ครึ่งหนึ่งของเพลงใหม่มาจาก AI แต่... ผู้ฟังก็เช่นกัน

NTD Thai
154 followers
1 Video View·Nov 14, 2026
© สงวนลิขสิทธิ์ทุกประการ
AI Generated·May contain errors
In the latest episode, we discussed the case of Anthropic.
Just settled a civil lawsuit worth $1.5 billion.
Due to the unauthorized download of millions of books for use in training
Their own AI
That constitutes the highest-value copyright infringement settlement in U.S. history to date.
More than 30 music companies have filed a class-action lawsuit.
Accused of having violated
I downloaded the lyrics illegally from a torrent website.
The same group and deliberately
Clear the copyright information.
To input the aforementioned data into the system and use it to train the AI
This new case may determine the fate of
Will the live music industry continue to exist in the next generation?
or must we sink amidst the musical debris created by
AI for sure
Let's get to the point.
But first, don't forget to like and follow me, please.
To help YouTube's algorithm
Share this video to help more people see it.
Thank you very much.
When pierced...
Delve into the details of the case involving Anthropic
It was found that a lawsuit was filed on August 28.
by Sony Music Publishing and Warner Chappell
Music in collaboration with over 30 music production companies
which have all filed a civil lawsuit in the state of California against
Anthropic and the company's management team
The complaint states that Anthropic
Violation of United States copyright law as follows
Using Torrent
Retrieve lyrics data and download lyrics from tens of thousands of copyrighted songs
Songs
To train AI
In the chord family
Music publishers are demanding damages potentially reaching into the billions of dollars.
Because they are seeking compensation at a maximum rate of up to per song
150,000 dollars
We have spoken with Mr. Kirk Simon.
Head of Legal for Innovation
and is a founding partner of Kledan Company.
which is a law office located in Washington, D.C.
Specializing in intellectual property, AI, and technology law
And we asked him about this new music-related lawsuit.
How is it related to the previous agreement?
In the agreement, Anthropic
Accused of downloading more than seven million books
Without authorization, and some volumes also hold copyright on the lyrics.
It seems there are signs of the idea that
Data is being retrieved from the internet, which is also undesirable.
The new trend we have observed is
The copyright holder is not merely objecting to downloading without permission.
such as through the BitTorrent protocol only
However, there is an additional issue regarding the extraction of data from public online sources.
Although they might be permitted to use that data.
Yet it was used in a manner beyond the scope of the authorized rights.
Therefore, in this regard
It is somewhat more delicate than it was before.
But of course one might imagine that
Within that ancient community
Some of this content should probably be included as well.
It's quite difficult to say for certain.
Because this matter has mostly been kept secret by Anthropic.
And the final fact he mentioned was
In fact, it was referenced by the plaintiff in the complaint as follows:
The copyright holders of the songs are still unaware of the true extent of the defendant's copyright infringement.
Through unauthorized distribution of works via the Torrent system
or aware of all the methods by which the defendant used the copyrighted work obtained through infringement.
Because the defendant still concealed crucial details regarding their wrongful conduct.
In addition to the issue regarding intellectual property infringement
The market share of generative AI continues to grow steadily.
In terms of income generated from streaming services as well.
Every time music is streamed through the application,
Spotify or Pandora
Singers, songwriters, and music creators will receive royalty payments.
For the royalties, which originate from advertisements viewed by listeners, this is merely a cycle inherent to the business model; however, the songs created by
AI and the influx of power entering these applications
While simultaneously reaping the benefits from royalty payments.
For example, Deezer reported that
It is the first time a song created by AI
More than half of all newly uploaded songs on the platform
In June 2026, a song created with AI
The production cost is almost negligible, yet it can compete with songs created by artists who spent several months composing and recording.
which Mr. Simon believes is a key factor leading to this lawsuit
To be honest, one of the more interesting aspects of this story is
Many are concerned that, in the end, works of this nature will not be of good quality.
To truly compete with music, film, and other forms of media.
We are already beginning to see signs of this from Model Suno.
including a large number of songs created by AI that have appeared on Spotify
This represents a major risk for these music companies.
And this is likely one of the many ways they have attempted to retaliate.
What they perceive as a threat
They could even destroy their entire industry system.
The most recent example of one case illustrates how easy it is.
One could say as much regarding these songs created with AI.
Use it to earn income by undermining real artists.
In March, the U.S. Department of Justice announced that Michael
Smith pleaded guilty to charges of producing hundreds of thousands of songs using AI.
Then use bots to inflate the streaming numbers of those songs.
There will be several billion hits.
With the vision of a true entrepreneur
He has completely removed humanity from this equation.
One robot
which is an AI robot that composes music.
Another robot was also listening to the music.
Furthermore
The robot also listened to the advertisement before starting to play the song.
which constitutes fraud against advertisers and ultimately harms the platform as a whole.
The prosecutor stated that
The aforementioned operation generated revenue through copyright fee fraud.
Over 8 million dollars
And here is the opinion of our new National Intelligence Director regarding this case.
Although the song and the listener are fake
The millions of dollars that Smith stole were real.
Millions of dollars in royalties that Smith embezzled from the artists
the rightful owner of the copyright deserves
Smith has revealed his daring plan.
He was found guilty of federal criminal charges.
Fraud using AI
Smith has not yet received a verdict or sentence.
The charge of electronic fraud to which he confessed
Maximum penalty is imprisonment for 5 years.
Furthermore, Smith also agreed to reimburse the amount of money
Another 8 million dollars as well.
Another issue that music artists are currently facing is
Generative AI technology
You can use the artist's recorded audio files to create a new set of recordings.
The voice is astonishingly similar to the original artist's that it's almost indistinguishable.
For example, the song "Heart on My Sleeve"
It is a song written and produced by an anonymous TikTok user.
Using the account name Ghostwriter977
Using sound
AI-generated audio recording
Got it. Here's the translation in a style reminiscent of Drake and Weeknd's vocal tone—smooth, introspective, with a touch of melancholy and urban cool:
The song was created using
AI simulates the voices of the two artists.
In 2023, this song became immensely popular and went viral.
It was previously available for listening on Spotify.
And Apple Music was at a certain point in time
Before ultimately being removed due to copyright issues.
Nevertheless, in that short period of time
This song has become extremely popular, soaring in popularity.
Eventually becoming a widespread sensation, to the point of receiving consideration.
Nominated for both the Grammy Award for Best Instrumental Composition and the Grammy Award for Song of the Year.
because there is the idea that it was written by a human who merely used
AI only adjusts the singing voice.
This issue has sparked widespread debate and become a major topic in the music industry.
Regarding the ethical and legal aspects related to music created by
AI and artists' rights in the form of vocal performances
The aforementioned dispute has prompted some celebrities and singers to attempt trademark registrations.
To one's own voice
Which is something Matthew McConaughey has also done.
When he trademarked the catchphrase that was characteristic of him
Lights on, lights on, lights on. I'm the one speaking, but don't report me, okay?
I'm just a journalist here to bring you the news.
Taylor Swift
It was carried out in the same manner last April.
Her team has filed a trademark registration application.
to the United States Patent and Trademark Office
For her two audio clips
And one more photo of herself.
They filed a patent to protect the sound and image of Taylor Swift.
which constitutes a meticulously planned legal strategy
and is a proactive measure to prevent the use of AI
Let's create a deepfake video or song
Mimic her voice and appearance in the future
It represents a new form of legal strategy.
We'll have to wait and see whether it will actually work or not.
Because this matter has never before been tested in court.
Moreover, it is still unclear whether it will be achievable or not.
Because she filed the petition back in April until now
It has already reached September.
Trademark for the sound and image of Taylor Swift
It has not yet been approved.
Therefore, we'll just have to wait and see which direction this situation will take.
We asked Mr. Simon about his opinion regarding celebrities registering trademarks for their personal image, identity, and voice, and this is what Mr. Simon stated.
For this group of artists, certainly
Their music and film repertoire is also a significant aspect.
Because surely no one would want songs to be taken up by
Taylor Swift is going to teach AI
Her name is frequently mentioned throughout this story.
Especially in the news reports concerning the aforementioned case
Even more than that
There is another aspect that is completely different.
Although it is not a matter of copyright regarding your work.
But it is what we call NIL.
Name, Image, and Likeness
or your rights to your name, image, and likeness
which is considered to be of immense value
That is another distinct aspect for these models.
Because these models are so skilled at creating what people call
Deepfake
or realistic audio images of spoken language, for example
Therefore, in these various cases, although there are some differences in details,
But the main concern is the same issue.
That means you have an enormous amount of my data.
I have many of my works in my hands.
And if I don't do something right now
I'm afraid you might
Item A
Secretly cutting off the opportunity for me to earn royalties from the use of my work by others
Just like the case of song lyrics
Item B learns how to come and compete against me.
That is something to be concerned about.
or option C
Use his good reputation to market low-quality products.
I don't like that either.
Currently, there is no government-level legislation regulating voice cloning.
AI
However, at the local level, many states are implementing concrete measures.
To protect the intellectual property rights of artists residing in those states.
For example
In 2024, the state of Tennessee passed a law called the Elvis Act.
which grants legal property rights to individuals regarding their own voice
This law helps protect artists in the state of Tennessee.
Due to having my voice illegally synthesized and used without my permission
Regarding the term "Elvis" in the Elvis Act
It is an abbreviation referring to the protection of the appearance's security.
Voice and image of a person
Before this law was enacted
The Tennessee state law regarding the right to exploit the state's image provides protection only for the name.
Photos and appearance of individuals only
But this new law clearly states that the voice
It is also considered an asset protected accordingly.
Nevertheless, the aforementioned law aims to address those who attempt to seek commercial gain.
Pretending that a voice generated by AI is a real voice by using someone else's voice.
For example
Creating songs using the voices of artists from the state of Tennessee
And make it sound exactly like the artist's real voice.
The law clearly states that
Does not cover the use of others' voices or appearances.
For social critique, satire
Comedy performance or any other similar entertainment
State of Tennessee
It is not just one state that is conducting itself in this manner.
There are still eight other states that have enacted laws similar to this law.
This Elvis as well
Although the state of Pennsylvania has some differing aspects.
In places where the state's laws stipulate the use of AI to imitate voices.
To defraud or cause harm to others
It constitutes a criminal offense.
In 2024, a study was conducted pursuant to CISAC's mandate.
which has been referred to as the first global study of its kind
delving into the study results
Economic impacts of applying AI in the music industry
For further information, the term CISAC stands for
International Confederation of Societies of Authors and Composers
International Federation of Authors and Composers
Basically, this organization is akin to a non-profit organization.
Responsible for protecting the rights of creators worldwide
including artists and musicians as well
According to CISAC's research on current trends
within the next two years
Songs created by AI may account for approximately 20% of revenue.
Revenue from traditional music streaming platforms
It is forecasted that the market value will exceed
$16 billion U.S. dollars by 2028
At the same time, this situation may affect the income of music creators up to
24%, equivalent to a value of over 1 billion U.S. dollars
Certainly, if you can perceive these trends.
So you're proficient in computer science.
And has the quick wit to discern what works and what doesn't.
Here it is, he told you that in the past 2
The following year will be a segment of the market that is growing.
If AI were to take a dominant role in the music industry
This trend will continue as predicted.
It would indeed be interesting to see how it will ultimately affect various activities.
such as live performances, concerts, and music festivals
which is something that countless people have counted on
If there are most popular songs or a large group
Created by AI
Using only AI tools
Will people go out to watch live performances again?
Will those things continue to proceed as they are?
But I think that for one group, there will still be artists performing live.
Those will continue to exist, sir.
Then what exactly will people be willing to pay money for?
They will pay money to see what from an AI artist
Conversely, concerts may be held in unconventional and unpredictable formats.
For example
Using animated characters appearing on the screen to represent music on stage
We'll just have to wait and see how it turns out.
Moreover, one thing that cannot be avoided is
There will be efforts to register and protect works created by
AI
Which is the ultimate logical irony.
When AI creators attempt to register copyright
Copyright the work created by one's own AI
To prevent others from stealing and using those works
It is a highly interesting situation, and fundamentally speaking
I view this as a threat to the survival of the music industry.
At the same level as the events during the year 2000
including Morpheus, Kazaa, and various torrent websites
which created loopholes allowing people to illegally download music
Just like Napster did
That was truly a defining moment in the history of the music industry.
But tight...
Of course, in the end they managed to recover.
Along with the rise of services such as Spotify,
Pandora, Apple Music, and similar platforms
But isn't this a brand-new change, isn't it?
Regarding music created by AI
Some of them turned out incredibly impressive.
For the past two months or so, whenever I listen to music on YouTube
The system will automatically play the next song after the first one ends, there's something like that.
Maybe 7 to 8 times that I listened
I listen to the song and suddenly think, Hey, this track is actually awesome.
Actually, it's like this song is permanently stuck in my head.
It's incredibly touching, with the perfect blend of emotion, atmosphere, and melody.
But when trying to find out who the artist is, I couldn't find any information.
Then it suddenly occurred to me—oh, right, this is a song created by AI.
There isn't a single real artist behind it at all.
It would probably just be the creators of works that use AI, that's all.
But the vocal performances, vocal synthesis, and production work
It's fully equipped; everything is right there.
As I mentioned, I simply can't picture it at all.
How excellent will AI-generated songs be by the year 2028?
Well, the current situation is just as you can see.
Feel free to share your thoughts on what you think.
with the changes occurring in this music industry
And don't forget to like and subscribe as well, please.
I haven't pressed it yet, see you next time, Romance, the show host.
From another perspective, I ask that everyone be provided with information and news, and most importantly, be given the opportunity to confess.
