Welcome to China in Focus, I'm Tiffany Meyer
Our top story: an unprecedented meeting just hours
away, the leaders of the U.S., Russia
and China are set to sit down together, but will each of
them gain from the meeting? Nvidia says it has stopped shipping
its licensed Hopper
AI data center products
to China despite having Washington's approval. Plus, how
China's tech giant Tencent says the latest
U.S. chip restrictions will affect its business
NVIDIA's board has ruled out Jensen Huang's return as CEO.
Meanwhile, new details emerge about Alice Huang,
the alleged Chinese spy
and woman Jensen Huang admitted to having an affair with.
An investigation found that her husband built
a vast network of China-based data centers backed by Beijing.
And a police raid in a warehouse just dozens of miles from Los Angeles.
The target was an illegal Chinese network for distributing vapes.
A historic summit meeting in a couple of hours.
President Trump will sit down with Russia's Putin
and China's Xi Jinping together for the first time.
What's at stake? Take a look.
I'm here in Shenzhen, China for APEC.
The upcoming meeting between Trump and Xi comes
with a new potential flashpoint.
U.S. restrictions designed to stop Chinese
companies from accessing
the most advanced AI chips through overseas data centers.
Beijing has condemned the move
and has warned of retaliation if U.S. proceeds with those
restrictions.
That is likely to limit expectations
for a breakthrough between Trump and Xi meeting.
The Trump-Xi-Putin meeting,
the trilateral meeting is even more striking than the Trump-Xi
meeting.
It's going to be an extraordinary picture,
leaders from U.S., Russia and China at one
table.
Not necessarily for a forum for quick agreements, but for optics.
For Trump, he can project his deal-making diplomacy.
For Xi, he can showcase China as a central global power.
And Putin, it can be a profile
of him returning back to the great power politics.
They can talk about Iran-Ukraine war
alongside broader AI security concerns.
And they can also talk about nuclear risk and arms control.
about this arms control is that China has resisted joining
this arms control framework
with U.S. and Russia.
And North Korea can be part of this trilateral conversation
from sanctions related to, you
know, North Korean nuclear weapons to,
you know, North Korea's close relationship with
Moscow.
Then attention is now turning to Kim Jong-un, the North Korean leader.
There is speculation that he could come to China to meet with Trump.
More recently, he was inspecting a new ski resort.
near the Chinese border, fueling, you know,
another speculation that he could just cross
into China to, you know, travel down here to meet with Trump.
There's no confirmed plan so far for his attendance
or a potential meeting Trump.
But Trump has floated the idea of meeting Kim.
China said, you know, it has no information
so far about a potential meeting between the
North Korean and U.S. leaders.
But, you know, U.S. Secretary
of State Marco Rubio said Trump is prepared for.
...for a dialogue with Pyongyang,
and he's very serious about engaging with North Korea.
NVIDIA's board says it does not intend
to bring Jensen Huang back as CEO.
Board Chair Harvey Jones made
that clear during yesterday's earnings call.
NVIDIA's Chief Financial Officer Colette Kress
is serving as interim CEO
while the board searches for a permanent replacement.
Meanwhile, NVIDIA also posted third-quarter revenue
of nearly $116 billion, more than a double a year earlier.
The company expects next quarter's revenue to top estimates.
NVIDIA shares rose over 3% in after-hours trading following the news.
NVIDIA is no longer shipping licensed
Hopper AI data center products to China.
That's despite having the United States approval to do so.
The company's interim CEO, Colette Kress,
announced it on Tuesday in an earnings call.
She didn't explain why.
The product line includes H200 AI chips,
which are two generations behind the most advanced ones,
but still very powerful in training AI models.
The change comes after NVIDIA sold over $2 billion worth of licensed
Hopper data center products to China in the third quarter this year.
It also marks a shift in a company that has
been pushing to sell more advanced AI chips to China.
Former NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang pushed hard to sell H200 chips to China.
His lobbying led to U.S. easing export controls on those chips.
But Huang's extramarital affair put NVIDIA
in a public relations crisis.
Days after the media reported
on his affair with a suspected Chinese spy
and two NVIDIA employees, Huang resigned as CEO.
The suspected Chinese spy, Alice Huang, is a former executive
at Megaspeed, a Singapore-based technology company.
The U.S. is now investigating Megaspeed
for allegedly helping send hundreds of thousands
of advanced AI chips to China, which the company denies.
Chinese firms have been using some
companies in Southeast Asia to get around
U.S. restrictions on advanced AI chips. While Washington
bars Chinese companies from buying top NVIDIA chips,
they can still rent computing power from
data centers in Malaysia, Thailand, and Singapore,
where those chips can be legally purchased.
Washington is closing this loophole.
The Commerce Department on Monday said it would require companies
to apply for licenses before selling advanced AI chips to Indonesia,
Malaysia, Singapore, Thailand and Brazil,
though companies headquartered in the U.S. will get exemptions.
Malaysia's trade minister saying Wednesday that its data
center operations should comply with new U.S. restrictions.
China's Tencent Holdings said new U.S. restrictions would
not substantially hurt its cloud revenue,
though they would likely slow development of its next AI model.
A new Wall Street Journal investigation found
that Alice Huang's husband built a huge network
of data center projects in China,
backed by the Chinese Communist Party, with plans to
invest more than $9 billion.
A billion dollars.
According to the journal, Conway's business
network partnered with Chinese tech giant
Huawei and pursued major data center projects across China.
This is the husband of the alleged Chinese spy,
Alice Huang, who Jensen Huang admitted
to having an affair with.
One of her husband, Kang's,
projects in Anhui province alone was valued at $4.5 billion
with local government support for electricity and infrastructure.
Kang also reportedly introduced his wife,
Alice, to former NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang,
whom he had known for years through the video game industry.
Meanwhile, Alice Huang's company, Megaspeed,
secured access to NVIDIA's advanced chips,
some of which reportedly reached China.
The Journal says it found no evidence
that those chips ended up in Kang's data centers.
Reports emerged on Tuesday that on October 30th,
California's Ontario Police Department
and U.S. Federal Homeland Security investigation officials raided
a warehouse in the city of Chino, east of Los Angeles.
That warehouse appeared to be at the center
of a major illegal Chinese vape distribution network.
Law enforcement at the warehouse found what appeared
to be some 850,000 legit and counterfeit
vapes. The Ontario police recounted
that a worker present during the raid said the factory began
operating this year. And among the products found there
were those belonging to the Chinese brands
Geek Bar and Fogar. They are widely popular in the U.S.,
even though the FDA has explicitly
warned companies against importing
or selling Geek Bar and Fogar products.
The raid puts into the spotlight China's massive role
in the vaping industry as a whole.
Back in December 2021,
Chinese authorities reported that China produced around 95%
of the world's vaping products.
Much of that is also fueling the black market.
British American Tobacco estimates that illicit vapes account
for around 70% of all U.S. vape sales.
The Chino warehouse raid raises many questions.
Was this part of a Chinese scheme
to get around Trump's tariffs with Made in America loopholes?
Was this part of some collaboration between Chinese business
and Mexican organized crime?
After all, Mexican cartels, including the Sinaloa cartel,
have a history of doing business with Chinese
e-vape manufacturers to make profit.
A spotlight on religious persecution
in China from Pennsylvania's capital.
State Senator Doug Mastriano hosting an event on Tuesday
in Harrisburg featuring Falun Gong practitioners and others
who are targeted by the Chinese Communist Party for their beliefs.
The state senator explains what disturbed him the most.
The testimony of William and his story about what he experienced
in the slave labor camp, it was just, it's horrific to me.
He talked about his body being burned because of the,
you know, the ovens he was by, the machines he was by.
The starvation, the isolation, the psychological breakdown,
and possibly, you know, being considered for organ harvesting.
This is sick to me, because all men
and women have the right by God to be free people,
and no government has the right
to tell you what you can and can't believe.
Speakers included William Pong,
who spent five years in a Chinese prison over his faith in Falun Gong.
Mastriano says one speaker described seeing products he made
in a labor camp for sale in an American store.
And a doctor from a group that fights forced organ harvesting
and a former Chinese lawyer who now lives in Pennsylvania also spoke.
Last year, Mastriano introduced
a state resolution condemning Beijing's persecution of Falun Gong
and its repression of people living here in the U.S.
He says he'll reintroduce it when the new session begins in January.
Closer trade ties with China and growing pushback.
Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney's push
for a strategic partnership with China
is drawing criticism at home.
Opposition lawmakers are raising concerns about security
and Beijing's human rights record.
This is Chinese territory, end of quote.
That is what a man told a peaceful protester outside
the Chinese consulate in Toronto
after he shoved her and kicked the woman.
He said, I can shoot you dead, end of quote.
Beijing no longer even attempts to conceal its intimidation.
It blocks Tiananmen Square memorials.
Its ambassador issues orders
to Canadian parliamentarians not to visit Taiwan.
It operates 18 illegal police stations right here in Canada,
yet the government remains silent.
When will the government stop appeasing
this terrible totalitarian regime?
And when will this government put an end to transnational
repression right here in Canada against Canadian citizens?
The criticism follows Carney's announcement that Canada will ease
tariffs on 32 more categories of Chinese steel and aluminum.
In return, Beijing is cutting roughly $400 million
in duties on Canadian pork and seafood.
Now, the government says the visit is delivering real gains
for Canadian farmers and exporters,
but one opposition leader accused Beijing of modern slavery
and even genocide against the Uyghurs and the Tibetans.
And conservatives point out that Carney himself called China Canada's
biggest national security threat during last year's election.
Coming up, a summit with Trump, Putin and Xi is just around the corner.
China affairs analyst Bradley Thayer weighs
in on the global balance of power.
More on that after the break here on China In Focus.
Welcome back to China In Focus. I'm Tiffany Meyer.
In an unprecedented three-way meeting
with President Trump, Putin, and Xi Jinping,
many factors are playing a role affecting the summit.
For more analysis, NTD's Kerry Dunst was joined
by Bradley Thayer, a founding member of the
Committee on Present Danger, China.
Thayer is the author of America's 100 Years War,
How to Win Against Communism,
and co-author of Understanding the China Threat.
Let's start with your overall impressions of this NVIDIA scandal.
It has so many elements to it.
It does indeed have so many elements,
but I think the key thing to focus on as we review the scandal,
the depths of the scandal, is that Jensen Wong is an individual
who has a very close relationship with the Chinese Communist Party.
I think that he's got the ability,
the fact that they're able to access him.
Through this woman is quite alarming, but the deep problem
is NVIDIA chips are getting to communist China and they're getting
to communist China through media, whether those are shell companies
or other means that Jensen Wong must have known about.
So there has to be an investigation.
into him and to NVIDIA in some detail.
Lastly, I would suspect that when it comes to other tech firms,
we're going to find the same problem.
We're going to find that the Chinese Communist Party's influence
has reached the leadership of those tech firms.
And there's a similar, if you will, warm relationship
between the leaders of those firms.
And the Chinese Communist Party.
So this is a deep problem.
And I'm afraid that he's the tip of the iceberg.
It's certainly something that as these investigations proceed,
more will be revealed.
I do want to pivot a bit now
to President Trump's agenda while in China.
Does the stop in the Philippines with the Quad
and the ASEAN partners help set the tone
for his next days of meetings when he arrives in China?
It did indeed. It was a masterclass in diplomacy.
What President Trump did was the following. First,
by meeting with President Marcos of the Philippines,
he reassured the Filipinos that
the United States is a Pacific nation standing
with the Philippines against the efforts by the
Chinese Communist Party to coerce the states of the South China Sea,
including the Philippines,
where that coercion is most acute.
As the CCP violates Filipino sovereignty.
Second, the meeting with the Quad was so important.
As your report identified, new organizations were created,
including the Quad Business Leaders Forum,
which is going to be very valuable in ensuring
that technology does not reach communist China.
But also because in the photo opportunity
with other Quad leaders, President Trump
mentioned that the United States
was about 10 months away from closing its vulnerability
to rare earths processing,
which Communist China has basically de facto a monopoly on
rare earth processing.
So the U.S. is 10 months away from breaking that.
And removing that vulnerability, that was a very important step.
That remark was extremely important.
And then finally, of course, the Quad met in Manila, not in...
One of the states that comprise the Quad,
Australia, Japan, India, or the United States,
that was a strong signal, again,
to the states of Southeast Asia, the states on the South
China Sea, that the Quad nations are standing
with them against communist China.
All right. Yeah. And certainly on a two-stop trip,
I was wondering, you know, why didn't he go to Japan
or one of the more obvious places that he goes?
And I think that really reveals why the Philippines was chosen.
Moving on to now his moving to China to have these meetings with Xi
and then also to expand that out to Putin, where does he have leverage
and where does he have gaps in negotiation? You point out
his comment 10 months away from having all the rare earths we need.
Thank
It seemed like just a few months ago we were years away,
now we're 10 months, so certainly
very interesting as they go into these high-stakes negotiations.
Very important. So President Trump comes to China
with a bounce in his step, and rightfully so,
because of the meetings that he had with Marcos
you.
and with the Quad leaders
and the agreements that were reached there.
So when he's meeting with Xi and Putin,
President Trump is really in a position of considerable power.
He's got the cards, not Xi Jinping,
whose economy is obviously in the doldrums
and who is doing everything he can to purge his own party.
He's facing, of course, obviously,
he's got tremendous domestic problems, both with the
Chinese Communist Party and economic problems.
And there's Vladimir Putin, right?
What is Putin doing there?
Putin has really very little economic might.
What Russia has is nuclear weapons in abundance.
And conventional capabilities, some conventional military capabilities.
So the three leaders are not equals.
There's a tremendous gap in power between Putin,
Xi Jinping, and President Trump.
Whether Trump and Putin will be able
to advance some type of an agreement to end the war that
exists between Russia and Ukraine is certainly something
that would be welcome if on humanitarian
grounds alone, given the horrific nature of that conflict.
And you'll remember, of course,
the audience may recall that President Trump did mention
in his remarks at the Quad meeting in Manila
that last month there were 32,000 killed,
32,000 individuals killed alone in October.
So that war is a horrific conflict and it needs to end.
And we'll see whether this meeting allows that to occur.
However, as a final note.
We want to bear in mind, Xi Jinping wants that war to continue.
The longer that war goes on, the tighter his grip on Vladimir Putin is.
So three leaders meeting on equal power
and with very different interests.
Yeah, it will be fascinating for sure.
And as you bring up the point on human life
and the loss of life in that Russia-Ukraine war,
I'd like to finish up.
We have about 30 seconds just for you to comment on human rights
and where, if at all, they get a place in these discussions.
Well, I would hope that President Trump does bring up
the human rights issues,
the gross human rights abuses that the Chinese Communist Party is
occurring against the Chinese people.
Communist parties everywhere wage war against their own
people, and the Chinese Communist Party is no exception.
They've been waging war
against the Chinese people since before they came to power in 1949.
The gross human rights abuses,
whether that's in Xinjiang or religious freedom or so many other
areas, needs attention.
And it needs sustained attention from world leaders like President
Trump. So let us hope that that is an issue that's raised.
That's all for today's China In Focus.
I'm Tiffany Meyer.
If you have any feedback on the show
or have something you'd like to see us cover,
send us an email at
[email protected].
We'd love to hear from you.
For on-the-clock original news coverage,
visit us at ntd.com or download our NTD app.
Thanks for watching.
See you tomorrow.