California's Megadrought Explained | Greg Thomas

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
Sign up our newsletter 👉 https://ept.ms/CAInewsletter
My Guest today is Greg Thomas, General Manager with Elsinore Valley Municipal Water District.
Is it true that California is going to lose 10% of its water in the next 18 years? And what can we do to avoid the water crisis?
#watercrisis #drought #watershortage
-
⭕ EpochTV EXCLUSIVES. Only $1 Trial (Limited Offer) 👉 https://ept.ms/1DollarNOW4
🔵 Stay up-to-date with exclusive newsletter: https://ept.ms/EpochTVNewsletterYT
💛Support us to fight for the truth👉https://donorbox.org/epochtv
🔵 Subscribe to California Insider👉 https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCFBMeA1yxZ7g8Z79t0O80-A?Sub_confirmation=1
And I think that's where a little bit we as water managers get a little frustrated.
We've conserved significantly. I think most agencies have cut water use and we think that
we think our residents, we think our customers. So people have really contributed. Oh 43, 50 percent
reduction in their water use from just 10 to 12 years ago. But unfortunately we have really strict
rules and regulations in the state that make it difficult for not only us as water managers,
water districts to operate under, but you look at just building something. Even in 2014 the voters
passed a water parks and recreation bond. 2.7 billion dollars was allocated to build additional
storage. Eight years ago we haven't built anything yet. My guest today is Greg Thomas,
general manager of Elsinore Valley Municipal Water District in Southern California. As water
managers really are expecting the state and everybody should expect the state to do more.
Is it true that California is going to lose 10 percent of its water in the next 18 years?
And what can we do to avoid the water crisis? Keep watching to find out the answers in today's
episode. I'm Siamak Korami. Welcome to California Insider. Thank you. Appreciate you being here. Thank
you for the invitation. Yeah so we want to talk to you about the drought and water shortage that we
have. We're hearing about this drought. We're hearing how we have to conserve and you know
some people are claiming it's climate change and whatever is happening. But from on another
counts it looks like we've had some mismanagement in the way we calculate how much water we would
have from the snow packs. Can you explain what's been going on? Sure. You know of course water
management across the state is can be very complex. We definitely know that there's climate
change going on throughout the world. You know somebody said once before that there's a set
amount of water in the world. It just where it goes whether it's an ice steam or rain and where
the patterns take it. We know that the climate in California you know you can just see the snowpack
in the Sierras how we're getting our water is changing every day you know over the decades.
I think you know we've been hearing a lot about climate change and those types of things.
The frustrating part is I think we haven't been adapting our management of it. So you know you
can see reports of 10% water loss in California by 2040 correct? Yeah. I was looking back at some
history and the first Governor Brown talked about some very similar things that there's three legs
to this that we need to think about the environment, agriculture, and urban you know the population.
You go back to 1992 Governor Wilson was facing a very similar situation we have now with a drought
and where are we going to get we had a lot more water in the Sierras. I think there was a lot
more precipitation and abilities but he identified and they had a three-way kind of funny word
three-way party but the environmental community, the farming community, and the urban community
got together and said how are we going to fix this and he set sort of a roadmap to fix the
management of the system. Nothing had really been built other than the state water project
and the central valley project that's federally controlled. So we're looking back 30 years ago
they identified we need to look at what we can do for off-stream storage, additional storage,
project what we're doing for the future. You know it takes such a long time to do anything in the
state and I think that's where a little bit we as water managers get a little frustrated
from the more state level is that we should have been building a lot more things and doing a lot
more things to prevent where we're at right now. We've conserved significantly I think most
agencies since the you know 12 years ago 10 years ago have cut water use and we think that we think
our residents, we think our customers, our constituents, and businesses. So people have
really contributed. Oh 43-50 percent reduction in their water use from just 10 to 12 years ago
and so conservation is important it's a I think it's a portion of how we get through this water
crisis but it's a very small portion because urban commercial that's your commercial that's
your institutional schools it's it's industry it's your residential folks use maybe 10 percent of the
total water in California. 40 percent goes to about ag agriculture and they're being cut and the rest
of the environment. When you look at things we can measure what we use urban we have meters not
everybody's metered but we can pretty much know I know how much water I sell a year and how much is
distributed and I can tell you all the buckets it goes into because we measure it. Farmers they're
probably the most efficient some of the most efficient people probably some of the best
businessmen because you know California feeds the not only the nation the world but they know what
goes in they measure those drops they they have they know how to increase their production cycle.
I commend farmers nowadays and what they have to go through and and the information and and the
efficiencies and the knowledge they have to have with with everything the plants climate so they're
about 40 percent but they're taking a haircut in their usage. You know there's five percent state
water project amounts going down to the farmers nothing on the central valley so you're following
500,000 acres of land so that's probably 20-30,000 jobs you're looking at probably
one point some billion dollars in revenue to the state you're looking at you know you can
have food so we're less food yeah and then with inflation definitely the less food and then you
look at just the cause and effects you follow 500,000 acres when you're not watering it
grasses are you know it's warm things aren't growing so now you have a dust issue and now
you're complicating the health issues of the locals because when the wind blows it causes
the dust that people breathe it in now you have potentially increases in asthma so it's kind of
this weird oodle loop but going back to the idea of you know I think we as water managers really are
expecting the state and everybody should expect the state to do more. So you mentioned that the
since 92 we actually recognized what we needed to do and it looks like we haven't done anything
about it right? No there hasn't been there's been a diamond valley lake has been built by
metropolitan water district this southern california I believe one reservoir up north
off-stream storage has been built we've identified like for sites I mean and even in 2014 the voters
passed a water parks and recreation bond 2.7 billion dollars was allocated to build additional
storage eight years ago we haven't built anything yet sites is the go-to reservoir but there was
eight projects identified in that bond proposition one to build additional storage and conveyance
nothing's been done so we're kind of a little behind the power curve in this is my opinion in
how we're addressing the crisis. Why do you think we can't do it because it's it's this is not a we
have a lot of engineers and we have a lot of innovation in this state this is not a if we
have a lot of technology probably we can do it right? It's kind of a multi-headed hydra in a way
it's it's you know kind of going back to governor Wilson in the 92 they had that
group just trying to work together there were the water wars you called it I think when it was is
if we all work together we'll all win and I think there's been a sort of a divestiture from that
where one group has kind of looked at winning over all the others and that would be I would
could call the environmental group. We have really strict rules and regulations in this
state that make it difficult for not only us as water managers water districts to operate under
but you look at just building something CEQA and then on the federal side NEPA
California Environmental Quality Act a CEQA and so that kind of hamstrings a lot of what we what
we want to do I think we're all environmentalists I'm an environmentalist I'm a conservationist I
grew up in Indiana belonged to Isaac Walton it was a conservation group it was about the
environment what we can do to better the environment also but to be smart about it for instance
you know overpopulation of deers that overpopulate or grow too much are actually bad for it and their
right aspect was you can hunt to a certain limit keep the herds down they're healthier they're
stronger they're better for the environment so those are kind of the some of the ethos that you
I grew up under and we all as water managers are about the environment about conservation
about being efficient in our water use but I think here in the state and this is again
me personally we've kind of there's one special interest group that tends to control a lot of
things in the up in Sacramento. Do you think this group which is the environmentalist right do you
they might have gone to an extreme or do you think they are not considering others in this
process? I think that overall the environmental special interest groups a good portion of them
want to balance they do want to work but I think like in any aspect of it you know whether it's
water management or or anywhere you have a fringe element that's very extremist and so I think that's
the portion that tends to get a lot of the public media attention etc that that does drive some of
the decisions that are coming out of Sacramento. So the water that the half that's going to the
environment it's it's to protect certain species right this is can you explain that part and there
was a supreme court ruling right? Correct on the delta smelt so and again we're I'm encouraging
and I think our water district we put five and a half million gallons of highly treated recycled
water into Lake Elsinore every day that's keeping the health of the lake otherwise it would be a
mud puddle but we're keeping the health of that lake so that you know it serves a lot of purposes
for recreation and the environment etc. So yeah you have certain species and again we don't want
things to go extinct but I think that has really hampered the abilities to manage the water system
more efficiently. For instance there's only certain times you can pump water through the
the bay delta based on the delta smelt or some other species aspect related to it. So when we
have these big delusions of water for instance in December we had so much rain and snow we had
massive amounts of rain all that went out under the. So we couldn't pump them more. Correct we
should have at that point again I'm you know. And essentially so you pump the water out to come to
take it through the bay delta through the normal estuaries etc. and then go south and we could have
put it in storage. And so I think you know from that again it's easy to play a little bit of
armchair quarterback not knowing the full climactic conditions that would have happened January through
April which is our more you know October through April is our rainy season for California. So do
these regulations do they not give us flexibility because it seems like it wasn't that we had to
pump certain hours certain amount of time no matter how much water. Certain times of the year
they're allowed to pump south. And so yes we're limited on those times when we can take advantage
of that large amount of water rainfall etc. and put it to where we needed to do it. So that would
have been a great advantage of having some of the off stream storage at that point. With all that
water coming we could have put it in an off stream storage like sites reservoir which is off you know
off the what river that is Sacramento I believe. Yeah. So coming off of that out of Shasta
we could have pumped that and then we would have that water for the environment
for agriculture and for the urban folks. And so I think you know when you look at that
I applaud we thank the governor for his recent plan that he just issued last week. Can you explain
more about this plan because they want to they want to do a tunnel. Is that a tunnel? Yes the
delta tunnel has been talked about for 40-50 years to fix help fix this whole issue in the
bay delta. Concerns about if there's a massive earthquake that the delta it's made up of a lot
of islands. In effect if you have a chance to visit it where you're actually on the island
and the water is above your head. Wow. Maintained by levees and it's kind of it's surreal in a way
you're like oh goodness gracious. So if those levees fail let's say we have a massive earthquake
then that whole water system could be complete compromised. So the tunnels is to move it about
45 miles or 35-40 miles so the intake is further upstream wouldn't affect as much of the
the species the delta smelt and saltwater intrusion. So we have a lot of saltwater
intrusion coming in just normal tides coming up and down and as sea level rises as part of
climate change you know the they're now having a little higher level of seawater. So we have to be
you know cautious of that seawater coming into the end of the bay delta and so that would provide a
won't provide more water but it provides more reliable water so that when we get these massive
rains and they're even projecting the next calamities for the state is flooding massive
flooding because of the droughts there's not there but now we're going to get these huge rains
and you've seen some recently across the United States because of climate change you're not going
to get a couple inches over a couple months you may get a foot of rain in a very short period so
the tunnels would help. So we wouldn't rely on the pumps anymore is that? No the pumps would still be
there but the tunnels would provide extra from a higher level that we can provide a more reliable
source. How realistic is this because you mentioned 30 years ago we had some plans and we
weren't able to do it from the reports I read that this this project there if even if they move
forward it will start construction in 2018 and there's still some people that are that are against
it. Correct so the Department of Water Resources just published the new environmental impact report
a very volumous aspect the Governor Newsom had gone from two tunnels to one tunnel
he realizes and his administration recognizes that we do need this and I'm hopeful that
the powers to play along the administration his cabinet folks can work with the various
groups there to get this completed and so it's just it's just one aspect of better water management
I think you know when we have solved the water crisis coalition of water agencies up and down
the state and we're working with the business communities the chamber the California Chamber
of Commerce or local chambers and a variety of groups we're recognizing that we need to not
conservation won't get us out of the drought it'll help but it's just a small facet. Because the
portion we can conserve is very small of the whole total equation. We're getting a lot more
efficient I mean new homes coming in in our service area we've had an eight percent increase
in in population and a six percent decrease in water usage. Wow. So you know we're doing our
managing yeah and new homes are more efficient your washers and dryers and and people how we're
getting that ethos of conservation being more water efficient our gardens are more water efficient
so I think the general population of the state recognizes that so we really need to focus on
educating our legislators and our business community and our administration to look at
these big projects we really need some off-site storage we need fixed to the conveyance system
the delta tunnels definitely thank and recognizing that water reuse recycling our
wastewater to drinking water standards it's happening in various places of the world Singapore
and some others the state water resources control board has a mandate through legislation and it's
in the governor's plan by the end of 2023 so about a year and a half from now to come out with
guidelines and regulations and how to do it and we're we're encouraged by that because we have
plans in the future to use our wastewater for drinking water and many many agencies are in that
boat and we we appreciate the support of the federal government the state governments and
ask others that help us fund it because it's very expensive now in terms of this plan what
do you think you will take for the state to be able to accomplish something like this tunnel
project I think that's going to require good leadership and not dropping keeping their keeping
their eye on the ball and really working with everybody and explaining the benefits of it
it'll be a major catastrophe if we have a major catastrophe and we don't have it
southern California which is two-thirds of your population of the state would be cut off from
significant amount of water a lot of water agencies and their experience here in metropolitan
water district are reliant only only have state water project or imported water from the Colorado
River that river is stressed also so my former water district that I was a general manager at
the only water we had was imported so if we don't have imported water we had emergency connections
with sister agencies that did have some other sources etc but that's not going to be enough
so you can just see the calamity in that regard so it is really we're encouraged by his plan
we're hoping that everybody gets behind it we really like everybody behind it so that we really
can fix it and we appreciate the influx or the proposal for funding could do local we're about
60 percent relying on imported water my our water district in terms of accountability on these
projects because we had the desalination project and the governor was for it but the people that
were on that board they didn't vote for they didn't allow it the coastal commission didn't
allow it in terms of accountability how much of it is there your colleagues when you guys local
level water district executives they sit together how do you see this state the water agency how do
you think they're doing and from what we get as as consumers we hear that there's drought this is
climate change sorry conserve and we may not farm as much farmers may not is there another message
that we should be hearing yeah i think the governor's the plan and then things that we've
all been talking about for many many years like decels are just one tool you know that we should
be using for water supply the carlsbad desalination plant there and you know in carlsbad
is about 50 000 acre feet a year somewhere around there and it can expand so that's a significant
amount of water that's going to be there 24 7 unless there's a plan upset of course but i mean
you can rely on that water 24 7 so that's that's significant and and the agencies in san diego
made that investment it wasn't cheap but they've i mean it's paying off now you have to make those
investments i think that you know desalination recycling our wastewater to drinking water or
indirect or direct potable reefs reuse is is key fixing the conveyance systems conservation
is a small part of that so the more we do overall collectively and i the better it is for the state
too so again locally we have a responsibility we've done a lot i can't speak for all my fellow
general managers but i know a lot of them in fact here in orange county they got orange county water
district one of the largest indirect potable reuse project uh reusing recycled water putting
it back in the ground fabulous what a huge what a significantly important project they're a lot
more independent from from the imported water but like i said a lot of agencies don't have that
ability so so it seems like the local water agencies are working very hard to to deal with
these obstacles but at the state level or or um the state agency might need to do better or at
least we should have some long-term planning so that you guys are not juggling all of this or
there's a flaw somewhere up there well yeah i mean given my background i'm sometimes a little
brutally honest or whatever um it's a group i think they're trying i think that we really need
to break down some of that stranglehold that certain special interest groups have on them
and really recognize that it's going to take everybody up and down the chain and that we need
to you know again work with solve the water crisis coalitions and other things to allow us as water
managers to be have a bigger say in what is happening we're the experts we run these we do
this day in and day out and i think sometimes we're our voices are not heard as much um through all
the noise that goes up and down the state and and through the those aspects so um i'm i'm encouraged
by the plan in the fact that we hopefully can get everybody to the table to work a little bit
closer because the better we manage our water is better for everybody like i said if we're
managing the water better and understanding the changes and putting things in place so if we do
a desalination plant and that frees up 50 or creates 50 000 gallons of new water or 50 000
acre feet of new water acre foots of 326 000 gallons enough for basically two to three homes
you know depending on so that's 100 to 150 000 homes correct yeah um or businesses or other
things um frees up that other limited resource for potentially the environment and so i think
one of the things you asked me what the challenge or what the roadblock a lot of it is i think the
regulations and i'm hoping that with the governor's plan to say let's look at what we can do to speed
up the permitting let's see what we can do for regulatory hurdles to sequa um how we can maybe
not we're too litigious in the state i don't like what happened i'm going to sue you you know you
could have we we do environmental impact reports they go through a litany of reviews they go through
all these other aspects they finally go through various agencies etc they get approved by let's
say my board of board of directors for a project and then somebody doesn't like it doesn't like it
sues and it gets held up for three or four years so you've got this project that could have been
built doing good being sued and it costs the rate payers even more it costs more and it will hurt
us in the long run if that yes so uh is there a way for the water experts to work with the
environmentalists is does it have to be some level of communication where it seems like there
might not be enough trust or whatever it is that is there a way for you guys to work together
and there is and and we are i think there's uh various groups that are working together i know
our our sister agencies up in the bay bay area uh san francisco etc do work uh often closely a lot
closer with the environmental communities than maybe some of us down here um and but yeah we
need to just come to the table and you know and be be honest and and want to work together um we're
always willing to work you know i've attended various working groups on low income rate assistance
and and those types of things and it was good dialogue but unfortunately i felt too that people
were like we'll solve it we'll fix it from the state level but they don't have the technical
managerial financial expertise and we would love to be able to be a little more helpful you know
i'd love to do and adopt a small community you know give them the technical managerial financial
assistance pro bono do it on my time i'll do it my time i'll drive on a weekend to somebody who
needs help i will have no problems doing that if we do that across the state we can solve a lot of
are even using charities there's a lot of charities like water for people is huge
internationally nine countries and they have a very good model that gets people
with clean water and sustainability and uh and sanitation incorporate some of those models uh
across so in terms of the the challenges that you guys face in the big picture what are are there
any other elements that you need to keep considering on a regular basis when you're running
that's a good question um yeah i think you know one of the things that
it's a little interesting is is the push towards complete green energy you know uh solar or wind
etc um and when you look at the impact for instance the colorado river is stressed with
low lake meet is the lowest it's ever been powell's low if we don't have any more
rain next year and gets that lake we're going to even be more stressed people will be taking less
water care arizona nevada and mexico are the first right now there was come out with some cuts
in their allocation starting next year but it's hydroelectric so those dams and a lot of the dams
produce a lot of hydroelectric power so we don't have enough backup in solar or or wind we really
need those um gas fired power plants we need those nuclear nuclear is clean energy we should
be building nuclear power plants water is very energy intensive to move it around even to treat
it i have wastewater plants water treatment plants it takes a lot of energy to treat that
thing that i get a little frustrated with is is the policy of the state to move to completely
renewable energy i mean they're wanting all electric homes all electric vehicles they've
mandated that we as public agencies etc go to electric vehicles and by certain times well i'm
going to tell you right now and they kind of recognize it there was we are at a conference
last week they recognize they want us to go to certain well dump trucks my vector trucks that
go out on the site to suck up sewer do cleaning etc there's nothing on the market will not be on
the market for years to be electric yet they're kind of mandating us to go to electric and yet
you know if you have a power outage how do you run all of this i have backup generators at all
my plants or all the key infrastructure the sewer plants the water plants etc the pump stations
and they're huge and so then you're battling with the air resources board that says
emergencies you're allowed a certain amount of thing but the restrictions on what you can use
and so you're kind of like this i'm being told you know i'm losing power here i got to go to
generators but i may be violating a regulation here are you losing are you is this a concern
that you may there might be blackouts and brownouts always yes yeah i think we're a little
more reliable at least in our service area but we've had some i mean all it takes sometimes is a
is a vehicle hitting a power pole taking out a portion of the grid you know that alone can
can cause problems so it's not just a over usage you know flex alert that you hear on
the news or whatever it could be just something local and so we're running and you guys are more
power intensive like what you use compared to because residentials may not feel the power
oh they do you're going to get it you know and so yeah you know you're you can't what kind of to me
is a little interesting is okay you want to have all electric house be alert from four to nine
because that's when everybody comes home does cooking and doing whatever that's when the power
teams increase consumption of across now commercial does sometimes drop off but if we have a power
during that time you can't even cook can't do your microwave can't use your stove we have gas
stoves i think that's smart to have a gas stove i mean it's it's not putting that much greenhouse
gas i mean california only does what i said one percent of the total greenhouse gases across the
world and yet we have such a you know and that was the environmental lawyer she you know you think
about we've pushed a lot of industry out of california you know one reason greenhouse gas
but think about the product that now now we've pushed it to china or it doesn't you know and
again we global economy they produce the widget whatever it is but they use coal they use coal
then they put it on a ship that burns fuel oil ship it across the ocean to put on a truck
to go somewhere else than another truck because or a rail car and then a truck and a truck so
when you think about the true impacts you probably cause more damage to the environment 10 to 20
times more just to do that if you hadn't just did it kept it here and had a job for people
right so i it just it's kind of like but it's out of sight out of sight out of mind it's over there
i can measure it here so that's where i get a little just uh frustrating frustrating part
thank you i was gonna use a different word but that's nicer
do you have any other thoughts for our audience just know that it's going to take a lot of effort
together but uh you know as water managers we want to we lots of things keep me up at night
cyber security you know cleanliness of our water etc but i think that overall and i'm like myself
but i think i could speak for a lot of our water manager we're trying to do and not fail
and fight the good fight as best as we can keeping it affordable too when we have all
these new constituents we have to clean out of the water potentially wastewater those are tens
of millions of dollars in technology we have to use you know and so we look and want to work with
the state and the federal government they've been good here the huge influx of funding to help us
with that but you know we we look at affordability and trying to keep everything as low water it's
a cost of water right you you have a water rate when you look at a gallon of water is about a
penny out of your tap and when super majority of the state gets really good water you can drink it
out of the tap i drink it out of the tap so we think about what it all takes all the you know
we have 1200 miles of pipe in our in our service area it's enough pipe stretch from here to denver
and we have to maintain all these systems and yet you only have to pay about a penny a gallon
that's pretty that's pretty good so you know again cost is what you pay value is what you get
and we provide a service so i'm kind of beating what we do as water water managers and water
agencies but i think again i think being conservation being efficient not wasting the
water is extremely important so don't just go down and hose down your driveway run your sprinklers
for you know four hours a day just because you want super lush yards etc think about those
aspects but let your electeds know what what's going on and be educated about things greg thomas
general manager of elson valley municipal water district it was great to have you on california
insider thank you a pleasure to be here thank you for watching please click the icon on the left to
subscribe to our channel we bring you the most pressing issues california is facing with
straightforward and in-depth interviews see you in the next video
