Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Tensions are flaring in America’s Hometown ahead of Thanksgiving, as the town of Plymouth pushes back against claims from a Native American group that officials are interfering with its National Day of Mourning.

The United American Indians of New England (UAINE) is seeking a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction against Plymouth over allegations that the town is trying to break parts of a decades-old agreement for a National Day of Mourning event on Thanksgiving.

After UAINE filed emergency motions in Plymouth Superior Court on Monday and a contentious meeting on Tuesday, the town shot back against the claims in a statement on Wednesday.

“The Town has gone above and beyond to accommodate UAINE’s event,” the statement reads. “That includes facilitating accessible parking, assisting Elders, identifying locations for meals and extended observances, and coordinating with Police and Fire officials.”

“The Town has continuously demonstrated a willingness to address concerns, offer solutions, and make accommodations at every opportunity,” it adds. “These efforts reflect a genuine commitment to the event.”

Every Thanksgiving since 1970, Indigenous people and supporters gather at noon on Cole’s Hill to commemorate the National Day of Mourning before they march through town.

Instead of celebrating the arrival of the pilgrims and other European settlers, the group says the day is a “reminder of the genocide of millions of Native people, the theft of Native lands and the erasure of Native cultures.”

Under a 1998 agreement, town officials have helped facilitate the installation of a stage and sound system for UAINE to use at the gathering. The pact came after the annual event in 1997, as police pepper-sprayed and knocked people to the ground, arresting 25 participants on charges that were later dismissed.

UAINE sued the town last year, arguing it tried to do what the group claims officials are doing now. The day before Thanksgiving, though, the court ruled that the town had to facilitate the 2025 National Day of Mourning “consistent with historical practice after the 1998 Settlement Agreement.”

The group says it was informed that the Select Board voted last Tuesday to “cease compliance with the 1998 Settlement Agreement… leaving UAINE without a stage days before over a thousand individuals travel to attend…”

“We believe they are throwing up roadblocks,” UAINE co-leader Mahtowin Munro said in a statement. “They don’t want the tourists to see or hear Native Americans who are speaking about the true history of the Pilgrim invasion and resulting land theft and genocide of Wampanoag and other Native peoples.”

In its statement on Wednesday, the town admitted the stage issue is “unresolved” before adding that one is not required under the original 1998 agreement and that multiple alternatives have been offered—none of which UAINE has agreed to.

The group is also taking issue with the town allegedly altering its march route, arguing that officials are pushing them into the “far corner of a park,” making them “less noticeable.”

The town said that despite information that has been shared online, it has “not interfered with the route.” Rather, the town asked if the group would be interested in ending the event on property owned by the state Department of Conservation and Recreation, which “reflects UAINE’s proposed route.”

Officials say that this ending location would allow “dedicated space for buses to park and to load passengers and offers a location for organizers to distribute lunches.”

“The Town has not received any response to this suggestion from UAINE,” its statement reads. “The Town has not sought to mandate any changes to the route.”

The Select Board received an earful at its meeting Tuesday night, as residents supporting the Indigenous community sounded off over UAINE’s allegations.

Rita Fiorillo described the 1998 agreement as a promise that the town and police care about safety and admit that the “things that they did then were wrong,” referring to the 1997 clash. The resident then threatened to “bring a million people down here to ruin the Thanksgiving Day parade for the next 20 years,” if this year’s National Day of Mourning is messed with.

“Now we’re going to throw our big Thanksgiving Day parade, this giant show of pilgrims and whiteness and how everything is just so hunky-dory,” Fiorillo said. “And yes, the natives helped us, and everything’s great. You’re like dancing on their backs by doing that.”

She added, “The natives and their history is just as important as the right-wing … pilgrims in this town.”

Original article