【爸媽在海外】來到海外還有必要讓孩子在學習上內卷嗎?西方社會階層如何劃分,哪些職業跨越中產及精英階層?拋開教育,我的‘美國夢’能成真嗎

爸妈在海外
162粉絲
261 次觀看·2023年10月1日
Hello everyone, I'm Ellie. Welcome to Parents Abroad
In many of my previous shows, I've introduced
how to help your child choose a school, choose a major,
or even how to improve their learning
But some parents always have this very common problem
That is, the reason why I came from mainland China to overseas
Whether it's to Australia, New Zealand, Canada, the United States, or the UK
I just don't want to live such a tight life in China
I want to have a more balanced life abroad
Now that my next generation is studying overseas
Is it really necessary for me to make her do this?
Do I still have to let her choose between public and private education?
Do I still have to let her go to tutoring classes on weekends?
Do I still have to let her take up maritime tactics
in high-tech physics and chemistry?
Shouldn't I give my child a happier education
or a happier childhood?
So in this episode, I want to talk to you about
whether it's necessary for a child to choose to study abroad
and still be a top student
In fact, whether it's necessary for a child to choose
to go to a good private or public high school
or even a top elite high school
in the process of applying for college
Is the child's goal
to go to those very famous prestigious universities?
Actually, before answering these questions
the most important question
is also a more conclusive question
That is, you might as well ask yourself
what kind of social class
do you want your child to be in
after becoming an adult?
What kind of career will she have in the future?
And what kind of life and social circle do you want her to live in?
If you understand these questions
then the so-called chicken-and-duck thing
or the domestic roll-up overseas
naturally, this answer is not difficult to say
This goes back to a very practical
and very essential question
That is, what kind of life do you want your child to live
in the next 10, 20 years?
Then I have to mention
the foreign life and the whole Western society
such a social circle and social system
In fact, if you have lived abroad for a while
it's not difficult to find
that no matter which Western country you are in
especially in these countries that speak English
these countries still have
a very obvious class system
Of course, when it comes to class
you might think of
what you saw in the movies
the king and nobility level
and the next level of the common people
Among the nobility, there is also the duke and the son of Bo
and so on
In fact, we are not exaggerating
It's really not the same nobility life as it used to be
or that you have to have a connection with the royal family
to stand out
However, if you really go to this current society
to feel it
to socialize with these local Westerners
it's not difficult to find
such a level or such a class
still exists in the present
in the present
It's just that you will find
whether you live in a relatively large capital city
or a relatively remote small city
the locals are generally very friendly and polite
They won't put their level on their lips
and they won't make it obvious that
because of the difference in level
the way they treat you will also be different
But that doesn't mean that
such a level or such a class does not exist
And in Western countries
the most common class we see
is actually divided into three levels
or four levels
because the middle level can be divided into a small gap
So what are these three levels or three classes?
First of all, it's a part of the population living at the bottom
that is, these people belong to the low socioeconomics class
So what is the middle class where most people live?
It's the middle class
This is the second level
At the top level
there is still a high-end elite society
If you live abroad
you will often hear that
the family from which a certain child comes from
their family is very rich
It's all long-term money
This is a family that has been very rich since ancient times
passed down from generation to generation
The one that compares with this is another family
That is, in the eyes of these families
who have been very rich and have a social status since ancient times
commonly known as the layer of the rich and powerful
In fact, if we talk about the upper class
or the real upper class
the so-called aristocrats
or the elite class
there will also be a difference between them
This long-term money and short-term money
Yes, you will also feel different
But this is not the issue we are going to discuss today
We are talking about this upper class society
Let's leave it alone
Because such a social class
how to say
it still pays attention to some of its identity background
This is really not the majority
It's really the top 1% or 2% of the society
Then what about the lower class society
I believe you don't really want your children
to be in such a social circle in the future
But let's go back
Most of these workers or white-collar workers
are actually from the middle class
But even in the middle class
you will also find that
in the middle class
there will also be ordinary middle class
and the elite class of middle class
So what about the so-called ordinary middle class
Most of the ordinary middle class
are the white-collar workers we often talk about
The work they do
is also our more common
work in these social fields
For example, office white-collar workers
For example, bank employees
For example, accountants, IT people
public service, engineers, engineers, etc.
These are our most common
these white-collar jobs
What about the elites in the white-collar
It is distributed in two ways
The first is according to its income
There will be such a differentiation in different countries
For example, if you want to be in Australia
It's almost more than 200,000
It's considered an elite in the middle class
What about in the United States
If you can get into Wall Street's investment bank
and can also be a small manager
Your annual salary is not impossible to reach one million US dollars
It depends on how hard you work
The performance includes your work experience
Plus your most basic company
Plus your bonus
A million-dollar investment in Wall Street is not a dream
This is completely achievable
This part is divided by our so-called income
When the income is above a certain value
Then everyone will usually call them
The elites in the middle class
What about the other part of the elite in the middle class
Although it is also related to his income
But more of it depends on his profession
Especially when he is a very experienced employee
There will also be a very good social status in a particular profession
We call it social status
At the same time, his income is also quite a lot
The two most respected overseas
I believe Ellie doesn't need to say more
Those two words have already appeared in your mind
That's right
One is a doctor
The other is a lawyer
Of course, if we put it back
You might say
This doctor, he sometimes makes
Maybe not a million-dollar financial entrepreneur
His income must be high
But the doctor's social status
Far more than what we said before
These financiers in this investment bank
Their social status must be higher
So is the lawyer
Of course, in fact, the income of lawyers and doctors is not bad
But more of it
Everyone still values their professional background
So people in these professions
In the middle class
It's also a typical middle-class elite
But let's be realistic
If compared with those long-term money
Those from ancient times
Compared with those big families
Then their millions of annual salary
It's really not worth mentioning in their family, right?
For example, in the family of Rockefeller
In the family of Rothschild
Right?
It's not enough for a little finger to pop out a gray
Then let's not compare this
Let's just say in the vast majority of this social class
In the middle class or the middle class
Then we can see
The elites in the middle class are also
There is a certain gap between ordinary middle-class people
So to put it back
You see what we just mentioned
Whether it's work or position
What are their requirements for employment?
If it's a doctor and a lawyer
Needless to say
One is the most difficult major in liberal arts
One is the most difficult major in science
Especially medical school
Everyone knows
No matter which country you are in
You want to enter a medical school
Especially a famous medical school
Among all the top students in Quanzhou and the whole country
What is their score?
It's really the two after the decimal point of their score
That is to say, your score
Is it 99.6% or 99.8%?
Such a gap
If you are in the position before the decimal point
Then this quota, this offer is not yours, right?
So there is no need to talk about this competition
Even if it's what we mentioned before
For example, like finance, finance, banking, IT, engineering, engineers, etc.
When they apply
Or when you want to do this kind of work
Most companies
He will still look for it in undergraduate students, right?
He won't go to a senior position
Or in the big brick
Find your own little engineering manager
The person in charge of the small engineering department
Or his engineer, etc.
Among these undergraduate students
If you graduated from a famous school, right?
No matter if you are in the 8th grade or graduated from Tengxiao
Tengxiao needless to say
Or Niujian, Niujin, Jianqiao
Of course, people will look at each other more
Overseas corporate employers, they are not stupid
They understand very well
How much gold is in these schools' graduation certificates
There are some more exaggerated ones
For example, Ellie heard about it herself
Some of the top 500 companies in the world
Including the four major companies and some investment banks
When they are interviewing
They will also ask
Where did you study in high school?
And there are some even perverted requirements
Look at your grades in high school
That's how exaggerated it is
So in other words
Even if you don't have a top million-dollar job
Or you don't have to go to medical school to study medicine
Or be a real big lawyer, big judge
Even if you want your child
To have a white-collar, working-class job
Obviously
At least it has to be a graduate of a university, right?
Of course, if you can have an honor
Or a master's degree
If it's a very famous school
Graduated from a famous major
Then there's no need to say
So all the ways you want to try in the future
These doors you want to open
Will eventually return to education
So in the end it will all return to
The most essential education in middle and elementary school
Of course, some people also said
Isn't there still American Dream?
Isn't there still Canada Dream?
Is there still Australia Dream?
Can't I have an American Dream?
Can't I be a genius who can do the opposite?
In fact, it's not impossible
One thing that cannot be denied is
The so-called American Dream
Or the British Dream, the Australian Dream
The degree or probability of this dream being realized
Compared to this
Maybe it's really much bigger than China
But Ellie also said
From her own experience
Many elite people
The elite we are talking about is the elite of the middle class
Not the elites in those old noble families
Now many middle-aged and even middle-aged elites
Especially those who used to be low in education
But later it was indeed in the workplace
These middle-aged and old people who succeeded in counterattack
When they came back to school
To give students some workshops
To give students some speeches
Or just simply socialize with students
When communicating privately with them
Many of them said
The possibility of this is getting smaller and smaller
What kind of possibility?
That is to say, success cases like theirs
Start with low education
But in the end, it can go to
An elite part of the middle class
Can go to millions of dollars a year
Or the position of company CEO, etc.
It can't be said that it's impossible
But she said
Such an opportunity or such a counterattack
It's getting harder and harder
The reason behind it is also obvious
Because now even those who are in high positions in the workplace
They will also have more and more choices
Most of the people who come to apply
Most of them get their degree
It would be better to have a graduate degree
Or some other work experience
For him who has now become a employer
Do you think he will choose a high school graduate student?
Or will he choose a student from a well-known university
To learn counterattack professionals, right?
So even they themselves will say
A successful path like their own
It's getting harder and harder to copy now
It's because the current environment has changed
Because when they first entered the workplace
The diploma of the university is in the limelight
And now you look back
The ratio of undergraduate students in the employment workplace
That is definitely far from high school graduates
Or students who graduated from technical school
So many people say
If you just want to take a technical school graduate
Or such a diploma from high school
To create such an American dream
Or say it's an Australian dream
It's not entirely impossible
But it will be more difficult than our era
Their era
It's going to be a lot, a lot, a lot more difficult
So let's go back to the previous question
When parents are struggling
I finally came out
When I don't have to roll in China
Is it necessary for my child to roll like this abroad?
Especially if it is necessary for him to learn
Still learn like a chicken
Should I let him experience
The foreign education that we have always dreamed of
And the so-called reduction
Should I stop struggling
In the end, do you want to choose an ordinary public high school
Or spend a lot of money to enter a private high school
I even have to work hard to get into those key high schools
Should I still work hard to buy a house in the school district at home
Is it necessary to sacrifice your weekend
Accompany the child to go to the tutoring class
Go to the sports club
Or spend the money to ask for a tutor one-on-one
Whether it's a student or a musical instrument
Or art
Is it really necessary to roll up these things?
Just like Ellie just said
You might as well go back and ask
After 10 or 20 years
Which social class do you want your child to live in?
Which class do you want the people around him to be in?
What kind of career do you want him to have?
Do you want to say that when he enters the mainstream society
What kind of positioning and choice does he give himself?
So if you have thought about these questions clearly
Whether to roll up or not
Such a problem naturally comes to light
Actually, speaking of which, Ellie reminds me of a movie
A famous movie before the United States
A bit like a documentary movie
The name of the movie is called Waiting for Superman
It is in the form of a documentary
To follow the footsteps of a few underage families in the United States
They are facing such a system when they choose to go to middle school
Or say it's the choice of fate
Most of these subjects are African-American children
These parents know very well
If he wants his child to leave his current class
The only way is to let them receive better education
Live a middle-class life in the future
But their family does not have economic guarantees
Can buy a relatively good school district house
There is no economic source to support them to go to a private school or a church school
It is even more impossible to send them to the weekend cram school or ask for a tutor
And their only hope is
The so-called lottery system of those better public schools
Then the number of people in the lottery is limited
Whoever gets it is whoever
Those lucky children who get it
Will have the opportunity to enter a key middle school to receive better education
And this movie is to follow the footsteps of such a few families
Also reflects the very real situation of contemporary education to everyone
I don't want to discuss with you about the education of the United States
What is the 369 level?
But you can see
What good education means to children
So finally, let me briefly reveal the industry
When you sit down and chat with educators around you
Many colleagues around
Including people who used to teach
Even people of a higher level in policy making
There is such a saying in the circle
They said in their opinion
They think in a mainstream society in a Western country like the United States
The two most successful ethnic groups in the cross-border class
One is Chinese
The other is Indian
What do you think about this matter?
You are very welcome to put your thoughts in the comment area
To communicate with everyone
Thank you very much for listening and watching
See you next time
