A former elementary school principal was found not guilty of four sexual offense charges after his attorneys presented evidence that his accuser recanted and argued that the child’s family had an immigration-related motive for pursuing the allegations.

By yourNEWS Media Newsroom

A North Carolina jury acquitted former elementary school principal Daniel McInnis of all four sexual offense charges Thursday, Nov. 12, ending a nearly three-year legal battle in which defense attorneys argued that a student’s allegations were fabricated to help his undocumented immigrant family obtain U-visas and avoid deportation.

McInnis, 46, formerly served as principal of Eastlawn Elementary School in Burlington, North Carolina. He was charged in December 2023 after a 9-year-old student accused him of sexual assault inside a school bathroom. The allegations resulted in his removal from school leadership and criminal proceedings that his attorneys said severely damaged his professional reputation.

According to The Alamance News, jurors deliberated for approximately two hours before finding McInnis not guilty of statutory sexual offense with a child by an adult, sexual activity with a student, indecent liberties with a child and sexual battery.

The defense challenged the credibility of the allegations throughout the trial, citing inconsistencies in the child’s statements, a reported recantation and the absence of physical evidence supporting the accusations.

Attorneys John Cox and Lisa Dubs also presented evidence concerning the family’s pursuit of a U-visa, a federal immigration benefit available to qualifying crime victims who assist law enforcement.

The boy’s family had reportedly sought immigration assistance after the accusations were made. Defense attorneys argued that the prospect of obtaining legal immigration status provided a potential motive for falsely accusing McInnis.

The family’s immigration circumstances became a significant issue during the proceedings. According to local reporting on the trial, the defense maintained that the family was subject to an active deportation order and that the allegations could provide an avenue for remaining in the United States.

Prosecutors attempted to exclude testimony about the family’s immigration status and U-visa inquiries, arguing that the information was irrelevant. Superior Court Judge C. Douglas Green permitted the defense to introduce evidence concerning the visa application but prohibited references to the family’s alleged deportation order.

The defense also called immigration attorney Helen Parsonage to explain the U-visa program and its eligibility requirements.

The federal program, established under the Victims of Trafficking and Violence Protection Act of 2000, allows certain crime victims to apply for temporary immigration status if they suffered substantial physical or mental abuse and assisted authorities investigating or prosecuting qualifying criminal activity.

Under U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services requirements, applicants must obtain certification from an authorized law enforcement or government official. Approval can provide employment authorization and a potential pathway to permanent residency for eligible applicants and qualifying family members.

A criminal conviction is not required for a U-visa application to be approved. However, applicants must meet federal eligibility standards, and filing an application does not automatically provide immigration status.

McInnis’ attorneys argued that the child’s account changed during the investigation and that a former teacher subsequently learned the allegations were untrue.

Xavier Jones, who taught the student during the 2024-25 school year, testified that the boy told him on two occasions that he had fabricated the accusations against McInnis.

According to testimony detailed by The Alamance News, Jones also disputed the mother’s characterization of her son’s behavior following the alleged assault. The teacher described the student as socially active, with numerous friends, and said he had become a student leader in the classroom.

Prosecutors questioned Jones about his conclusions concerning McInnis’ innocence and whether he had approached the case with preconceived views.

The child’s mother, Tania Perez, testified that she learned of the alleged assault after her son experienced nightmares and that she subsequently sought legal assistance concerning the family’s immigration status.

Perez rejected the suggestion that obtaining immigration benefits was her priority, telling jurors she was prepared to face deportation.

“If I have to be deported, let it be,” she testified. She also stated, “I don’t care about that [U-Visa] anymore.”

The prosecution maintained that the child’s allegations were credible and relied partly on forensic interviews conducted after the accusations were reported. Defense attorneys challenged the interviewing procedures and argued that repeated questioning contributed to inconsistencies in the student’s statements.

McInnis had worked at Eastlawn Elementary since 2011 and became principal in 2012. He was suspended with pay in December 2023, and school officials subsequently recommended his dismissal.

He rejected a plea agreement that would have required him to plead guilty to a lesser offense, maintaining his innocence despite the possibility of a lengthy prison sentence if convicted.

Following the acquittal, FOX8 reported that McInnis’ attorneys described the extensive personal and professional consequences of the allegations.

“We got information that, at some point, the child had recanted, had taken it back. We went out and interviewed that teacher. It was the year later. The child had formed a close relationship with the teacher and told him that it didn’t happen and that he felt really bad because Mr. McInnis was really nice to him,” Dubs said.

The defense attorney said the evidence gathered during the investigation persuaded her that the accusations were unfounded.

“Just one thing after another sort of led to a clear conclusion for me that this was a false allegation,” she said.

McInnis received support throughout the proceedings from former colleagues, teachers and community members who attended court sessions.

“What really stood out to me was the support that Dan had in the community and … among the teachers who worked with him. We had people who came to support daily … who would be in the courtroom throughout the whole trial,” Dubs said.

His attorneys said one of McInnis’ first questions after the verdict concerned whether he would finally be permitted to attend his children’s activities, something restricted under the conditions of his pretrial release.

They also acknowledged uncertainty about whether he would return to education after spending years defending himself against the criminal allegations.

The case has drawn renewed scrutiny of the U-visa program and its potential vulnerability to fraudulent claims. However, the jury’s acquittal does not independently establish that the family deliberately fabricated the allegations to obtain immigration benefits, and publicly available reporting does not establish that immigration authorities approved the family’s application.

The criminal proceedings have concluded with McInnis cleared of all four charges. His attorneys said he is now focused on rebuilding his personal and professional life following nearly three years of legal uncertainty.

Original article