An online researcher claims Republican vote shares followed a consistent mathematical pattern across hundreds of counties in the 2026 midterms, although an independent review disputes that the formula accurately predicts results or establishes election manipulation.
By yourNEWS Media Newsroom
WASHINGTON — A statistical analysis circulating on social media has renewed allegations of election irregularities following the Nov. 3 midterm elections, with an independent researcher claiming that results in 673 of 692 examined counties closely matched a mathematical formula derived from President Donald Trump’s 2024 presidential vote totals.
The allegations, promoted by conservative news outlet The Gateway Pundit on Tuesday, Nov. 10, center on an analysis published by the X account Truth Is Freedom, which claims Republican candidates consistently received approximately 85% of Trump’s 2024 vote share across Senate and gubernatorial contests.
The researcher argues that the similarity between predicted and reported results is too consistent to reflect ordinary voter behavior. However, the analysis has not established that votes were manipulated, and an independent examination found substantial variations that contradict the claim of a uniform nationwide pattern.
The controversy began with a Nov. 6 analysis published on X, which compared Republican performances in 2026 with Trump’s presidential results two years earlier.
<span data-mce-type="bookmark" style="display: inline-block; width: 0px; overflow: hidden; line-height: 0;" class="mce_SELRES_start"> </span><span data-mce-type="bookmark" style="display: inline-block; width: 0px; overflow: hidden; line-height: 0;" class="mce_SELRES_start"> </span><br>
The researcher proposed the following formula:
Republican 2026 vote share = 0.85 × Trump’s 2024 vote share.
A companion formula estimated Democratic performance by adding 15% of Trump’s 2024 share to former Vice President Kamala Harris’ vote share.
The researcher calculated that Republican Senate candidates retained approximately 85% of Trump’s 2024 support, while Republican gubernatorial candidates retained approximately 86%.
The analysis further suggested that states where Trump received less than roughly 58.5% in 2024 would fall below the 50% threshold for Republican candidates in 2026.
Texas, Kansas, Iowa, Ohio, South Carolina and North Carolina were among the states identified as matching the proposed pattern.
On Monday, the researcher published an updated county-level analysis claiming that 673 of 692 counties fell within five percentage points of a revised formula incorporating Trump’s previous vote share, Republican strength in heavily conservative counties and the Hispanic population.
The updated chart circulated by The Gateway Pundit depicts reported 2026 results as individual points plotted against a predicted line.
“The gold line is the ‘Perfect Prediction’ line. It is the visual of the formula. The dots are the actual 2026 results plotted against those predictions,” the researcher explained.
“The slight deviations matter because they show how little the actual results are straying from the prediction line. Under this formula, the dots stay close instead of scattering the way different turnout levels and local factors normally push them.”
The researcher argued that such clustering would be unexpected across numerous independently conducted elections.
“Does the graph explain that this is impossible? In a natural system driven by human behavior, a pattern this uniform should be nearly impossible,” the explanation continued.
The researcher also asserted that the pattern was unprecedented when compared with earlier American elections.
A second comparison graphic, attributed to Grok and RazorbackEngine, was circulated to support the argument that the 2026 results differed from historical voting patterns.
<span data-mce-type="bookmark" style="display: inline-block; width: 0px; overflow: hidden; line-height: 0;" class="mce_SELRES_start"> </span><br>
Jim Hoft, founder of The Gateway Pundit, amplified the analysis and suggested that the election results had been predetermined.
His publication compared the allegations with its earlier claims about the 2020 presidential election, including the disputed “Drop and Roll” theory involving changes in reported vote totals during ballot counting.
The updated November 9 social media post claimed the formula had been established before votes were counted, although no independently verified evidence has been presented showing that election officials used such a formula to determine or alter results.
The findings have also attracted scrutiny from independent election analysts.
In a Nov. 8 fact-check, Lead Stories examined the original 85% formula using presidential results from 2024 and reported Senate results from 2026.
Its analysis found that Republican candidates in several strongly conservative states performed close to the formula’s predictions, but results in numerous other states differed substantially.
The review identified variation in both directions, including instances where Republican candidates exceeded the predicted vote share and others where they fell well below it.
In Maine, for example, the Republican Senate candidate performed better than Trump had in 2024, contradicting the assumption that Republican candidates uniformly retained only 85% of Trump’s support.
Lead Stories also examined the original chart’s presentation, observing that its elongated dimensions and broad vertical scale made differences between predicted and actual results appear smaller.
The review concluded that the existence of an average decline did not demonstrate that individual election results followed an identical mathematical rule.
That distinction is important because an equation derived from election results can describe an overall voting trend without establishing that the trend was predetermined or artificially imposed.
The county-level analysis introduces another question: whether a five-percentage-point margin represents an unusually close prediction.
A prediction falling within five percentage points of an election result does not necessarily indicate an exact match. Determining whether the reported 673-county agreement is statistically unusual would require comparisons with historical elections, alternative prediction models and results obtained without adjusting the formula after observing the data.
The publicly circulated claims do not establish that those tests were completed.
The revised county-level formula also differs from the original statewide calculation because it incorporates additional variables related to Republican strength and Hispanic population share.
Those adjustments could improve the formula’s fit without demonstrating that the election results were manipulated.
Election researchers have previously examined statistical arguments alleging vote manipulation based on unusually consistent voting patterns.
A peer-reviewed study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences examined multiple statistical allegations arising from the 2020 presidential election and found that the purported anomalies either failed to withstand scrutiny or could be explained without assuming fraud.
The researchers emphasized that political geography, demographic similarities and historical voting behavior can produce strong correlations across elections.
Statistical evidence can help identify results warranting closer examination, but establishing election fraud generally requires additional evidence involving ballots, voter records, tabulation procedures or unauthorized interference.
The 2026 midterm elections produced substantial Democratic gains, including victories in several states that had supported Trump two years earlier.
Those results prompted debate among Republicans about the political effects of economic conditions, the Iran war and the administration’s domestic policies.
The Associated Press reported Nov. 5 that allegations of widespread fraud had circulated online following the elections, but major claims examined at that point lacked substantiating evidence.
The new formula-based allegations add to that debate, although they have not been accompanied by verified documentation of altered ballots or manipulated vote totals.
Election results are administered and certified by state and local authorities, with procedures differing among jurisdictions. Those records provide a means of independently examining discrepancies between reported totals and underlying ballots.
The Truth Is Freedom analysis could be evaluated further through a transparent release of its underlying county-level dataset, calculations, selection criteria and historical comparisons.
Such information would help determine whether the observed relationship is genuinely unusual or reflects the broader shift in voter preferences between the 2024 presidential election and the 2026 midterms.
For now, the claim that 673 counties followed a common mathematical pattern remains an allegation rather than verified evidence of election manipulation. The independent review of the original formula found meaningful discrepancies, and no evidence has established that Democrats or election officials used an algorithm to predetermine the results.
Original article


Comments