🔵 Sign up for the American Thought Leaders newsletter to stay up-to-date on new episodes, releases, and events 👉 https://ept.ms/ATLnewsletter
“They're not calling you racist because they care about race or racism or eliminating racism. They're calling you racist because it works. … It's a tool to shut people up,” says Konstantin Kisin, a UK-based satirist, political commentator, and co-host of the TRIGGERnometry podcast.
Born in Moscow during the Soviet era, Kisin is the author of the new book, “An Immigrant’s Love Letter to the West.”
“The problem isn't evil, malicious people running around who want to make things worse. The problem is people who buy into ideology that gives them permission to do terrible things in the name of the greater good.”
Today, I sit down with Konstantin Kissin, a UK-based satirist, political commentator,
and co-host of the Trigonometry podcast.
They're not calling you racist because they care about race or racism or eliminating racism.
They're calling you racist because it works. It's a tool to shut people up.
Born in Moscow during the Soviet era,
Kissin is the author of the new book, An Immigrant's Love Letter to the West.
The problem isn't evil, malicious people running around who want to make things worse.
The problem is people who buy into ideology,
that gives them permission to do terrible things in the name of the greater good.
This is American Thought Leaders, and I'm Jan Jekielek.
Konstantin Kissin, such a pleasure to have you on American Thought Leaders.
Thanks for having me back.
Well, Konstantin, I had such a good time reading your book,
An Immigrant's Love Letter to the West. In fact, in many ways, I felt a deep kinship here,
although technically I was born in Canada. Polish was my first language.
I certainly came to know a lot of the kinds of habits in the family that you describe
in the book. For example, this idea, which frankly drove me crazy as a kid,
that anything that is talked about in the family stays in the family.
So why don't we actually start there? Why would it be the case that in a family,
and growing up in the Soviet Union?
Well, if you grew up in the Soviet Union towards the end of it, as I did, it was a strange time
because the Soviet Union was no longer nearly as powerful as it was either externally or internally.
But at the same time, many of the habits continued. And so even in the mid-'80s,
the late-'80s that I lived through, there was a climate of fear about speaking your mind because
only 40 or 50 years ago, people would have been put in a camp or executed for speaking their mind.
So you don't wash that away overnight. It takes generations for people to overcome that.
And even in the early-'80s, my grandfather, as you know, I talk about in the book,
he made some comments on the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan that were considered anti-Soviet.
And he was immediately made unemployable. He was ostracized by friends, many of whom,
like in today's climate, many of whom agreed with him privately, but refused to back somebody who
spoke out against a controversial thing in public. And so even at that point, it was still the case
that my parents, when I was a kid going to school, they would say, well, look, all of this dissident
stuff that we talk about around the kitchen table, you can't be saying that out there because
your dad will be in trouble, or your mom will be in trouble, or the family will be in trouble.
And there were examples all around us. So growing up like that, it definitely made me aware
of how precious it is, what we have here in the West, which is, until recently, at least,
the opportunity to speak your mind without fear. It's a hugely valuable thing that I think we
underestimate massively, because we've always had it, or we feel we've always had it,
and we take it for granted far too much.
And it's really interesting. It takes a while for someone that comes from
an authoritarian or totalitarian society, once they arrive in a free society, to
realize that things work a little bit differently. And this was indeed the case with my parents,
because all those internal rules just de facto stayed in place until perhaps many decades later,
where it became a little less of an issue. This idea of not appreciating what you have,
this is something that really comes out when you read an immigrant's love letter.
Explain to me why you think it's like this, that in quite probably the freest society
that has ever existed, at least in recorded history, many people feel that it's terrible.
Yeah. I think it's a symptom of our success, Jan. We have created the most free, open
society where you can come and make something of yourself.
And I'm going to add tolerant, frankly, right?
Well, as you know, I make the point in the book and in interviews that I've done,
we live in one of the most open, tolerant, progressive societies, in the right sense of
that word, in the history of the human species. And I think it's because we've created that,
that so many, particularly younger people, they don't even know that a different world
either existed somewhere in the past or exists in a different geographical location.
Many of them haven't seen other countries, other societies. They don't understand
that the problems that we have, in quotation marks, pale into insignificance when you contrast
them with other countries. Just one example in Russia at the moment with what's happening with
war in Ukraine, the people who were protesting against this in Russia, initially they went out
on small protests, a few hundred people, all arrested immediately. Then they started going
out with a single protest, single man, single woman protest, with placards saying, I'm for peace,
and they would get arrested. Then they would satirically go out with no placard and just
their hands in the air, and they would get arrested. To the point where I was just in the
former Soviet Union for my sister's wedding, and we met some of my family who live in Russia now,
and they were telling us how this guy whose name is the Russian, his name in Russian translates
to for peace, because he comes from one of the Muslim areas of Russia, and Zamir is a name that
is common there. He was stopped and arrested at the airport because he had a placard saying,
my name is Zamir, I'm here to be picked up by somebody. That is the level of paranoia and state
oppression that many, many people around the world live in right now. But if you've grown up in New
York, or Los Angeles, or London, or whatever, you have absolutely no conception that that even
exists. That contrast isn't there. That comparison isn't there. Of course, by comparison with the
imagined utopia of progress that we all now suddenly bought into, then the West does seem
all the usual isms and phobias and whatever, because we're not comparing it with reality,
we're comparing it with things that we imagine. Is this imagined thing that is imagined in this
current cultural moment actually something that we should be striving for?
I think it's a very good question, and it kind of puts me in a difficult position,
because on the one hand, I do think, the way I would say it is, I do think if it were possible,
it would be desirable to achieve. My concern is that it's not possible. We talk about
eliminating things from our society, like racism, or sexism, or whatever. We can't even
eliminate murder from society. We can't eliminate rape from society. We can't eliminate so many
problems, because we're not perfect. We're human. We're fallible. Human beings have
mental health issues that can't always be resolved. Human beings, some of them are just psychopathic.
We can't get to a point where we've got zero problems in society unless, and this is perhaps
what we'll be talking about, unless you're willing to use extreme authoritarianism
to achieve it. So for example, we could say, well, we do want to eliminate murder,
so why don't we take all males between the ages of 16 and 40 and lock them down in a prison?
We'd eliminate 95% of the murder, right? That's the level of tyranny it takes to be eliminating
things to the very, very, very end, to create utopia. And the pursuit of that is why I think
we're starting to see a willingness to use authoritarianism, a willingness to shut down
comedy that questions the narrative, a willingness to shut down media conversations, a willingness to
destroy and smear politicians who attempt to challenge some of these things,
because we're embracing a level of totalitarianism, culturally, that is necessary
to pursue the utopia that we're talking about. That's fascinating. So another part of the reason
why I asked this question is, I'm not entirely clear, and certainly some people that both of us
know believe this to be the case, I'm not entirely clear, that it is clear what this final outcome is
really supposed to be, right?
It's rainbows and unicorns. It's the dream that we were all sold in the Soviet Union,
from each according to his ability to each according to his need. Everybody's equal.
Life is fair. We all want life to be fair, don't we? That's what we imagine. And it's the pursuit,
unfortunately, of equity, which is what we're really talking about. That's where you have to
use an awful lot of force, because the truth is, we didn't evolve for life to be fair.
We're a competitive species. We evolved to have hierarchy. The moment you walk into a room,
you instantly know who is in charge. This is how our brains evolved. We're not capable of living
in a flat society. We want hierarchy. We want structure. We want these things, and we can't
live without them. So they attempt to pretend that we are ants in an anthill who are all
genetically related and therefore can work towards the common good, completely sacrificing
their own ambitions. Human beings ain't that. We just ain't.
And it's interesting because at the beginning of your book, in one of the first two chapters,
you kind of describe, I'll say this in quotes, how great a society the Soviet Union had created.
Healthcare for all. You give a series of examples. Education for all.
Childcare. Free childcare. You get paid to go to university, to college. You get paid, Jan.
Think about that in today's climate, where young people are racking up hundreds of thousands of
dollars in tuition fees. Incredible. Universal healthcare. Guaranteed job. Wealth inequality,
very, very low compared to what we have. Incredible society in many ways.
And then the other piece, of course, is that you're always equalizing across the bottom,
so to speak. That's the effect. You make everyone equal by making everybody
equally poor. That's what you do. That's how you do it. And that's why you need the tyranny,
because people don't want to be equally poor. People who work hard and who are talented and
who contribute more want to feel rewarded for that. They don't want to feel like in the Soviet
Union, most people didn't work hard, because why would you? If you're operating an organization
where it doesn't matter whether you work hard or you're the laziest person in the world. You get
treated the same. You have the same salary. You have the same opportunities for promotion, etc.
Why would you work hard? Why would you create? That's why you need the whip. You need the whip
to get people to do stuff, because the incentive of their own life, their own desire to better
themselves is suppressed by the state. And so you have to make them. So this is the point,
the pursuit of equality in this way, equality in inverted commas, is predicated on authoritarianism.
You cannot do it without that. You can't make people equal without the authoritarianism.
They don't want to be equal. We think we do. We claim we do. We don't want to be equal. We want
to be rewarded on the basis of our merits and talents. That's what everybody wants.
So your current level of understanding in these totalitarian societies that we've seen,
socialist societies that we've seen, like Nazi Germany, like the Soviet Union, like North Korea,
like Communist China, is it more that with this type of a vision, this sort of society will
naturally result with these kinds of ideas? Or is it that there's just some very cynical
folks that are just taking advantage of it to seize the wealth for themselves and seize control?
It's always both, because the structure at the top will always be a few corrupt people
who capitalize on the system. But the ideology that underpins that at the mass level is much
more what we've just talked about. But yeah, of course, it's going to be run by a few old men
who take advantage of that system. That's how it is. That's how it always will be.
And to some extent, I think that's probably true in a democratic society as well. It's just
the nature of structures, the nature of hierarchy. People will, at the top, attempt to collect the
resources and power and influence in order to better their own life. It's inevitable. You're
not going to get rid of that entirely either. Something very important in your book is this
ideology that seeks to seize equality. You make the case pretty strongly, and I think you believe
this, that the project is actually to subvert the West, to shake it at its foundations, to break
apart the threads that bind society together. I'm inclined to believe this too. I would quibble
with the word project. I haven't decided whether I think it's sort of organized or whether it's
more organic. There are definitely hostile forces that accelerate processes that are already
happening. But whether it's all entirely deliberate, I question. I think it may be
more a product of several technological revolutions that have changed the way society
is organized, whether that's the sexual revolution or the internet revolution in recent times.
They've created new ways of behaving that are detrimental to our society.
The sexual revolution is obviously really important and great in many ways, but one of the things it
does is it affects the family unit. The multi-generational impact of that is not good.
Sexual revolution in terms of women's empowerment or sexual revolution as in free-for-all sex?
Both. If you think about women's empowerment, women going into the workplace, it changed the
dynamics around the upbringing of children. It also changed the value of men and women
in terms of the dating sphere. One of the reasons you're seeing fewer intact families now is that
that change, while it was necessary in some ways and very healthy, certainly from a women's rights
point of view, it also had an impact on how the family was organized and how children are brought
up and raised. You've ended up going in the space of only a few decades from a situation where most
people were born into a family with two parents to a situation where those rates are plummeting.
We know the impact on children of being brought up without a parent. That technological change,
there's a lot of conservatives that think it was the war on poverty and incentivizing
single parents. I don't know whether that's true or not. I'm just saying I think the technological
side is probably very big. Then, of course, you come to, more recently, the technological change
in terms of social media and how that helps people propagate certain ideas that make them
feel good without necessarily being accurate. What I was mentioning before was that there's
women's empowerment very clearly. To me, isn't the same thing as saying that sexual activity is
perfectly normal and fine any which way you want it as opposed to say within some kind of family
structure, which is how it has been since time immemorial as the accepted norm. It's that part
that to me strikes me as something that fundamentally attacks the family unit.
I think that's part of it, but I think it's not just that. I also think just the change to
the family structure. I hear what you're saying, but I think that is only a part of it. Now,
I know that from a more socially conservative perspective, that is the bit that you hone on,
but I think more of the impact comes from the changing relationship between men and women.
Very interesting. It's interesting that you might take issue with the word
project because the whole title of your book is obviously an ode to Yuri Bezmenov. I'm sure you're
on record saying that somewhere. No, no. You're one of the few people that's worked it out.
Yuri Bezmenov outlined a very clear project. It was the Soviet Union's project to subvert America.
He explained how he was going to do it. Tell me why you picked this.
I do think that the foreign powers that dislike what we have in the West
are obviously keen to destabilize the way that we do business. That's what they want.
As I say in the book repeatedly, I don't believe that the West has anything to fear
from communist China, from Vladimir Putin's Russia, from Islamist terrorism, from whatever
threat you want to name. I don't believe the West has anything to fear as long as we have
confidence in ourselves and that we're willing to defend ourselves and stand up for what we believe.
Then we have nothing to fear. My concern is that there is a culture internally within the West,
whatever Russia is doing with the troll farms or whatever, internally in the West there's a
culture that has emerged from something that happened on university and college campuses
decades ago that means we are not willing to maintain our immune system when we haven't
been for some time. That's why I wrote An Immigrant's Love Letter to the West. I hope
it's a sort of antibody injection in my small way into the body of Western civilization.
We've got to learn to understand we have threats and they're external, but the only way that a
civilization collapses is when it is internal. You can have the biggest threat outside. If you're
strong internally, you're going to be fine. In fact, look at America during the Cold War.
America was booming because it had something to position itself against and it had to think about
what are our values? Why are we in the standoff? What makes us different? What is it that we have
that people there don't have? Why is it that we want to be here in this moment?
America and your leaders, you had to think about this. You had to chisel it out. You had to define
we are a people who believe in freedom above all, whereas in many other parts of the world,
people don't have that and they don't necessarily even think that they want that. This is who we are.
I think it's really about understanding that this is coming from the inside. I think other powers
may want to accelerate it. They may want to help the destabilization along, but I think it's
we ourselves who are doing this to ourselves. I want to touch on Yuri a little bit more here.
As far as I can tell, we're kind of living in the world that Yuri Bezmenov predicted. He talked
about this long stage of demoralization, which is essentially basically stopping people from
believing in themselves. Exactly this sort of Achilles heel, this key thing that you're
describing right now. Then there's this time period where all this is being normalized. I
can't remember the final stage is normalization, but there's also the stage of crisis. It kind of
feels like the West is in a kind of crisis. Basically, it's a very destabilized society
where all these values that have been kind of the rock on which American society was built
are up for grabs. They are. I have been very enthused. I don't know how you feel about it,
Jan, but the West's reaction to the Russian invasion of Ukraine. There are quibbles I have,
obviously, with some of it, particularly in Europe in terms of Germany, but generally speaking,
I have been very pleasantly surprised by how actually quite unified the reaction has been.
I think that I, like the person who authorized the invasion, overestimated the extent of the
West's internal division. I don't think it turned out to be quite as bad as I thought it was, which
enthused me. I was pleased to see that, but I don't think that means the problem is solved.
We still have a problem. It's just not as bad as I thought it was.
The thing is, I think most people have no idea that they're demoralized. They don't know that
the lack of confidence that they now have in their own society is not normal. This endless
self-flagellation is sort of seen as par for the course. This is what we do now,
but it's not. We're in a very abnormal society now, a society that endlessly questions itself.
It's a very strange way to be. Likewise, if we were just obsessively proud of ourselves,
it would be equally abnormal. I often think of a society as a bit like a human being,
a human being who's just proud of themselves and just obsessed with how brilliant they are.
It's probably not a healthy human being, but a human being who is obsessed with their
inadequacies and their imperfections and the past mistakes is not a healthy human being either.
That's why I've never been someone who said, the worst needs to just think that we're the
best people ever and American exceptionalism and Western exceptionalism and there's nothing for us
to learn and there's nothing for us to improve. The way you improve is by asking questions of
yourself and demanding more of yourself as a society and being truly committed to the principles
that you consider to be the core values of your civilization. But the fact that we spend so much
time beating ourselves up now is not normal. It's not, and it's not leading to good places.
I always found it so fascinating that this particular brand of Marxist or socialist
thought infused with postmodernism, it actually comes from America. Are you unhappy about that
as an Englishman now? And then frankly, later I've been thinking actually it makes perfect
sense that it would come from America. This is the place that really is the fulcrum
where freedom is sitting. If we're victims of our own success, then the most successful
place will be the place where the victimhood is greatest. If we're the victims of the fact that
we've created the freest, most prosperous societies in the world, if that is what's causing the
reaction, then it will be in the home of greatest freedom like the United States where that would
take place. That makes perfect sense, doesn't it? And this is one of the things that Francis,
my co-host from Trigonometry and I, we've been here in New York for a few days and we kind of see
how much more dynamic this country is than even us in the UK. This is the place where
ideas are generated and discussed and they have an impact and they spread around the world. So
we consume your culture in the UK and because we speak English, we're sort of deluded into thinking
that we are the same culture, whereas of course we aren't. It's one of the things that
I find amazing that I talk about in the book is in the UK now, we talk about how we're a nation
of immigrants, which is a complete historical falsehood in every way. It's just nonsense.
Britain is not a nation of immigrants at all. The only reason we repeat this rubbish is because we
get it from you guys, because you are a nation of immigrants. And people would just take this part
of the culture, import it into the UK and just repeat it endlessly without realizing that
different places have different histories. It's not that complicated, but it's a testament to
the power of American culture in the Anglosphere particularly, that we adopt all your ideas
wholesale. So this is why I always sort of encourage my American friends is please look
after your culture because we are the ones that are eating all the crap that gets produced
as well as you. It's not just your own country that's affected by this, it's the entire world.
I found your critique of multiculturalism to be one of the most thoughtful and interesting
things sort of summarized that I've come across. I want to give you a chance to kind of tell me
what you think about multiculturalism because frankly, it sounds great, right, on the surface.
Well, I think that the difficulty we got ourselves into, particularly in Western Europe, but I know
less about the United States, I'll confess, but in Western Europe, we confused the desire to live
in a multi-ethnic society, a society in which people from different ethnic backgrounds,
different religious groups come together and live together peacefully, which I think is perfectly
possible. It's more difficult than a sort of ethno-state like many of the ones that exist
around the world. It's more of a challenge, but there are huge benefits that come from that too
in terms of innovation, drive, creativity. It's really important, but that is not the same as
saying to people, you are here in Britain or in America and here's a piece of land and carve
out for yourself a piece of this land in our country in which you live by the standards by
which you choose. There is no need for you to integrate into our society. There's no need for
you to abandon some of the ways of thinking and doing business that you did in the society from
which you come. That doesn't work because if we're living in America, if we're living in the
United Kingdom, then there are certain things that we have to equalize and be common on in order
to be able to live cohesively together. We have to have an understanding, for example, that we all
live under the same law. We cannot have people who bring, whether that, you know, it's not just
Muslims in our country, it's also Jews as well. You can't bring your religious legal system into a
society and demand that that is parallel with the legal system of the state in which you operate.
We all have to say, I am originally from Russia, but I am British. I've come to this country to
be part of this country. Now, I'm not abandoning the things that I learned and the ways of thinking
that I got by being born where I was born, but I have to embrace this new identity and make myself
part of this society and contribute to it. This is one of the reasons I love doing what I do because
we've now created a YouTube show in the UK that employs local people, right? I, as someone who
came from outside of the society, am now so meshed with it that I'm creating work for people who were
born in that society. I'm creating jobs. That, to me, is the way that an immigrant, in my opinion,
should be, and I'm not saying that because that's the way I am. I'm saying that because that's how I
want it to be, because I think that's what the purpose of traveling to a different place and
making a home there is. You become part of that society and you want to make it better,
whereas if the idea that we're teaching is you come to that society and you live
isolated from that society, you don't necessarily learn the language of that society, you don't
integrate, you don't embrace some of the important values, then you get to the stage where you have
problems like the ones that we're seeing in the UK where, you know, a teacher teaches his kids
a lesson about religious tolerance, which involves something to do with the prophet,
and suddenly this teacher has to go into hiding because we have people in society who believe that
their religious views are above the law, the law of the land to which they come or which their
parents brought them. This is not sustainable. We cannot live in a society where we have parallel
structures. So multi-ethnic society, very, very important, very desirable, I think hugely
beneficial. Multicultural society is the recipe for disaster.
In the past in the US, there were very, very clear assimilationist policies. You would come
and you would, there's a whole series of steps you would take to become part, to become an
American, to become part of the culture. But somewhere along the way over the last 20-30
years, that became racist or any other, there's probably a whole bunch of other ists. Certainly
colonialist would be a term that was used. So what you're describing is the cost here of a nation of
immigrants where that sort of encourage everyone to join the shared culture is a problem. Why?
Because the implicit assumption is that culture is better. And that is sort of an anathema, isn't it?
Well, I think Thomas Sowell is the best on this. He talks about multiculturalism being the idea
that you can praise any culture except Western culture and criticize only Western culture and
no other. I, by the way, don't make, I mean, I do say in the opening chapter is called Trust Me,
West is Best. But I'm not actually making a claim that Western society is best in some necessarily
universal way. I just think it's best for people like me and for people like us, whose values
include things like freedom, the opportunity to speak their mind. There are plenty of people in
the world who I suppose are less bothered by that and are more concerned about other things.
They want perhaps more social cohesion than I'm obsessed about. You know, they want society to act
as one. There are more communitarian societies further east that do that. And if that's what
people there want, then that's up to them. I'm just saying, I think those of us who think freedom is
important, those of us who think the opportunity to speak your mind is important, those of us who
think the pursuit of scientific rationality is important, that the hard sciences are important,
that they're not Western colonialist patriarchal concepts, they're just the truth of how we improve
society. You know, I just, I'm amazed every time we travel around the world how technology has made
life so much better for us in some ways. And that comes from the idea that actually it's quite
important to work out what's true and what's not true. It's not just opinions. There's physics
and chemistry and biology and, by the way, psychology too. These are things that have
predictive power. They're not just things that we can deconstruct endlessly with no consequence.
So if we want to continue in these technologically advanced, scientifically expanding,
progressing societies, the freedom is the thing that makes it all happen. And if you don't want
that, there's lots of societies you can go and live in. Just don't bring that crap over here.
Well, freedom and the acceptance that there is objective reality that we can all agree around,
and that it exists outside of perception and, frankly, power dynamics.
Absolutely. And to me, that is what the Western project is. That is why the West is successful.
Because technologically, it's way ahead of everybody else, and that's because people
are free to experiment. They're not taking a dick tap from a mid-level apparatchik as they
were in the Soviet Union, or they are now in communist China. You are free to make something
and see if it works. And if people like it, and if it's of value to other people, you will be
rewarded. Not because you managed to persuade some kind of Mandarin that what you're doing
is the right thing. It's because that's what the people around you benefit from. You measure your
contribution by the success you're having in society. Now, of course, that's an idealistic
view. Not everyone who's successful in Western society is contributing. Some people are parasitic,
too, and some organizations are parasitic. But the model is that if you create something that
makes other people's lives better, you will be rewarded. And that is all based on the idea of
freedom. And this is also the reason why so many people are clamoring to get here,
because they know that that's actually possible. And it's certainly not possible everywhere,
not by a long shot. Look at me. My parents were dirt poor when I was born. They then had a period
when they were wealthy for a short period of time, sent me to boarding school in the UK.
And in the meantime, my dad was falsely accused of various things in the Russian government,
had to flee the country under false identity, lost all of his money. So I went to university
as this rich kid. And by the time I was in year two, I was sleeping in the local park,
because I didn't have a roof over my head. And that was 20 years ago, Jan. And here I am,
sitting here in New York, just next to Madison Square Garden, we're having this conversation.
Where does this happen? Which other part in the world does it happen that you've got
no family, no connections, no one to pull strings for you? Where does it happen that you can just
pursue a dream and make something of yourself, and you have those opportunities? Are you telling
me that that's happening in Russia now? No, it's not. Is it happening in communist China? No.
Where are these societies that allow you to do this? It's only in a society like this one
that allows you to achieve your potential. If you really want to, you can. It doesn't matter
where you come from. It doesn't matter what your skin color is. That's why people come here.
That's why people are dying in the Mediterranean, scraping and scrimping to get to the West.
That's why people are crossing the southern border in this country. That's what they want.
And by the way, look at all these racial activists in this country and in the UK.
They talk about how America and Britain or whatever is the most racist country in the world.
Notice how they never leave. They don't go to these whatever better places exist out there.
They never leave. Why is that? Why is that? And arguably, many of them are quite entrepreneurial,
I would say. Right. They've got the opportunity to do what they want to do here, which is the
grift that they do. They've got that chance here because it's a society that rewards you
if you pursue things. For the record, what is the grift?
The grift, I think, is capitalizing on Western white guilt. That's what it is. We're very
successful. Like every other society in human history, we've committed awful atrocities all
around the world, like everybody else. But we are the most successful society ever. And
we feel bad about it. We feel guilty about it. We feel terrible about it. And we've been
trained to think like that. Like me, I'm a dark-skinned, first-generation immigrant.
Even I'm like, oh, maybe I shouldn't talk about this because this is the idea that we've now
indoctrinated in ourselves. And these people know that. And they know that it works. It's
a tactic that works. I was saying this to you before we started. We have this election
for conservative party leader in the UK at the moment, which is also about who will be
the next leader of the country, the prime minister. And it's the most diverse field
that we've ever seen in British politics. So there's more people in that race than in
the left-wing Labour Party that have ever been a minister or a shadow minister. It's
crazy how women of different backgrounds, from an African background, from an Asian
background, an Indian background, people from all over the thing. And the conservatives,
it makes me laugh how naive conservatives can be sometimes. They're thinking about,
oh, well, if we do this, they're going to stop calling us names. They're going to stop calling
us racist. They're thinking, oh, look how diverse we are now. Now we have it made,
something like that. But it's never been about that. Calling people racist, they're not calling
you racist because they care about race or racism or eliminating racism. They're calling
you racist because it works. That's why they're doing it. They're not going to stop. They're
not going to stop. But you're saying because it's a tool to gain power. It's a tool to
shut people up. Because if you can't win the argument, if you can't actually have a conversation,
well, you're saying we are bad society. OK. What are we comparing to? Compared to what?
This is one of Thomas Sowell's three great questions. Compared to what? In Russian, we
have the same saying. Everything is understood in comparison. But if you can't win that conversation,
then what you have to do is shut down anyone who asks that question. And it's just a tool. That's
why they've got no problem. They'll take a gay person who doesn't agree with their politics,
and they will say he's got internalized homophobia. They'll take a brown person and say they're a
traitor to the race or a black person. They're a traitor to the race. Because it's not about
the truth. It's about winning to these people. So free speech is important to you?
Yeah, I think we've worked that out.
I certainly have talked about this on a number of American Thought Leaders programs.
Frankly, as a comedian, your comedy across the world, certainly in the U.S. and the U.K. that
I'm aware of has been decimated by these types of rules. So explain to me a little bit, aside from
your bias, which is you want to be a comedian, you want to be able to say whatever the heck you want
to say that you think will be funny. Why is it so important? Well, what's happened with comedy is
that the people who are very successful, they can still do whatever they want. If you're Bill Burr,
or if you're Joe Rogan, or, you know, Chappelle, Ricky Gervais, there is no problem with free
speech. I'm not joking, I'm genuine. For them, there is no problem with free speech. They can
do whatever jokes they want. Netflix are going to get a few complaints about Dave Chappelle's
show, but they're going to keep it up on the platform, and he's going to be fine. And he's
going to make a lot more money than he would have done without all these people who are helping him
by attacking him. But below that, which is where the next generation of comics is coming, you've
got a very different situation, because particularly in the UK, where the comedy industries are very
small, everybody knows everybody, and the people who run that industry, they've been talking for
years about how, you know, in 2018, a woman called Nika Burns, who's the organizer of the
Edinburgh Festival, this is the biggest arts festival in the world, and in Britain, there is
no way to success in comedy if you don't go to the Edinburgh Festival, if you don't do well there.
She said that she's looking forward to a new era of woke comedy, and these are the people who
said the taste of the comedy industry, they decide who goes on the TV comedy, and it's completely
separate from the comedy circuit. This is people who play the comedy clubs and perform to ordinary
people, who have very different flavors and taste preferences to the people who decide what goes on
Look, I'm hesitant to say, because I think if people are enjoying something, there's
clearly an audience there for that. I don't have a problem with people doing comedy I don't find
funny. That's cool. I just don't want them to tell me what to say or not to say. That's my
issue. I think if people are engaging in creativity that I disagree with, that's great. Let them.
This is what makes the West great. People should be free to be comedians in whatever way they want,
and if I think it's awful and not funny, well, who cares? There's other people who enjoy that.
That's the free market, but my concern is that it's eating the industry out from the inside,
and so the next people are not coming through. You've got a situation with comedy clubs,
where audience members are now increasingly comfortable to go to the owner of the club
after a performance and say, I didn't like what that comedian said. Don't book him again.
Twenty years ago, if you'd said that in a comedy club, they would have told you to get lost.
No one would have respected that sort of request in comedy, because it was universally understood
that comedy will provoke, comedy will challenge. It's never going to be great.
Sometimes you'll go and see a comedy show and it'll just be terrible.
Here's what I mean when I say comedy has been decimated. You go into this in your book and so
forth. Basically, comedy very often is funny because it's speaking truth to power. It's the
court jester that's allowed to do the things that if anyone else did, it might be off with their
head. That provides that levity, that opportunity. In this sort of situation, I don't know what the
exact situation is at the Edinburgh Festival with the director there, but it seems like
that is what's not allowed. Of course. People with opinions like mine
in the comedy industry, which is I'm just someone in the center trying to
understand what's happening in our culture without being party political or partisan.
By merely asking the questions, you become persona non grata automatically. I'm not complaining.
I'm not saying I'm a victim. My life is great. I'm very happy with where I am, but I do observe
that there's a culture of self-censorship in comedy in a big way. Lionel Shriver, the writer,
when she was on Trigonometry on our show, she made the point that we don't even know what books
aren't being written at the moment. We don't know what jokes aren't being told because
people are self-censoring a hell of a lot because they know the punishment that comes.
You have to basically create your own thing now if you want to be true to yourself. You have to
be outside of the industry because it's very restrictive. It's allowing people who are already
successful to continue doing what they do, and that's brilliant. But the next generation of
people who are going to be genuinely challenging the status quo and asking the right questions
through comedy, that's not coming through right now at all. I want to jump to your last chapter
in the book. It's the 10 Ways to Destroy the West. This is one of the both funniest, but also
I think maybe useful. I found this to be a fascinating, deeply enjoyable experience.
I'm going to quickly read them. We'll put them up on the screen so people can see.
Number one, see everything in terms of race. Number two, embrace self-loathing. Number three,
make everything political. And yes, I mean everything. Four, get your political opinions
from celebrities. Five, remember truth is a lie. Gosh, it's like everything we've talked
about in this interview, right? Number six, promote socialism through bad capitalism.
Number seven, start a battle of the sexes. Number eight, drink the Kool-Aid of cultural relativism.
Number nine, encourage porous borders. And number ten, be a useful idiot.
Which of these is the biggest problem? I think the useful idiot is the biggest problem
because the things that you and I are both concerned about are happening.
I think there are a few people who maybe have malicious intent, but I don't think they're the
majority. I think an awful lot of people, like it was in the Soviet Union. I told this story last
time I was on your show about my grandmother who was born in a gulag. Her family ended up living
in a small town where the only people that lived there were people who were previously in a gulag
and the guards who were previously in the gulag as well. You had the guards and the people living
together in the same town. And when Stalin died and all the terrible atrocities of his reign
were exposed, a lot of these guards in these small towns where they were confronted with the victims
of that system, they shot themselves because they were horrified by what they'd done in the name of
an ideology because they believed it. They thought they were doing the right thing. They thought that
by torturing or executing or enslaving these people, they were doing the right thing. This is
the biggest problem. The problem isn't evil malicious people running around who want to make
things worse. The problem is people who buy into ideology that gives them permission to do terrible
things in the name of the greater good. Those people are the biggest danger to every society.
The people who are going to make things a lot worse because they think it's, you know, we just
got to break these eggs right here. We just break these eggs and everything. We'll break 50 million
of these eggs and then we are going to have a great omelette. Forget about the 50 million eggs
that we've just put in a camp. That's fine. It's for the greater good. They are the biggest danger
and it's the useful idiots. And I talk right at the end, as you know, in the book about how
Stalin got the nuclear bomb. It was Western scientists who were involved in the Manhattan
project that gave it to him. They gave it to him because communism was this beautiful ideology that
they believed. They gave the enemy of the West, a man who killed more Russians and Soviet citizens
than Hitler, they gave him a nuclear bomb probably decades ahead of schedule. Decades. The one, the
nuclear bomb, the first nuclear bomb the Soviet Union had was a carbon copy of the one that was
dropped on Hiroshima or Nagasaki, I think one of those two. Because they gave it to them in the
name of ideology. This is the power of bad ideas, Jan. It can make people do terrible things and
feel good about it. Here's the thought that I have. Very, very
interesting. I don't know if you've ever read, one of the most interesting books that I've read
in recent times is a book called The Psychology of Totalitarianism by Matthias Desmet. COVID has
been shocking. The whole reality around COVID, the policy and how people have thought about it
in response has been frankly shocking to me and has been the subject of many, again, American
thought leaders' episodes. One of the things that was shocking is how a whole suite of ostensibly
perfectly normal people became ready to aggressively vilify and shut out of society,
and God knows what else, if it were allowed to continue, the unvaccinated. As you were describing
the scenario of the Soviet Union, and in the book, I'm thinking about this now. What created
that situation with these guards that you described, realizing, oh my God, I've been on the
wrong side? Let me connect these things. In The Psychology of Totalitarianism, we talk about this
phenomenon of mass formation, where people start believing deeply that something that is ostensibly
crazy, like for example, supporting the socialist project, when you know you have to torture and
kill people to do it, people just are in it almost like a kind of hypnosis. The only way to break
them out is some kind of, and actually, Yuri Bezmenov, I believe, if I remember correctly,
calls it, you got to kick him in the nuts or something like this. So that's what Khrushchev
did, when he basically explained to the Soviet Union, because he had the full power of the Soviet
press behind him and under his control, the crimes of Stalin over whatever it was, four hours or
something like this. And that was the kick in the nuts, so to speak. Anyway, this is fascinating,
because it also tells me that there's a way to help people who have been indoctrinated,
for lack of a better term, come out of that. What are your thoughts?
There must be a way. I've never thought about this. This is a really good question.
You know what? What you've caught me out on is, I think on this issue, I've probably been focusing
on the problem less than I should, on the problem a lot, and I haven't focused enough on what the
answer might be. Because I don't know how you get people who've so willingly gone along with
demonizing people, how you get them to see what they became during this time. I sort of jokingly
said, during the course of this COVID madness, that at least it's the first pandemic where we
haven't blamed the Jews. Because that's kind of how it felt like. Do you know what I mean?
Yes.
We just need a scapegoat. And the Jews played that role very well for millennia,
and everybody was happy. Now we've got this, except us Jews, obviously. But we've got to a
point now where I don't know how you get these people to see what they became during it. I
genuinely don't know. I couldn't understand how we had the polling that we had in the UK,
where people were like, I think we should wear masks forever. It doesn't matter if there's COVID.
30% or 40% of society just wear masks forever. What's your problem? There's nothing wrong with
wearing a mask. What, you want to kill granny? I tried. Everybody's got their own take on the
vaccine. I'm not a doctor. I don't have an opinion. I'm just on the medical side of things.
I have a personal opinion that I use to make decisions for me and my family,
but not a public one, because it's not what I understand. But on the civil liberties and
rights side of it, I tried. I went to the protest in the UK. I contacted the government ministers.
I told them, what the hell are you doing? But there weren't that many people who heard what
I said. They were like, why are you freaking out? Why are you freaking out that the government wants
to force people to inject something into their body? They don't see it. But I don't know. My
take on it was, and this is probably crude and rudimentary and an unfair comparison or whatever.
I don't know. It's just how I feel. When I think about those people who came together in a place
called Nuremberg in 1945 and said, we must never, ever again force people to take medical procedures
that they don't want, I think that we're onto something here. Do you know what I mean? And I
don't think I'm a weirdo for thinking about that. People will say, oh yeah, but the Nuremberg Code
didn't cover vaccines. I don't know anything. I'm not an expert on it. I'm just saying it as a layman.
When I see that people, after one of the greatest horrors in human history,
made some decisions that, let's just be extra careful about this thing here, because it can
be misused by people, even well-meaning people in the future. I think we ought to just take a little
bit of a moment of thought before we just ride roughshod over those rail guards that they put
in place for society. It's not a trivial thing to force people to put things in their body that
they choose not to. It's not a trivial thing. If you're a religious person, it's a
I consider that a natural right of a human being, to control what goes in and out of their body,
and to make decisions for themselves. We do that every day. We do that on all sorts of things, and
we accept that the decisions I make may have a negative influence on you, and the way to decide
that is for us to come together and set laws in place that we can all agree on. It's not for a
people to just unilaterally say, well, we're in power now, so we're going to just, you know,
this is what we're doing. We're forcing all doctors to take a vaccine. Again, I'm not a
doctor, I'm a layman, but it seems strange to me that you've got doctors who don't want to take this,
being forced by people who are not doctors. How does that make sense to you?
That people who are not medical experts are forcing some medical experts
to take a medical procedure. Does that seem normal to you? Because it doesn't to me,
and I'm not saying that the vaccine is dangerous or whatever. I'm genuinely not saying that. I'm
just saying I don't understand how we are okay with that part of it, the social control part of
it. I don't get that. I don't understand why other people don't get it. I've tried.
Let me ask you another question. Have you ever thought that there might be a connection
with the cultural change that we've been seeing in the West and the sudden interest in these
policies, which I would definitely agree with you, depart considerably from what was decided
at Nuremberg after the war? I think there is a connection that I've
certainly noticed, which is, I don't know whether this is true of the United States.
It's not a country that I've spent that much time in to be able to say, but certainly in the UK,
we have an attitude that the government is the answer to everything. Whatever the problem is,
is because the government didn't do something, right? And so if you've got a problem,
well, the problem is the government didn't do something. It's not that there's a global pandemic
that may kill people. Whatever the government does, if there's a pandemic, people are going to
die. But we don't accept that anymore. We believe that if there's a problem, that means the
government messed up and we need more government to come in and deal with the problem. So if we
continue to believe that, then whatever the problem is, the answer will be more government.
And it strikes me that that is kind of the direction that we're heading in. And again,
it's probably due partly to technology. We are much more confident in our ability to solve
problems because we can solve more and more problems. And so any problem that comes up,
we're like, well, this has to be solvable. Whereas where I resonate with elements of
conservative ways of looking at things, it's that we accept that we're not going to be able
to solve every problem. Like we talked about at the beginning of the interview, if we can't
solve the problem of people murdering each other, then there's probably other problems
that we can't solve entirely. And when there's a global pandemic on, well, it's obviously terrible
and tragic that it will take people's lives. And genuinely, I mean that. At the same time,
I think if we're naive enough to think that if only we'd done all the right things, nobody would
have died, we may find ourselves doing things that go too far. And I think that's kind of where we've
ended up. Well, and as with the pandemic, you can end up enacting policies in the name of good
that actually end up being far worse than what might have happened. So that's just a fascinating
discussion. And frankly, I could talk to you for hours. Any final thoughts as we finish up?
No, Jan, I appreciate you having me on. And this is one of the most enjoyable conversations that
I've had about these issues because I think you asked questions that no one's asked me before.
Thank you for thinking about these things together with me.
Well, Konstantin Kissin, it's such a pleasure to have you on the show again.
Thanks for having me.
Thank you all for joining Konstantin Kissin and me on this episode of American Thought Leaders.
His book again is An Immigrant's Love Letter to the West. I'm your host, Jan Jekielek.