Full: https://www.ganjingworld.com/s/Gwe2gmmE0k Ebook: http://e.pc.cd/O32y6alK ----- Preface Introduction Chapter One: The Specter’s Strategies for Destroying Humanity Chapter Two: Communism’s European Beginnings Chapter Three: Tyranny in the East Chapter Four: Exporting Revolution Chapter Five, Part I: Infiltrating the West Chapter Five, Part II: Infiltrating the West Chapter Six: The Revolt Against God Chapter Seven, Part I: The Destruction of the Family Chapter Seven, Part II: The Destruction of the Family Chapter Eight, Part I: How Communism Sows Chaos in Politics Chapter Eight, Part II: How Communism Sows Chaos in Politics Chapter Nine, Part I: The Communist Economic Trap Chapter Nine, Part II: The Communist Economic Trap Chapter Ten: Corrupting the Legal System Chapter Eleven: Desecrating the Arts Chapter Twelve, Part I: Sabotaging Education Chapter Twelve, Part II: Sabotaging Education Chapter Thirteen: The Media — The Specter’s Mouthpiece Chapter Fourteen: Popular Culture – A Decadent Indulgence Chapter Fifteen: The Communist Roots of Terrorism Chapter Sixteen, Part I: The Communism Behind Environmentalism Chapter Sixteen, Part II: The Communism Behind Environmentalism Chapter Seventeen: Globalization and Communism Chapter Eighteen, Part I: The Chinese Communist Party’s Global Ambitions Chapter Eighteen, Part II: The Chinese Communist Party’s Global Ambitions Conclusion: How the Specter of Communism Is Ruling Our World ----- ntd.com
You're listening to The Audiobook of How the Specter of Communism is Ruling Our World.
Written by the editorial team of the Epoch Times groundbreaking series,
Nine Commentaries on the Communist Party.
Chapter 16 The Communism Behind Environmentalism
Introduction
The earth is the living environment of mankind, providing food, resources,
and conditions for development. It has allowed humanity to prosper for thousands of years.
Humanity interacts closely with the natural environment. Both traditional Chinese and
Western culture emphasize the benign symbiotic relationship between man and nature. As the
Chinese philosopher Dong Zhengshu writes in Luxuriant Due of the Spring and Autumn Annals,
everything on earth was created for the benefit of man. The meaning is that the purpose of the
creator was to offer conditions for humanity to live and all things on earth may be used by man.
At the same time, people must follow the principles of heaven and earth in their lives
and thus use everything in moderation and proactively maintain and safeguard the natural
environment in which human beings are to live. Western traditional culture states that the
creator provides the natural environment for human beings and asks them to manage it. Thus,
man should cherish and make good use of the natural environment.
In the philosophy of traditional Chinese culture, there is a balance between everything as well as
the imperative to avoid harm. The Confucian doctrine of the mean states, quote, it is this
same system of laws by which all created things are produced and developed themselves, each in
its order and system, without injuring one another, that the operations of nature take their course
without conflict or confusion. The Chinese ancients valued protection of the environment.
According to historical records, at the time of Yu the Great, quote, in the three months of the
spring, people didn't take axes to the forest so the forest could flourish. In the three months
of the summer, people didn't put nets to rivers so fishes could breed. Zeng Si, a Confucian scholar,
wrote, quote, wood could only be cut down in the right seasons and animals only slaughtered at the
right time. These show the traditional Chinese idea of moderation in all things and of cherishing
and protecting the natural environment. After the Industrial Revolution, industrial pollution
caused severe ecological damage and Western societies began to become aware of the issue.
After environmental protection laws and standards were implemented, pollution was effectively
treated and the environment greatly improved. In the process, public awareness of environmental
protection grew enormously and it was widely acknowledged that environmental protection
is a proper goal. We must distinguish between several ideas, environmental protection,
environmental movements, and environmentalism. Environmental protection, as the name indicates,
is the protection of the environment. Since the beginning of human civilization, people have
understood the need to protect the environment and this had nothing to do with any particular
political ideology. The environmental movement is a social and political movement for environmental
issues. Its primary goal is to change environmental policies and public thinking and habits through
mass movements, media influence, and political agitation. Environmentalism is a philosophy and
ideology emphasizing the need for protecting the environment and the harmonious coexistence
between human society and the natural ecology. The motivations behind environmental protection
and environmentalism are not the same as communism, but communists excel at hijacking mass movements
and manipulating them to their advantage. Thus, we see that from the beginning of modern
environmentalism, communists have systematically gone about co-opting the movement. The issues
surrounding environmentalism today are extremely complex. The movement has used sensational rhetoric
and people's genuine desire to protect the environment to create a global political movement.
Many participants are well-meaning, have a sense of justice, and truly care about the future of
mankind. However, what many don't recognize is how communists use environmentalism to claim a moral
high ground to promote their own agenda. This is how environmental protection becomes highly
politicized, made extreme, and even turned into a pseudo-religion, but one without traditional
moral foundations. Misleading propaganda and various mandatory political measures
have become dominant, turning environmentalism into a kind of communism-lite.
This chapter will focus on how environmentalism as an ideology has become related to communism,
and how the environmentalist movement was hijacked, manipulated, and co-opted into
serving the goals of communism, as well as the impact this will bring if unchecked.
1. The Communist Roots of Environmentalism
Communism has made intricate preparations in many fields for the destruction of humanity.
Originating in Europe, communism launched violent revolutions
and seized power in the two great powers of the East, Russia and China. The communist camp
and Western society entered into a long confrontation in the Cold War. After the
Soviet Union and the Eastern European communist bloc, communists began sowing their factors in
both Eastern and Western societies and also sought to establish a tightly controlled global government.
In order to achieve this goal, communism must create or use an enemy that threatens all mankind
and intimidates the public around the world into handing over both individual liberty
and state sovereignty. Creating a global panic about looming environmental and ecological
disasters almost appears an inevitable route to achieving this goal.
2. The Three Stages of Environmentalism
The formation and development of the environmental movement is inextricably
linked to communism. Specifically, its development has gone through three stages.
The first stage is the theoretical gestation period, which can be counted from the publication
of the Communist Manifesto by Marx and Engels in 1848 to the first Earth Day in 1970.
At the beginning of this stage, Marx and his disciples did not regard environmentalism as
the focus of their theoretical discourse, but Marxist atheism and materialism were
naturally consistent with the main tendency of environmentalism.
Marx declared that capitalism is opposed to nature, that is, the environment.
Marx's disciples devised the term ecosystem and quietly included environmentalism in certain
subjects where it was set to ferment. In the last decade of this phase, from 1960 to 1970,
two best-selling books, Silent Spring, 1962, and Population Bomb, 1968, appeared in the United
States. Environmentalism entered the public arena under the guise of, quote, environmental protection.
The landmark event at the beginning of the second phase was the first Earth Day held in 1970,
with the United Nations shortly after, in 1972, holding the first UN conference on the human
environment in Stockholm. At this stage, a battery of organizations were rapidly formed and their
activities increased. In the United States and Europe, they pushed governments with propaganda,
protests, and activism under the guise of scientific research, legislation, meetings,
and so on. At the macro level, the counterculture of the 1960s functions almost like a military
parade of communist elements in the West. They took the stage by co-opting the civil rights and
anti-war movements and then quickly spread to other forms of anti-capitalist battles,
including the feminist movement, the homosexual movement, and more. In the 1970s, after the
anti-Vietnam War movement wound down, communist ideas began their process of institutionalization
called, quote, the Long March Through the Institutions, while also flooding into feminism
and environmentalism. And this is the root cause of the upsurge in environmentalist ideology
and agitation. One of the most important forces that shouldered the banner of environmentalism
in the 1970s were the hippies, the backbone of the counterculture. In fact, communism was in
the process of repackaging itself under the banner of environmentalism after its failure
in the Cold War with the intent to introduce global communism under any other name. The third
phase began on the eve of the end of the Cold War. In 1998, the United Nations set up the
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, IPCC, and the concept of global warming began to enter
the political realm. On the eve of the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1990, an international
environmental conference was held in Moscow. In his speech, the General Secretary of the Communist
Party of the Soviet Union, Mikhail Gorbachev, advocated the establishment of an international
environmental monitoring system, signed a covenant to protect, quote, unique environmental zones,
expressed support for UN environmental programs, and called for a follow-up conference held in
June 1992 in Brazil. Almost all Western environmentalists accepted these proposals.
Global warming became the main enemy of mankind for environmentalists at this stage.
Propaganda that used environmental protection as an excuse for heavy-handed policies
suddenly escalated, and the number and scale of environmental laws and regulations proliferated
rapidly. Environmentalism has become the main tool for restricting the freedom of citizens around the
world, depriving nations of sovereignty, and limiting and fighting against the free societies
of the West. The result was that after the end of the Cold War, the former communists of the Soviet
Union, as well as the communists and their fellow travelers in the West, all started afresh to join
the environmental protection movement. Environmentalism emerged as a force on the world
stage and increasingly began to take on a communist color. B. Environmentalism and Marxism, the same
roots. In the understanding of believers in orthodox religions of both the East and West,
human beings were created by God in his own image, and human life is thus endowed with a higher value,
purpose, and dignity than other forms of life on Earth. Likewise, the natural environment is
created by God. Man has the obligation to care for nature, though simultaneously nature exists
for man, not vice versa. In the eyes of atheists and materialists, however, human life has no such
special quality. Engels writes in one of his essays, quote, life is the mode of existence
of albuminous bodies. In this view, human life is no more than a unique configuration of proteins,
not different in any essential manner from animals or plants. Thus, it is only logical
that humans may be deprived of freedom and even their lives in the name of protecting nature.
In 1862, in a book on organic chemistry, German chemist Justus von Liebig, Marx's colleague,
criticized British farmers for using imported bird droppings as a fertilizer. British agriculture
had benefited from bird manure, an efficient fertilizer, and crop yields had significantly
increased. By the middle of the 19th century, the British had ample high-quality food sources.
The bird droppings business had benefited businessmen in various countries, the British
farmers, and the public. Why did Justus von Liebig want to condemn this practice?
His moral indignation was due to four reasons. First, the process of collecting bird droppings
damages nature. Second, merchants exploit workers with low wages. Third, high yields of food
stimulate population growth, which in turn requires more food, exceeding what nature can supply. And
fourth, more people and livestock mean more manure and garbage. At the time, while writing Das
Kapital, Marx carefully studied Justus von Liebig's work. He praised it for having, quote, developed
from the point of view of natural science, the negative, i.e. destructive, side of modern
agriculture. Like Justus von Liebig, Marx regarded any effort in creating wealth by using natural
resources as a vicious cycle, with the conclusion that, quote, irrational agriculture is incompatible
with the capitalist system. After Lenin and his Bolshevik party launched a coup in Russia,
they quickly promulgated the, quote, decree on land and the decree on forests to nationalize
land, forest, water, mineral, animal, and plant resources and prevent the public from using them
without authorization. American meteorologist and writer Brian Sussman writes in his book
Ecotyranny, How the Left's Green Agenda Will Dismantle America, that Marx and Lenin's ideas
are highly consistent with those of today's environmentalists. In their view, no one has
the right to profit from natural resources. Quote, whether it's saving the forests, whales,
snails, or the climate, it all comes back to a deep-rooted belief that the quest for such profit
is immoral and will ultimately destroy the planet unless ground to a halt. This global environmental
movement has involved a large number of thinkers, politicians, scientists, social activists,
and media personalities. This text does not have sufficient space to enumerate their thoughts,
speeches, and actions in full, but one figure cannot be ignored. This is the founder of the
United Nations Environment Program, Morris Strong. Strong, a Canadian, also organized the 1972 UN
Conference on the Human Environment, as well as the 1992 UN Conference on Environment and
Development. Strong is the nephew of Anna Louise Strong, a well-known pro-communist journalist
who settled in China. Morris Strong, who was deeply influenced by his aunt, described himself
as, quote, a socialist in ideology and a capitalist in methodology. Morris Strong has come to occupy
an important place in the global environmental movement. Quote, he shares the views of the most
radical environmentalist street protester, but instead of shouting himself hoarse at a police
barricade at a global conference, he's the secretary general inside wielding the gavel.
The views espoused by the United Nations Environment Agency, led by Strong, appear almost
identical to Marxism. Quote, private land ownership is a principal instrument of accumulating wealth
and therefore contributes to social injustice. Public control of land use is therefore
indispensable. Morris Strong chose to settle down in Beijing after retirement and died in 2015.
Natalie Grant Raga, a late expert on the Soviet Union, conducted an in-depth study on the issue
and wrote, quote, protection of the environment may be used as a pretext to adopt a series of
measures designed to undermine the industrial base of developed nations. It may also serve to
introduce a malaise by lowering their standard of living and implanting communist values.
In fact, environmentalism does not originate only from the former communist bloc. It goes deeper
and relates to the overall goal of communism to undermine the cause of freedom around the world.
C. Ecological Marxism. At the juncture of the 19th and 20th centuries, British scientists
Ray Lancaster and Arthur Tansley developed the idea of the ecology and the ecosystem.
Both were Fabian socialists, a variation of Marxism. Lancaster was a zoologist and at a
relatively young age became a friend to an aging Marx. When Marx was in his senior years,
Lancaster frequented Marx's house and was among the few who attended Marx's funeral.
Lancaster once wrote to Marx saying that he was studying Das Kapital with, quote,
the greatest pleasure and profit. Tansley was the most important figure in ecology and botany during
that period in England and as the first chairman of the British Ecological Society, he was the
inventor of the term ecosystem. While attending the University of London, Tansley was deeply
influenced by Lancaster. The originating links between ecological ideas and Marxism appear to
emerge in this connection between Lancaster, Tansley, and Marxism. Though, of course, ecology
and environmentalism are not the same thing. Ecology is about the relationship between living
things and the environment, while environmentalism is concerned with ecological disasters.
Ecology, however, is closely related to environmentalism because it provides the
theoretical basis for defining ecological disasters. Ecological Marxism, which was
derived from ecology, is a further step away from these ideas. Ecological Marxism adds the concept
of ecological crises as an augmentation to Marxian arguments about the economic crisis
of capitalism. It seeks to expand the supposed conflict between the bourgeoisie and the
proletariat by adding an inherent conflict between production and the environment. This is the theory
of double crisis or double conflict. In Marxist theory, the basic conflict of capitalism is between
productive forces and the relations of production, which is called the primary conflict. The secondary
conflict happens between the environment of production, the ecosystem, and the productive
forces and relations of production together. In this theory, the primary conflict leads to
economic crisis, while the secondary conflict leads to ecological crisis. The century-long
development of capitalism proved Marxism wrong after the failed prediction that capitalism would
collapse due to economic crisis. On the contrary, capitalism continues to prosper. In response,
the notion of ecological crises became a tool of communism, as leftist scholars discovered that
Marxism could be a theoretical basis for environmentalism, thus radicalizing the
environmentalist movement and worldview.
d. Ecological Socialism
As its name suggests, ecological socialism is an ideology combining ecology and socialism.
Critics have called it a watermelon, green on the outside and red on the inside, for adding
typical socialist demands, such as social justice, to ecological concerns in an apparent attempt to
advance socialist ideology by new means. A good illustration of ecological socialism is
An Eco-Socialist Manifesto, published by Joel Koval and Michael Lowy in 2001.
Koval was unsuccessful in his campaign to become the U.S. presidential candidate
from the Green Party. Lowy is a member of the Trotskyist Fourth International.
The manifesto states that capitalism cannot resolve the ecological crisis and will be
replaced by ecological socialism. They do not view ecological socialism as a branch of socialism,
but rather as the new name of socialism in the new era.
In 2002, Koval published a book titled The Enemy of Nature, The End of Capitalism or
The End of the World. The book detailed the theory of ecological socialism,
harshly criticized capitalism, and suggested a change to the current situation with radical
new directions. e. Green Politics
Green is the New Red
When environmentalism enters politics, green politics, or eco-politics, is born.
The Green Party, established in many countries around the world, is a result of green politics,
which typically extends beyond environmental protection to social justice, feminism,
anti-war activism, and pacifism. Global Greens, for instance, is an international
organization associated with the Green Party, and its 2001 charter is heavily inflected with
Marxist ideology, including a heavy emphasis on a supposed equality between man and animals.
Environmentalism is usually propelled by socialism and communism.
After the fall of communist regimes in Russia and Eastern Europe, many former communist party
members and remaining communist forces joined or established Green Parties, resulting in the
the term Green Left. After the fall of the Soviet Communist Party, former Soviet Union
leader Gorbachev tried and failed to re-enter politics. He then became an environmentalist
and established the Green Cross International. Obviously, Gorbachev would be likely to introduce
communist factors into his environmental pursuits, and he often promoted the establishment of a world
government in order to stop environmental crisis. Many communist parties in the West are directly
involved in environmental protection movements. Jack Mundy, one of the founders of Australia's
Green Ban Movement, is a member of the Australian Communist Party. His wife is the national chairwoman
of the Australian Communist Party. F. Eco-terrorism. Due to its leftist influences,
environmentalism has been relatively radical from the start. There are many radical branches,
including deep ecology, eco-feminism, social ecology, bioregionalism, and the like.
Some of these branches are extremely radical. The most well-known include groups like Earth First
and Earth Liberation Front. They utilize direct action, like use of explosives and arson, known
as eco-terrorism, to stop activities they consider damaging to the environment. The Earth First
group was started in 1979, and its slogan is, quote, no compromise in defense of Mother Earth.
The group utilizes direct actions against main targets like logging, dam construction,
and other projects. One of the group's well-known tactics is called tree sit, where they sit under
or climb up trees to prevent logging. These operations of Earth First have attracted many
new members, including leftists, anarchists, and others seeking to rebel against mainstream society.
In 1992, some of the more radical members started a branch called Earth Liberation Front
and adopted arson as their tactic. Around the end of 2000, nine luxury mansions on Long Island
were burned to ashes overnight. The main justification was that these mansions were
built on a natural forest. After committing the arson, the Earth Liberation Front put out the
slogan, quote, if you build it, we'll burn it. In 2005, the FBI announced that the Earth Liberation
Front was the largest terrorist threat in the United States, was suspected of involvement in
over 1,200 criminal incidents causing tens of millions of dollars in property damage. Their
actions have long since exceeded the limits of normal political protest or differences in views.
Communist ideology has exploited hatred to turn some environmentalists into eco-terrorists,
no different from any other terrorists. G. Greenpeace, not a peaceful story.
Greenpeace was established in 1971 and is the largest environmental organization in the world,
with offices in 40 countries and income of over $350 million. Greenpeace is also one of the most
radical environmental organizations. Greenpeace co-founder Paul Watson, who left the organization
in 1977, said, quote, the secret to David McTaggart's, the former chairman's, success
is the secret to Greenpeace's success. It doesn't matter what is true, it only matters what people
believe is true. You are what the media define you to be. Greenpeace became a myth and a myth
generating machine. Patrick Moore, another co-founder of Greenpeace, was committed to
environmental protection. He later quit his position because he found that the organization,
quote, took a sharp turn to the political left. It developed into an extremist organization with
a political agenda, such as including hostility toward all industrial production and reflecting
an agenda based more on politics than sound science. The strategy employed by radical
environmental organizations such as Greenpeace is to use any means necessary to achieve their goals.
On this one point, radical environmentalism is highly consistent with communism. In 2007,
six Greenpeace members broke into a British coal power plant to cause disruption. They were sued
for causing around 30,000 British pounds of property damage. They admitted their attempt
to shut down the power plant but claimed that they were doing this to prevent even larger damage,
an environmental crisis due to greenhouse gases. The court eventually agreed that their actions
were innocent. Before this, Greenpeace already had many such records of court wins, including
damaging nuclear power plants, automotive companies, and fighter jet manufacturing facilities.
The boundary between legitimate and illegitimate tactics is simply erased with such logic.
Traditional Marxism-Leninism uses the promise of an eventual utopia to legitimize killing,
arson, and robbery. Similarly, under the banner of environmentalism,
communists warn of environmental crises in order to legitimize violent and illegal tactics.
In the above example, Greenpeace members successfully persuaded the jury to accept
their criminal motives as legitimate, demonstrating that a large group of people
and society can be misled into accepting misleading and groundless arguments. All of
this is part of the abandonment of universal values and is a sign of the moral downslide of society.
2. The Myth of Consensus on Climate Change
Climate change is a hot topic in today's society. Public debate about this issue is unusually active,
with different opinions from the media, among the general public, and in politics. The most
frequently heard argument is that the emission of greenhouse gases by humans has caused global
warming that will lead to dangerous climate disasters. Advocates claim that this conclusion
is reached through scientific consensus or is already settled science. To some environmentalists,
people who reject this conclusion are not only considered anti-science, but also anti-humanity.
The aforementioned Greenpeace members who damaged the power plant were acquitted of their crime
because a famous expert, who was a proponent of this quote consensus, testified for them,
claiming that the amount of greenhouse gases emitted by the power plant each day would lead
to the extinction of up to 400 species, and so on. Has the scientific community really reached a
consensus? Retired Massachusetts Institute of Technology meteorology professor Richard Linzen
wrote an article expressing his view that climate science isn't, in fact, settled. Stephen Koonin,
a former U.S. Department of Energy Undersecretary for Science and current New York University
professor, wrote in his article, climate change is not settled, quote, we are very far from the
knowledge needed to make good climate policy. In another essay, Koonin reminded readers, quote,
the public is largely unaware of the intense debates within climate science. At a recent
national laboratory meeting, I observed more than 100 active government and university researchers
challenge one another as they strove to separate human impacts from the climate's natural variability.
At issue were not nuances, but fundamental aspects of our understanding of climate, such as the
apparent and unexpected slowing of global sea level rise over the past two decades. In general,
the surface temperature of the earth has risen on the whole since 1880, and carbon dioxide and
other greenhouse gases emitted into the atmosphere by humans have a warming effect on the world.
Regarding these basic questions, scientists do not differ in their opinions. However,
the more important questions, which are questions that are hotly debated by scientists,
are these. Is warming primarily caused by human activity or due to natural factors? How warm
will the world be by the end of the 21st century? Does humanity have the ability to predict how
climate will change in the future? Will warming cause a disaster? From another perspective,
however, the scientific community does appear to have achieved some sort of consensus,
or to have settled the science of climate change to a certain extent,
for the voices of those who oppose the so-called consensus seldom appear in the media or academic
journals. Physicist Michael Griffin, a former NASA administrator, said in an interview with
National Public Radio NPR in 2007, quote, I have no doubt that a trend of global warming exists.
I am not sure that it is fair to say that it is a problem we must wrestle with. To assume that
it is a problem is to assume that the state of earth's climate today is the optimal climate,
the best climate that we could have or ever have had, and that we need to take steps to make sure
it doesn't change. First of all, I don't think it's within the power of human beings to assure
that the climate does not change, as millions of years of history have shown, and second of all,
I guess I would ask which human beings, where and when, are to be accorded the privilege of deciding
that this particular climate that we have right here today, right now, is the best climate for
all other human beings. I think that's a rather arrogant position for people to take. Although
Griffin was trying to express the humility that people should have regarding science,
he immediately encountered severe criticism by the media and some climate scientists,
who even called his remarks ignorant. The next day, under immense pressure, he was forced to
apologize. A few months later, in another interview, Griffin commented, quote, I personally think
people have gone overboard in the discussion of climate change to the point where it has become
almost not legitimate to view it as a technical subject. It has almost acquired religious status,
which I find deplorable. From Griffin's view regarding, quote, scientific consensus,
we see that the so-called consensus regarding climate change wasn't in fact part of the
scientific process. He felt scientific progress is the result of debate. Quote, you develop your
theories, publish your data, advance your concept, and others shoot it down or try to. Scientific
consensus evolves in that way. To use all manner and means to stifle scientific debate itself
violates the spirit of science. Due to his stellar reputation and standing in his field,
Professor Leonard Bengston, a fellow of the British Royal Meteorological Society and former
director of the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts, joined the Global Warming
Foundation, a think tank that challenges global warming theories. As a result, he faced intense
scrutiny and pressure from his peers around the world. Two weeks later, he was forced to resign.
In his letter of resignation, Bengston wrote, quote, I have been put under such an enormous
group pressure in recent days from all over the world that has become virtually unbearable to me.
If this is going to continue, I will be unable to conduct my normal work and will even start
to worry about my health and safety. Colleagues are withdrawing their support, other colleagues
are withdrawing from joint authorship, etc. I would never have expected anything similar
to the time of Senator McCarthy in such an original peaceful community as meteorology.
Apparently, it has been transformed in recent years.
Bengston's observation was correct. This, quote, transformation in recent years was the result of
communist ideology and struggle tactics hijacking the field of meteorology. In reality,
the alleged scientific consensus regarding climate change has transformed climate change
theory into dogma. Climate change is also a crucial tenet of today's environmentalism,
sacred and never to be challenged. The scientists, media, and environmental activists,
who accept this tenet, work together in spreading fear of imminent disaster. This doctrine is an
important tool used by the environmentalist movement to frighten the public into obeying
a political agenda. Through the process of establishing and solidifying this dogma,
the techniques of communist style political struggle, including deception, mobbing,
public shaming, call-outs, and open conflict are all apparent.
A. A Brief History of Consensus in Climate Science
In 1988, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, IPCC, was established. One of its important
missions was to evaluate the existing scientific research about every five years and release an
authoritative statement on climate change. It was supposed to establish a scientific consensus
on climate issues and provide the scientific basis for policymaking. The IPCC's report
often encloses a list of thousands of first authors, co-authors, and reviewers. Hence,
the conclusions in the IPCC reports are often described as the consensus of thousands of the
world's top scientists. In 1992, the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change,
UNFCCC, stated that its goal was to achieve stabilization of greenhouse gas concentrations
in the atmosphere at a level that would prevent dangerous pollution created by humans interfering
with the climate system. One must note that it was already assumed that climate change
was caused by humans and was dangerous. Later on, the IPCC was tasked with identifying human
influences on climate and dangerous environmental and socioeconomic impacts of climate change.
When the UNFCCC assumes that people are the culprits of dangerous climate change,
it has restricted the direction of what the IPCC should identify. Also, if climate change wasn't
dangerous or wasn't caused solely by industry, then policymaking wouldn't be needed and there
would be no reason for the IPCC to exist. Such conflicts of interest also restricted the focus
of the IPCC's inquiry. IPCC Reports Removed Statements of Uncertainty
Right before the IPCC released its second assessment report in 1995, Dr. Frederick Seitz,
a world-renowned physicist, former president of the National Academy of Sciences and president
of New York's Rockefeller University, obtained a copy of the report. Seitz later discovered
that the content in the report was largely altered after it passed scientific review
and before it was sent for print. All of the uncertainties of human activities about climate
change were deleted. Seitz's article in the Wall Street Journal stated,
In my more than 60 years as a member of the American scientific community,
I have never witnessed a more disturbing corruption of the peer-review process
than the events that led to this IPCC report. The deleted statements included the following.
None of the studies cited above has shown clear evidence that we can attribute the observed
climate changes to the specific cause of increases in greenhouse gases. No study to
date has positively attributed all or part of the climate change observed to date to anthropogenic
man-made causes. Any claims of positive detection of significant climate change are likely to remain
controversial until uncertainties in the total natural variability of the climate system are
reduced. Though later the IPCC claimed that all the modifications were approved by the authors,
the alterations reveal how the IPCC's reporting was influenced by politics. The evaluation report
doesn't contain original research, but mostly summarizes existing research. Because the
existing research contains so many different views, in order to, quote, reach consensus,
as it set out to do, the IPCC simply got rid of the opposing views.
In April 2000, the IPCC's third assessment report said in its draft, quote,
there has been a discernible human influence on global climate. The version published in
October the same year says, quote, it is likely that increasing concentrations of anthropogenic
greenhouse gases have contributed significantly to observed warming over the past 50 years.
In the final official conclusion, the statement was even stronger, quote, most of the observed
warming over the last 50 years is likely to have been due to the increase in greenhouse gas
concentrations. When the UN Environment Program's spokesman, Tim Higum, was asked about the
scientific basis of the rhetorical changes, his answer was honest, quote, there was no new science,
but the scientists wanted to present a clear and strong message to policymakers. Put another way,
the UNFCCC gave a homework assignment to the IPCC, making the answer they wanted clear.
The IPCC then delivered as required. IPCC report overstated disaster consensus.
Paul Reiter, a professor at the Pasteur Institute in France, is a leading expert on malaria and other
insect-borne diseases. He disagreed with the IPCC report and had to threaten to initiate a lawsuit
against the IPCC in order to remove his name from the list of the top 2,000 scientists who are said
to have endorsed the report. He said that the IPCC, quote, makes it seem that all the top scientists
are agreed, but it's not true. In his testimony to the United States Senate on April 25, 2006,
Reiter said, quote, a galling aspect of the debate is that this spurious science is endorsed in the
public forum by influential panels of, quote, experts. I refer particularly to the Intergovernmental
Panel on Climate Change, IPCC. Every five years, this UN-based organization publishes a, quote,
consensus of the world's top scientists on all aspects of climate change. Quite apart from the
dubious process by which these scientists are selected, such consensus is the stuff of politics,
not of science. Environmentalists have been promoting the notion that insect-borne diseases,
such as malaria, will wreak havoc when climate warming continues, which is also the main
argument of the IPCC. As Bloomberg stated on November 27, 2007, quote, global warming will
put millions more people at risk of malaria and dengue fever, according to a United Nations report
that calls for an urgent review of the health dangers posed by climate change. But Reiter does
not acknowledge this simple correlation between climate warming and the spread of infectious
diseases. He pointed out that malaria is not confined to tropical areas. A massive outbreak
of malaria occurred in the former Soviet Union of the 1920s and another one in the city of Archangel,
Arkhangelsk, near the Arctic Circle, where there were 30,000 malaria cases causing 10,000 deaths.
According to a 2011 report in Nature, scientists found that, contrary to the previous assumption,
malaria transmission from mosquitoes slows with rising temperatures. This confirms Reiter's
opinion. Another scientist's withdrawal from the IPCC also shows that it has used alleged,
quote, disaster consensus as part of its operational culture. Christopher Landsee,
a hurricane researcher at the U.S. Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration and one of the leading
authors of the IPCC's fourth assessment report, withdrew from the IPCC in January 2005.
In an open letter, he stated, quote, I personally cannot, in good faith, continue to contribute to
a process that I view as both being motivated by preconceived agendas and being scientifically
unsound. He urged the IPCC to confirm that the report would adhere to science rather than
sensationalism. Landsee disagrees with the lead author of the IPCC report regarding the relationship
between hurricanes and climate change. The IPCC lead author, who is not an expert in hurricane
research, stressed that climate warming would cause more intense hurricanes without solid,
factual data to support his claim. Landsee pointed out that past studies have shown
that historical records could not verify such a correlation.
Theoretically, even if there is a correlation, it is insignificant and negligible.
David Deming, a geologist and geophysicist at the University of Oklahoma, obtained the 150-year
historical temperature data for North America by studying ice cores and published his research
article in Science. Consensus advocates then regarded Deming as a supporter of consensus.
In a U.S. Senate hearing, Deming said that an IPCC lead author sent him an email saying, quote,
we have to get rid of the medieval warm period. The medieval warm period refers to the climate
warming of the North Atlantic region between around 950 A.D. and 1150. Erasing this period
in the historical curve of climate change would strengthen the claim
that today's warming is unprecedented. There are many such incidents. In his book,
Red Hot Lives, How Global Warming Alarmists Use Threats, Fraud, and Deception to Keep You
Misinformed, Christopher C. Horner, a senior American researcher at the Competitive Enterprise
Institute, listed many of the original IPCC authors who opposed the IPCC's conclusions
and its politicized operations. They have raised reasonable questions with supporting data and
have challenged the IPCC's so-called consensus. However, in the current academic and media
environment, their voices have been marginalized. B. Establishing Dogma in the Scientific Community
The establishment and consolidation of the alleged consensus on climate change
is a main step in the use of environmentalism to manipulate the public, amplify the sense of
disaster, and distort human values. If carried to its conclusion, the natural trajectory
is the establishment of a global super-government, that is, communism. While this has mainly played
out in the scientific community, it has been helped along with the joint strength of the media,
government, and academic institutions. No matter the academic reputation of a scientist,
once he publicly expresses doubts about the consensus dogma, he immediately faces tremendous
pressure from his peers and academic institutions, forcing him to submit. People who have lived in a
communist totalitarian society have had similar experiences, the only difference being that they
have questioned communist party dogma. David Bellamy is a well-known British environmental
activist and the chairman of the Royal Society of Wildlife Trusts. But when he publicly stated
that he did not believe in the consensus dogma of global warming theory, the agency issued a
statement expressing dissatisfaction. He then ceased to serve as the chairman, and environmentalists
who previously respected him began to suspect he'd lost his senses or was taking money from big
oil. Henk Tennekens, former director of the Royal Dutch Meteorological Society, was dismissed
because he did not support the consensus dogma on climate change. Similarly, World Meteorological
Organization official Axel Wynne-Nielsen was slandered by IPCC officials as, quote,
an industry tool. After Italian researcher Alfonso Suterra questioned the theory of anthropogenic
climate warming, he was no longer able to obtain research funding. In his book Climate of Extremes,
Global Warming Science They Don't Want You to Know, Patrick J. Michaels, past president of the
American Association of State Climatologists and a climatologist at the University of Virginia,
listed numerous examples of environmentalists suppressing scientific dissidence in order to
reach their alleged consensus. Because he insisted that the climate would not lead to disaster,
this optimistic stance was inconsistent with the consensus dogma, and one day he was told by the
governor that he could not speak on global warming as a state climatologist. He ultimately chose to
Another state climatologist, George Taylor of Oregon State University,
encountered the same trouble, and Taylor was eventually forced to resign. Dr. David Leggetts,
former director of the Center for Climate Studies at the University of Delaware,
is a state climatologist in Delaware. He was also told by the governor that he could not
speak as a state climatologist on the issue of global warming. Washington state climatologist
assistant Mark Albright was fired because he emailed an inquiring journalist and citizens
of the state about the entire snowfall record for the Cascade Mountains, instead of selecting
partial records which appear to show warming, despite having been warned by his boss.
The focus of debate here is on the climatologist's area of expertise,
climate science issues rather than state policy issues. In communist countries,
crude political interference in science is common. In western countries, environmentalist politics
are being used to interfere with academic freedom. Academic research that casts doubt
about the consensus dogma is rarely seen in academic journals, a phenomenon that began in the
1990 documentary, The Greenhouse Conspiracy, that if a person's point of view is politically
unacceptable, then there will be trouble. His paper was rejected by more than one academic
journal. When he asked a journal editor why, the answer was that his paper must pass a higher
evaluation standard than others. According to the 1990 IPCC report, the understanding at the time
was that the extent of global warming was equivalent to natural changes in climate.
Therefore, although Michael's point of view was different from that of many others,
it could not be regarded as particularly heretical. However, the goal of establishing
a false consensus had already been set, and everyone had to get on board.
The tilt of government funding has greatly contributed to the formation and consolidation
of the alleged consensus. The hypothesis that humans caused global warming and brought
disasters has pushed climate change research to the position of advising on policymaking.
Therefore, research supporting this hypothesis will naturally receive a large amount of research
funding and a large number of academic articles will be published. Conversely, enforced consensus
hinders scientists from exploring and researching in other possible directions.
Dr. William Gray, a renowned professor, was a pioneer of American hurricane research. Because
he criticized the consensus dogma in climate theory, he suddenly found that his applications
for research funding were repeatedly rejected. The reason was that his proposed research was
not the focus. In March 2008, many scientists who doubted the consensus dogma on climate issues
held a private academic event in New York. These scientists said that they encountered
various obstacles when trying to publish their research results in academic journals.
Meteorologist Joseph DiLeo, former chairman of the American Meteorological Society's Committee
on Weather Analysis and Forecasting, said that some of his colleagues did not dare to attend
the meeting because of fear of being fired. He believed that there was, quote,
very likely a silent majority of scientists in climatology, meteorology, and related sciences
who did not support the consensus position. Professor Judith Curry, former dean of the
School of Earth and Atmospheric Sciences at the Georgia Institute of Technology,
stated in a Senate testimony in 2015 that a scientist employed by NASA said to her, quote,
I was at a small meeting of NASA-affiliated scientists and was told by our top manager
that he was told by his NASA boss that we should not try to publish papers contrary to the current
global warming claims because he, the NASA boss, would then have a headache countering
the undesirable publicity. Curry further said in her testimony, a climate scientist making
a statement about uncertainty or degree of doubt in the climate debate is categorized as a denier
or a merchant of doubt whose motives are assumed to be ideological or motivated by funding from
the fossil fuel industry. My own experience in publicly discussing concerns about how uncertainty
is characterized by the IPCC has resulted in my being labeled as a, quote, climate heretic
that has turned against my colleagues. There is enormous pressure for climate scientists
to conform to the so-called consensus. This pressure comes not only from politicians,
but from federal funding agencies, universities, and professional societies,
and scientists themselves who are green activists and advocates. Reinforcing this
consensus are strong monetary, reputational, and authority interests. Dr. Curry is a member
of the American Meteorological Society and a member of the National Research Council's
Climate Research Committee. Despite her academic success, she chose to retire early because she
was unwilling to continue to live under such pressure. Because she has challenged the IPCC's
consensus in recent years, she has been stigmatized as, quote, anti-science, a denier,
and so on by the media, other scientists, and a senator. A member of Congress even sent a letter
to the Dean of the Georgia Institute of Technology to question Curry's motives. She said that another
reason for early retirement was that she felt that she could not tell students and postdoctoral
researchers how to, quote, navigate the craziness in the field of climate science. Roger Pilkey,
Jr., a professor at the University of Colorado, has worked with Curry on climate change issues.
He was originally at the university's Cooperative Institute for Research in Environmental Sciences.
Although he agreed with most of the IPCC consensus conclusions, he was subjected to
similar pressures because he pointed out that data does not support the idea that extreme
weather events, such as hurricanes, tornadoes, and droughts, are influenced by climate change.
He eventually moved to the University of Colorado's Sports Governance Center.
Dr. Pilkey pointed out that Curry's experience shows that, quote,
having a tenured position isn't a guarantee of academic freedom. It is no wonder that Joanne
Simpson, an academician of the American Academy of Engineering and an outstanding former NASA
atmospheric scientist, declared her skepticism of the consensus after retirement. Since I am no
longer affiliated with any organization nor receive any funding, I can speak quite frankly,
she said. As a scientist, I remain skeptical.