世事Infocus:美国最高法院究竟是谁的最高法院?

法律天秤座
20 followers
44 Video Views·Sep 26, 2024
On June 24th, the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade ruling,
deciding that there's no longer a federal constitutional right to abortion.
Before realizing Roe v. Wade might soon be overturned, Democrats tried to remedy the
situation. On May 11th, Senate Democrats took out Women's Health Protection Act,
a bill that would codify abortion, but the effort ultimately failed.
Now it seems Republicans have the last laugh, but Republicans were not born to oppose abortion
rights. In 1972, a Gallup poll showed that Americans were united in their opinion about
abortion. 68% of Republicans and 59% of Democrats agreed that the decision to have abortion should
be made solely by a woman and her physician. It showed that Republican voters were on average
more pro-choice than their Democratic counterparts. The chair of the Republican National Committee,
Mary Louise Smith, supported abortion rights, as did First Lady Betty Ford,
who declared Roe v. Wade a great, great decision. So what caused Republicans to
change their attitude towards abortion rights? The answer is simple. Votes.
The Republican Party found that many of the people who opposed abortion were fundamentalist
or conservative from swing states. If they openly stated their opposition to abortion,
they could win support of these people. So at the 1976 Republican Convention, the party endorsed a
constitutional amendment that would restore protection of the right to life for unborn
children. This shift in the Republican Party also prompted some of its pro-abortion legislators
to switch to the Democratic Party. It can be said that for the past 50 years, both parties
didn't care about a woman's right to abortion per se. The abortion issue is more like a
purification process that divides the two parties, the voters, and the United States into two
distinct and incompatible groups. Let's take a closer look at who are the five conservative
justices that voted to end Roe v. Wade. Samuel Alito was nominated by President George W. Bush.
Clarence Thomas was nominated by President George H. W. Bush. Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh,
and Amy Coney Barrett were nominated by President Donald Trump. These five conservative justices
were all nominated by a Republican president. President Trump and George W. Bush have one
thing in common. Their votes were lower than their competitors that they won the election
due to the nature of the U.S. election system. The winner takes all systems established by most
state laws. In other words, it's possible that the U.S. president is not a choice of the majority.
Such a president would in turn elect justices who don't receive majority support. Such justices
now occupy five seats in the U.S. Supreme Court. In today's American society, this
anti-democratic character of this political system is becoming more and more obvious.
From gun control to abortion rights, the U.S. is making great strides towards a constitutional
crisis with almost no possibility of renewal. Of course, it's a dangerous signal for the Democratic
Party, the 2022 midterm elections, and the 2024 presidential election. The arbitrary and no-fix
term of judicial power, the mismatch between the number of seats in the Senate and the population,
and the winner-takes-all electoral system contribute to the structural advantages of
conservatives in the United States. For Americans, this might be a signal of intensifying social
division. On the one hand, abortion is legal in at least 14 states, while on the other hand,
22 states will ban abortion immediately. Among these states, 13 have passed so-called
trigger laws, which are bans designed to go into effect if Roe is overturned.
Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell earlier said in an interview with USA Today
that a national abortion ban is possible if the court overturned Roe.
