POUGHKEEPSIE – The Democratic majority of the Dutchess County Legislature quashed debate on a resolution to replace the Clerk of the Legislature this week, then passed it along party lines, except for Democrat Anna Shah, who opposed it. Democrat Randy Johnson was absent but expressed his discontent through a letter read by Legislator Shah. Republican Rob Faust was also absent, and Republican Doug McHoul abstained. With 13 Democrats voting in favor, Deputy Clerk Greg Totino, who also serves as a Fishkill Town Councilman, replaced Julie Shiroishi.
Before debate began on the resolution, Chairwoman Yvette Valdés Smith set specific rules. “The resolution is about the appointment of Greg Totino as Clerk,” she said. “Members may address the appointment, the candidate’s qualifications and its timing. Remarks questioning motives of members or details of personnel matters are not in order.” The chairwoman limited each member of the body to two opportunities to speak, the second of which could only happen after each member wanting to speak had their first opportunity.
The ruling sparked Assistant Minority Leader John Metzger to object. “I cannot support this resolution, especially when it’s tied to freedom of speech for sitting county legislators, who are the voice of the people.” He then apologized to his constituents, noting that Democrats were limiting the ability to debate. Minority Leader Mike Polasek pointed out that when Republicans controlled the legislature, they allowed Democrats to speak for hours during contentious debates, such as those over renovations at Dutchess Stadium.
Breaking away from fellow Democrats, Legislator Shah addressed the timing of the change. “We are in the midst of budget deliberations—reviewing amendments, balancing millions of dollars in public funds, confronting significant fiscal challenges, and weighing potential cuts to programs and services our constituents depend on. These are serious responsibilities with real consequences for the people we represent. They demand our full attention, sound judgment, and a willingness to put aside personal issues and political differences in the public interest.”
Shah, who was forced to speak at the podium during the time reserved for “public comment” because it went against the arbitrary rules put in place by the chairwoman, also said, “The Clerk serves at the pleasure of the Legislature as a whole, not at the pleasure of Chair Valdes Smith, Assistant Majority Leader Munn, or the Democratic caucus. The Clerk’s Office is supposed to be a neutral referee that ensures both the majority and the minority have equal access to records, timely amendment processing, and procedural fairness. When the Democratic caucus unilaterally replaces the Clerk mid-session, it erodes public confidence that the Clerk’s office and legislative process are fair and open to all.”
Shah read a statement from Poughkeepsie Legislator Randy Johnson, who opposed the move and said his words would have been harsher if he could have attended the meeting. “Having served 10 years on the Dutchess County Legislature, I know firsthand what this job is supposed to be about. I represent my constituents in the City of Poughkeepsie, not the party. That is why we are here—to represent our constituents. As leaders in our community, you have an obligation to the residents and taxpayers who placed their trust in you, not to a handful of individuals pushing their own personal agendas. Voters elected you because they believed in your integrity and trusted that you would think independently, rather than let others manipulate you. If you cannot stand on your own convictions, you have to ask yourselves why you are serving in these seats.” He continued, saying, “Going along with an unwarranted removal just to appease a few voices sets a dangerous precedent. When you blindly follow the herd instead of standing on principle, you risk facing the exact same treatment when it is no longer convenient for others to support you.”
Ahead of this week’s meeting, Mid-Hudson News asked Chairwoman Valdés Smith about the resolution that was covertly added to the agenda on Saturday. “The majority caucus is seeking to appoint a new clerk,” was the abrupt response, and she declined to expand despite being asked to explain.
Shiroishi tallied the votes on the resolution that replaced her, announced the tally; 13 yes, nine no, one abstention, and two lawmakers were absent. Following the announcement, the clerk stood up, walked off the dais, down the center aisle, and exited the chambers.
Shiroishi declined to comment on the termination.



Comments