Will Solar Junk Overwhelm California? | AJ Orben

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
Sign up our newsletter 👉 https://ept.ms/CAInewsletter
My guest today is AJ Orben, Vice President at We Recycle Solar. He has worked towards strengthening the circular economy, extending the useful life of devices, and minimizing waste.
Is solar waste a growing problem in California? Will it have an adverse effect on our environment?
#solar #solarenergy #solarpower
-
⭕ EpochTV EXCLUSIVES. Only $1 Trial (Limited Offer) 👉 https://ept.ms/1DollarNOW4
🔵 Stay up-to-date with exclusive newsletter: https://ept.ms/EpochTVNewsletterYT
-
💛Support us to fight for the truth👉https://donorbox.org/epochtv
There are reports that we're going to face a disaster in our landfills with all the solar
panels ending up there.
People are improperly or illegally disposing of their solar panels, generally through landfill.
In the coming years, potentially millions of panels could end up in other landfills,
an area like Nevada or Arizona.
Why do you think there is no push for doing more recycling of these materials?
Most people have the thought that there's these precious metals in the solar panels.
A solar panel can cost upwards of $30 a panel to separate out, you know, the metals.
And what you get back is somewhere between $2 and $4. It's a loss.
My guest today is AJ Orban, Vice President at We Recycle Solar.
There hasn't been much thought put into the financial element of recycling
in terms of, you know, how that's going to be either subsidized or paid for.
Is solar waste going to turn out to be an environmental nightmare in the near future
in California? Are the solar industry and regulators who encourage solar energy
considering end life of these panels? All this and more in today's interview.
I'm Siamak Korami. Welcome to California Insider.
Thank you so much.
California is moving towards solar energy and actually more and more solar. We are going,
actually 15% of our energy is coming from solar and we are trying to increase that.
Now, there are reports that we're going to face a disaster in our landfills
with all the solar panels ending up there. Is this true?
So I would say in the state of California directly, probably not.
However, it is feasible that solar panels could be still improperly and illegally disposed of
if taken out of state and could end up in other landfills.
You know, the California EPA, the California DTSC are quite strict on their environmental
enforcement and crack down quite often. I think, you know, for a solar panel to end up
in a landfill here domestically in California, it would be a lot more challenging than say,
getting it out of the state and then dumping it in an area like Nevada or Arizona.
Can you explain more like what you have seen in your space?
Sure. So right now, when it comes to disposal,
unfortunately, most people are improperly or illegally disposing of their solar panels,
generally through landfill, because they haven't properly allocated or budgeted for recycling.
Generally, larger entities like commercial developers and utilities,
you know, they may require a decommissioning plan and decommissioning bonding
when they're installing a new solar system. So a lot of times they have allocated
funds toward it, whereas like consumers and smaller contractors maybe have not.
And what does it look like? So they just take the solar panel and throw it out?
It depends on the state, you know, they may be able to take it to a local landfill. It really
depends upon where they live. And what about California? How do we deal with it here?
So California made a classification change to solar panels on January 1st of 2021,
and has labeled them universal waste. Universal waste is essentially a less hazardous form
of hazardous waste, similar to batteries. And what it does is it restricts your outlets
so that you do not improperly dispose of it. It makes it easier from the perspective of,
you know, having companies that can pick it up, can handle it, can manage it, can store it,
and can transport it, but really doesn't change with how it's processed at end of life.
So either it's still going to be sent to a permitted recycler, such as, you know, my company,
or a hazardous waste treatment facility, which is going to treat it as hazardous waste.
When we hear about the recycling and solar panels,
how big is this industry and how much waste are we talking about?
I mean, in the coming years, potentially millions of panels.
And can you explain to us what you have seen? So there's research numbers,
and then there is actual, you had your experience with it.
Sure. So I think, you know, there's several research organizations like NREL or IRENA
that publish reports about disposals and quantities. Right now, a lot of that
information is, you know, coming from a vacuum in that, you know, there's nothing to track
how much is actually getting disposed of, with the exception of now California and the
universal waste law and requiring the generator or the person that's disposing of those solar
panels to file a report with the state. Outside of that, you know, there's nothing
to say that that information needed to be tracked. So, I mean, personally, I've had,
you know, at least one client that has had more panels than I think what one of those
reports would indicate they anticipated as being needed to be disposed of in the coming years.
Is there any danger from these solar panels? Is it toxic? Is it something that could have an
impact on the environment if it's not recycled? Sure. So the solar panels themselves, there's
several different chemistries or types, typically silicon-based modules, which are known as
monocrystalline or polycrystalline. There's cadmium-based modules or cadmium telluride.
And then there's copper-based panels, which, you know, copper, indium, gallium, selenide, or
SIGS. The cadmium and the SIGS panels are both thin film panels that are really more for, like,
commercial or utility use than, say, residential. But typically, in our findings, more than two
thirds of panels are legally hazardous federally for elevated levels of lead and silver if they're
silicon-based or cadmium if they're cadmium-based or selenium if they're copper-based.
And that's after performing a TCLP or a TCLP, essentially a test that's designed to simulate
what would happen if these panels were sent to a standard landfill, how much of that material may
leach into the soil or groundwater. And why do you think there is no push for doing more recycling of
these materials? I think it just comes down to the financial side of things in terms of,
you know, the economics behind it. It costs more to recycle a solar panel than the value of the
raw materials. Without any kind of subsidies or advanced fees or really way of funding that,
it makes it very challenging. Can you explain to us, for our average audience members, like,
the cost of a solar panel and how it works? Because some people have them on their
roofs and we buy them. Can you explain to us how does the financial model work? Sure. So,
you know, solar panels you could freely purchase. You know, don't quote me, per se. I think,
top of the line solar panels today run into the $300 range. But essentially, you know,
most of what you're paying for as a consumer when you're installing the solar panels on your home
is really more of the soft cost. It's the labor and the installation versus the product itself.
So how much is it for an average home? Do you have any thoughts like average installation?
It's in the thousands of dollars, right? Right. I couldn't really speak to that as
I really don't focus on residential. What I would say is that, you know, for my understandings,
it generally could range between $20,000 and $40,000 a home. And how much of that is the
panels? Like, is it a couple of thousand or a few thousand dollars is the panels?
Is it a certain percentage that's a panel and the other percentage is the labor installation cost?
I really couldn't speak to that. I would assume maybe 25% could be the actual product itself.
Again, I think there was an article that was published more recently that stated the prices
of solar panels have fallen upwards of 90% over the last decade. Assume that, you know,
most homes are only going to fit somewhere between 20 and 40 solar panels. So assuming,
you know, 40 panels at a retail price of $300, I mean, you might spend $12,000 in solar panels
alone. And what is the cost of recycling these? So the cost to recycle is generally upwards of,
you know, $30 a panel. It is something I think most people have the thought that there's these
precious metals in the solar panels and that, you know, the value of that material is going to
exceed what it's going to cost to dispose of it. You know, I think in many instances they think of
it as something akin to copper cabling or wire or aluminum cans, you know, where it's something
that's just easily recycled. You know, aluminum you can take, you can shred, you can crush,
you can heat up, you can smelt, and you can form a raw block of aluminum and it can go right back
into reuse. And there's enough value in that material that you could take it to little to
no cost or even pay out on it. Whereas, you know, a solar panel, as I mentioned, can cost upwards of
$30 a panel to dismantle, to sever, to shred, to mill, to undergo secondary chemical or thermal
processing to separate out, you know, the metals. And what you get back is somewhere between two and
four dollars in aluminum, copper, glass, lead, silicon, silver, and tin. It's a loss. And so,
you know, there does need to be something to subsidize that processing. Otherwise we will end
up with a lot of these in the landfill, right? Correct. We are always told that when people are
buying solar panels, they're told that they're going to come with warranty for like 20 years or
25 years. We just went through that. We just started this solar movement. Why do you think
there's going to be a lot of solar panels that are needed to get disposed? Well, so solar panels get
retired for a variety of reasons. That could include, you know, manufacturer defects. So a solar
panel that was produced at the plant and maybe there's some issue with the back sheet that maybe
doesn't develop until three to five years down the line. There are panels that get damaged at
delivery where, you know, the distributor is delivering them to the site, whether it's a
residence or a commercial site, and maybe the panel gets cracked on delivery. The other percentage of
panels could get damaged during installation. So as the technician is installing it, maybe he drills
through it or, you know, does something that cracks the glass and just really has an impact on its
integrity. In other instances, and in a lot of the majority of instances, it's more weather-related
damages. So for instance, in kind of the Midwest, areas like Texas, you see that, you know, they get
huge hailstorms and it wipes out thousands of panels at a time. I think, you know, other
environmental concerns here in California, wildfires. I believe I read somewhere that the
salt from the sea can cause corrosion on panels that are, you know, closer to the sea. So there's
a lot of instances where, you know, weather-related events can impact the integrity of the panel
and require them to be retired. Do you think they will last that long? And the technology is
getting better, right? They're constantly coming up with new. Do you think that 20 years, 25 years,
is it something that for average users, they will stick to it? Or do you think they will replace
them more regularly? So I think addressing the first part in terms of lifespan, the solar panels
are warrantied for generally somewhere between, I think, 15 and 30 years. My understanding, again,
not having originally come from solar, was that those warranties were originally meant to cover
the payback period, the amount of time it would take to really cover the investment. In all
actuality, you know, the solar panels of today degrade at less than 1% a year, their capacity.
So, you know, a solar panel that is properly maintained without manufacturer defect
could last decades. But as you just kind of alluded to, more often than not, people are
going to retire them at a certain point and replace them with a newer, more efficient module.
And so the life cycle is going to be a lot shorter, right? So we're going to have to
get rid of these solar panels and put new ones, right? Correct. I mean, it's ultimately up to,
you know, the consumer or the business that's using them. But, you know, as time progresses,
you know, the panels become more efficient. You know, maybe 10 years ago, panels were in the 250
watt range, whereas panels today are upwards of 550 watts. So, you know, the capacity is nearly
doubled. Again, I'm not in the, you know, the production of solar panels, but I would assume,
you know, over the coming decade that likely there'll be newer technology, more advancements,
making the panels thinner, lighter, using less raw materials, you know, doubling the output,
increasing the output significantly, at least. And we are having a big push in California for
having solar homes, right? We passed a law, right? Is that? Right. I believe there was a
law that was passed over the last several years requiring new single family homes and multi
resident units to include solar on the rooftops. So with all this that we have, and having this
kind of shorter lifespan, do you think there's going to be a lot of solar panels that need to
kind of, they get retired for whatever reason? Of course, of course, you'll see,
you'll see an influx of panels that still have plenty of life left in them, you know,
a lot like a car lease. Now, where do you think this will end up? I think
reasonably panels that can be repurposed and reutilized will be much like anything else in
this world. You know, computer equipment, cars, appliances, I think, you know, there is a healthy
secondary market for repurposed and refurbished equipment. And I'm sure that the demand for that
will grow as time progresses. And so I think a lot of that material that still has life remaining
could be repaired, refurbished, and reasonably redeployed in other markets, either domestically
in off grid applications, lower income areas, or even internationally. Do you think a lot of it
will end up in the landfill? I think what would potentially end up in a landfill would be panels
that would not qualify for reuse. So there is the likelihood that a lot of that could.
I think California has been pretty progressive in the institution of the universal waste law.
And I think that will have a significant impact on the ability to improperly dispose of the panels
here. Generally, California has been pretty tight around the proper disposal of things.
And so I would say it's less of a concern in the state of California as it is in,
you know, maybe another state. And can you explain that more? So what are the disposing laws?
How does it impact the landfill and the people that are disposing it? Sure. So currently,
solar panels are governed as hazardous waste under RCRA, which is federal law.
In California, California has made them universal waste, again, a less hazardous form of hazardous
waste. It makes the management, the storage, the transportation and disposal much easier,
as it allows the consumer, be it a residence or say a commercial entity, it allows them to
give it to someone for disposal without making a waste determination. Whereas in another state,
say, for instance, New Jersey, New York, in order for you to legally dispose of a solar panel,
if you're not going through a permitted recycler, you would have to perform what's known as a TCLP
or a TCLIP. That's the toxic characteristic leaching procedure. It is a test that's required
by the federal government to determine the toxicity of a product, not just solar panels,
anything that could potentially be hazardous. So you have to do it as a consumer? Or as somebody
that has it? Yes, you would technically have to do it as a consumer as well. Unless again,
you're giving it to a permitted recycler, such as my company that has the permits in place to act
under the federal exclusion. But essentially, that test would test for eight top heavy metals
that the EPA considers to be hazardous at certain thresholds, like lead, like silver,
like cadmium, like arsenic. And essentially, you would have to perform that test on a solar panel,
determined that it is non-hazardous, meaning it does not exceed any of the thresholds set forth
by the EPA. And if it's non-hazardous, it is a solid waste, no different from any other garbage,
and legally, you could send it to a landfill. If you have not done that test, or if you have
done the test, and the test shows that the solar panels are hazardous, then legally,
they could not go to a standard landfill. They would have to go to either a permitted recycler
or a hazardous waste treatment facility, which is a specialized landfill.
So I could speak from personal experience that in the Northeast, New York, New Jersey,
Massachusetts, Maryland, the landfills, the scrapyards there, they know that legally,
they cannot accept that material, not without a waste determination that shows that it's
non-hazardous. Whereas in other states where it has the same federal law, but maybe environmental
enforcement is a little more lax, oftentimes you will see that people are able to improperly and
illegally dispose of their solar panels, because they may go to a landfill that either does not
know they are not supposed to accept the material, or is being unscrupulous. I think
California has always been a little bit more progressive in that the EPA, the CalEPA rather,
or the DTSC generally are a lot more stringent on enforcement, and so you see a lot less of
that activity happening here. Do they go in other states, because it's more strict in California?
Do the waste get disposed in other states? I would say it is possible, yes. For clarification,
for instance, my company, We Recycle Solar, our primary processing plant here on the West Coast
is in Yuma, Arizona. It's about two and a half hours southeast of San Diego. The reason that
we exist in Arizona and not in California directly is because in California, in order to do the
process that we have to truly recycle the solar panels, it would require a RCRA Part B permit,
which is a haz waste permit that's a multi-million dollar capital investment that's just not in line
with our business model, nor is it necessary for what we do. It's what would be required to
operate the plant here in California. Is that impossible to do based on the cost models that
you just shared? It would make it a lot more costly. Essentially, the RCRA Part B permit is
the same permitting used for haz waste treatment, as it really reflects the chemical processing
portion of our process, and so that is a multi-million dollar investment that just,
again, for all intents and purposes, doesn't make sense for our business model.
Now, in terms of subsidies that are given to the solar industry, how much of this end-of-life
thought about in this industry? Zero. In terms of the subsidies, I believe like the the tax
credits and things, there's no subsidy for disposal. In terms of disposal and subsidy
right now, I think currently Washington State has implemented an extended producer program,
which requires that manufacturers and retailers of solar equipment both provide and finance
a recycling program, so that would come at the expense of, say, the manufacturer. Arizona has
talked about instituting a recycling program where they wanted to put, I believe, either a five or
fifteen dollar credit toward each solar panel that gets sold for recycling. I believe Niagara
County, New York has just implemented a recycling program that's requiring that manufacturers
subsidize a program, but outside of that, there's really no program set forth federally,
nor so at the state level that really subsidizes anything. The one thing that I'll give
to California that I always appreciated about doing business with California or in California
was that if you were to draw the parallel to, say, electronics recycling, which is an industry that
was really formed in the early 1980s and has had now 40 years to mature,
electronics are universal waste in probably about half of U.S. states, much as solar
panel is in California currently. So there's a mandated landfill ban in about half of U.S. states.
Out of the states that have made universal waste out of electronics, California is the only state
that has instituted the Consumer Electronics Waste Tax, which charges you an advance fee at the time
of purchase, and that money goes into a fund that then is used to subsidize disposal. So at the end
of your electronics, be it a cell phone, a computer, an appliance, you can take that, you can bring it
to a local privatized electronics recycler, they can take it at little to no cost, and the state
will pay them to collect it on its behalf. That was something I always appreciated about the state
of California. Unfortunately, nothing like that exists for solar at this time. Why do you think
they haven't done it for solar? Because there is this movement of being green. I have my
fingers crossed that perhaps they will. I think that it's an idea that's been talked about
nationally in terms of how to make this work. I think there's a lot of interested parties,
there's a lot of key players, there's a lot of people involved in trying to come to a consensus
that makes sense for everyone, is I think the challenge. Do you think they have looked at the
big picture and understand that, okay, there's going to be this material 10, 15, 20 years,
and we have to get rid of them, and we get new ones with this solar space, or do you think they
just have just looked at it as, okay, we're going solar and it's green, it's good? I think that there
has been consideration in this, and I say that as, again, my company, we came into existence
as We Recycle Solar now a little over three years ago, but really as a spinoff of an existing
company where we had gotten involved, I don't know, five to seven years ago. At that point in
time, it was other publications that were nationally running articles about the coming
solar waste issue in, say, the next two decades. So it is something that I think people have
considered. It's just not something that anyone has reasonably come up with a way to tackle.
I know, for instance, each program that gets set up is not without its flaws, meaning
the extended producer program being set up in Washington, to the best of my knowledge,
based on where that program was, 100% of the burden of that disposal cost is being bared by
the manufacturers of the product, and it's being bared by their share of the market nationally,
meaning hypothetically you could have a company that maybe is the number one seller of a solar
panel nationally, but in the state of Washington sells less than 1,000 units a year, and they may
end up having to pay a share that exceeds what their total sales were for the state.
Again, the direct parallel there would be the state of Connecticut, in which
I think for electronics waste, I believe it was Vizio, the TV manufacturer, at one point in time
had to, I believe it was, had to pay over a million dollars for their share of
disposal for electronic waste in the state of Connecticut, whereas they had sold, I think,
less than a thousand units in that state in that year, because Connecticut had gone based off of the
national market share, and that was something that was, again, pretty widely covered
in the industry through different publications. So again, I think each program is not without
its faults. I don't know that 100% of the liability should be on the manufacturer.
I think perhaps if there's a percentage of the sale that goes into a fund
to subsidize, that would work. An advanced fee, much like the consumer electronics waste tax here
in California, you know, at the time of purchase, that could work. I think there's a happy medium
somewhere. A.J. Orban, Vice President of WeRecycle Solar, it was great to have you on California
Insider. Thank you so much, I appreciate it. Thank you for watching. Please click the icon
on the left to subscribe to our channel. We bring you the most pressing issues California is facing,
with straightforward and in-depth interviews. See you in the next video.
