Sanxingdui civilization|The secret of the Bronze Sacred Tree: Ancient Egyptians or Sumerians

Yellow Emperor
60 followers
大家好,歡迎來到腦洞風暴冷知識,今天我們來聊一下三星堆文明的來源問題。 Hello everyone, welcome to Brainstorm Trivia, today we will talk about the origin of Sanxingdui civilization.
三星堆遺址,自1929年被發現以來,歷時近百年的考古挖掘,正日益成為全球考古界矚目的焦點, Since its discovery in 1929, the Sanxingdui site has been excavated for nearly a hundred years, and is increasingly becoming the focus of the global archaeological community.
特別到了2021年,已經成為中華大地上最神秘最被關注的一個地方。 Especially in 2021, it has become the most mysterious and most concerned place in China.
三星堆文明,因為完全迥異於華夏主流文明-黃河流域文明的超然風格,從它重見天日的那天起, Sanxingdui civilization, because it is completely different from the transcendental style of the mainstream civilization in China - the civilization of the Yellow River Basin, since the day it reappeared,
它的來源問題就讓中國史學界產生了巨大的分歧。 the question of its origin has caused huge differences in Chinese historians.
國內主流的觀點認為三星堆文明屬於本土的巴蜀文明,而另外有些人認為三星堆文明屬於外來文明, The mainstream view in China is that the Sanxingdui civilization belongs to the local Bashu civilization, while others
還有一種腦洞更清奇的說法認為,三星堆文明屬於外星人留在地球的遺跡。 believe that the Sanxingdui civilization is an alien civilization.
雖然關於三星堆的來源問題,還有太多問題需要考證,但至少,它應該不屬於本土誕生的文明,而是屬於遷徙而來的外來文明。 Although there are still too many questions about the origin of Sanxingdui, at least, it should not belong to the civilization born in the country, but belong to the foreign civilization that migrated.
從考古斷代上來講,三星堆根據考古專家的推測,大概在西元前2650年至西元前1000年存續。 In terms of archaeological dating, according to the speculation of archaeological experts, Sanxingdui probably existed from 2650 BC to 1000 BC.
這個時期中原黃河文明是什麼時期呢,炎黃戰蚩尤的時代。 根據記載,黃帝時期大約在西元前2717年-西元前2599年。 What period was the Yellow River civilization in the Central Plains during this period, the era of Yan Huang and Chiyou. According to records, the Yellow Emperor period was about 2717 BC - 2599 BC.
也就是說三星堆文化與黃帝時期幾乎是同時存在的。 That is to say, the Sanxingdui culture and the Yellow Emperor period coexisted almost at the same time.
那麼在三星堆文明出現時,華夏人文始祖黃帝部落還處於什麼水準呢? So when the Sanxingdui civilization appeared, what level was the Yellow Emperor tribe, the ancestor of Chinese humanities?
《越絕書》曾有過一段記載:“神農以石為兵,黃帝以玉為兵。” "Yue Jue Shu" once recorded: "Shen Nong used stone as his soldiers, and Huang Di used jade as his soldiers."
這段話從側面表述了當時炎帝與黃帝那個時代人們的生產工具是多麼落後,還大多以石頭玉器這種石質的工具為主。 This passage expresses from the side how backward the production tools of people in the era of Emperor Yan and Huang Di were, and most of them used stones. Jade is mainly a stone tool.
而同時期的三星堆文明,已經可以批量製造精美絕倫的青銅器。 At the same time, the Sanxingdui civilization was able to mass-produce exquisite bronze wares.
你還會認為三星堆屬於華夏本土誕生的文明嗎? Do you still think that Sanxingdui belongs to the civilization born in China?
胡適提倡做學問要「大膽地假設,小心地求證」,我覺得這句話尤其適用於考古領域。 Hu Shi advocated "bold assumptions and careful verification" in learning. I think this sentence is especially applicable to the field of archaeology.
所以,所有關於三星堆來源的觀點,不管有多離奇,只要提供的論據充分,且真實可靠,都是不可忽略的。 Therefore, all opinions about the source of Sanxingdui, no matter how bizarre, as long as the arguments provided are sufficient and true and reliable, they cannot be ignored.
所以,當我偶然看到國內有位學者提出三星堆文明源於北非西亞的閃米特人時, Therefore, when I happened to see a domestic scholar put forward that the Sanxingdui civilization originated from the Semites in North Africa and West Asia,
我雖覺奇怪,但仍然很認真地對他所提出的論據做了一個系統的瞭解。 I felt strange, but I still earnestly made a systematic understanding of the arguments he put forward.
雖然這位學者並非專業的歷史學家,但就其提供的各種論據來講,我認為他的觀點相比其它觀點,可信度更高,也更合理。 Although this scholar is not a professional historian, in terms of the various arguments he provides, I think his view is more credible and more plausible than others.
接下來,我們就簡單說說這位學者的觀點: Next, let's briefly talk about the scholar's point of view: The
三星堆古國,是古代中東地區閃米特人建立的政權,三星堆文明實質上更是閃米特文化的遺澤! ancient country of Sanxingdui was a regime established by the Semites in the ancient Middle East, and the Sanxingdui civilization is actually the legacy of the Semitic culture!
首先,閃米特人是什麼人呢,根據《辭海》的解釋,泛指古代北非和西亞說閃含語系的人, First of all, who are the Semites? According to the interpretation of "Ci Hai", it generally refers to the people who spoke Semitic languages in ancient North Africa and West Asia,
包括巴比倫人,亞述人,希伯來人,腓尼基人,重點以古埃及與猶太人為代表。 including Babylonians, Assyrians, Hebrews, and Phoenicians. Represented by ancient Egypt and Jews.
具體來說,閃米特人曾經生活的區域包括,北非衣索比亞,古埃及,西亞兩河流域。 Specifically, the areas where the Semites once lived include Ethiopia in North Africa, ancient Egypt, and the two river basins in West Asia.
對於閃米特人如何從遙遠的北非西亞到達成都平原並建立三星堆政權的,這位學者並沒有提供出直接的證據, As for how the Semites arrived in the Chengdu Plain from far North Africa and West Asia and established the Sanxingdui regime, the scholar did not provide direct evidence,
只是猜測說,有可能是經中東到達現代的印度,再經緬甸進入中國雲南,繼而最終到達成都平原。 but only speculated that it may have reached modern India through the Middle East, and then entered China through Myanmar. Yunnan, and finally to the Chengdu Plain.
而他提供的論據,則是三星堆出土的文物與閃米特人文化特徵的高度相似性。 The argument he provides is that the cultural relics unearthed in Sanxingdui are highly similar to the cultural characteristics of the Semites.
第一 金杖 The first golden rod
如圖所示,三星堆出土的金杖發現於兩個祭祀坑的一號坑,總長度142釐米, is shown in the picture. The golden rod unearthed in Sanxingdui was found in the No. 1 pit of the two sacrificial pits, with a total length of 142 cm and a
直徑2.3釐米,杖上鐫刻的圖紋包括頭戴皇冠耳掛三角形耳環的人頭像、魚鳥勾雲紋飾以及穗葉形柄等。 diameter of 2.3 cm. The engraved patterns on the rod include a person wearing a crown and earrings with triangular earrings. Head portrait, fish and bird hook and cloud patterns, and spike-shaped stalks, etc.
很明顯,這是一根象徵著王權的寶杖。 Obviously, this is a scepter that symbolizes kingship.
在中國黃河文明中,帝皇王權從來沒有以金杖為象徵的傳統,鼎才是中國傳統中的王權象徵, In China's Yellow River civilization, the emperor's kingship has never been symbolized by a golden scepter. Ding is the symbol of kingship in Chinese tradition.
直至今天,鼎一直被認為是中國獨有的一種文明,這是中國史學界至今公認的事實。 Until today, Ding has always been regarded as a unique civilization in China. accepted fact.
事實上,這種認知是錯誤的。 In fact, this perception is wrong.
雖然鼎在中國歷史上有其特殊的地位,但卻不是中國獨有的。 在非洲的衣索比亞境內麥絡 Although the tripod has its special place in Chinese history, it is not unique to China. In Ethiopia, in Africa,
埃遺址就有過鼎的出士。 there are monks from the Meloei site.
“麥絡埃遺址”存在於西元前730年左右,與古代埃及的聯繫在於,直受埃及統治的衣索比亞的庫施王國突然推翻了埃及統治, The "Meiroe Ruins" existed around 730 BC, and the connection with ancient Egypt is that the Kush Kingdom of Ethiopia, which was directly under Egyptian rule, suddenly overthrew the Egyptian rule and
建立了埃及的第25王朝“衣索比亞王朝。 established Egypt's 25th Dynasty "Esoi". Biya Dynasty.
鼎這個東西的造型實在並不特殊,特殊的是古代的青銅冶鍊技術,誰具有這個技術和冶鍊的能力才是真正的政權統治者, The shape of the tripod is really not special, what is special is the ancient bronze smelting technology, who has this technology and the ability to smelt the chain is the real ruler of the regime, in
換句話說,中國古代的青銅冶鍊技術有相當可能只掌握在皇家王者手中。 other words, the bronze smelting technology in ancient China It is quite possible that the chain technology is only in the hands of the royal kings.
而且,在中國的考古史上,青銅鑄造術從商朝開始,出土的商朝青銅器無不製作精良, Moreover, in the history of archaeology in China, bronze casting started from the Shang Dynasty, and the unearthed Shang Dynasty bronzes are all well-made and
美倫美奐,從來沒有出土過製作技術不成熟的過渡產品,高超的青銅器鑄造術好像從天而降一樣, beautiful. A transitional product, the superb bronze casting technology seems to have fallen from the sky.
沒有一個從發明到成熟的過程,那有沒有可能,商朝的青銅冶鍊鑄造技術就源於三星堆文明呢? There is no process from invention to maturity. Is it possible that the bronze metallurgy chain casting technology of the Shang Dynasty originated from the Sanxingdui civilization?
而三星堆政權,與傳統的中國歷代王朝都不同,用金杖象徵至高無上的王權。 Different dynasties have used the golden scepter to symbolize the supreme kingship
這與哪裡的傳統一至呢? . Where is this tradition?
是的,以古埃及與猶太人為代表的閃米特人! Yes, the Semites represented by ancient Egypt and the Jews!
1922年,英國考古學家霍華德·卡特率領的考古隊在埃及帝王谷發現了古埃及法老圖坦卡蒙陵墓, In 1922, the archaeology led by British archaeologist Howard Carter The team discovered the tomb of the ancient Egyptian pharaoh Tutankhamun in the Valley of the Kings in Egypt. In the
陵墓中不管是壁畫上還是雕像上的圖坦卡蒙都手握像徵王權的金杖。 tomb, whether on the frescoes or on the statues, Tutankhamun was holding a golden scepter symbolizing kingship.
而且,三星堆金杖上的魚紋明顯就是非洲尼羅河特有的羅非魚,特徵非常明顯, Moreover, the fish pattern on the Sanxingdui golden scepter was obvious. It is the tilapia unique to the Nile River in Africa. It has very obvious features
背上一排魚鰭,這是世界上其它魚類所沒有的。 . It has a row of fins on its back, which is not found in other fish in the world. The
第二 青銅神樹 second bronze sacred tree
三星堆出土了一尊青銅神樹,上有九個分枝,分枝上是九隻鳥和果實等。 Sanxingdui unearthed a bronze sacred tree with nine branches. On the branches are nine birds and fruits, etc. It
可以肯定的是,神樹是中東西亞一帶相當普遍的裝飾物,巴比倫烏爾王陵的出士法器就大致如此, is certain that the sacred tree is a very common decoration in the Middle East and West Asia, as is the case with the burial instruments of the royal tombs of Ur in Babylon,
其主要用途是向神祈禱風調雨順。 不同的是,那棵巴比倫的神樹只有八個分枝。 whose main purpose is to pray to God for good weather. The difference is that the Babylonian sacred tree has only eight branches.
在蘇美爾文明遺蹟中也不止一個地方出現了類似的神樹,被稱為蘇美爾生命樹, There is a similar sacred tree in more than one place in the remains of Sumerian civilization. It is called the Sumerian tree of life, and the
雕像上有蘇美爾文明中的吉爾伽美什國王,也有蘇美爾的神化人物恩基,吉爾伽美什做為蘇美爾最聞名的英雄人物, statue has Sumerian on it. The king of Gilgamesh in civilization also has Enki, the deified character of Sumer. As the most famous hero of Sumer, Gilgamesh
在現存的蘇美爾遺跡中隨處可見,其中就包括這塊吉爾伽美什在生命樹前祈禱的雕像, can be seen everywhere in the extant Sumerian ruins, including this one. The statue of Gilgamesh praying in front of the
生命樹的原物雖然沒有發現,不過可以肯定這棵神樹是曾經存在過的,而且枝幹向下彎曲的造型, tree of life, although the original tree of life has not been found, but it is certain that this divine tree once existed, and the shape of the branches bent downwards is
與三星堆青銅樹有著極高的相似度。 very high with the bronze tree of Sanxingdui.
至於神樹品種,極有可能是石榴樹,不管是在蘇美爾文明,還是後來的亞述文明, As for the species of the sacred tree, it is very likely to be the pomegranate tree, whether in the Sumerian civilization, the later Assyrian civilization, or the
波斯文明中,石榴樹都具有極高的地位。 Persian civilization, the pomegranate tree has a very high status. It is
還有必要指出的是關於九隻鳥的問題。 首先,鳥是中東地區非常普遍的裝飾物和神聖的象徵 also necessary to point out that On the question of the nine birds. First of all, birds are very common decorative objects and sacred symbols in the Middle East
,一些民族崇拜鳥,比如古埃及是最著名的崇拜鳥的國家,很多出土的古埃及壁畫上都有鳥的形象, . Some ethnic groups worship birds. For example, ancient Egypt is the most famous country for worshiping birds. Many ancient Egyptian murals unearthed have birds on them.
而且,有些壁畫上的鳥與這個青銅神樹上的鳥的造型十分相近。 Moreover, some of the birds on the frescoes are very similar to the bird on this bronze sacred tree.
即使在現代埃及,他們的國旗上依然有著鳥的圖形。 Even in modern Egypt, their national flag still has bird graphics.
在蘇美爾文明遺跡中,鷹與石榴樹都是常見元素,三星堆出土的青銅神樹中,鳥與樹極可能對應的就是鷹與石榴樹。 In the relics of Sumerian civilization, eagles and pomegranate trees are common elements. Among the bronze sacred trees unearthed in Sanxingdui, birds and trees are likely to correspond to eagles and pomegranate trees.
(其實在蘇美爾文明中,還流傳有一個叫ETANA的古老的神話故事,在該故事中, (Actually, in the Sumerian civilization, there is also an ancient myth called ETANA, in which
有一棵白楊樹,蛇住在樹下,鷹住在樹上,兩者在太陽神Shamash的見證下, there is a poplar tree, the snake lives under the tree, the eagle lives on the tree, the two are in the sun god Shamash. Under the witness, they
結為互幫互助的好兄弟,一方不在的時候,另一方可以代為照管對方的孩子,只是後來, became good brothers who helped each other. When one party was away, the other party could take care of the other party's children, but later, the
鷹背叛了蛇。 在這個故事中,蛇,鷹,神樹,太陽神四個元素,與這個三星堆出土的神樹與五輻太陽輪非常一致。 ) eagle betrayed the snake. In this story, the snake, the eagle, the god tree, and the sun god are four The elements are very consistent with the sacred tree and the five-spoke sun wheel unearthed in Sanxingdui.) The
第三 半人半獸面具 third half-human, half-animal mask
三星堆出士的「半人半獸面具,自出土伊始,就充滿神秘的色彩,因為這種造型的面具在中國從未出土過, Sanxingdui's "half-human, half-animal mask has been full of mysterious colors since it was unearthed, because this shape The mask has never been unearthed in China, and
有學者猜測這是古蜀王蠶從的神化形象,但可信度不大。 some scholars speculate that it is the deified image of the ancient Shu king Cancong, but it is not very credible.
其實這個面具是對牛的藝術化處理,上有牛鼻子、牛眼睛(突出其大而鼓) 和牛耳朵。 In fact, this mask is an artistic treatment of a cow, with a nose and eyes (to highlight its Big and drum) and bull ears. The
古代閃米特人恰好也有崇拜牛的習慣,尤其他們的原始宗教有崇拜金牛的傳統, ancient Semites also had the habit of worshipping bulls, especially their primitive religions had the tradition of worshiping the Taurus,
這是一種可稱為 「埃皮斯神牛」 的公牛崇拜,來源於埃及文明,這些牛死後還要隆重下葬。 which is a bull worship that can be called "Epis", which originated from Egypt Civilization, these cows will be buried grandly after they die.
很明顯後來的西班牙、印度也接受了該種崇拜。 這個崇拜因為金牛座的緣故和太陽崇拜掛上了鉤。 Obviously later Spain and India also accepted this worship. This worship is linked to the worship of the sun because of the sign of Taurus.
同時埃及也有崇拜白羊的人,如喜克素斯人。 At the same time, there are also people who worship Aries in Egypt, such as the Hyksos.
(這個論斷因為沒有提供充分的證據,暫存疑) (This assertion is temporarily doubtful because no sufficient evidence is provided.)
不過就本人來看,這個半人半獸的面具更像是蘇美爾文明中的水神恩基的形象, However, as far as I am concerned, this half-human, half-beast mask is more like the image of Enki, the water god
在蘇美爾文明留下的泥板雕像中,可以對照一下。 in Sumerian civilization, and the mud left in Sumerian civilization. In the plate statue, you can compare it.
第四 青銅大立人像 Fourth Bronze Dali
三星堆出土的青銅大立人像在服飾上也與中原漢人迥異,長袍外加一個罩袍,罩袍的式樣右襟壓左襟, Figure The bronze Dali figure unearthed in Sanxingdui is also very different from the Han people in the Central Plains in terms of clothing, with a long robe and a burqa.
而且罩袍只及膝蓋,著名的古以色列王所羅門就經常穿風格類似的袍子。 Solomon often wore robes of a similar style.
而傳統中原漢服皆是左襟壓右襟,稱為「右衽」。。 這種穿衣方式的起源,是為了方便慣用右手的人伸手入懷中拿放隨身物件。 In the traditional Central Plains Hanfu, the left lapel is pressed against the right lapel, which is called "right collar". . The origin of this way of dressing is to make it easier for right-handed people to reach into their arms to hold their belongings.
但既成正統之後,「右衽」便成為華夏文化“尊禮成服”的概念里一個基本象徵“文明”的符號 However, after the establishment of orthodoxy, "you ren" has become a basic symbol of "civilization" in the concept of "respect for ceremonies and clothing" in Chinese culture
第五 帽子
許多三星堆遺址的青銅人頭像頭上有明顯的小圓頂帽子,並且類似的帽子不止一次出現於青銅人頭像頭上。 . Similar hats appear more than once on the heads of bronze figures.
考古學家稱其為「太陽帽」,實際上這可能是如今猶太人最明顯的一個頭上裝飾:「吉帕帽」(kipa)。 Archaeologists call it a "sun hat," and it's actually probably the most visible head decoration for Jews today: the "kipa."
它是在古代漫長的歷史中猶太人受到排擠和傷害的標誌,最先由所在國的統治者規定他們必須戴帽子以區別於當地民族。 It is a symbol of the exclusion and harm of the Jews in the long history of ancient times. It was first stipulated by the ruler of the host country that they must wear a hat to distinguish them from the local peoples.
後來猶太人乾脆就以這個小圓帽作為自己民族的標誌,一直流傳了下來。 Later, the Jews simply used this small round hat as a symbol of their own nation, and it has been handed down.
第六 五輻太陽輪
在世界古代史中,幾乎全世界的人都有太陽崇拜的習俗,標誌太陽的多輻輪在古代印度半島常常是六輻, In the ancient history of the world, almost people all over the world had the custom of worshiping the sun. The multi-spoke wheel that marked the sun was often six-spoke in ancient India
在古代以色列是六輻或八輻,而三星堆出土的太陽輪則是五輻,相比六輻或八輻, , and six or eight in ancient Israel. The sun wheel unearthed in Sanxingdui has five spokes. Compared with six or eight spokes,
五輻因是奇數,從幾何學上來說,把圓平分成五份更難實現,為什麼一定要做成五輻呢。 five spokes are odd. Geometrically speaking, it is more difficult to divide the circle into five equal parts. Why must it be made into five spokes?
這可能與三星堆文明崇拜數位5有關,三星堆祭祀房裡的檯子數也是5,在墓葬中, This may be related to the worship of the number 5 in the Sanxingdui civilization. The number of tables in the Sanxingdui sacrificial room is also 5. In the tombs,
也發現器物都是5個一組。 在古蜀文化中,也有古蜀王“五丁力士”的故事。 utensils are also found in groups of 5. In the ancient Shu culture, there is also the story of the ancient Shu king "Wu Ding Li Shi".
同是五輻太陽輪的,在古埃及壁畫中曾有發現,兩個狒狒與聖甲蟲一起膜拜代表太陽神的五輻太陽輪。 The same five-spoke sun wheel was found in ancient Egyptian murals. Two baboons and scarabs worshipped the five-spoke sun wheel representing the sun god.
以上,只是對三星堆文明源頭的一種探討,一種猜測,距離歷史的真相還有相當長的一段距離。 The above is just a discussion and speculation on the origin of Sanxingdui civilization, and there is still a long distance from the truth of history.
歡迎大家說出自己的觀點,共同探討,大膽想像,尊重史實。 Everyone is welcome to express their views, discuss together, imagine boldly, and respect historical facts.
關於三星堆文明的產生與消亡,史學界也並沒有共識。 據考證,三星堆文明的逐漸消亡的原因是水患, There is no consensus among historians on the origin and demise of Sanxingdui civilization. According to research, the reason for the gradual demise of Sanxingdui civilization was the flood. After
一場大洪水之後,三星堆的居民慢慢散居開來,逐漸被原住民同化,或被中國北方黃河文明征服。 a major flood, the residents of Sanxingdui gradually dispersed, gradually assimilated by the aborigines, or conquered by the Yellow River civilization in northern China.
距離三星堆不遠的涼山彝族人,被認為是最有可能與三星堆人有淵源的民族,從服飾, The Liangshan Yi people, not far from Sanxingdui, are considered to be the most likely ethnic group to have a relationship with the Sanxingdui people. From clothing,
相貌,民族風俗,圖騰標識都與三星堆有著太多的相似之處,具體分析,請關注下一個視頻! appearance, ethnic customs, and totem logos, they have too many similarities with Sanxingdui. For specific analysis, please pay attention to the following a video!
好,今天的視頻就分享到這裡,歡迎您的觀看,我們下次再見! Well, today's video is shared here, you are welcome to watch it, see you next time!
