【爸媽在海外】有必要讓孩子一定選學中文課嗎?學中文vs不學中文原因大PK,您站哪邊?

爸妈在海外
162粉絲
402 次觀看·2023年10月20日
Hello everyone, I'm Ellie. Welcome to Parents Abroad
In the first two episodes, I talked to you about
what age group is most likely to become a bilingual expert in helping kids transfer to another school
After that, I heard a lot of feedback from parents
So today, I want to continue to do one or two episodes of follow-up programs
I want to tell you if in the world of bilingual experts
the sky is always blue, the sea is always clear
life is always happy, just like in the fairy tales
Speaking of which, I'm sure you have the answer in your heart
Of course it won't be like this
Experts have difficulties in their life
and the difficulties they face may not be something you can imagine
So today I will talk to you about
those legendary bilingual experts
Those second-generation immigrants whose Chinese and English sound like their mother tongue
Why is their life not so easy?
Why is it not so easy to be a bilingual expert?
Speaking of bilingual experts
there is always a premise
when we discuss
we always assume that
when these kids whose Chinese and English are very good
when they go to middle school
when they choose classes
they will naturally choose Chinese
So let's start with the matter of choosing Chinese to choose classes
Will all the kids choose Chinese?
Will all the parents also let their kids choose Chinese?
Let's talk about choosing classes first
Many people will think that
Chinese and English are so good
It's a pity that they don't choose Chinese
These bilingual experts will definitely choose Chinese
In other words, when they go to middle school
Chinese is one of their elective courses
plus other courses
When they take the college entrance exam
they have an advantage in language
because they have a better grasp of the age of transfer
and benefit from it
On the other hand
learning Chinese may not take them too long
to get a relatively high score
So these kids will definitely choose Chinese
But the answer is not like that
Some kids do choose Chinese
but some don't
It's like some parents
also help their kids choose Chinese
Some parents don't encourage them that much
or force their kids to learn Chinese
Today I will tell you
when choosing classes
why some students and their parents choose Chinese
while some don't want to choose Chinese
So let's start with the NO side
Why do some second-generation immigrants
who are so good at both English and Chinese
end up not choosing Chinese?
Why don't the parents of these second-generation immigrants
encourage them to choose Chinese?
From my own experience
I would like to share with you
There are three reasons why they don't choose Chinese
Reason No.1
This kid thinks that
his Chinese is already very good
He has no problem communicating normally
He even has no problem reading books and reading newspapers
The books and newspapers we are talking about
are mostly Chinese newspapers
that can be read and understood
from overseas
As you know, Chinese newspapers
are of good quality
The content of the articles
whether it's news or magazines
is quite deep
Some newspapers are simplified Chinese
and some are Chinese characters
These kids can understand them
Of course, going to a Chinese restaurant
ordering food in Chinese
is just a piece of cake
It's really a piece of cake
So when these kids reach this level
they think
I think it's enough
Why should I still go to school
and choose this course?
They are purely looking at it from a pragmatic perspective
So they would rather choose
a course that they are really interested in
rather than this course
Those courses that they are interested in
are probably like
cooking, sports
singing, dancing
or choosing a more
complicated course
like physics or chemistry
The reason behind this is
that they think their Chinese is good enough
and they don't want to continue
developing their Chinese
They don't want to become
a Chinese literature researcher
or a scholar
or even go further
They don't want to develop in this direction
So if it's good enough, they quit
The second reason is that
it comes from the parents
and this type of parents are generally
more Buddhist
When parents go overseas
they fully understand a different way of living
a different way of thinking
including the way they teach their kids
So this part of the parents
don't want to continue
They think that if the kids like it
they will of course support the students
If the kids don't like it
this part of the parents
will force their kids
to learn Chinese
It's entirely up to the kids
Some kids think that
they are not interested in Chinese
and Chinese is more difficult
so they don't want to learn
So this is the second reason
The parents of Buddhist schools
won't bully their kids
After that, these kids
won't continue learning Chinese
This is not a minority
When these kids grow up
they won't be able to communicate in Chinese
But this part of the parents
their English is pretty good
Their communication with the kids
is no problem at all
So this is the reason
why the kids won't continue
learning Chinese after middle school
So the third reason
comes from the relationship
between the parents
These kids' parents
don't mean that they don't want
their kids to learn Chinese
We say that the parents
have a passionate love for Chinese
But they are not sincere
They have tried everything
they can
Whether it's hard, soft,
compromising,
negotiative,
or even threatening
They want their kids
to learn Chinese
But it's really not successful
As long as they want to learn Chinese
their family will be in chaos
It's like the third world war
Every time they go to
a Chinese tutoring class
it's like going to a execution ground
Before class
parents and kids
have to fight
so that the kids can go to class
After class
if they don't go to the drawing board
the kids won't be able to do their homework
In the end, it's not only the kids
who are heartbroken
but also the parents
Because of learning Chinese
it's very tough
So in the end,
there's nothing they can do
Who is compromising?
Of course, it's the parents
So the parents decide
to not learn Chinese
They spend so much time and money
and in the end,
they can't even say a word
What the kids do to me
is not only complaining
but also hate
So this part of the parents' giving up
is not like what we said before
about the parents of Buddhist schools
They are willing to
use all kinds of methods
to make a compromise
After that,
the kids really didn't continue to learn Chinese
So this is the third reason
Of course, it's not like
all overseas students are like this
These are the three main reasons
for not learning Chinese
There are also a lot of students
especially those who are bilingual
They will also choose to learn Chinese
Especially the parents of these students
are doing everything they can
to make their kids learn Chinese
So let's talk about
why these students' parents
really want their kids
to learn Chinese
Actually, if you look at it
you will find that
there are really a lot of reasons
behind learning Chinese
that are not related to
Chinese
But before we talk about the reasons
let's talk about the prerequisite
The prerequisite for these kids
to learn Chinese is that
they have already chosen Chinese classes
So why would they choose Chinese?
First, these kids feel
that they are not so rejected by Chinese
It's okay to learn, it's okay not to learn
Let's learn first
Second, there are some kids
who have found some interest and fun
in learning
and they continue to learn
So step by step
they have come to the college entrance exam
So let's look back
Why do parents want their kids
to learn Chinese?
The parents' reasons
also have four main points
The first reason
is that parents want
their kids to communicate
better and more smoothly
In this case
many parents feel that
their kids' Chinese is much smoother
and clearer than English
and sometimes deeper
We are not talking about
a normal one-on-one
chat
Some parents really want
to have a deeper
communication with their kids
a more heartfelt communication
At this time, they find that
Chinese is the most sincere and clear
So they encourage their kids to learn Chinese
The second reason
is that
English is really not that fluent
for the parents of the first generation
So it's more difficult
to communicate with their kids in English
So at this time
they encourage
or force their kids to learn Chinese
so that they can ensure
that their communication with their kids
is normal
So there are two reasons
Some parents have good English
and still want to have a deeper
and more Chinese-oriented
communication
They really encourage their kids to learn Chinese
Another reason is that
their English level is really limited
It's difficult to communicate with their kids
in English
So they can only communicate in Chinese
Of course, they also encourage their kids
to learn Chinese
so that they can have a better
and smoother communication
So these two reasons
form the first big reason
to encourage their kids
to learn Chinese
This is the first reason
The second reason
is that some parents
think that
even though their kid is from overseas
even though their kid immigrated overseas
I hope that they don't forget their roots
They will still speak their mother tongue
In their heart, Chinese
has always been their child's mother tongue
Remembering Chinese is like remembering your roots
When do you want to find your roots
and climb back up
to your roots
This is why many parents
want their kids to continue learning Chinese
This is the second reason
The third reason
is that
these parents may know more about
the overseas society
When they know more about the western society
these parents
will be more inclined to
let their kids learn more Chinese
and not worry about their kids' English
Some parents may think
that because their English level is limited
they are not fully integrated
into the overseas mainstream society
so they are worried that
their kids will not be able to
integrate into the mainstream society
So they will highly recommend
their kids to learn more English
Even if they give up Chinese
it doesn't matter
But when many parents
really understand the overseas
mainstream society
they will highly recommend
or highly recommend
their kids to learn Chinese
Why?
Because when these second generation
immigrants grow up
the ABCs
when they grow up
they will discover that
ABCs will have their own unique
group and circle
Even though they grew up overseas
even though English is their mother tongue
even though they grew up with
the ABCs
it's hard for them to
integrate into the white community
We are not saying that
there is no discrimination
but when they grow up
they will understand
whether it's because of their
special background
or other reasons
they often describe themselves
as people in the middle
They don't belong to the local
white community
They don't belong to the Chinese
Chinese community
Meaning, those who were born in China
grew up in China
and immigrated overseas
Those ABCs
don't feel like they are
in the same group as the Chinese
After all, their growth experience
including their ideas
and outlook on life are different
So these ABCs
feel like they are in the middle
This leads to ABCs
ABCs
