was falsely accused of being a homosexual, which
Hitler and the other Nazis weren't happy with either.
Canaris and Oster, one of his subordinates, as well as Ludwig Beck and Schacht of the
Reichsbank, planned to gather some of the generals in the army, march on Gestapo headquarters,
arrest Himmler and Heydrich, and then publish all captured evidence, which would force the
Führer to back down on the Blomberg-Fritz Affair and compel him to abolish the Gestapo.
But they failed to persuade Raeder, von Rundstedt, List, von Kluge and Halder to join them, so
the plot fell through. Canaris and Keitel even went to Göring and presented evidence
that Fritsch was innocent, which didn't work. The point is though that this was when
the systematic organization of Hitler's opponents began.
Canaris did turn against Nazism prior to the beginning of the war, before most of the serious
crimes were committed. But obviously he had to pretend to be a loyal Nazi, whilst at the
same time was playing a double game against the regime and Hitler, so he really was in
a difficult position. This game was made worse by the fact that Canaris and Heydrich, head
of the rival SD security service, lived on the same street and had a personal and friendly
relationship, even though they were enemies. While Heydrich was planning and implementing
the final solution, Canaris and Oster tried to help the Jews during Kristallnacht, with
some being sheltered in their homes. Afterwards, they set up an organization to sneak Jews
out of Germany, and Canaris also posted Jews to foreign countries, claiming that they were
doing the Abwehr's bidding when challenged by the Gestapo. He even smuggled out of Poland
one famous rabbi who had a large following in the United States.
However, at the same time, Canaris' secret police were handing over civilians to the
Einsatzkommandos in Poland. Canaris also helped plan the war of extermination in the
Soviet Union, at least regarding the execution of Jews and the commissars. So Canaris wasn't
squeaky clean. But then again, he couldn't openly resist Hitler, because in order to
resist Hitler effectively, he had to pretend to be on his side whilst also trying to sabotage
him. So, you know, he was in this grey middle-ground area playing a double game, which makes you
wonder if we can really blame him for going along with Hitler publicly whilst privately
resisting him. And, to be fair, he was genuinely horrified by what was happening, and ordered
his agents to compile notes on the executions, getting angry when they failed. He also started
saying more openly that they needed to remove Hitler by force. Therefore, this was a dilemma,
and can we really blame him for doing these things whilst also trying to sabotage Hitler
behind his back? I'm not sure, but I'd like to hear from you guys what you think
about this. Anyway, Canaris was appalled by what he saw in Poland.
It is dreadful. Our children's children will have to bear the blame for this.
Canaris also tried to stop some of the executions in the Soviet Union, or at least reduce the
casualties, and even lodged an official complaint about the treatment of prisoners of war. But
Keitel dismissed his complaint.
"...adults express correspond to the soldierly conception of chivalrous warfare. We are dealing
here with the destruction of a world view. Therefore I approve the measures and support
them."
And Canaris was manipulating the flow of information to Hitler to slow him down, or divert him
from certain courses, and was providing information to the Allies, the Czechs, the British, and
probably also the Soviets, to try and get them to stand fast against Hitler. Canaris
also had infiltrated Mi6, and it does appear that he was talking to the British, at least
indirectly. All this points to the idea that Canaris was against Hitler, but had to play
along with him in order to continue to undermine him.
Apart from Canaris, there were some other important German resistance members. Karl
Goedeler was a conservative who became the Price Commissar on the 5th of November 1934,
hoping he could use his position to change Hitler. He resigned in 1936, and then became
a resistance member. Ludwig Beck, Prussian conservative and head of the German General
Staff, had first welcomed the Nazis when they took power, and was even anti-Semitic
due to his Lutheran faith, but was horrified by the murder of von Schleicher and his wife
during the Night of the Long Knives. The failed coup in Austria in 1934 convinced Beck that
Hitler wanted war, and this was later confirmed when Beck was ordered to start planning, in
1935, the invasion of Czechoslovakia, and the planning in 1937 for the annexation of
Austria. By the time of the Blomberg-Fritzsch Affair, Beck had realized that passive resistance
from the Wehrmacht wouldn't work, and only active resistance could now stop Hitler. Another
man, whose identity was only established after the war, was working to pass German secrets
to the Czechs, and then later the British. We now know him as Paul Thümmel, one-time
Master Baker, founder member of the Nazi Party, holder of the Party's Golden Badge, friend
of Himmler, and in 1936, a member of Wilhelm Canaris's Abwehr station in Dresden, which
was charged with spying on Czechoslovakia. There were others, like General Walter von
Brauchitsch, who shared Beck's views about Hitler, although didn't actively partake
in the resistance. And it's not clear, but Georg Thomas, the general in charge of German
logistics, may have been in the German resistance, or at least was hovering on the borderline
of joining it, like Schacht of the Reichsbank, or even possibly, although I'm sceptical
about this, Franz Halder.
Obviously, those around Hitler knew of his plans for war. Most, such as Himmler and Ribbentrop,
supported the Führer, but some, like Goering, were more cautious. Others, such as the Minister
of Economics and President of the Reichsbank, Jamalar Schacht, hovered in the outer circles
of the resistance, without ever quite allowing themselves to be drawn fully in. In the pre-war
years, the resistance was trying to warn the world about what was coming. Prior to the
fall of Czechoslovakia, Paul Thumel met the head of the Czechoslovakian intelligence and
not only gave the German codes, but also full information about the German network of spies
in Austria. He warned them that SS regiments were gathering on the border, and that they
were preparing to march on Vienna.
I've already talked about the Munich Crisis and the Oster Conspiracy during last week's
video, so I won't go over that again. What I will point out though, is that the German
resistance had failed in that instance, and would continue to do so in the pre-war and
early war period. This was because, when the German plotters went to the British in 1937
and 1938, they were seen as meddlers and interferers, not as good men. This was why, when Paul Thumel
informed the Czechs after the Munich Agreement that the rest of Czechoslovakia was about
to be taken over by Germany, the Czech Intelligence Service informed their superiors, who dismissed
it. As did the British.
It was only after the Munich Agreement that London started hoping for a coup attempt to
remove Hitler. Chamberlain had also changed his mind. Rather than trying to appease Hitler,
it was clear by the March of 1939 that this policy had failed, and so he finally decided
to stand firm. But the best opportunity had been lost, and many of the plotters felt betrayed
by the West, losing faith in the idea of removing Hitler, and began to turn away from active
resistance. So it was too little, too late.
Still, there was hope that the war could be avoided. Yamilar Schacht and Goerdeler met
on the 23rd of March 1939 in France. Schacht told Goerdeler that Hitler was going to invade
Poland that autumn. And on April 3rd, Hitler ordered his generals to plan the invasion
of Poland. So, Schacht knew about the war before the generals did.
Strangely enough, it was about this time that Chamberlain changed his mind, and finally
started to stand firm against Hitler. Coincidence? On the 6th of April, Chamberlain forged the
Anglo-Polish alliance, and the Poles immediately became less willing to discuss Danzig.
In June 1939, Paul Thumel warned the British that the invasion of Poland would start no
later than the 1st of September 1939. In August, he also told them that Hitler believed that
the British and the French wouldn't intervene if Hitler invaded Poland. His report to the
British contained a sketch of the invasion plans, as well as the names of German commanders
down to divisional level. It also said that Hitler ordered Himmler to provide the SS with
150 Polish uniforms and weapons for the Brandenburg Regiment. Paul said that they were probably
for a fake border incident. So, all of those saying that Hitler didn't want war, but
was forced into it? No, he had been planning this since at least April 1939. And by June,
the commanders down to divisional level were already known, suggesting that the plans were
well in place by the time they got to September.
Another plot occurred on the 25th of August 1939. The problem was that Hitler cancelled
the invasion of Poland on the 25th, and the plotters got cold feet again, believing that
war had been avoided. Obviously, war had not been avoided, only delayed, and the German
resistance had failed to stop Hitler in the pre-war period.
In the first ten days of the Polish campaign, an anti-Nazi general invited Hitler to his
army headquarters in the west, where he planned to arrest and kill him. But Hitler was suspicious
of the general, and turned down the invitation, so the plot was foiled. There was yet another
coup being formed before the invasion of France though. Halder supposedly told one of the
plotters that he would support a coup, and that he had been going to Hitler's headquarters
with a pistol in his pocket with the intention of killing Hitler, but hadn't. Considering
that this is Halder, and we know that he had a big influence on the post-war narrative,
I'm reluctant to believe this.
Brauchitsch decided to try one last time to persuade Hitler from attacking the west. Hitler
raged at him and refused, and Hitler's words persuaded Brauchitsch that Hitler knew of
their plot to assassinate him, and so told Halder. In a panic, Halder ordered that all
the documents related to the plot should be destroyed. But unfortunately, some were not,
which would come back to haunt them later. More plots against Hitler were started, but
failed to gain the support of the army's leadership. In October 1939, Hans Oster warned
the Dutch that Hitler intended to invade the west through the lowlands of Belgium, Holland
and Luxembourg. He also established contacts with the British through the Swiss Intelligence
Service. Godeler informed the British through a different channel, and Canaris was also
determined to do the same, setting up yet another channel to the British. Then Georg
Elser, a carpenter or watchmaker, the sources vary, working entirely alone, successfully
planted a bomb, which detonated at the place where Hitler made a speech. Unfortunately,
Hitler cut his speech short to catch a train. The bomb exploded 13 minutes after Hitler
left. And so it was that a lone anarchist carpenter came closer to assassinating Hitler
than all the plans, and all the preparations, and all the rehearsals, and all the generals,
and all the spies, and all the high officials, and all the diplomats, and all the experts
in Berlin put together.
Elser's bomb plot was initially blamed on the British, which was reinforced by another
event that took place the next day in the Dutch town of Venlo. An event that would have
massive repercussions. Heydrich had sent an officer to pretend to be a German general
who wanted to dispose of Hitler and negotiate peace with Britain. When two British agents
reached the meeting point, Alfred Naujocks, the guy who had been part of the Gleiwitz
incident, covered in a previous video, led an assault team of SD men and captured the
British agents. They were interrogated, and revealed lots of information about the British
spy rings in the Low Countries, and more. This scandal forced the entire MI6 operation
in Holland to be closed down, and unfortunately the files for the Venlo incident are still
closely guarded in the archives, so we don't know the full story even today.
The point is though, that from this moment onwards, MI6 became super-cautious, no longer
trusting the information passed to them from sources like Oster, Canaris, Thummel and others.
This meant that many warnings would be ignored, and it also exposed the fact that Chamberlain
was secretly negotiating with the Germans to end the war, which Churchill used to challenge
Chamberlain for political power, and ultimately made Churchill less willing to negotiate a
peace with Germany. Venlo also made Canaris more cautious, forbidding any more conspiratorial
activities for the time being, and after a couple of tirades against his generals by
Hitler, the resistance basically collapsed in the November of 1939.
He, Canaris, has abandoned all hope of resistance from the generals, and believes there is no
point in trying anything further in that direction. Even though he had given up hope of a coup,
Canaris was willing to warn the West of what was coming.
On November 25th, 1939, Paul Thummel informed the British that the Western Offensive had
been delayed until the summer of 1940. He also warned them of an aerial torpedo which
Hitler was constructing to launch against London. The British and the Netherlands were
informed in January 1940 that Hitler intended to invade both Norway and Denmark in the April
of 1940. Canaris informed Hitler that the British were planning to attack Narvik in
Norway to cut off Swedish iron ore supplies to Germany, and Hitler responded by ordering
plans for an invasion of Norway and Denmark to be drawn up. But Canaris was also feeding
wrong information to Hitler, saying that Sweden's defences were much tougher than they really
were. This was designed to prevent Hitler from invading Sweden, which is where the German
resistance had established important communications to Britain.
Canaris also tried to negotiate a peace deal with the British through the Pope, whom he
knew personally, having rode horses together in the pre-war years. The Pope didn't take
part in the negotiations, just acted as an intermediary, and tried to persuade the British
that the German plotters were genuine. Hans Oster also used the Pope to inform the West
about the invasion of the West, but Hitler found out and demanded that Heydrich and Canaris
hunt down those who had betrayed him. Unfortunately for Canaris and the Abwehr, Heydrich also
had spies in the Vatican, including a Benedictine monk, and was trying to connect the dots.
Thus, the British backed down, and Canaris had to cover his tracks.
On the 21st of February 1940, Paul Thummel informed the British that there would be air
attacks on Britain, that fuel consumption had been cut by half, all private cars were
confiscated, leave was suspended, a new bomber was under construction, and that the Germans
would probably cross the French and Belgian borders near the Channel. On the 25th of March,
Paul then informed them that a feint attack would be made on Belgium, but the main attack
would come through the Ardennes. Panzers would cross the Meuse near Sedan, and strike to
the Channel. And this was in the March of 1940. Britain actually accepted the information,
but it was the French who deemed it a Venlo-style misinformation. More information came to the
British that Hitler was going to attack Norway, while yet another source told them again that
the main attack on France would come through the Ardennes.
On the 6th of April, the Swedes also informed Lord Halifax in London of the forthcoming
attack on Denmark and Norway. After Norway fell, Paul again told the British that once
France fell, Britain would be attacked by the air. Canaris once again sent an agent
to the Vatican to warn the West of the attack on France, knowing full well that Heydrich
had spies there. This just shows how desperate they were. The date of the attack was passed
to the West, but the Dutch and Belgians refused to act on the warning. Thus, the Western Allies
were defeated.
With the successful conquest of the West, Canaris mournfully noted at this time that
the active members of the resistance had shrunk to fewer than five fingers on one hand.
It's not clear if Canaris and Churchill had a direct line of communication or not,
but some evidence suggests that they did. The British had certainly broken the Abwehr's
codes in the May of 1940, and were now able to follow Canaris' movements and study him.
The British government later claimed that it wasn't until 1941, or even 1942, that
they knew much about the Abwehr, since only a few documents had been captured prior to
then. They supposedly broke the Abwehr's decryption in 1942. Thus, the British government
covered up the fact that they broke some of the code in May 1940, and were following Canaris.
But don't believe that fact, because that would make you a conspiracy theorist or something.
And the last thing you would want to do is believe that there are conspiracies by States
to hide information from you, even though that's exactly what they're doing.
Wikipedia even admits this.
"...an Official Secrets Act is legislation that provides for the protection of State
secrets and official information, mainly related to Socialist security, but in unrevised
form. Can include all information held by government bodies."
Well, that is a conspiracy by the State to keep information from you.
Oh no, that means that Wikipedia is a conspiracy theory website. We better follow the science
and shut it down.
More conspiracies were afoot. One group of Wehrmacht officers tried to create a commando
unit to strike at Hitler, but didn't get enough numbers to carry it out. Another wanted
snipers to take Hitler out during a parade, but the parade was cancelled. Another planned
to use a hand grenade to kill Hitler when he visited a headquarters on the Western Front,
but Hitler didn't show up. Then the German resistance informed the British that Hitler
was planning to invade the British Isles in Operation Sea Lion. Canaris leaked the details
of the plan to London, and at the same time exaggerated the British strength to Hitler,
saying there were 39 divisions in the landing area, when there were, in fact, only 16. He
also said that there were defences in areas that there weren't, and that they're impossible
to spot from the air. The German resistance then informed the British that Sea Lion was
cancelled.
After the war, when Michael Saltycow asked Churchill how it was possible that he had
been so well-informed about Sea Lion, Churchill merely pointed to Colvin's book on Canaris.
How the intelligence reached Churchill remains a subject for speculation. In other words,
information is being suppressed because there's a conspiracy to suppress that information.
In a nutshell, we're not being told the full story here, and I think the suppression
of this information is related to another topic. There's your clue, which I'll come
back to discuss in the future because it's complicated. But the point is that information
is being suppressed on this topic.
Canaris was instrumental in keeping Spain out of the war. He had previously earned Franco's
trust as a result of his actions during the Spanish Civil War, and now even advised Franco
what to say to Hitler when they met face-to-face on the 23rd of October 1914. The meeting turned
into a fiasco, and Hitler later told Mussolini that he would rather have his teeth pulled
out than have another meeting with Franco. This is perhaps what led Hitler to despise
Franco and the Flanger at the time, with Hitler calling Franco a subaltern, and also
a Jesuit swine, complaining about the false pride of the Spaniard, and saying,
"...we were deceived, because had I known the true facts, I would never have permitted
our aircraft to be used to destroy the starving, and to reinstate the Spanish nobility and
black frocks into their medieval prerogatives."
It wasn't just Canaris that had helped Franco to this decision, since the British had bribed
him £10 million, and also the strategic situation didn't warrant it, but he was a big part
of it.
Of all the steps Wilhelm Canaris took in pursuit of his self-declared aim of frustrating Hitler's
relentless expansionism and denying him victory, this was arguably the most important. For
now, checked by Britain's stubborn refusal to submit in the north, and by Spanish neutrality
in the west, Hitler had only one way to go. East. I would say though that Hitler was going
east anyway, but obviously it would have helped to have taken out Gibraltar and or Portugal,
so Canaris' role here was important.
Canaris and others warned the British that Hitler was intending to help the Italians
out in Greece and invade Yugoslavia. Canaris also informed the Yugoslavs that Belgrade
was going to be bombed, which may have influenced their decision to declare it an open city.
This didn't stop the bombers though. Unfortunately, Heydrich's SD discovered the British telegram
that warned the Yugoslavs that the Luftwaffe would attack Belgrade. They realized that
the leak came from an Abwehr safe, but got no further.
The German resistance were feeding the Dora spy ring information, which was then being
sent to Moscow via Switzerland. Canaris' agents may have also infiltrated the Dora
ring, and the Swiss and British were also feeding information to it too. And they were
all telling the Soviets where Hitler would strike next.
From September 1940, the German resistance had informed London that Hitler was going
east, with them confirming that the invasion would take place in 1941. Paul Fummel confirmed
the positions of the three army groups on the 18th of May 1941. Canaris' agent in
Japan seems to have provided Soviet spy Richard Sorge with information as well. Meanwhile,
the British were sending information to Stalin, as were the Americans, but he wasn't believing
any of it. In fact, he told his spies not to send him any more reports on this nonsense
about a German attack, which they ignored and kept sending him information anyway. For
example, on the 17th of June 1941, just five days before Operation Barbarossa, Stalin received
another report from a source in Göring's Air Ministry, saying that German preparations
were complete and that they were about to attack. In response, Stalin wrote a note to
his security chief saying,
"...Comrade Merkelov, you can send your source from the headquarters of German Aviation
to his f***ing mother. This is not a source but a desinformator."
Stalin must have thought that the German attack was a conspiracy theory. But to explain why
Stalin chose to ignore this information would require a whole video in and of itself, so
I'll save that for another day. The point to note is that the German resistance had
been largely ineffective at warning the other powers about what Hitler was going to do,
because nobody except for Franco, who wasn't on the Allies' side, believed the German
resistance until it was too late.
Moscow was getting information from the Dora Ring until 1944, helping them win battles
like Stalingrad and Kursk, and cementing them as one of the great spy rings of the war.
But the Dora Ring was subsequently stopped by the Germans.
Strangely, not a great deal is written about the spy activities of the Abwehr between 1941
and 1943, which makes me a little suspicious. The only thing that seems certain is that
Canaris sent out peace feelers to the USA in 1943, wanting to know if there was any
alternative to Unconditional Surrender. Roosevelt stood by Unconditional Surrender, so Canaris'
peace attempts fell through.
I'm not going to go into detail about what happened to end Canaris' Abwehr and much
of the German resistance, but I will sum it up. Basically, tensions rose between Canaris
and Heydrich, and it was getting to the point where Heydrich was arresting Canaris' resistance
agents and getting more power over Canaris.
The Czechoslovakian government-in-exile in London, in cooperation with the British Special
Service, assassinated Heydrich on the 27th of May 1942, most likely to save Canaris,
but that's debated. Then, several events all happened seemingly at once that sealed
Canaris' fate. He was forced to close down most of his operations in Turkey, Spain and
Argentina, and Hitler blamed Canaris personally. In early March 1944, Hitler ordered Himmler
to relieve Canaris of command, and create a unified secret service, with Himmler in
charge. Canaris was therefore put in reserve, probably on Himmler's orders.
Canaris wasn't directly involved in the July Plot of 1944, where von Stoffenberg planted
a bomb in Hitler's headquarters that almost got him, but failed. However, Canaris' successor,
Hansen, named Canaris as the spiritual founder of the resistance movement during interrogation,
which sealed his fate. Canaris was, therefore, arrested, along with others like Hans Oster.
Canaris denied all accusations at first, quite successfully as well, and had this been it,
then he may have been spared. But a bunch of files, and later Canaris' own diaries,
were discovered, and that sealed his and the other conspirators' doom. Hitler was informed
and that was that. Canaris and a group of other conspirators who had been caught were
hanged and cremated on the 9th of April 1945, just weeks before the war in Europe ended.
Based on the available sources, themselves limited by the fact that some of the documents
are being hidden from us conspiracy theorists, we can say that the German resistance did
keep Franco out of the war, and did provide intelligence to the Allies that became effective
during the 1942 to 1943 period. It also conducted several plots against Hitler, most notably
the July 1944 bomb plot, but also others getting very close to the mark. Outside of that brief
window, the German resistance was mostly ineffective, and it wasn't necessarily their fault either.
The Allies and the Soviets largely ignored the information that was being passed to them,
both before the war, and during the war as well. The Munich Agreement, the invasion of
the rest of Czechoslovakia, Poland, Norway, Denmark, Belgium, the Netherlands, France,
Operation Barbarossa. The German resistance gave information on all of these events weeks
or months before they happened, yet that information was dismissed. Ultimately, their plots failed
to kill Hitler, and their attempts at finding peace with the West fell on deaf ears because
of Roosevelt's Unconditional Surrender policy. So, while we cannot just dismiss the German
resistance, it was ineffective for quite some time.
To what extent did it have an effect on the eventual collapse of the Third Reich? I would
say, given the sources that we currently have, it didn't have much of an effect. Even if
Spain had joined the Axis, I don't think that would have turned the tide of war in
the Axis favour. And by the time the resistance was being taken seriously, it was mid-war,
and I would say that the tide had already turned by that point. Maybe they shortened
the war by a few months. It's hard to say. But had there not been a German resistance,
I don't think it would have altered things dramatically, because they were largely ineffective.
That said, the books that I have, especially Bassett's, make it clear that the files
on these activities are largely concealed in the State Archives, suggesting that there's
more to this than the information that we currently have. As part of another video,
I'm going to be talking about one of the events which, in my opinion, definitely involved
the German resistance, even though the sources don't quite confirm it, but it would make
a lot of sense if it did, and there may be more going on behind the scenes than we know
about, so the German resistance may have had a bigger impact than we realize. So even though
I'm concluding now that the German resistance was largely ineffective, should more information
come to light after the publication of this video, then we should absolutely reassess
the evidence.
Until then though, I think Paddy Ashdown's Book 9 is a great intro to this topic, and
I'd recommend it if you want more details than what I provided here. Thank you Spectre
for your question, thank you all for watching, bye for now.