Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

TOWNSEND — A federal judge has granted an injunction and temporary restraining order against the town’s decisions in three Town Meeting warrant articles meant to recoup the costs of multiple lawsuits the town clerk filed against the town.

U.S. District Court Judge Allison Burroughs granted a motion by Town Clerk Harrison Mayotte, for now preventing the town from implementing the provisions in Articles 1-3 from the Nov. 10 special Town Meeting. Article 1 was a vote to transfer $41,000 from the fiscal 2027 town clerk salary line item to the legal expenses line item, reflecting the total cost to that point the town had incurred from defending against three lawsuits Mayotte had filed against the town this year. Mayotte has a salary of $71,795.

Article 2, which was voted on first, was a vote to reduce Mayotte’s salary to $30,795 by adjusting the rest of his paychecks for the year. During the Town Meeting it was noted that Mayotte had been paid approximately $25,000 of his annual salary by that point, which would have left him with approximately $5,000 spread out across the remainder of his paychecks until the end of June.

Articles 1 and 2 were citizen petition articles brought forward by Townsend resident Dawn Priest. Article 3 was put forward by the Select Board and was meant to change the town clerk position from an elected role to one that is appointed by the board. The passage of the article only began the home rule petition process, meaning the issue still would have to go through the state Legislature for approval, which would take some time.

In her 15-page decision, Burroughs said the Town Meeting articles passed in response to Mayotte’s lawsuits “impose extraordinary burdens on Mayotte’s right to petition,” and that he is likely to succeed on the claims he made against the town.

“By requiring Mayotte to personally bear the costs the Town has incurred as a result of his litigation, the challenged Articles create enormous coercive pressure on Mayotte to cease any further petitioning activity … Likewise, Article 3, which abolishes Mayotte’s elected position and replaces him with a town clerk appointed by the Select Board, has a similar coercive effect to the extent it punishes Mayotte for his past petitioning activity,” said Burroughs’ decision.

With that in mind, Burroughs said the warrant articles “implicate protected First Amendment rights,” and later that “The Town has offered nothing to rebut the resulting presumption of irreparable harm.”

Through the decision Burroughs ordered that the town cannot implement any of the three warrant articles until at least the conclusion of Mayotte’s term in 2029, or until the order is dissolved.

In a statement sent to The Sun in response to the ruling, Mayotte said “the rule of law has prevailed.”

“The government cannot punish an American for seeking justice in a court of law, and constitutional rights do not disappear because a majority votes against them. This ruling reaffirms that the First Amendment protects the right to challenge government itself,” said Mayotte. “I am grateful for an independent federal judiciary and proud to live in a nation where even the government must answer to the Constitution. God bless these United States of America.”

In a statement Friday, the Select Board and the town’s legal representatives said the town is “disappointed and frustrated” with the court’s ruling on the motion for preliminary injunction.

“The Town is evaluating the Court’s opinion and weighing its options, including the possibility of challenging the decision on appeal or seeking reconsideration or clarification from the Court. The Town maintains its position that the actions taken by an overwhelming majority of voters present (more than two-thirds with respect to Articles 1 and 3) at the November 10, 2026 Special Town Meeting were not retaliatory,” said the board.

The special Town Meeting and federal lawsuit were the latest steps in a feud that has been ongoing for months between Mayotte and other town officials, starting with a lawsuit filed in April by Board of Health Chair Dr. Christian Roman-Ramirez, which Mayotte joined as a plaintiff intervenor.

Roman-Ramirez filed that lawsuit while alleging that the town had failed to respond in time to a public records request he had made in February. He later moved to allow the lawsuit to be dismissed after getting clarity that the records he requested, revolving account budgets for the town, did not exist because revolving accounts do not have budgets.

Despite Roman-Ramirez’s move to dismiss his lawsuit, it has since continued on with Mayotte as plaintiff intervenor.

Mayotte filed his second lawsuit in July in response to a July 7 Select Board agenda that originally included the items “Reassignment of Records Access Officer,” and “Use of ARPA funds for Records Access Officers (RAO) stipend,” which Mayotte believed to be retaliation for the first lawsuit. The agenda was amended before the meeting to remove those items, and in September the case was voluntarily dismissed by Mayotte.

The third lawsuit in Middlesex Superior Court was filed by Mayotte in October in response to an issue the morning of the Sept. 1 primary election, when the door to the Town Hall polling station was left locked for a period of time at the beginning of voting hours that day. Mayotte said he had sought security footage from the building from that time to see if any voters may have been turned away from the polls by the door being locked, but recordings were only able to be obtained from five out of nine cameras. Town Administrator Kieran Meehan told The Sun at the time that the footage from the other four cameras had been automatically overwritten due to the security system’s storage limitations, but that efforts were made to retrieve it.

On Thursday Burroughs ordered both parties in the federal lawsuit to come up with a joint schedule for the remainder of the case by Dec. 3

Original article