1A Audit of the South Carolina Human Affairs Commission
We were informed that this place needed to be checked, so here we are. After a lengthy process and five capital policies, they finally accepted the education
If you like the content on @upstatescnews16 channel and would like to help support the channel and keep me on the road, you may make donations at https://paypal.me/upstatescnews454
FAIR USE NOTICE This video may contain copyrighted material; the use of which has not been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available for the purposes of criticism, comment, review and news reporting which constitute the fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. Not withstanding the provisions of sections 106 and 106A, the fair use of a copyrighted work for purposes such as criticism, comment, review and news reporting is not an infringement of copyright.
First Amendment auditors visit the South Carolina Human Affairs Commission to file FOIA requests, highlighting tensions over government transparency. The encounters focus on the staff's reluctance to provide identification and the conflict between government safety protocols and the constitutional rights of citizens to record and access public information.
First Amendment auditors, don't let them catch you slipping or you'll be on YouTube forever.
And here's where we be. South Carolina Human Affairs Commission.
No public restrooms again. This guy gonna get mad right now.
No, I think he's being helped right over here.
Hey, where are y'all up to? What's that? Where are y'all up to? Are y'all with the press?
Are y'all doing a story on the commission? What's the story about? Can't give out the details.
Huh? Can't give out details. That's an investigator story. No worries. We do great work here.
Sure, it's probably what you're reporting on is how awesome we are.
What's my name? That's not me. Me. I don't need my name for a records request.
No, I need to make a record request. Yes ma'am. Ma'am. Here we go again.
I need to start recording.
Good.
You're so smart. I said go back and sit down. I ain't gonna do a damn thing for you.
Oh, now I'm gonna do a damn thing for you? You okay there? I just did.
You're an old smart ass. That's what I thought. Back to my position.
I don't think it worked out. Now he's leaving. Yeah. Okay, how y'all doing? Do y'all need help?
Yes, I've told this gentleman my purpose for being here and there was a lady came to the
window and I told her as well. Can you tell me what the purpose is? I don't believe in repeating
myself but I'm gonna do it again. I'm here to do a public records request or you may call it a
FOIA request whichever one you prefer. Okay. So that's my reason for being here. For what is that?
FOIA request. For you for what? You have a FOIA form? Yeah. If you provide me with the form,
I'll fill out the form. Okay, that's it. So these people are not smart enough. I mean like how many
times have I gotta tell you? I understand the first time when he asked for a FOIA request
it took him three times so let's see if somebody else appears. He's leaving again.
These premises are under surveillance. That's right. Right now.
Nice black dress. Don't forget that Z.
It's smart ass with a double Z.
There you go. That's what you do. You learning.
He left a crack when he got to sit back down. Watch him.
How long did it take to get a form?
There's this lady here. She's been on the phone since we come in.
Ring the bell again. Say, you know, how long does it take to get a FOIA form?
When she changed her mind, I want her to open the door because you hit that bell.
Yeah, maybe the doorbell opens that door.
Hey, could you please ask them back there how come it's taking so long to get a FOIA request form?
They're right there. Huh? Yeah. Yeah, but they're not. We've been here for a while.
There's Mr. FOIA. Let's see how many people I thought today would be doing his thing.
Sir, are you filming me?
Are you filming me, sir?
Yeah, can we get a stamp copy, please?
Nice star. It's good. It looks like it might.
It's like the woman over at the health department. Yeah.
Oh, I see you. I see you. Your head's still shining.
If you think they put them awards and stuff out here, we'll be seeing.
All we need is a copy and we're gone. Dang. Why are they prolonging?
That's a beautiful building on the inside, man. It looks so small though. I guess because I
guess when you know what though when they built it, it was it was probably big for this area
and everything else just. It ain't small. I'll tell you that. Yeah, but when you look at the
surrounding buildings, it looks small. I was telling you there's like 200 rooms.
It's beautiful. It really is.
They'll give you a tour. The lady that gives the tours. Well, at least when I went over there,
she's handicapped. She's in a wheelchair. Very, very nice lady.
Sir, that's public disorderly conduct. They're building the copy machine.
Are they're delaying waiting on the blue line to get here? One of the other.
Oh, that's fine. Yeah, because it's most likely it'll be Alan again because it's
he didn't write it down.
Please get a copy. He was the one who just had it in his hands. I got places to go.
That's the fumigate, the lobby, this guy right here. Can you cover it up?
We have 30 days to respond.
All right. Anything else you need? You're about to say something about that.
This is public information. Where's 30 days come from? I didn't argue that. Don't create a public
record. I'm sorry? Don't create a public record. What's that mean? That means you just, if you take
a photo or video, that's a public record. You are just now created a public record. So now we need
to do it for you on that. It doesn't matter. Maybe you should look up 30-2-1.
Don't delete that. If you delete that, if you delete it, it's a crime.
Is there anything else that you need? Is there anything? He's inspecting it.
So do you want to go ahead and give up that public record you just created?
Well, you can make it real easy and just let me inspect it right now.
All right. Well, he needs another FOIA then. Absolutely. Now, can I have your name for the
record? Okay. So I'll just name this as the asshole that took my phone. Sir, we have to
have your name to FOIA it. Well, you don't have to have my name. You just indicate on there.
Who do we know to FOIA to? I don't know who you are. You're not supposed to know who I am.
Well, then that's okay. So we're good to go. But you'll be able to ask for the person who did the
video and I'm sure they'll be able to give you all the information that you need. No.
What's your position here? I'm an employee. What is your position here? I'm an employee.
That should suffice for now. Well, yes, I am an employee. It's not. You're a public employee.
You're supposed to give up that information. Mine said under state law and the identification
law for public officials. Maybe you should look up the law. Thank you for educating me. I will.
Okay. So name and position, please, sir. Who's your boss? The commissioner.
Can we speak to them, please? I will control the commissioner's schedule.
Do you mind if I ask what this is all about? We're here doing public records requests. That's it.
Okay. And you got the public records request. Yeah, but you created a public record. So now
we need your name and position. Well, you'll get that when you make the request. But I don't
understand. Who handles the request? They'll go through our legal office. How do they know
who we're talking about? You just put down the person that came to talk to you.
Put the time down. And you can even put the guy dressed in green.
I'm the only guy dressed in green. But I'm just trying to understand.
You know, I've been working here. We have the right to come in. That's it, bro. That's it.
So in the interest of providing and we're documenting the process,
when you as a public official try to record us and we tell you that once you do that because
you're in your professional manner in my official position, that once you do that,
that makes that a public record, whether it's your personal phone or not. But when we ask for
you to ID your position and stuff like that, good customer service would be like, I'm such and such.
My position is such and such. Let me ask you another question. So if I'm on a break and then
if you're recording, but if I'm on a break and I'm not doing this in an official capacity,
I'm out here just asking because I've got people who are recording.
Am I in my official capacity? Yes. You're helping a member of the public.
I'm not helping anything. I'm not. I'm just. I rang the bell and you came out. You brought
back. You brought me the form that would be considered. I was on my way out to take a break
and now I'm engaging in conversation. You didn't go out the door. Well,
because we had a conversation, it would be rude for me to leave if we're having a conversation.
What's rude is you're not giving up your name and position.
To the people you work for. Well, I work for the state. Who pays you? Who pays your salary?
Who pays the state? You pay taxes, right? So you get our money. I'd love to get a raise.
You get our money. Get turned around into your paycheck. Did you just say you'd love to get a
raise? I would love to get a raise. It's an opportunity to the way you act. Well, I mean,
come on, put yourself in a position of a neutral observer. I've been working in state government
for a long time and I've never seen three people come in with cameras. Get used to it. And that's
fine. There's this old adage that people always used to say there's a first time for everything.
And I get that. I'm just passive to the work you do.
So we need another copy.
Don't forget the date stamp. I'll be off my break in a minute.
So I'm just and again, I'm not trying to be antagonistic. I'm just asking.
No, because I mean, when you actually first came out and spoke to us, we even all said that you're
the first one now was actually professional. Everybody else. But you didn't you didn't
when he told you what we're here for, we're waiting for. We're not accusing you of anything.
We're just telling you it's in your policy to identify.
Whose policy? Your personal policy? Sorry. Your personal policy or
Yeah. And that presumes that you know what our policy is. I did. I read the employee hand and
in the employee book, it says a funny request. I have that request from a citizen. You are supposed
to identify. You're right. Okay, well, is there anything else that I can do aside from giving you
my personal identification? Anything else that I could do? I mean, you have all your position.
I mean, so how do we know that you're you're an employee here and you're not just maintenance?
That's true. That's true. It could be a passenger or it could be someone's family member that they're
allowed to go to the back and they felt uncomfortable and since you have a lot of speculation.
I have to admit that I don't know if you've done this in other places or not. This is my
first experience and I feel a little bit uncomfortable. You should. Why? Because you're
doing what you're not supposed to be doing. What am I? I'm doing what I'm not supposed to be doing.
Sir, could you identify this man, please? His name and position. We helped you all. No, I need his name
and position now. Is there any other way we can help you? You could give me his. Okay, and yours.
And now yours. This gentleman just took a video or photograph of us during the course of his
business. Therefore, creating a public record under 30-4-30, so he's getting his business card.
Okay, he could have done that to begin with. We would have already been gone.
And your name and position? Thank you, sir. And you know, they took the internal commissioner to
come out here before that fellow would go get a business card or whatnot. The whole time he's
basically saying he wasn't going to identify. Well, now he can put it on the FOIA request
because he wouldn't give up his name.
I mean, it should only take 10 minutes.
See, and this is all part of our story. They don't get how the story goes, do they?
This is the story. Are they coming in?
Man, let me get in the corner then. I'll say they put me in a corner. Yeah, where I'm parked.
She probably pulled my car out to them so they can get my name.
See, they're probably waiting on them. Is the copier like on the fourth floor or something?
Run down there and see if they're around the corner. Run down there and see if they're around
the corner. I don't identify. This is the house all the state employees at. Damn, Randy.
I'm here again. For real?
Good, because it stinks in here now. How you guys doing? Good, man. Good.
Four deep now, huh? How you doing, brother? You too. You've been doing all right?
We're just waiting on a copy of the records request we made, but you know.
All right, let's go one more time. Name?
Okay. Yeah, I'm the same guy. I couldn't hear it. Oh, that's fine. I'm Alan.
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
Are you Italian? Yes.
We saw you guys moving around. We've been here now
37 minutes and 20 seconds waiting on a FOIA request, which it should take maybe 10 minutes
at the most. I don't understand why they got to make it so difficult, man. It's very easy
just because there's cameras.
Let's save gas.
Yeah, we've seen y'all come across.
Of course, it doesn't look like I needed to. I figured I'd just hang out still since I
didn't get a report. Yeah, but it's the same here. I mean, I think y'all must know. Y'all
must recognize yourself. Hey, y'all are good. You can request this up here.
So when you do the FOIA, you comply with the FOIA. You can that request.
And I'll tell you what, your other officer, Alan, and that other guy. That's all we wanted.
That's how simple it is. Okay, good. Anything else? No, sir. Thank you, sir.
Well, I doubt that, but thank you anyway.
See, this is the story. We come in, we do a FOIA request, and we document this process.
We should have been in and out of here in the most of 10 minutes.
You know how long we've been here now? 40 minutes.
The best way to remember it is we get our own calls.
And yes,
yeah, well, so we in the SBI,
I'm sorry. No, I was born in the military, though.
You're ex-military.
Thank you for your service, sir.
10 years.
See, that's what it's all about. I didn't get to finish. This is all about educating.
It's to prove that when we come in here, like I said,
this process should take maybe 10 minutes, but every building we go into, it takes forever.
And see, that is our story.
Or come across to the public and say, yeah, well, we're not here, you must have been.
Identify him, or ask him how long it takes.
It took him asking three times for a FOIA request before they even attempted to get him a paper.
I promise you it would not take that long.
All right.
If we came in here without cameras, it probably would have been a totally different thing.
See, that's another point. You should treat the public
exactly the same if they got a camera or they don't.
How is this threatening?
We don't have to.
That's the whole thing. It's an exercise of our rights, your rights and our rights.
I don't need to be on that side.
I get the same thing.
But the difference is, I am a private citizen. You're not.
I don't have to give up my Fourth Amendment right.
My concern was for my safety, as well as the safety of my staff.
If it takes being a little bit evasive, then I'll let that one out today.
There are so many rights right now that are violating both the Constitution.
From FOIA, a lot of officers coming up, they can demand RIDU and stuff like that.
I mean, a lot of what we're doing, basically,
if you don't practice those rights or enforce those rights, you're losing them.
It's like a muscle. If you don't exercise in muscles, they're going to go away.
Same with our rights that you fought for.
We certainly don't want to infringe on anybody's rights.
As a private citizen or as anything else, we want to make sure that we adhere to everything.
But again, a lot of supervisors stay involved.
I have to also consider the safety of my staff.
And it's a delicate type of battle.
And the way your security officer is afraid to be on camera,
I hope he's watching these cameras and not just hiding behind that door
where he can't see the interaction, what's going on in this lobby.
See, he did the right thing.
You see what he did over there, right?
He created privacy.
Well, but his job was a little different than ours.
We have to actually allow him to be in there.
And so, you know, again, I think it might just be more of a misunderstanding,
because, A, my section is the one in Centralia that's part of it.
And when we get threats, especially because we have a lot of them,
I'm not trying to be sexist or anything,
but we get a lot of females working here,
and we don't get serious threats of sexual assault.
So, brother, imagine.
Well, see, doing what we do,
you wouldn't believe the threats that we get.
Is that supposed to intimidate me?
This is going on from sea to shining sea,
from coast to coast, because our rights are getting eroded.
This is the only way we can fight back.
No, man.
What I will edit out is the dead time,
us waiting and waiting that,
but all the interaction will be there.
I mean, all the way up to you.
Right now, I'm at 47 minutes.
People won't watch that.
What I do is cut out the dead time,
just sitting there waiting, but everything else will be there.
It's an educational purpose for you.
I mean, some people, they kind of take it the wrong way
when we say that, but you did learn the idea
of me asking stuff like that as a state official
or a state representative of this department,
and a lot of people, they just feel like,
no, they don't have that kind of body,
and it's kind of like what we're saying,
well, how do we know how to report a request?
Anybody could be wearing a green shirt.
I mean, I can say, it sounds bad
but the older black guy,
I've noticed y'all have a couple black guys that work here.
Don't be talking about no bald head.
We're not bald.
We're falling for the challenge.
Hey, I'm up.
I haven't been sitting here a lot.
I might get there one day.
Anyway, I didn't catch your name.
What was it again?
My name is Alex.
Alex, I appreciate you turning around, man.
I really do.
I apologize for anything that I might have said there.
I want to make sure we reflect on this agency
in a positive way.
Well, you ended it well.
And I appreciate that.
If we just ended it before they came in and everything
and you brought the card out and then just back in there,
that would have looked bad.
Yeah, I mean, just truthfully, that would have looked bad.
They call me Mr. Foyer.
That's my nickname.
And you can ask them, that's my nickname.
When I tell you 30-4-30, like I said earlier,
that's about a sub-session.
I can tell you all 31 sub-sessions
by the back of my hand.
So if I tell you something that pertains to the FOIA law,
100% out of 100%, I win this guy.
Next time I got a question, I'll try to track you down.
Curricular audits.
With a Z.
And like you were saying, this camera here, like I said,
I'll bust up the dead time.
This camera here, I will show the whole thing.
This will go on one channel.
This will go on another channel.
So if you want to see the whole thing,
you want to see that one.
But how?
Okay.
I'm so curious, man, why people think
when we come in with a camera and do a FOIA,
how is that, you know?
What was it on?
Well, it's a safety concern.
From what?
It's a perceived safety concern.
Because again, if we get 100 people that walk through this door,
99 of them will sign.
Because they don't know their rights.
Well, and maybe they just don't want to accept it.
Everybody, they don't feel like they're new to not getting it.
That makes sense.
See, that's the thing.
Everybody has just been trained to just give up their rights.
Or they don't know them.
And we're out doing this to teach people their rights.
We educate the public, the government, them, the police.
We track the number of people that come into this office on a monthly basis.
So what would be an alternative to giving a name?
You can put down four officer safety.
Well, no, he's saying instead of the public coming in,
they'll sign in.
What would be the best alternative for that?
Because there's some people that don't want to give up their rights.
Like most agencies, when they, like a sign-in sheet,
instead of someone writing their name on the sign-in sheet
that says a privacy concern or citizen safety,
I don't want other people to know my name or that I've been here.
You ask them for their name at the window, they tell you their name.
Then when you get them in the back, that's when you get the actual ID
or you can keep a log in the back so it's not out in the public.
I got you.
I got a suggestion.
Like the highway department.
You go, you get a ticket, and then that logs it.
Of how many people came in.
Instead of them having to give up their fourth amendment right.
Or you can put like a computer out here,
and they type their information in the computer,
and then it just goes to the back.
That way, when they come out, then you can call them by a number.
Yeah, but I'm saying they shouldn't even have to give up their name.
Yeah, yeah, you're not required to.
Right.
That's what I'm saying.
But he was saying they like to log how many people come in.
And I was saying, that's a way to do it.
Grab a ticket or whatever.
The hardest part about here though is saying he goes in and out that door five times.
Yeah, that would be a false.
All right, guys, we got other places to go.
So we might see you again, Sarge.
Well, yeah, man, I mean.
Education, not cheer.
And like we said, we appreciate your turnaround.
And again, thank you for your service.
A lot of people, they take it the wrong way until
towards the end of the interaction when it's this right here.
Minimal, there is no threat, bro.
There is no threat.
Before I went to this, my hair was here.
No, the hair is the reason she married me.
Okay, hopefully.
You did good, man.
You did good.
All right.
Thank you, sir.
All right.
Thank you, sir.
Have a blessed day.
Yeah, he.
Jesus is the only way, man, the only way.