Who Is the Real Boss of Hollywood?

Indo-Pacific Conflict Zone
34 followers
45 Video Views·Aug 28, 2022
The Chinese Communist Party (CCP) influences the movies Hollywood makes. At the CCP’s demand, Hollywood self-censors American-made films released into China and around the world. Who is the real boss of Hollywood?
July 16th, 2020. U.S. Attorney General William Barr made a speech on Hollywood's self-censorship.
Barr said, Hollywood now regularly censors its own movies to appease the Chinese Communist Party,
the world's most powerful violator of human rights. This censorship infects not only the
versions of movies that are released in China, but also many that are shown in the United States
theaters to American audiences. Is this characterization accurate? P.E.N. America
published a 71-page study in 2020. It is a non-profit organization founded in 1922 and
based in New York. The study found the Chinese Communist Party's influence on Hollywood is
posing a serious threat to free expression. According to the report, studios and filmmakers
increasingly make decisions about their films, including the content, casting, plot, dialogue,
and settings, to avoid antagonizing Chinese officials. Those Chinese officials control
whether their films gain access to the booming Chinese market. James Tager, the lead author of
the study at P.E.N. America said, We don't see this issue through a national lens of us versus
China. We see this issue through the lens of our long-standing work defending freedom of expression.
And indeed, we end the report saying we want Hollywood to take more action to oppose government
censorship from any government, be that from Beijing, Washington D.C., Moscow, Cairo, or Riyadh.
The CCP took propaganda very seriously well before its takeover of China in 1949.
Making the foreigners serve China was one of the previous CCP chairman Mao Zedong's favored
strategies. At a CCP meeting on propaganda and ideology in August 2013, Xi Jinping also said,
Tell China's story well and properly disseminate China's voice.
In 2016, China's National People's Congress passed the Film Industry Promotion Law,
the first national law on film in China. The intent is to promote socialist core values.
The law adopted the CCP's long-standing policies on censorship. Article 16 forbids content that
stirs up opposition to the CCP and harms national unity, sovereignty, or territorial integrity.
It also bans content that exposes national secrets, harms Chinese security, dignity,
honor, interests, or spreads terrorism or extremism. Influencing Hollywood is an integral
part of the overarching strategy for the CCP to dominate the world. It works tirelessly to ensure
that the only stories told about China are those that the CCP approves. To enforce censorship,
the CCP must make sure filmmakers are unwilling or unable to criticize the CCP.
Here is what has happened. In 2012, the mainland Chinese Wanda Group spent 2.6 billion U.S. dollars
and acquired AMC, the second largest U.S. movie theater chain. Since then, it has acquired
Legendary Entertainment, a major U.S. film company, for 3.5 billion U.S. dollars.
For 1.1 billion U.S. dollars, it also bought Carmike Cinemas, the fourth largest movie
theater chain in the United States. In 2016, China's billionaire Jack Ma's Alibaba Pictures
Group acquired a stake in Steven Spielberg's Amblin Partners and placed a representative
on Amblin's board of directors to participate in major decision-making. In China, it has been
well known that in every business entity or company, regardless of whether it is privately
owned or owned by various government entities, the CCP mandates that a CCP branch be established
in the company. Furthermore, the party branch is the big brother to oversee the company.
In fact, most of the company's owners or senior management themselves are CCP members. The CCP
controls the Chinese company through the party branch. So, the Chinese company ensures the
foreign businesses it buys will follow the CCP and tell China's story well.
The CCP's influence continues to grow. From 1997 to 2013, China invested in only 12 out of the top
100 highest-grossing Hollywood movies. But from 2014 to 2018, China co-financed 41 of Hollywood's
most popular films. This has been effectively helping force Hollywood to follow the CCP's script
to paint a positive image of the CCP and conceal the regime's tyrannical ambitions.
On the other hand, Hollywood studios are also eager to get into the Chinese market for an
obvious reason, its size. In 2018, China surpassed the United States in quarterly
theatrical box office revenue for the first time. By 2023, the Chinese box office revenue
was predicted to reach 15.5 billion U.S. dollars, well above the U.S. box office total for 2019,
about 11.4 billion U.S. dollars. Hollywood covets China's rapidly growing movie market.
Hollywood's executives are well aware that they will be excluded from it if they fail to toe the
CCP's rules. Thus, they set about ensuring they follow CCP's censorship. American movie stars who
have taken a stand against CCP oppression are blocked from entering the country, or their
films are excluded from the Chinese market. For example, Hollywood star Richard Gere's clear
support for Tibet led to his being denied access to China, thus limiting his career in the United
States since film producers sought to avoid offending or provoking the CCP. Other movie
stars blacklisted by the CCP include Sharon Stone, Selena Gomez, Harrison Ford, and so on.
They participated in films critical of China or simply met with or took a photo opportunity with
the exiled Dalai Lama. There is an infamous 3T rule that CCP officials never want filmmakers
to break, namely do not touch Tiananmen Square, Taiwan, and Tibet. Whoever dares to shoot or say
anything negative related to these three topics will be punished, and their movies will be banned
in Chinese markets. Indeed, the movie directors, actors, and actresses will be blacklisted.
For some, blacklisting may be too much to bear. Jean-Jacques Arnaud, director of Seven Years in
Tibet, a 1997 film, was believed to be blacklisted along with star Brad Pitt for their involvement
in the movie. The CCP did not like the film because it touched their nerve on the Tibetan issues.
Over a decade later, in 2009, Arnaud was going to direct the French-Chinese joint production
Wolf Totem. For reasons we can only guess, Arnaud released an open letter on Weibo,
a Chinese Twitter-like social media app. Arnaud apologized for his participation in
Seven Years in Tibet. Thanks to the apology, Arnaud later finished the movie Wolf Totem
and continued to produce the Chinese film Genghis Khan in 2018 without the unpleasant
experiences of harassment by CCP officials. A drama like what Arnaud played in 2009 was
replayed by John Cena, a star actor in the movie Fast and Furious by Universal Pictures in 2021.
The film, co-produced with the state-owned China Film Group Corporation, premiered in China and
several other places. Shortly after the movie came out, Cena posted a puzzling video to the
Chinese social media platform Weibo and repeatedly apologized for his mistake. It seemed that what he
said during a press interview touched another of the CCP's nerves, namely the Taiwan issue since
he had called Taiwan a country. Again, Cena's apology avoided some potential troubles and made
many Chinese nationalists happy. Chloe Zhao, the director of the movie Nomadland, had some
unexpected experiences with the CCP. She was born in Beijing and had close ties to some well-known
Chinese entertainment figures. She made history as the first woman of color to win Best Director
at the Oscars. For a while, she was highly regarded in China. The CCP newspaper Global Times anointed
her the pride of China. Soon after, there was a twist. One of her interviews in 2013 went viral.
In the interview, she called China a place where there are lies everywhere. The whole situation
turned upside down. The release of Nomadland in China was cancelled. Chinese social media
removed all the praises and celebrations of her winning the Oscar. Obviously, the CCP did not like
what she said in that 2013 interview. Now, she may have been the latest addition to the CCP blacklist
for Hollywood. Hollywood is not the only film industry under the CCP's pressure. In 2018,
producers of the German anthology film Berlin, I Love You, Rheingold Films, and Walk on Water
Films 2019 removed a section of the film directed by Chinese dissident artist Ai Weiwei before the
final cut. Ai Weiwei has been openly critical of the Chinese government's stance on democracy and
human rights. The film's producers publicly confirmed that the segment was removed due
to concerns that the artist was on CCP's unwelcome list in China. In other words,
the CCP imposed self-censorship in films is not unique to Hollywood. The CCP's long arm touches
entertainment industries worldwide. Through its censorship over film industries, the CCP
misleads the world and influences what we see, hear, and think. Hollywood has sold out to China,
kowtowing to Beijing's censors is now the norm. Coming back to the question,
who is Hollywood's real boss nowadays? According to an Atlantic article, no matter their clout in
Hollywood, filmmakers and actors have always been subject to bosses who decide which movies get to
soar at the box office and which are left to languish. Now, more than ever before, that boss
is Beijing.
