중국 내 美 기업들, 이윤 사상 최저치...‘리스크 최소화’에 주력 [크로스로드]

추봉기의 이슈타파
178 followers
101 Video Views·Sep 25, 2024
여러분의 후원은 큰 힘이 됩니다.
후원하기 : https://secure.donus.org/epoch/pay/step1
KEB하나은행 : 415-910018-06104 (주)에포크미디어코리아
-
© 에포크타임스 All Rights Reserved.
Welcome to Crossroads. A new report shows that businesses in China are seeing their profits
plunge to record lows. Now, according to a new report, only 66 percent of U.S. businesses
were profitable in China last year. And this is not just limited to the United States.
Even European companies are watching their businesses fall like this in China as well.
The latest development notably, you know, it's dashing the beliefs that the market is going to
improve. That's having a ripple effect, of course, through investment. But new CCP policies also
that favor domestic companies, their tumbling economy with real estate and the banking crisis,
and also an expanding global trade war. All of this is coming together and really taking the
toll on the country. The development could also accelerate the process of companies leaving China
because they're facing diminishing profits, which could likewise, again, have kind of a domino
effect through investment and then to the economy again overall. Now, for U.S. businesses in China,
they're especially being impacted. This is according to a new report released by the
American Chamber of Commerce in Shanghai on the business climate in China. They're saying a few
factors, including increasing geopolitical pressure, China's economic slowdown, all these things
are contributing to a, quote, less optimistic outlook for China. Here's some of the exact
numbers about what is happening to these businesses from the American Chamber of Commerce report.
It says this, only 66 percent of U.S. businesses were profitable in 2023, again in China.
This is a record low according to the report. It says that 47 percent of the respondents are
optimistic about the five-year business outlook in China, while 13 percent of respondents rank
China as their headquarters top investment destination. Both rates are the lowest in our
survey's history ever. And notes that over two-thirds of companies are following a de-risking strategy
with 36 percent investing in supply chain resilience and 25 percent segregating China and
non-China data and information. What does that mean? It means they're making sure that if the
Chinese economy collapses, it doesn't destroy their business. When they say de-risking,
it means they're removing the risk of being too closely tied to the Chinese economy so that as
things go further down, it will not put them out of business as well, right? And when they talk
about segregating the China data and the non-China data and other information, it means they're
basically building two separate empires, so to speak. Not to mention when they talk about, again,
you know, investing in supply chain resilience, that means also think, imagine, you know, if you're
working in real estate development and you need iron. If you're working, for example, in some kind
of computer technology, you need rare earth minerals. It means you need supply chain resilience.
If the CCP cuts off the supply to something, you have other places to go. They don't see the CCP
in China now as being stable. And it's a record high of 25 percent cut investment in China last
year, but only 20 percent expect to do it this year. And that's the top reasons for members
decreasing investment is concerns over China's, quote, slowing growth. And it's as well that
opportunities in other markets are the reason why 40 percent of members are redirecting
planned investment with Southeast Asia and India, the Indian subcontinent, being the most popular
choices. They can manufacture just as cheap, just as efficiently somewhere else. Why keep it in
China? That's what they're saying. And that's as well that only 22 percent of respondents expressed
confidence in the Chinese government's commitment to further opening up their industry in the near
future. Because aside from everything else, the CCP is focused on domestic production. They want
Chinese companies, not American companies, not European companies, not anywhere else. They want
Chinese companies. And with this trend, we also see some businesses, well, just moving out of China.
The Epoch Times said this, IBM has decided to follow the example of what has become a long
list of American brands and close some of its operations in China. And it said although
management has remained very businesslike in its statements, right, they're trying to be diplomatic,
it has clearly read the same writing on the wall as other American firms. If this is an
inconvenience and an expense for the firms moving away from sometimes decades-long arrangements,
it hardly helps China to lose the expertise and business acumen of these operations.
Now, what's even more interesting is, again, this is not just an American issue. It's not just the
CCP going after American businesses. This is a trend across the board. And we see this notably
happening with European businesses. There was a report that came out with very similar findings
for European companies in China. This was from the European Union Chamber of Commerce in China.
In their latest position paper, they said this. They said the central concern for European
chamber members is China's economic slowdown. However, several other factors are dragging
on business confidence, including perennial market access and regulatory barriers, meaning
the CCP is kind of cutting off their access to the markets and Chinese regulations are making
it hard for them to do business there. Again, the CCP is favoring domestic companies, not foreign
companies. And as well, the highly politicized business environment where the CCP is kind of
bringing back more state control over economic sectors, which includes not just businesses,
but also investment in banking and the whole nine yards. And also lackluster domestic consumption,
overcapacity, the persistence of ambiguous rules and regulations, and the government's continued
focus on national security and developing a high degree of self-reliance. They don't need nobody
else. They want Chinese companies. And notes further in that a sentiment is emerging at company
headquarters and among shareholders that the returns on China investment are no longer commensurate
with the risks faced. It's not worth it. And as a profit margins in China are equal to or below
the global average for approximately two thirds of European chamber members and pessimism about
future profitability is at an all time high. In other words, the costs of being there are very
high. The risks of being there are very high and the benefits of being there are kind of low. There's
not a lot going for it. And so that's raising the question, well, why are they there? Why are
they doing business there? Why are they putting their headquarters there? Maybe they want to
regard it as a market to sell products in, but do they need to be fully embedded there?
That is what the question is. Now, like the writing for this has been on the wall.
We pointed out previously, including on this show, the Chinese Communist Party,
they were expected to announce a solution to their economic woes, right? We watched the
Chinese banking crisis, the runs on the banks, people getting arrested for doing so. We watched,
of course, Evergrande and all these big Chinese real estate companies start to go under. We watched
the CCP saying, we have a plan, right? And what happened? Well, they had their recent third plenum
meeting and a top level Politburo meeting. And that was expected to come out with a big announcement
of the solution, right? For the Chinese economy, how they're going to save it. What happened?
Well, the Chinese Communist Party came out with lofty sounding statements on how they're going
to be like, you know, the future world power and so on, and all their plans of, you know,
what they want to look like. But they didn't propose any actual steps to achieve that.
There was no actual proposal on how to fix the problems. And, you know, it wasn't even just
the China hawks saying this, it was the mainstream news outlets. This was investment, you know,
investment groups calling it out. People were noting the CCP presented no actual steps for
solutions. And even then you still had some people who were maybe hopeful. You still had
some investors saying, well, you know, we think they have a plan and they're just not telling us
what that is. You know, you got to invest to find out what it is, right? And they found out, well,
they found out what it was. They found out the CCP actually does not have a plan and the plan
that it does have involves pushing them out for the most part. What the CCP also did alongside of
this was declared a focus again on domestic production. They have a goal stated publicly
to replace even outside technology on every single system. They don't want windows, right? They don't
want American operating systems. They don't want American software. They don't want anything from
any other country being used in their country that they have to rely on. And if they're relying
on it, they're looking at how to replace it. They're not looking at how to buy it. Now the
important thing with this is that means that foreign businesses are facing a diminishing
future in China. Now here's more on this from the European Union Chamber of Commerce's position
paper. They say the foreign business community had been looking to the third plenum of the
Central Committee of the Chinese Communist Party for signals that at least some of these concerns
would be addressed. And they say this, instead the third plenum decision, again this top-level CCP
group, continues to promote investment in manufacturing as a key driver of China's
economic development, albeit under the moniker new quality productive forces, right? That's a CCP
slogan. And they say i.e. the aim is to increase production capacity and strategic higher value
added goods and technologies. They note the intention to step up efforts to develop a
complete domestic demand system is asserted, but the document contains nothing concrete as to how
consumption will be stimulated. How are they going to make the Chinese people start spending their
money and buying? That's the big question and the CCP is giving no answers on that. And it's not
just that. The CCP has been taking some pointed actions at European businesses. I'll be talking
more about how China has been doing this in the international business space after I come back
from a quick break. Welcome back. Foreign businesses are seeing record drops in profits in China.
Now this is amid the geopolitical tensions and slow growth in the Chinese economy. It's not just
U.S. businesses facing this either. Even European companies are watching their profits in China get
impacted. This is as China the CCP turns domestic focus to domestic production. And a goal notably
to replace basically anything they get from the outside including technology and any kind of
reliance or dependence on outside businesses. And outside countries are doing the same thing to the
Chinese market. But with European businesses in particular, the CCP is taking some more pointed
actions. ABC News said this. They said in August, China filed the complaint with the World Trade
Organization over European Union tariffs on electric vehicles made in China. It also launched
anti-dumping and subsidies investigations of European dairy products, brandy and pork exports.
The tit-for-tat actions have raised fears that a trade war may break out. It's many European
businesses are deciding that their returns on investment in the world's second largest economy
are not worth the risks due to issues including China's economic slowdown and a politicized
business environment. Now briefly on that you might remember, the European Union put tariffs
on Chinese electric vehicles. Why did they do that? Well the CCP overproduced them. They had
overproduction. They had too many of them sitting on the shelves. They needed to get rid of them and
so they wanted to dump them on foreign markets at a significant price drop. The problem with that
because Chinese businesses, many of them are subsidized by the government, especially EVs
and other things like that. Things they want to compete with in future markets. They want to sell
them at prices that nobody can compete with because they don't need to make profits. They are propped
up artificially by the Chinese Communist Party. The CCP does that, right? They cut the prices, they
sell below the red line, businesses can't compete. The CCP puts its competitors out of business and
when the competitors go out of business, the CCP then has a monopoly on the entire industry.
Once they have the monopoly, they can buy up their former competitors or become you know majority
investors. They then have a global monopoly within an entire sector. Now Europe, the United States,
many other countries, they don't want that happening. They want to make sure the CCP doesn't
control the future of like you know vehicles. They want to make sure the CCP doesn't control
the future of technology that you know again we're going to be needing for the world. And so they say
no, you can't have this if you're going to be subsidizing it. You can't be selling below the
red line to put us out of business so you can have a monopoly. So they hit back, they made it so the
CCP couldn't do it. The CCP now being very angry about that is saying they're well we're going to
do the same thing and they're going after milk or pork products and things like that. Now for the
EU as a whole that's not that big of a deal but for individual EU member states, some of them that's
a big market for them. And so the CCP is bypassing the EU going to individual countries and trying to
strike trade deals to get around these tariffs. And that's where things are at right now. But
interestingly the general signal right seems to be that what the economy for China is going through
right now it's going to get worse. And so even aside from the trade war there's more to it. Add
to that the growing sanctions and tariffs from inside and outside. The CCP's growing role in
global conflicts. Think Russia, Ukraine, think Israel, think the South China Sea, Taiwan, possibly now the
Arctic. And you can see where the trend is heading. Now back to that European Union Chamber of Commerce
position paper. Here's how the European businesses are reacting to that. And you know perhaps it may
be a bit hopeful where they're coming from. Their recommendations they're giving for China.
The European Union Chamber of Commerce paper says this. They're asking the CCP to quote
enact legislation to establish a truly level playing field between foreign and Chinese
enterprises. Improve the predictability and reliability of China's regulatory environment
by ensuring legislation is specific and clearly defined and drafted in consultation with industry.
Refrain from erratic policy shifts and allow reasonable transition times before implementing
new or amending existing policies or regulations. Permit access to legitimate sources of data
and business intelligence that companies need to make well-informed investment decisions.
Refrain from punishing companies for their actions for the actions of their home governments.
So what they're doing is they're kind of like asking the CCP to not be the CCP. The feasibility
of these recommendations in communist China are like it's basically slim to none. The CCP is going
to accept this. The Chinese Communist Party is not going to change its nature. The CCP is not going to
domestic production. The CCP is not going to adopt you know clear and straightforward laws
because it uses those gray areas as a way to control foreign businesses to make them over
censor for example. And it's not going to back off all the international trade wars and other
conflicts growing just because a few businesses that it doesn't even seem to want right now
are complaining about it. Now look the CCP the trend right now is actually going in the
opposite direction. The Chinese Communist Party is becoming more aggressive and not only that
the CCP's priorities are not on these European businesses. The priorities are on domestic
production, independence from foreign markets. They don't want to be reliant on anything outside
of China. And so the likelihood that the CCP is going to adopt the demands of these European
companies it's about slim to none. Now what's also important is that the trends we're watching
they're very likely going to have kind of a compounding effect with each other.
Now the important factor here is investment. If businesses leave China because business is bad,
what message does that send to investors? Investors say well geez uh this business we're
investing in is leaving China. They're probably going to have a hit to their mark because they're
losing a market. Do we want to invest in them? The CCP has domestic policies that no longer favor this
business. What's going to happen to them? Now if China loses investors that also means importantly
less money in the economy. And the problem they're having with a lot of these businesses
just aside from everything else is lack of consumption. People in China are not buying
products like they used to. And in business that also means people have less money to spend.
Because again you know where do people get their money from? Well they work in companies. The
company makes a profit. They get paid. Then they can go to restaurants and go online and shop and
buy other things. Which means money goes to other businesses which then goes to the employees.
And that's how a normal healthy economy works. But when people stop spending money what happens?
Money no longer goes to the businesses. Money from the businesses no longer goes to the paychecks.
And the people getting the paychecks no longer have the money to go and spend it. And you enter
this death cycle. Now investment sometimes can help you break out of that. But it needs people
to spend. And it also needs some kind of hope in the future of the economy and for these business
prospects to even want to go there. When that thing starts breaking down that's when you enter
what the CCP is facing right now. All of that right. All the people not having money to spend.
Maybe people's feeling that they need to sit on their money and save it because it might not be
there tomorrow. Well all of this has an effect. It comes right back and hits the ability of people to
spend money on products for businesses. And that cycle just keeps repeating. The result is like a
thread being pulled out of a ball of yarn. The economy in China is unraveling through this.
Now CNBC said this. They said European businesses in China have grown so discouraged with the
outlook for operating in that country that Beijing the CCP must act if the companies are to invest
further. According to the EU Chamber of Commerce in China. They said quote we do believe actually
that we are in sort of a tipping point situation. If you want to do something the time is now.
That's according to Jen's Escalon president of the chamber telling reporters ahead of the
paper's release. Notice as well that foreign direct investment into China fell by 29.6 percent
during the January to July period versus a year ago. According to China's Ministry of Commerce.
Now we're also seeing this reflected in warnings on the other end of those businesses. Because look
again it's not just businesses trying to make money in China. There are warnings also being
issued to the investors to even stay away from companies. If those companies are too embedded
in the Chinese market. Bloomberg said this. Quote stay away from China exposed stocks in Europe.
City says. It notes as well that luxury goods makers, miners, car makers are seeing sharper
cuts to earnings expectations than the broader market. And that won't change soon. The city
strategist said in the report. Which contrasted with last week's Bank of America recommendation.
It notes that city's basket of European companies with high revenue exposure to China has fallen
over seven percent this year. A sharp divergence from the six percent gain seen for the stock 600
benchmark. Now notably we also see this sentiment being expressed at government levels. And so
consumer, business, investment, government right. The United States we're here right. Policies
against the CCP are becoming mostly bipartisan. What does that mean? Well normally for countries
doing business with the United States. They understand that every you know two years with
the midterm elections. Every four years of the presidential elections. There's a chance that
American policy will change. Because you know we tend to oscillate between Republican or Democrat
administrations. And there tends to be kind of a rotating policy system we have here. Things
shift from one way to the other. The difference is when you have Republicans and Democrats aligned
on an issue. And when it comes to China, Republicans and Democrats are relatively aligned.
You have the Atlantic now for example saying. That one of the few things that came out of the Trump
administration. The whole trade war with China. The tariffs and sanctions that have now remained.
That's one of the few things that Republicans and Democrats both seem to agree on.
And we're seeing that reflected even now in the future possible administrations. It's unlikely
that this US stance on China is going to change. No matter who gets elected. And they're taking
notice. And the European Union also. The EU. They just wrote about their stance on business with
China. And it shows that the trend for them is quote de-risking. In fact this is from the official
statement just recently released from the European Union. This is from the official website of the
European Union. Their official stance on this. They say quote. China is the EU's second largest
trading partner for goods after the United States. With bilateral trade reaching 739 billion euros in
2023. This represents a decline of 14 percent compared to 2022. And that was even a rough time
because of the COVID lockdowns. They note at the European Council in June 2023 EU member states
reaffirmed the EU's multifaceted policy approach towards China. Outlined in its 2019 strategic
outlook. They say this. China is simultaneously a partner, a competitor, and a systemic rival.
However the balance of challenges and opportunities presented by China has shifted over time. They say
our economic relationship is critically unbalanced. Both in terms of trade flows and of investment.
Due to a significant asymmetry in their respective market openings. Meaning basically they lose money
doing business with China. And China gains more money than they do. It is more profitable for the
CCP to get their business than it is for them to get the business of the CCP. There's a discrepancy
here right. The same thing America has. This trade imbalance with China. They note that in addition
China's economic model has brought about systemic distortions with negative spillovers to trading
partners. According to the IMF, International Monetary Fund, China's use of industrial policies,
notably in support to priority sectors, has an impact on trading partners. The policies of the
CCP in other words are having an impact on the global markets. And you know one of the hopes of
opening up to China when they said reform and opening up. And they let him into the World
Trade Organization and other things. The hope was that if the CCP engages more with the free market
it would become less communist. And what happened? The CCP made the free market more communist. It
went the other way. It notes here that another area of concern is China's drive towards import
substitution and self-sufficiency. Meaning they don't need nobody else. They want domestic companies
to succeed and they don't want foreign companies to have that market. They note that while the EU
welcomes efforts by the Chinese authorities to attract foreign direct investment. They want
money to pour into China. EU companies continue to face discrimination in the Chinese market because
again they want domestic production. And they say and it remains difficult for European businesses
in China to compete due to the lack of a level playing field. Moreover despite the Chinese
government's stated ambition to pursue a high level opening of its market and build mutually
beneficial trade partnerships. China still remains largely closed in many important sectors. The CCP
does not have a level playing field. In other words they rigged the game against foreign companies.
They say this as well. The EU is committed to quote de-risking not decoupling from China.
They say this entails reducing critical dependencies and vulnerabilities including
in EU supply chains and diversifying where necessary. So what does that mean? Again diversifying
de-risking. What does that mean? It means getting risky businesses out of China. It means getting
rid of the risk of you know if the Chinese economy crashes or if they really do want to
push out all your companies that you're not affected by it. They want to make sure that
they're not dependent on the CCP. If the CCP decides hey we're going to ban all these rare
earth minerals. We're going to ban iron. We're going to ban the ore you need to build your products.
We're going to make it so that you can't build automobiles anymore. We're going to make it so you
can't build any kind of high-tech goods because yeah you need us for it. If you want to build say
solar panels or other things that need these rare earth minerals well the Chinese Communist Party
has a global monopoly on them and if they just cut you off your business is dead. They want to
make sure that does not happen and so they're talking about de-risking, diversifying, looking
at new supply chain options right. Now they say it's different from decoupling and what they mean
by that is they still want to do some business with China but they don't want to be so in business
with China that they depend on it. They want to have it so they don't need the business in China.
The trend right here right is that it's becoming too risky for a business for an investor or even
a country to place their bets on the Chinese market and they no longer want to be intertwined
with it. Even beyond that if they're intertwined with it there are warnings for investors to not
even invest in those companies. It's becoming too dangerous, too unstable and the future trend
seems to be coming more so. Well everyone that's all for today. Thank you for joining us. Let me
know what you think in the comments. Also please help share this episode. Help us get the word out
and as always please take care of yourselves, stay informed and stay free. Thank you.
