As the universe expands, #expanding#space is said to "stretch" photons. But if it stretches photons, does it also stretch molecules, galaxies and you? A portion of this video was sponsored by Salesforce. Go to https://salesforce.com/veritasium to learn more.
References: Expanding Space: the Root of all Evil? Matthew J. Francis, Luke A. Barnes, J. Berian James, Geraint F. Lewis https://arxiv.org/abs/0707.0380
Editing and VFX by Trenton Oliver Thumbnail by Ignat Berbeci
A portion of this video was sponsored by Salesforce.
More about Salesforce at the end of the show.
The first piece of evidence
that showed our universe is expanding
came in the light from distant galaxies.
If you look at the spectrum of the sun,
you see these dark lines.
And we see those same lines in the spectra from galaxies,
except they're shifted to longer wavelengths
towards the red end of the spectrum.
So we say their light is red shifted.
Now, the usual explanation for this redshift
is that as the light is traveling through expanding space,
the photons themselves become stretched.
So short wavelengths get longer.
And this is known as cosmological redshift.
And the explanation is fairly intuitively satisfying
and most people go on without giving it a second thought.
But the problem is, if you do give it a second thought,
you think, well, if expanding space
can stretch something like a photon,
something that's so incredibly tiny,
does it also stretch atoms and molecules?
Is expanding space stretching stars and galaxies?
And what about you?
Are you expanding with the universe?
To answer these questions,
we've got to take a closer look
at what it really means to redshift.
Physicists actually talk about
three different types of redshift.
Doppler redshift,
where observers moving relative to one another
measure photons to have different wavelengths.
Gravitational redshift,
where observers at different locations
in a gravitational field measure different wavelengths.
And cosmological redshift,
where observers exchanging photons
over vast cosmological distances
in an expanding universe measure different wavelengths.
These three cases appear very different
and they're governed by different equations.
So how does each redshift actually occur?
Let's start with a photon in a gravitational field.
There is this famous experiment
conducted in 1959 by Pound and Rebka
sending photons up and down a 22 meter tower at Harvard.
Now they used gamma rays,
but I'll represent them with a visible light.
They found that photons detected at the top of the tower
were redshifted relative to the source
by the exact amount predicted by general relativity,
which is a tiny amount.
I'm dramatically exaggerating the effect
just so you can see it.
Now, where along the photons path
does this redshift take place?
Well, it seems to happen continuously.
The photon loses a little bit of energy
each millimeter it climbs up that tower,
meaning that the photon in the middle of the tower
would appear green.
Now, according to Einstein's equivalence principle,
being at rest on earth's surface is indistinguishable
from being in a rocket in deep space accelerating up at 1G.
So we could do the same experiment in a rocket ship
and we should get the same result.
If we send blue photons from the back of the rocket,
they should be red when they reach the front.
And in the middle of the ship, they would appear green.
This is exactly what we saw at rest in a gravitational field
so the equivalence principle holds.
Now imagine there are a line of external observers
just hanging out in space at rest relative to each other
and they can all see into the rocket.
Let's also say the rocket is initially at rest
and the thrusters are switched on
the instant the photon is released.
Now, since both observers are at rest at this moment,
they will both measure the photon
as having the exact same wavelength, it's blue.
But what about when the photon
reaches the middle of the rocket?
Well, we know someone inside will see it as green,
but what about a stationary observer outside?
Well, to them, the photon has just been moving
through ordinary flat spacetime so it must look blue,
just as blue as it was when it was emitted.
So what's the deal?
How can the same photon look green and blue
at the same time?
Has the equivalence principle been violated?
The answer is no.
It matters a lot to this measurement
who is doing the observation.
Consider this, after the photon is emitted,
the rocket accelerates, it's speeding up.
So by the time the photon reaches the middle of the rocket,
everyone inside is now moving at high velocity
relative to the source when the light was emitted
and relative to the observers outside the rocket.
So it makes sense that the photon as measured inside
will look different, it'll be redshifted.
This is the Doppler redshift
because the observer in the middle of the ship
is moving very quickly away from the source.
By the time the photon makes it to the top of the rocket,
well, the rocket will be going even faster
and this is why it appears red.
But to a stationary observer outside,
well, it still looks blue.
This thought experiment shows us that wavelength and energy
are not intrinsic properties of photons.
They are properties of the photon observer system.
Now, let's recreate the Harvard Tower experiment.
Observers in the building
see the photon redshifted as it climbs.
But here's a question for you.
What would a free-falling observer see?
Well, they would be just like
the stationary observers in space
watching the rocket accelerate up.
The physics of these two situations are identical.
So they would measure no redshift.
To them, the photon would look blue the whole time.
What I wanna show is that there aren't actually
three different types of redshifts.
There is only one.
We've seen that the gravitational redshift
can equivalently be seen as a Doppler redshift
when we do the same analysis
in an accelerating rocket ship.
So what about cosmological redshift?
Well, for this, we have to zoom way out
past our solar system, the Milky Way galaxy,
our local cluster of galaxies.
We wanna zoom so far out
that the galaxies in the observable universe
are like molecules in a fluid, the cosmic fluid.
At this scale, we can treat the whole universe
as being smooth and uniform.
Cosmologists say it is homogeneous.
And just as you don't notice the individual molecules
in a cup of water, at this scale,
we don't notice the individual galaxies
in the cosmic fluid.
And the cosmic fluid looks the same in every direction.
There is no preferred orientation.
It's said to be isotropic.
Now, what you'll notice
is that the cosmic fluid is spreading out.
It doesn't matter where you look, you see the same thing.
Things moving apart.
The density of the cosmic fluid is decreasing over time.
And this is the basic property of an expanding universe.
We can draw some coordinates on the universe.
We could pick any different coordinate system we like,
but one way it's often done is to make a coordinate system
that expands with the cosmic fluid.
So there will be certain observers
whose coordinates don't change over time.
And these are known as co-moving observers.
They are at rest with respect to the cosmic fluid.
By the way, on Earth, we are not a co-moving observer.
Our galaxy is moving at 600 kilometers per second
relative to the cosmic microwave background radiation.
Now let's pick two co-moving observers
a large distance apart and have them exchange a photon.
Its wavelength will be stretched
by the amount the universe has expanded
during the photon's journey.
This is the standard picture of cosmological redshift.
But now consider a bunch of other co-moving observers
along the path of this photon.
Each one absorbs the photon
and instantaneously emits another
identical to the one they measured.
Now each successive observer
will measure a slightly longer wavelength
than the observer before them,
the photons stretching out just as you'd expect
in an expanding universe.
But the reason they would give for this redshift
would be different.
To each observer, their neighboring co-moving observers
would appear to be moving away from them
in locally flat spacetime.
So they would attribute the increase in wavelength
to the Doppler shift
just due to the relative motion between them.
The entirety of the cosmological redshift then
can equivalently be thought of
as the result of a long series of Doppler shifts.
What we've seen is redshifting is not something
that happens to a photon itself.
Instead, it depends on what's happening to observers
at the point of emission and absorption of that photon.
And because of this,
there are actually not three different types of redshift.
There's only one described
by a single underlying mathematical framework.
They only look different
depending on your frame of reference.
Now it can be convenient to talk about expanding space
when you have two co-moving observers
exchanging a photon over vast distances
in an expanding universe.
Then the photons wavelength is just stretched
by the amount the universe expanded during its journey.
That's nice and simple.
But you can equally well describe the redshift
by a long chain of Doppler shifts,
no expanding space required.
The misconception is to think that
because photons are redshifted
as they travel across the universe,
that means expanding space is pulling on things
and stretching things apart.
That's not how it works.
Space is not like that.
So let's come back to the central question of this video,
which is, do you expand with the universe?
The answer is no.
Because on the scale of people,
the universe is not homogenous.
I mean, matter is condensed down into objects and the earth.
And the universe is not isotropic.
Looking up looks decidedly different from looking down.
The basic assumptions we made
about our expanding universe just don't apply here.
I mean, the local space-time curvature
is dominated by the earth.
So what if we took you out into deep space,
the middle of nowhere?
Then would you expand?
Still no, because your body is held together
by electromagnetic forces.
But what if we could turn off the electromagnetic force
so your body is just a jumble of particles
that don't interact?
Well, in that case, over time, you would expand,
but only because our universe
is now dominated by dark energy.
So the take-home message of this video
is that redshifting photons don't mean
that space is expanding and pulling on everything,
stretching things apart.
So molecules are not expanding,
and neither are stars, and neither are galaxies,
and neither are you,
except for very extraordinary circumstances.
That tells you it's recording.
Here we go.
Hey, this portion of the video was sponsored by Salesforce,
a company that can help you expand your business.
The world is transforming right now,
and a lot of people are working from home
or working from anywhere,
accelerating the shift to doing business online.
And Salesforce Essentials can help your business
adapt to the evolving needs of customers.
For example, you can make your website work harder for you
by using lead capture forms from Salesforce
right on your site.
You can then generate new business
and develop relationships with customers
right from your CRM.
To get a message out or to share a special promo,
Salesforce Essentials helps you target
the specific customers you want,
whether that's broad or focused.
You can also help customers find answers
with a Help Center page,
or meet customers where they are
by connecting your email, phone, and social channels.
Follow the link down in the description to learn more.
I wanna thank Salesforce
for sponsoring this portion of the video,
and I wanna thank you for watching.
That's where you push the button again.