Would California's Reparation Achieve Its Goal? | Andrew Quinio

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
Sign up our newsletter 👉 https://ept.ms/CAInewsletter
My guest today is Andrew Quinio, attorney with Pacific Legal Foundation. He used to work with U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs Office of General Counsel, where he litigated employment discrimination and whistleblower cases.
What’s in California’s controversial reparation plan? How many meaningful results could it provide to help relieve California’s housing crisis?
#reparations #housing #california
⭕ EpochTV EXCLUSIVES. Only $1 Trial (Limited Offer) 👉 https://ept.ms/1DollarNOW4
🔵 Stay up-to-date with exclusive newsletter: https://ept.ms/EpochTVNewsletterYT
💛Support us to fight for the truth👉https://donorbox.org/epochtv
We want to talk to you about the Reparation Task Force.
Can you tell us what's going on with this?
A few months ago, the Reparations Task Force
came out with their preliminary report.
What stood out to me the most, especially here in California,
is their recommendations for the housing crisis.
The primary program that they're recommending
is providing subsidized mortgages
for black residents and black applicants.
So rather than addressing that core issue,
that core cause of building more homes
and getting rid of the things
that are preventing the building of more homes,
the solution, at least for now,
recommended by the task force,
is to just throw money at it,
to make sure that people can pay these high prices.
My guest today is Andrew Quinio,
attorney with Pacific Legal Foundation.
He has served the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs
Office of General Counsel,
where he litigated employment discrimination
in whistleblower cases.
How do you show that people today,
black Californians today,
who are far removed in generations from slavery
and the victimization from slavery,
are themselves victims of it?
How are they victims today?
That's something that the task force,
and I think that's something that Californians
will be asking, too,
when they come out with their final programs.
What's in California's reparation plan?
How much meaningful results could it provide
to help relieve California's housing crisis?
We will find out in today's episode.
I'm Siamak Karami.
Welcome to California Insider.
Thank you so much for having me.
We want to talk to you about the reparation task force
that California State has,
and there has been some updates.
Can you tell us what's going on with this?
Certainly.
So the California Reparations Task Force
was founded in 2020,
and it's a committee, essentially, of nine individuals,
and they have the mission or the purpose
of studying slavery and its impact here in California
and coming up with proposals and policies to remedy that
and come up with a reparations program.
So they've been meeting since 2020, holding hearings,
taking testimony from different experts, historians,
policymakers, all different types of people
in different fields to study the effect of slavery,
its history, its effect here in California,
and the effects of it in the form of different
racist programs and racist government actions.
And from there, they have recommended
some preliminary recommendations for reparations
or a reparations program.
So a few months ago, the reparations task force
came out with their preliminary report.
Which is a really big one, right?
It's a 500 page, you mentioned, yeah.
It's about 500 pages, and it covers all sorts of topics
from healthcare, criminal justice,
the environment, education,
and it talks about the impact of slavery
or the badges and incidents of slavery
in the form of racist policies in those fields.
And they come up with recommendations
on how to remedy those things.
And what's interesting about the report
is a lot of the recommendations they come up with
are a lot of things that we've seen before.
Raising the minimum wage, free healthcare programs,
housing subsidies, different types of lessons
to be taught in our public schools.
What stood out to me the most,
especially here in California,
is their recommendations for the housing crisis.
Among their proposals for remedying racist housing policies
is to provide state subsidized mortgages to black residents.
And that stood out to me
because when you think of the housing crisis
here in California, race and prejudice
is, if anything, only part of the story.
It's not the complete story.
And it certainly is not the root cause
of the housing crisis here in California.
I mean, the bottom line is,
Californians can't afford their homes.
They can't afford to buy homes.
And this affects everyone, regardless of their race,
their background, their ethnicity.
There was a study by UC Berkeley, or a poll,
that showed that the housing crisis
and the concerns about it affect everybody
of all stripes, of all backgrounds,
of all political persuasions, et cetera.
So to isolate the cause of the housing crisis
to race and the after effects from slavery
is really, to me, not the complete story.
And it diverts from the true causes of that crisis.
And the cause of that crisis
is we just don't have enough homes.
California is undersupplied for building homes.
And that's not anything that's covered
by the Reparations Task Force report.
So how are they going to address this?
Well, the primary program that they're recommending,
and again, this is just a preliminary recommendation,
is providing subsidized mortgages
for black residents and black applicants.
To me, that's just subsidizing the high cost of housing.
The reason housing is so expensive here in California
is, again, there's just not enough housing.
There's not enough houses being built.
So rather than addressing that core issue,
that core cause of building more homes
and getting rid of the things
that are preventing the building of more homes,
the solution, at least for now,
recommended by the task force,
is to just throw money at it,
to make sure that people can pay these high prices.
But that does nothing to address
the lack of supply of homes in California.
And there's several things that are causing
a lack of supply of homes in California.
You've got over-regulation from environmental laws,
in particular, the California Environmental Quality Act,
CEQA, as it's more commonly known.
Land use policy, zoning ordinances
that restrict building of homes.
Building fees are among the highest in California
compared to other states in the nation.
So all of these things that are the core problems
causing a lack of housing supply
just completely go unaddressed
in the reparations task force report.
They should use that opportunity in their reports
and in their further hearings
and study of California's problems
to address those issues and come up with solutions
that impact all Californians.
So essentially, they want to subsidize
for blacks, like just the mortgage, right?
So you have to pay the same housing costs, is that,
and then you'll get some subsidies
on the mortgage interest rates or interest, or is that?
Right, what they're proposing
is subsidizing low-interest mortgages.
So what that could look like remains to be seen,
again, because this is just a preliminary report.
They're due to have their final report in June of next year.
But you can look to some other jurisdictions
and other parts of the country
to see what maybe that would look like
or what would be a model
for a California housing reparations program.
Evanston, Illinois, for instance,
has been already implementing their own version
of a reparations program in the form of housing vouchers.
They've been providing housing vouchers
to individuals who are descendants
of black residents in Evanston from, I think, 1919 to 1969.
So there's a specific timeframe.
But what a lot of folks would think of
as a reparations program,
which would be cash payments to victims of discrimination
or state injustice, has largely morphed into,
like in Evanston, Illinois, and other parts of the country,
into these sort of government programs,
not direct cash payments.
So I think that's what you're gonna end up seeing
as a final product
of the Reparation Task Force recommendations,
not these direct cash payments,
but these programs like a housing voucher.
Again, the details are yet to be seen until next year,
but that's what it probably will shape up to be.
And your institution is actually taking a stand
on the results of this, right?
Is that what you guys are gonna legally challenge this?
Well, it remains to be seen what can be challenged in it
because the final details of the programs
have yet to be determined.
They only have preliminary recommendations.
Pacific Legal Foundation stands for opportunity for all.
We stand against discrimination and prejudice.
So we're looking at it in terms of
what would ultimately be a program
that could violate the constitution.
So because the details aren't out yet
as to what the final reparations program will look like,
we are keenly aware and are keeping track
on what's gonna come out eventually.
And I'll tell you what would not be allowed
in their ultimate final program.
First of all, anything that is providing benefits
based on race is immediately suspect.
And any program like that
should be treated with some suspicion.
Our country has had a very awful, bad history,
terrible history with race and prejudice.
So any program that tries to use race to provide benefits
or classify or differentiate people,
even if it's remedial, even if it's benevolent,
should be looked on with some suspicion.
A reparations program or any program
that will come out of this,
number one, it can't address generalized discrimination
or societal discrimination.
It's gotta look at specific harms.
It also can't be a program that lasts forever.
There has to be some duration to it that has an endpoint.
It can't last in perpetuity.
And then here in California, we have Proposition 209.
So any reparations program that uses race
to provide benefits can't do that
when it comes to providing benefits
based on or regarding public employment,
public education, or contracting.
So those are some of the guidelines
and some of the barriers or things
that would make a reparations program
based on race or using racial classification suspect
or some things that you would look at
in determining whether it satisfies the Constitution.
A good example that you can use as a model,
and the reparations task force
would probably be looking at this already,
is the internment of Japanese Americans
and the reparations that came out of that afterwards.
You had the Civil Liberties Act of 1988
that provided reparations to Japanese Americans.
But that program was very targeted.
Even though it used Japanese ancestry
to determine who gets the benefits,
it was very targeted as far as the harm
that it was remedying.
It was specifically for Japanese Americans
who were relocated, imprisoned, evacuated,
interned because of the orders during World War II.
It wasn't trying to address societal discrimination
against Asian Americans
or the descendants of Japanese Americans.
So that reparations program would be a good model
for the reparations task force.
There would still be some issues
with the reparations task force
because slavery was generations ago.
And we didn't have a lot of it.
I guess California, it was only a few years
before California stopped it, right?
Or banned it, right?
When California was admitted to the union
and it became a state,
slavery was banned in its constitution.
California wasn't admitted as a slave state.
That doesn't mean there were no problems
with race and prejudice against black Americans
or black Californians.
But California entered the union as a free state.
Again, that isn't to say
that California didn't have its issues
with race and with the-
Discrimination.
With discrimination, right.
And now, what about this task force?
Do you think they're actually going
after a bigger societal discrimination
or are they thinking about this,
what happened with the Japanese Americans?
You know, the way that the task force puts forth
the history of discrimination
and prejudice towards black Americans,
it does tend to suggest a broader societal discrimination
that it's going after.
It has to, the task force has to make the case
that there is a nexus between the outcomes
of black Americans today
and what their ancestors, their relatives experienced
starting from slavery and continuing on
as far as the prejudice that their ancestors faced.
So if a program says,
if a reparations program ultimately comes out and says,
certain people get these benefits because their family,
their ancestors lived during a certain time period,
you don't have enough of that targeted harm
of that specific harm
to justify a race-based entitlement program.
So that's a task that the task force will have to deal with.
How do you show that people today,
black Californians today,
who are far removed in generations from slavery
and the victimization from slavery
are themselves victims of it?
How are they victims today?
That's something that the task force,
that's something that Californians will be asking too
when they come out with their final programs.
Do you think this will get challenged in the court
or this is, if it's not in these boundaries
that they will get challenged, right?
I think that's possible, yeah.
Because again, when you're looking at societal discrimination
and programs that aren't brief in time
or don't have an endpoint in time,
you could draw some challenges.
And the Japanese reparations program
had their own challenges from people
who didn't have Japanese ancestry or Japanese heritage,
who thought that they also were entitled
to reparations under the Civil Liberties Act.
Those challenges ultimately failed
because what the courts found
and what Congress eventually found
was that the remedy to Japanese Americans
was justified because of this targeted harm,
this targeted crime that the government put them through.
Now, what about some people that argue,
why don't we just deal with this?
Like, why shouldn't we allow these reparations to happen
and actually compensate the people for it?
Yeah, you know, and I think acknowledging the history
is absolutely important.
There's a lot of issues that are raised
by the issue of reparations
and what the task force is dealing with.
Number one, it's how do you acknowledge the history?
What of the history do you acknowledge?
And then how do you compensate for it, if at all?
And if you are gonna compensate for it,
who are you going to compensate?
So there's a lot of those issues
that eventually come up from this one issue of reparations
as to how to remedy it or who is going to benefit
and who's going to have their grievances
ultimately resolved.
Again, that's something for the task force
to try and figure out.
It's a good thing, ultimately,
for a government to acknowledge its wrongdoings.
I think you will rarely find a government
actually acknowledging or apologizing
for the things it's done.
You're gonna very rarely find that.
So it's not a bad thing to acknowledge the history
of prejudice in California.
But the question is, how do you move forward?
How do you move forward in a diverse state like California
where its population has individuals
who themselves can claim grievances
or claim harms that were done to their ancestors,
to their family members?
California, beyond the prejudice against black Californians,
had something called the alien land law,
which prevented Asian immigrants from owning land.
There were restrictions on the ability of people of color
to testify in court against white Californians.
That's not just something that affected black Californians,
but a lot of Californians of color.
The lynchings that occurred in California,
which the reparations task force report does cover,
happened not just to black Californians,
but mostly to Chinese immigrants.
So you have a diverse population
that will ultimately face this question of,
where is my role in remedying something that was horrible
and should be acknowledged,
but has problems that now are rooted
in things that aren't just from racism,
not just from slavery,
but policy choices by our government,
in particular with housing and the lack of housing
and those things that are common
to all people in California of all backgrounds.
So there will be different groups
that would look for reparations as well
if this moves forward.
Other groups wanna do that too.
But it seems like we have fundamental problems
that we don't wanna deal with in this process.
Yeah, and it's how you deal with it
that comes up as an issue.
And I don't know if other groups
will want to seek reparations.
I mean, I certainly won't try to speak for other groups,
but the claims of discrimination
and grievances coming from that certainly is prevalent,
not just to black Californians.
But the question is, how do you move forward?
And the best way to move forward
is getting at the root causes of problems
that are common to all Californians,
regardless of their skin color,
regardless of their ethnicity.
So again, you go back to the housing issue.
This is an issue that affects all Californians.
Californians are moving out of the state
because they can't afford a home.
If you're gonna have a program
that subsidizes only one set of the population,
that's not gonna do anything
to address the high cost of the housing.
Housing will still be expensive.
And what you might end up having
is a population that will move out of the state,
and then you end up losing your tax base.
You end up losing the source
that will fund these subsidized mortgages.
So there are these byproducts that can be avoided
if we look at the root causes of these issues
that aren't based on race,
that don't look at the skin color
of the people that would benefit,
but look at the actual issues,
the actual root causes of these problems.
So in your opinion, why do you think we're not doing that?
You know, I don't know why the reparations task force
is only, is not looking at the other causes
of the housing crisis, for instance.
They're not looking at environmental regulatory reform.
They're not looking at other reforms in education,
for instance, like school choice or expanding school choice
that could help solve a lot of these problems.
I could only speculate as to why they're not doing that.
I think ultimately, I imagine they're,
and I think their intentions are well-intentioned.
But California is ultimately, it's a progressive state.
And the reparations task force here in California
is the first state-led effort of its kind
compared to other efforts across the country.
So it may be the California background
as a more progressive state
that would want to look at this issue the way it does,
that causes it to not look at these other causes
of these problems.
But again, the best way to solve these things
and move forward is to expand opportunity
for all Californians, regardless of their background.
Do you think we're gonna get more attention nationally
when we have this task force
and we're working, we're looking at it this way
instead of really going to the fundamentals
of solving the problem?
I think we will.
You know, California is a big state
and we have a lot of issues
that come to the forefront of the country
because of how big our population is.
We, you know, we have a governor
that has attracted some attention
because of his future prospects in the political scene.
He wants to run for,
it looks like he wants to run for presidency.
It seems like that's where it's going.
So whatever happens with the task force's recommendations
and what the state eventually does with it,
whether it pushes it forward or ignores it or denies it
or goes a different direction,
it'll definitely be looked at.
I mean, as I mentioned,
there are other cities across the country
who have their own reparations efforts.
I mentioned Evansville, Illinois.
Asheville, North Carolina has a commission
looking at reparations.
Washington, D.C. is looking at a housing program
tied to a reparations effort.
So all these different cities,
all these different municipalities
are engaged in this effort.
They're gonna be interested in seeing
what California ultimately does
and what it ultimately recommends
and sees if it is a model to be copied by other states.
Do you have any recommendations for this task force?
I think the task force would benefit
from going beyond the experts that they've already talked to
talk to advocates of CEQA reform,
talk to advocates who want to reform land use and zoning
when it comes to fixing the housing crisis.
Governor Jerry Brown was one such advocate
of reforming CEQA.
And it was one of his goals,
at least he stated that CEQA should be looked at
as far as being reformed.
So looking beyond the folks that they've already talked to
would be beneficial.
Talk to these other individuals
who know about the housing crisis,
who know about what's causing the lack of supply
that we have for housing.
I think the number was 2.5 million
that were short in housing.
We have to build 2.5 million units by 2030
to catch up with the needs of the state.
That's like if the entire population of Houston, Texas
was without a home.
That's how big our crisis is here.
So the task force would do well
to talk to every type of expert,
every individual that has knowledge and expertise
and has creative policy solutions
that aren't just based on race,
but based on actually fixing the root causes
of these problems for everyone in California.
Because ultimately a solution
that benefits everyone in California
doesn't exclude black Americans and black Californians.
And you can acknowledge,
and we should acknowledge
the past history of discrimination,
but that doesn't mean we have to stay stuck
in the lane of only looking at race-based solutions either.
We can do an acknowledgement,
we can acknowledge the past
and move forward as one California.
Do you have any other thoughts for our audience?
Yeah, you know, when it comes to race
and our background, our ethnicity,
whatever hardships, whatever injustices
that our families face, that our ancestors faced,
all of those things and our race
and our skin color is not our destiny.
We can move forward as Californians
with solutions that benefit all of us.
Our backgrounds aren't our destiny.
The best reparations program ultimately
is preserving individual liberty.
We don't have to be defined by our injustices
and the injustices of the past.
We can move forward as one California
towards solutions that are common to us all.
And ultimately that would be a better way
to preserve opportunity for every Californian.
Andrew Kineo, attorney at Pacific Legal Foundation,
it was great to have you on California Insider.
Thank you so much for having me, it was great to be here.
Thank you for watching.
Please click the icon on the left
to subscribe to our channel.
We bring you the most pressing issues California is facing
with straightforward and in-depth interviews.
See you in the next video.
