Why Shoplifting is Getting out of Control in California | Vern Pierson

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
Sign up our newsletter 👉 https://ept.ms/CAInewsletter
Why did theft and robbery go rampant in California? Why are the statistics not reflecting the rising crime?
My guest today is Vern Pierson, District Attorney of El Dorado County from Northern California, He also served several years with California Department of Justice as Deputy Attorney General.
#California #Crime #ZeroBail
⭕ EpochTV EXCLUSIVES. Only $1 Trial (Limited Offer) 👉 https://ept.ms/1DollarNOW4
🔵 Stay up-to-date with exclusive newsletter: https://ept.ms/EpochTVNewsletterYT
💛Support us to fight for the truth👉https://donorbox.org/epochtv
🔵 Subscribe to California Insider👉 https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCFBMeA1yxZ7g8Z79t0O80-A?Sub_confirmation=1
Some people are saying theft in California is legal now.
What we've done is we've convinced a large number of people
here in the state that there is no consequence for their action
and so we have this increased lawlessness that comes from it. The view
is, I can take other people's property because
nothing will happen to me. So what happens if somebody steals at
the store? Most retailers have learned that if they
call law enforcement for a theft of less than $950
that either law enforcement will not respond or if they respond
at most what they will do is issue a citation.
My guest today is Vern Pearson, District Attorney of El Dorado County
in Northern California. He also served several years with California's
Department of Justice as Deputy Attorney General. You have to
hold people accountable for their actions. That is the practical reality
and if you tell people you're not going to hold them accountable for their
actions there's a consequence for that and the
consequence is increased crime. Why is theft and robbery out of control
in California and why are the statistics not reflecting
this rising crime? We'll find out in today's episode.
I'm Siamak Khorrami. Welcome to California Insider.
Well thank you for having me. Pleasure to be here. We want to talk to you about
theft. Some people are saying theft in California is legal now.
Is this true? Well it's technically not legal
but not enforced is probably the better way to put it.
Certainly if it's less than $950. So with the passage of Prop 47 about
eight years ago what we did was we we looked at most
property crimes and that were being prosecuted that
time and said many of them that were felonies
are now misdemeanors and many that were felon
misdemeanors are essentially nothing and there's a lack of enforcement for them.
So what happens if somebody steals at the store or
if somebody steals? Yeah and one of the
the core areas to understand here is that there's this
used to be what was called petty theft of the prior. In other words
if someone steals and they have any amount of property on them
when they're caught by law enforcement if they have a history
of that same type of theft they could be charged with a felony
hence petty theft with the prior. And nowadays what happens and we've seen
it with some of these swarm smash and grab robberies in stores
where the 15 people are running out with
stolen property. Nine are detained let's say. Two of
them have large quantity amount of money of
theft that's been stolen property that's been stolen and the other
seven have four five six seven eight hundred dollars worth of property.
They're only going to be charged with a misdemeanor depending on the
circumstances. And in California the way it works is
that essentially misdemeanors have very little consequence certainly
as it relates to property crime. So can you explain very little
consequence what it means? Well in the practical reality is is that
most retailers have learned that if they call law enforcement for a
theft of less than nine hundred and fifty dollars
that either law enforcement will not respond or if they respond
at most what they will do is issue a citation
to the person who is stealing that property. So the practical reality is
most retailers in in California has some type of policy
telling them telling the employees not to report low-level property crimes
and and that's for a number of understandable reasons. One is
there's no consequence for if if they do report it
and number two if the person is emotionally disturbed in some way
fights with their employees, injures an employee,
something like that happens then oftentimes what will happen is that
the store or will be sued by the person that they attempted to arrest.
So from a liability standpoint oftentimes retailers are just so the
thief can actually go and sue the store and the stores are afraid of that
lawsuit. Right right we're a very litigious
society here in California and the stores are
and their insurance carriers really are afraid of being sued
for trying to stop a crime that has little or no consequence.
You mentioned when somebody has a misdemeanor they would get a ticket
right what does that mean would they end up having to pay a fine would they have
to would they end up going to prison or
would they? The practical reality is over the last
several years they would get a citation citing them into court and they
probably would never show up to court and there probably would never be any
consequence for the most part and depending on
what city you're talking about San Francisco, Los Angeles there's
little or no consequence for for theft and so what we've done is we've
convinced a large number of people here in the
state that there is no consequence for their
action and so we have this increased lawlessness
that comes from it. The view is I can take other people's property
because nothing will happen to me and if you do that enough times and we've
seen it there's been a number of different studies that have been done
that said we have the same people that are stealing over and over again
and when they're caught there's no consequence.
And what is the impact of this is this going to affect us
in any bigger ways? When we watch when you turn on the news or we watch
turn on YouTube and you see the smash and grabs taking place or
large-scale thefts and then you have Walgreens let's say closing their
stores or Starbucks more recently saying we're going to close stores in
certain areas because we can't deal with the crime
that's associated with it. And it's I think it's a
it's something that increases over time in terms of
where society at large is saying there's no consequence for for
criminality then we're kind of losing a big part of
society itself. And so people don't feel comfortable
walking the streets of San Francisco you have large
associations that say we don't want to have our conference in San Francisco or
in Los Angeles because we don't want to have our people being
robbed or otherwise harmed in that manner.
Now do you think this could spill into other types of crimes
or is it going to stay with what it is? No I think it is I mean
when we as a society say that low-level crimes have little or no
consequence I think the effect of that is that more
serious crimes increase as well and I think that's
what's happened over the last several years.
Some people and some newspapers are actually looking at the data
and they're saying that crime is not up.
Right. Despite all the videos that we see on social media
and what are your thoughts on that? Well it's wrong.
The data is incorrect at this point and let me explain what I mean.
When Prop 47 decriminalized certain types of drug crimes and
low-level property crimes it changed the way we report crimes.
In other words if it was a misdemeanor before
it became essentially nothing. Many felonies became misdemeanors.
So when people say they feel in their communities as though
their neighbors' houses are being burglarized,
they see videos of Walgreens having as many as 20 different shopliftings
in a day and then they ask the question
where's the reports of this? When we look at the numbers
why isn't the data following that? And what this goes back to
is this problem with retailers not fully reporting the crimes.
In other words if there's a disincentive to report
for a retailer. In other words you might if you call law enforcement
number one they might not respond. Number two if they do respond
they'll only issue a citation at most and there'll be no consequence.
So retailers have kind of shifted the way they deal with that.
The more accurate numbers within the data
of where crime is are things around shootings because those are
reported to law enforcement. Crimes involving automobiles. In other
words a car burglary, a car theft. Insurance companies
here in California and throughout the United States require
people to to have a police report even if it's a simply
a police report where you call in and you take have a police report taken by
by phone call or you go online and taking it. There's an accurate
record of that and what we've seen in the last
six or seven years is those types of crimes
have gone up dramatically. Auto burglaries,
auto thefts are up dramatically and that's a
truer set of data for where crime actually is in California.
What about the shootings? What's the difference between shootings and
homicides? Because the homicide numbers are very up.
The homicide numbers are up but we've been told by experts to
only trust the homicide homicide numbers. Well and that's true
because there's an accurate reporting for homicides but it's also not true. In
other words the the shootings are up even more than
homicides are up and what's happened post 9-11
is most trauma centers throughout the United States and
particularly here in California are staffed with doctors
and and nurses who have developed a high degree of expertise in
dealing with gunshot wounds. A lot of them are veterans or have
served either in the military or supported that
and the the various techniques for treating gunshot wounds
means that your survivability today is significantly higher than it was back in
the the peak of crime in the 1990s. So we've
gotten better at dealing with shootings. Right. But we have a lot more shootings
so we have less homicides. Right. Is that is that? Yeah we have a
proliferation of guns. There's a lot of firearms here in the
United States and here in California and because of various policies that
have gone into effect more people are carrying firearms
when they're committing crimes and then ultimately there's more
shootings but the treatment for for people who
have been shot the the likelihood of surviving is
tremendously higher today than it was back in the 1990s. Now what
about the policymakers? So you have been involved with the
district attorneys. You've led the organization. What what are
the policymakers thinking when they're seeing all of this?
Well I I think they're the legislature here in California
is largely disconnected from the people they represent
and I just don't know there's any other way of describing it.
I'll give you for instance recently over the last few years there was a
effort to go to what's called zero dollar bail. In other words
bail where the person is not required to to they can be released without putting
up any money. They mentioned bail was racist right
because there's all sorts of arguments about if you're
poor you can't afford it. Right and and so there was a there was a bill that
passed and then there was a referendum where the people of the state of
California rejected that referendum
rejected that law so it's not on the books today
and there's an effort going on again in the California legislature to come back
to it. So in other words that's what I mean by
disconnect in terms of the voters spoke very clearly
we don't agree with letting people out of custody who have committed crimes
without some type of consequence or some type of
a string tied to them to ensure that they come to court
and that they don't commit other crimes. The voters rejected
that type of zero dollar bail and yet the legislators
are seeking to do it once again. And what about the rest of the
California government? So you guys the district attorneys and then there is the
police and then there's other factors. How much say do you guys have or how
much can you guys do or have you been doing? Well the
district attorney in any given county has a lot of
influence over how crimes are prosecuted
and from county to county there's a huge variety
in other words or huge difference is probably the better way to put it.
In Los Angeles county you have George Gascon who
when he came into office he made certain policy decisions
that zero bail letting people out of custody not
not using three strikes not differentiating
on offenders that had significant criminal history versus ones that have
little or no criminal history not prosecuting people for
for using firearms in the commission of a crime
and and then you you compare that to certain other jurisdictions and the
district attorneys are very aggressive with dealing with
crime and the differences are pretty stark in
terms of you know counties like my county
Placer county have the lowest per capita crime in California and among
the lowest in in the United States and law
enforcement has a very good relationship with the communities
versus in other jurisdictions where law enforcement does not have a very good
relationship the DAs do not have a good relationship with the community
and crime is very high. So do you think certain counties in California based on
the district attorneys that they have they're going to be very different from
rest of California? Yes. You know you're going to have a
complete different experience living in LA
versus you live in San Diego or live in Orange County is that how it's going to
be in the near future? Well it really
shouldn't be that way that there's a a different quality of life from
jurisdiction to jurisdiction but we we you know the practical reality is
that you have certain communities where there's been
a philosophical shift there is a political shift
to to what I can characterize as a culture of lawlessness
and we're the the DA behaves more of a public defender
and is sympathetic to defendants as opposed to sympathetic to the victims
of crime and that's a kind of at its core what the
differences are in my view the way I was trained
and in my experience in my career as a prosecutor for 30 years
is that you know we look for first and foremost to take care of the victims of
crime and we can acknowledge and recognize
that that sometimes people get involved in
criminal activity for whatever reason might be
and I'm certainly not an advocate for what been characterized as mass
incarceration but you have to hold people accountable
for their actions that is the practical reality and if you
tell people you're not going to hold them
accountable for their actions there's a consequence for that
and the consequence is increased crime. Now do you think criminals are actually
looking at different districts and saying okay I
in here I can do if I'm in San Francisco
it's okay for me to break into a car and take the backpack versus I shouldn't do
that in some other. Yeah and that's an excellent point so
with with car burglaries car thefts the city of San Francisco versus
San Mateo County where the the SFO the airport in San Francisco is actually
located in San Mateo County which is right next
door that the the policies between those two
jurisdictions are night and day in San Mateo County
if you steal things if you break into cars you steal a car
you will be held accountable for that in San Francisco you will not
car break-ins car thefts are dramatically higher in San Francisco
than they are right next door in San Mateo County
and what we've seen is that the criminals do communicate with each other
there's videos we have a video out of Folsom prison
of a a murderer from L.A. County right after the George Gascon directives
came out in into effect and they're they're toasting
drinking it's called pruno inmate manufactured
alcohol and they're toasting the Gascon directives
and how that will change them so we I think we've seen it I've seen it in my
career the criminals know how laws have shifted
when three strikes took place going back many years
crime rapidly was it was decreasing after the passage of three strikes
when inmates would come into custody they were all talking about whether or
not someone was a striker or not a striker there was a real
communication amongst criminals regarding what the consequences would
be and there was an awareness that they had
that they would be held accountable for their actions
it seems like some counties are more easier for criminals to go to
to commit the crime and then maybe people go to these counties commit the
crime and come out is this happening all right well I think
it's definitely happening in depending on jurisdiction
jurisdictions have reputations for whether or not people are held
in custody or not held in custody and going back to the example I used before
with San Francisco and San Mateo County right next door
in San Francisco it's pretty well known that most people will either not be
booked in who are arrested will either not be
booked into jail or if they're booked into the jail they'll be released pretty
quickly right next door in San Mateo County that's very different and there's
a there's a recent example where a a person on BART traveling from San
Francisco down to the airport was assaulted and robbed on the on the on
the tram the BART tram and the in technically in San Francisco he the
individual was arrested taken to the San Francisco jail it was a Sunday and the
jail basically told law enforcement we're not going to take this individual
because it's a Sunday and we're not doing intake today so law enforcement
drove down to San Mateo County booked the person in San Mateo County jail and
because it's public transit San Mateo County actually prosecuted that
individual and we know it people that work within the system we know where
these variances are and we're silly to think that criminals don't also aren't
also aware of the same differences you mentioned Gascon and where do you
think these policies come from because they've been pretty controversial a lot
of people have have said that these are not good for the criminal justice system
well I think in some respects it's just a a well-intentioned but misguided
effort to change the system and I my own personal opinion is that he although he
has a lot of experience in the criminal justice system he just doesn't
understand it he doesn't understand that when you change something on one end
of it as as in you put out a directive saying there will be no firearm
enhancements he doesn't seems to not understand that if you say something
like that people who before were going to do a what's called a strong arm
robbery they wouldn't carry a firearm because they knew there was a
significant consequence for that they would feel free I guess I will carry a
firearm if nothing's going to happen to me if there's no real consequence for
being armed with a firearm then that's what I'll do and in in California we
had something called 1020 life which was basically that you would if you carried
a firearm during the commission of a felony if you discharge a firearm in the
commission of felony where you you killed someone with a firearm there would
be a significant increase in penalty for that the existence of that firearm so
it's this odd thing to where California professes at a policy level to be
anti-gun and yet we have in a large part allowing yes yes it's it's completely
inconsistent gun to do a robbery then it's okay right right now is this
fixable based on what you see I hope it's fixable I hope as the public sees
what's actually happening for themselves and despite some of the the newspaper
articles some of the being told by politicians that don't believe your
lying eyes in other words that I think the public is waking up to it and saying
you know what this is really a problem when when when you cannot walk the
streets of San Francisco when when people are telling moving out of San
Francisco or LA even and because they're saying I don't want my kids to
get off the bus and have to step over homeless people that have a needle stuck
in their arm I think there will be a consequence and there will be a tipping
point that happens when the public will begin more aggressively to push back
against these misguided policies and how should the public get involved would
they have to talk to their district attorneys or is it something they have
to go to the how can they make this change or what do they need to do they
need to pay more attention to this role I think they need to pay more attention
to it and really ask you know tough questions in terms of what are their
policies when when someone is running for elected office whatever the office
may be to ask them tough questions about what are their plans what's their what's
their solution for dealing with let's say homelessness what's their solution
for dealing with crime do they believe in personal accountability and
responsibility in the way that they manage their office I was interviewing
a district attorney and he told me that in his County if you actually steal a
car and you actually get into you get arrested you get in trouble they give
you two years and then you go to jail and you get out in two weeks right
because they're overcrowded can you explain this how it works like is that
well the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation has as
because of things like prop 57 because of prop 47 prop 57 and some other
changes in the rules regardless of the amount of time someone is being
sentenced they will make a determination on whether or not that person should be
released I'll give you a very good recent example in our County there was a
person who was caught about five years ago he had he conducted numerous
residential burglaries were broken houses he was convicted of 28
residential burglaries or breaking into because of the magnitude of them that
many residential burglaries the judge essentially sentenced him to 40 years in
prison very lengthy sentence for a lot of crime and he had a prior history of
committing those types of crimes in a little more than four years before after
a little more than four years of a 40 year sentence the California Department
of Corrections and Rehabilitation released him out of custody so that's
what's happening so you right now in the state of California well let me back up
ten years ago we had a hundred and sixty five thousand inmates in in Department
of Corrections in prison felons who are serving time in prison today we have a
right around 90,000 so we've dropped dramatically the number of people that
are in custody and a significant percentage of that 90,000 are people
doing a long long sentences for things like multiple aggravated sexual assaults
murders people doing life without the possibility of parole so the Department
Corrections can't release them it's as though they're falling over themselves
to release people early the big what was characterized initially as a mass
shooting in Sacramento a few months ago the primary participants in that what
turned out to be a gang gunfight as opposed to a mass shooting were people
who had been released early from from their sentences and so it's a very big
problem here in California why is that you're releasing these inmates is that
because there's no space because there was a court ruling back in the day that
said that we are jamming people into this prison right or is there other
reasons well we went from as I said a hundred sixty five thousand the capacity
what the prisons were supposed to be because of that was somewhere around a
hundred and thirty five thousand so but we didn't stop releasing them when we
had a hundred thirty five now we're down to ninety thousand and we're continuing
to release people early and it's as though this administration and the
California legislature they just don't want to hold people accountable they
will they it started out saving money but then now it's gone to a point where
we're just releasing people if there's a way to release someone from custody
they're releasing them so it's more ideological I believe so being in your
position you're seeing all that's happening with the district attorneys in
San Francisco LA and crime is going up how do you feel about it well I'm
bothered by it I mean I love you know to go to San Francisco or Los Angeles is
not where I live but I love to visit them and I grew up a big chunk of the
time in LA County as a child and did to see the the countless homelessness that
goes on the crime both in San Francisco in LA and throughout the state of
California it's very disturbing and and I'd like to see some change there do you
have any other thoughts for audience no I greatly appreciate being here and
talking to you about this and I I hope that the public really does you know
continue to increasingly wake up to the problems that are here and how you know
well-intentioned but misguided policies have created a lot of the problems we're
dealing with Vern Pearson the district attorney of Eldorado County was great to
have you on California insider well thank you appreciate being here thank
you for watching please click the icon on the left to subscribe to our Channel
we bring you the most pressing issues California is facing with
straightforward and in-depth interviews see you in the next video
