A new J.L. Partners analysis indicates that Republican losses in the 2026 midterm elections were driven more heavily by declining participation among President Donald Trump’s previous supporters than by voters switching to Democratic candidates.

By yourNEWS Media Newsroom

More than one-third of Americans who voted for President Donald Trump in 2024 did not participate in the Nov. 3 midterm elections, according to a new post-election survey that attributes much of the Republican Party’s congressional losses to declining turnout among its existing supporters.

The analysis by polling firm J.L. Partners found that 35% of Trump’s 2024 voters stayed home, compared with 8% who supported Democratic House candidates. The findings, reported Monday by the New York Post, suggest that Republican difficulties mobilizing previous supporters contributed more to the election results than defections to the opposing party.

The firm’s analysis was based on an Election Day survey of 1,000 registered voters, cross-checked against more than 30,000 interviews conducted throughout the campaign. Researchers calculated that lower turnout among Trump supporters accounted for approximately 10 percentage points of the 15-point national shift toward Democrats compared with 2024, while voters changing party preferences accounted for the remaining five points.

James Johnson, founding director of J.L. Partners, said the findings demonstrated the importance of voter participation to Republican electoral performance.

“Even without a single voter switching, the GOP would have lost the Senate and House,” Johnson said. “That is how important turnout was at this election.”

The survey identified particularly substantial declines in participation among several groups that supported Trump in 2024. Among his previous voters without college degrees, 46% did not vote in the midterms. The nonparticipation rate was 44% among supporters older than 65 and 39% among those living in rural communities.

Those results indicate that reduced participation extended across demographic groups that have provided substantial support for Republican candidates.

Johnson cautioned against interpreting the election results solely as evidence that voters had permanently abandoned the Republican Party.

“The GOP should not throw the MAGA baby out with the bathwater just yet,” he said. “If Republicans can energize their 2024 vote in 2028, then they may yet have a shot at winning again.”

The findings also provide additional context for disagreements among Republican leaders about the causes of the party’s losses.

Trump has argued that Republican candidates suffered because he was not personally on the ballot, despite encouraging his supporters to participate in the midterms. Johnson said the president’s presence as a candidate would likely have affected Republican turnout.

“If Trump was on the ballot, you would have expected a better result,” Johnson told the newspaper.

Vice President JD Vance offered a different explanation following the election, arguing that Republican losses were driven primarily by voters switching their support to Democratic candidates rather than declining turnout.

“The main problem is not turnout,” Vance wrote on X the day after the election.

Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis also addressed Republican participation, suggesting that dissatisfaction with the party’s performance in Congress contributed to the decision by some supporters not to vote.

“A lot of our voters who stayed home, they stayed home because they were frustrated with the lack of productivity from Republicans in the House and Senate. That’s just a fact,” DeSantis said during an appearance on Fox News.

Although the J.L. Partners findings emphasize turnout, the survey also documented defections among voters who supported Trump in 2024.

Approximately 8% backed Democratic congressional candidates this year, with the rate rising to 16% among Trump supporters younger than 30.

Those who changed parties tended to be younger, male, nonwhite and urban, reflecting demographic groups in which Trump had expanded his support during the 2024 presidential election.

However, the survey found that many of these voters continued to express favorable views of Republicans. Half of the respondents who switched to Democratic candidates reported a favorable opinion of the Republican Party, while 41% approved of Trump’s performance as president.

The research also examined Democratic voters’ motivations. According to the survey, 48% described their midterm vote primarily as opposition to Trump rather than support for Democratic policy proposals.

When asked whether Democrats had a candidate prepared to lead the party in the 2028 presidential election, only 30% of registered voters answered yes. Among Democratic respondents, 29% said the party did not have a candidate ready for the next presidential contest.

Economic concerns remained prominent among voters, with the cost of living identified as the leading issue. Johnson suggested that dissatisfaction surrounding economic conditions, including the effects of the Iran war, may have contributed to the election results.

The J.L. Partners survey had an overall margin of error of 3.4 percentage points. Findings involving the 87 respondents who switched from Trump to Democratic candidates carried a substantially larger margin of error of 10.5 percentage points.

Other post-election research has also identified both declining Republican participation and Democratic gains among former Trump voters, although estimates of their relative importance differ.

A Nov. 13 survey by Cygnal, involving 3,000 midterm voters, concluded that reduced Republican turnout and voter defections each contributed substantially to Democratic victories.

The J.L. Partners findings offer a different breakdown, estimating that declining participation accounted for approximately two-thirds of the national electoral shift. Those figures represent the firm’s statistical analysis rather than a direct count of every voter who abstained or changed parties.

The survey provides new evidence about the composition of the electorate following the Nov. 3 elections, highlighting the distinction between Republicans who supported Democratic candidates and previous Trump voters who did not participate at all.

Original article