Planning a move to the Tampa Bay area in 2026? Contact Juan Alcala and the Tru Living Group at Real Broker, LLC to analyze real-time MLS sales data and secure hidden builder incentives.
In this video, Juan Alcala breaks down the critical difference between "The Menu Price" (asking price) and "The Receipt" (closed sale price). Discover why the biggest discounts in today's market never appear on a price tag, how 76% of new-construction buyers are securing over $20,000 in closing credits and 5.99% fixed mortgage rates, and how to track the 4 leading indicators that reveal where the Tampa market is heading next.
00:00 - Should You Wait? 01:51 - The Menu Price and the Receipt 04:02 - The discount you can't see 06:41 - The Rate 10:07 - Where the puck is going 12:39 - The menu changed. The receipt barely did. 13:28 - Reach out to us
If you're considering buying, selling, or investing in the Tampa Bay area, we'd love to be your real estate team of choice!
Juan Alcalá | Tampa Bay REALTOR® | Tru Living Group at Real Broker, LLC 283 families served • $129M sold • 108 five-star reviews on Google, Zillow & realtor.com.
Hey, I keep hearing that home prices are down in Tampa.
I hear some version of that on our Zoom
calls all the time. Somebody saw a headline,
somebody's brother-in-law sent them an article,
and they want to know if they should wait to buy a home
or even move to Tampa Bay right now.
So what I usually do is pull the numbers
with them live. And most of the time what
homes actually sold for isn't down. In some places it's actually up.
So the question is who's right?
The headline or the sale?
Now here's the thing, as I dug into the numbers, they're both right.
They're just measuring two
different things. And once you can tell them apart,
you'll never read housing headlines the
same way again. So if you're planning to move
to Tampa Bay sometime in the next three weeks,
three months, or even three years,
and the news has you wondering whether you should wait for
the prices to drop, this one is for you.
And by the end, you'll know how to read this market
for yourself. Where the puck is going
and where the real deals are hiding right now.
And a quick spoiler alert, they're not on the price tag.
And if we've never met before, my name is Juan Alcala.
And almost eight years ago now,
my wife Kate and I packed up our family of five,
sold almost everything we owned,
moved 1200 miles south here to the Tampa Bay area,
and we have been loving it ever since.
I also run a local real estate team called The True Living Group,
where we've helped over 200
families make that exact same move. And I'll be upfront.
I'm not going to tell you that home
prices are about to go up, and I'm not going
to tell you that they're about to crash either.
Because the reality is no one truly knows
and anybody who tells you for sure is selling you
something. But what I can do is teach you how
to read the information. And just so you know what
you can expect from the rest of this video,
first what you're seeing in the headlines right now,
then what's actually happening with sales,
then we're going to talk about the discount that never
shows up in the sales price,
and last the four signs that tell you where this market is most
Most likely headed.
So let's start with the headline everybody's seen. In September,
Realtor.com reported that the typical asking price
for a home in Tampa Bay area was around
$385,000. That's down 6.6% from a year ago.
And more than one of every four homes for sale had
to cut their asking price. And that number is real.
Our team is seeing it. Homeowners
are seeing it. And you, if you're looking to buy a home,
are looking at the same thing.
But if you think about what the asking price actually is,
it's a menu price.
It's what a homeowner hopes to get
when they sell their home.
It's not always what the buyer's paid for
because what somebody paid is the receipt.
And the receipt comes from what actually closed,
not what someone asked for.
So here's the receipt.
In September, the typical single family home
in the Tampa Bay area sold for $400,000.
That's up one half a percent from the same time period last year.
So that means that home prices are basically stagnant.
In Pinellas County, where I live, it was up more than 9%.
In Hillsborough, it was down just a little over 1%.
And Hillsborough County is where Tampa is.
So the question is, how can the menu go down and the receipt stay flat?
Ah, and that's the tricky part.
It's the homes that are still sitting on the market waiting to
sell. Because right now when a home is priced like it's still 2022,
nobody wants to buy it. It sits
and the homeowner is forced to cut their price.
That cut lands in the asking price headline.
Meanwhile, the homes priced right are selling
for about what they sold for last year.
And if you caught my video from last week
about people leaving Florida, you saw a short
version of this.
And if you haven't, I'll make sure to link it at the end.
That way you can watch it right after this one.
Because here's the part I want you to keep.
Next time you see a housing headline, ask one question.
Is that the menu or the receipt?
Because that question takes most of the scare out of the news.
Because the market isn't crashing,
it's just stopped rewarding wishful thinking.
Now here's where things get really interesting.
Even the receipt doesn't tell you the whole story
because some of the biggest discounts
in this market never show up in the sales price at all.
So I wanted to see this for myself.
I pulled every new construction home that sold around
Tampa Bay in the last 60 days,
between $500,000 and a million and a half dollars. It was 537 homes
that sold across Hillsborough, Pinellas, Pasco,
Manatee, and Sarasota counties. Then I pulled
about 400 previously owned
or what we call resale homes in the same price range to compare them.
And here's what I found.
The two groups play the same game, completely different.
When a resale homeowner needs to sell, they drop the price.
The typical resale home in that range came down $34,000
from where it was first listed,
and it sold for about 97.5% of what the seller was asking for.
Builders almost never do that.
The typical new construction home,
on average, sold for 100% of its list price.
Full price.
On paper, it looks like nobody got a deal.
And if you're just looking at those two numbers side
by side, you would think that the builders aren't negotiating,
but here's what's actually happened.
Three out of every four
of those new construction buyers got money back at the closing table.
The average amount was about $20,500
and almost half of them got $20,000 or more. And trust me,
when I say or more, it was a lot more.
Builders love to use these fancy marketing terms like
Like flex cash.
And all it means is the builder is gonna pay
for some of your closing costs
or puts money towards buying down
your mortgage interest rate.
It's a credit and you see it on your closing paperwork,
but you never see it reflected in the sales price.
So a new home that's sold for full price
may have come with $20,000 back to the buyer.
And that's why the headline numbers miss it.
Now, a couple of things I want to cover really quickly
because we sell a lot of new construction
homes. As a matter of fact, we're going
to build about 35 homes with our clients this year,
and I don't want you to walk away with the wrong idea.
Number one, there is a limit on how much a
builder can give you, and it depends on your loan type
and how much you put down. On a regular loan,
conventional, if you will, the more you put down,
the more they are allowed to cover in closing costs
Two, when you add it all up,
The price drops on resale home
and the cash back on new homes come out in the same neighborhood.
Builders aren't necessarily giving away more,
they're giving it in a different way.
And their goal is to keep the price up
so they don't deflate the property
values in the community that they're building
in and make their clients upset,
and then they hand you the cash at closing.
But here's the part that the multiple
listing services don't capture at all.
And for you, it's worth more than the cash.
It's the mortgage interest rate.
And as of last week, the average 30-year fixed mortgage in the
United States at the time of this video was about 7.3%.
And what our team is seeing from builders
around Tampa Bay is a rate about one to one
and a half percent lower than that prime rate.
And that's on a 30-year fixed loan. It's not some teaser that jumps up
after a year or two or an adjustable rate mortgage.
It's fixed for the life of the loan.
Through the builder's lender specifically.
So the sake of this conversation, we'll call it 5.99%
and run the math. Say you buy a $670,000 home.
That's the middle of those 537 new construction
sales. You put 20% down.
At 7.32%, your mortgage payment is going to be around $3,680 a month.
At 5.99%, it's about $3,210 a month.
That's around $470 a month in savings, around $5,650 a year.
And let's just say you have to
hold on to that 5.99% interest rate for five years.
That's more than $28,000 back into your
pocket. And that's more than the cash
that most buyers are getting at the closing table.
Now here's why that number matters so much in Tampa Bay specifically.
One of the biggest reasons that people choose
to skip new construction is the fees that come along
with it. The HOA and something called the CDD,
which is a community development district fee.
And to sum it up, it's basically how a lot of new communities here
pay for their roads, water lines, amenities, etc.
And as a homeowner, you pay it back on a line
on your property tax bill every single year.
And then the communities that we serve,
we see CDD fees as low as $500 a month.
And those are usually the ones that are about to expire
because they do at some point, not fully.
We'll get into that in a separate video,
but they are also as much as $3,400 a year,
depending on the community that you buy in.
When you add the HOA fee on top of that,
because it's a separate fee,
So that $5,650 a year in a lot of communities,
that lower rate covers most, if not all of your CDD and your HOA.
So the thing that scared you off in new construction,
the builder's rate can actually pay for it.
Now what's the cost that comes with it because there always is one.
That mortgage rate usually
comes from the builder's own lender.
This is a company they own or have partnered with
and usually it's out of the same pot
of money as your closing cost help.
So you might have to choose either the lower rate
or the closing cost or a lower price.
Now, if you hire a great real estate agent
who really understands a new construction,
like Stacy on my team, for an example,
she was able to negotiate over $146,000 in total
incentives for our client, including a brand new pool.
So make sure you ask for every option in
writing or hire a great professional
who really understands what's going on in the backend and
And has your best interest at heart.
Now, this is mostly a new construction story.
Out of those 537 homes, only 24 were in Pinellas
County. So the real question isn't, are prices dropping?
It's what's attached to the price.
And that brings us to the part that I care most about,
because you're not buying today.
You're buying in the next three weeks, three months, or three years.
So the question really is, how do you know where this is going?
Now, growing up in Detroit, I was a huge hockey fan.
As a matter of fact, I was a wing nut,
but I also grew up watching Wayne Gretzky, who is the GOAT.
And Wayne says it best. He said he wasn't great
because he skated to where the puck was.
He skated to where the puck was going.
And that's the job here. The headlines are telling you where
the puck was. But now I'm going to share the four signs
that tell you where it's going so you can
check all four for yourself.
Sign number one, how many homeowners are cutting their price? Right now
it's more than one in four homeowners.
Price cuts usually show up before the sales price moves. So
If that number keeps climbing,
you're going to have more room to negotiate.
If it starts falling, that room is shrinking.
Signed to the months of inventory.
I used to hate hearing this.
I didn't know what it meant.
And what that means is how long it would take
to sell every home that's currently listed
for sale if nothing new got listed.
And right now, it would take about four months
to sell every home in Tampa if nothing new
was listed.
For condos, it's more than six months.
Now, a lot of people in our business that will tell you
that six months is where a buyer's market
really starts, but that's not necessarily true.
Again, you have to look through the numbers,
but condos are definitely already there. Sign number three to look for,
how long homes take to go under contract.
Right now it's about 41 days.
When that number stretches out, homeowners start to get nervous
and nervous homeowners negotiate.
Sign four, what's attached to the price? And this is the
thing that nobody's tracking right now, but you should.
The cashback, the mortgage interest rate,
the pool. When builders get more generous,
it shows up here first, long before it shows up in
the sales price. So here's how you read all four together.
Price cuts are going up.
Inventory is going up.
Homes are taking longer to sell.
Builders throwing in more incentives.
The puck is moving your way.
If all four of those indicators start to turn the other direction,
your window to negotiate is closing
and waiting starts to cost you more money.
And right now, three of those four lean in your favor.
Single-family homes aren't in a buyer's market yet,
technically. Condos are.
But where do you think the number goes from here?
I have a take, but it's my take, not the data.
And if you want it, feel free to reach out.
I'm more than willing to share.
But the goal of this video is to help you
be able to read it for yourself
so the next headline doesn't make the decision for you.
So let's zoom all the way out. Are asking prices down? Yes.
Are homes actually selling for less? Mostly no.
And the best deals right now aren't even printed on the price tag.
They're attached to it.
Cash at closing and a rate
that can save you hundreds of dollars a month,
especially on new construction.
And oh, by the way, they're usually paying all
of our compensation to help guide you
through the process so you have professional representation anyways.
So here's one thing you can do after watching this video.
Pick a home you like online.
Look at its price history.
Write down the first asking price and today's price.
If it's new construction, call the builder and ask one question.
What are you offering right now on the rate and closing cost?
And can I get that in writing?
That's it. You'll learn more
from that one call than you will from a month of headlines.
And if you want a hand putting it all together,
matching the right part of Tampa Bay to how you
actually want to live and running the real numbers on a rate,
taxes, insurance, HOA, and CDDs.
And that's what our personalized relocation blueprint is for.
If you look in the description down below, you'll see a link.
That'll take you to our website.
It'll ask you just a few basic questions.
And behind that, you'll get a link to my calendar
where you can schedule a Zoom call.
We'll in real time build you that relocation blueprint.
Our clients have found this to be extremely helpful
and take all the stress out of their relocation move.
And I'm also gonna put up that video from last week
because I promised it to you.
If you find this content helpful,
please make sure you hit that like button.
Don't hesitate to subscribe.
And as always, until next time,
go out and live that Tampa life.