At 73, the conductor is still lobbying presidents and bellowing at the violins in five languages. But has his passion project – an orchestra of players from across the Middle East – achieved any real change? We meet him in Buenos Aires.

Even now, days later, the very thought of Daniel Barenboim leaves me exhausted. Over the course of a week, I trotted behind as he charged across the world’s widest avenue – the Avenido 9 de Julio in Buenos Aires, 110 metres and four red lights across – wafting a large Cuban at the oncoming traffic. I was press-ganged into his campaign to eat more pudding than the waiters thought absolutely wise. Only one of us came out a happier man. Even the adjectives were explosive: in Barenboim-world, nothing is merely fine – it is “fun-TUSS-tic”. At 73, he is among the most venerated of all classical musicians. He is also as relentless as a stag weekend.

“To be famous young and to make fame last – the secret of combining the two is glandular,” Kenneth Tynan wrote of Noël Coward. “It depends on energy.” The same goes for Barenboim. Born in Buenos Aires in 1943, he gave his first piano recital there at seven, was making records by 11, and debuted, age 13, at the Royal Festival Hall. At the end of this decade, he will mark 70 years on stage. The celebration plans are already being drawn up.

The rest is mythology. How the great Wilhelm Furtwängler declared, “The 11-year-old Barenboim is a phenomenon.” His marriage at 24 to cellist Jacqueline Du Pré and their stint as a golden couple, before multiple sclerosis forced her to give up playing. The friendship the Argentine-Israeli pianist and conductor formed with the American-Palestinian literary theorist Edward Said that led to them founding the West-Eastern Divan Orchestra, a forum for “Israeli, Palestinian and other Arab musicians” to meet, talk and play alongside each other.

But to meet the conductor in Buenos Aires, hammering out the programme that he will bring to the Proms on 17 August was to see something less stately and more volatile. It was to witness how a legend is maintained.

My introduction began at 10.30 sharp on a Tuesday morning. The musicians of the West-Eastern Divan Orchestra are gathered onstage at the Teatro Colon opera house. In jeans and sweatshirts, the eldest among them were still only half the age of Barenboim, who perched on his conductor’s podium in a crisp black shirt and navy trousers. He’s been performing here since 1960.

They began with Siegfried’s Funeral March from Wagner’s Götterdämmerung. And for the rest of the morning, they just kept beginning. Over and over. The first few low bars of menace would fill the hall, then the conductor would shout: “STOP STOP STOP. It must be absolutely claustrophobic. EEE-vil!”

Again.

“STOP. What is with you today?”

Again.

“STOP.” It had not been apparent before how suitably built Barenboim is to convey anger. But his hooded eyes were flashing, the barrel chest and jutting arms thrust out.

The cellists were beaten up for a full 20 minutes. Accusations of laziness were flung around, of musicians having skipped “hotel-room practice”.

Over half an hour Barenboim did not allow the orchestra more than 30 seconds into the March. In two days’ time, this piece would be performed here as part of a sequence of Wagner excerpts stitched into a kind of symphony. “We haven’t even begun to hear how it’s going to sound!” he bellowed, as if this was news.

Again.

                                                              Daniel Barenboim & Claudio Abbado.

“STOP.”

The longer this went on, the more the ensemble wilted. After two weeks of concerts and rehearsals, they were already “really exhausted,” one said to me. “A lot of music in the head and a lot of problems.” Finally, on being allowed to progress on to the next few bars, the players burst into an ovation of pent-up frustration.

“The greatness of a musician is measured by the degree of fanaticism he brings to his playing,” writes Barenboim in his memoirs A Life in Music. If, as a violinist, you fail to produce just the right accent on a note: “It should cause you almost physical pain.”

Now, at one such pang of pain, Barenboim wheeled around to his assistant, who had led earlier rehearsals. Two days ago, the shaven-headed and sharp-suited Julien had sat on the stage as a page-turner in Barenboim’s duet with Martha Argerich. As the two legendary pianists sprang through Brahms’ Haydn Variations, Julien had leaned forward to flip the score – only for Barenboim to slap him away, in front of 3,000 people. This time, the assistant sat a few rows back in the dark of the stalls.

Evidently, not far enough back. “JULIEN,” Barenboim yelled. “What have you been doing? They have no clue.” Throughout the rehearsal, the polymath had hopped between English, Spanish, Italian and French – but for 24-carat bollockings he preferred German. His shout “keine Ahnung” carried through all seven storeys of the gilt and red plush of the Colon.

Visiting that week was a conductor at the national conservatory, Rodrigo Gonzalez Jacob. From his box seat, the 35-year-old marvelled at the last of a previous epoch of conductors. Like the late Georg Solti and Herbert von Karajan, Barenboim had made his name during the long boom of the record industry, when classical music could command private budgets on top of public handouts and the term “maestro” was used without irony.

“Some in my generation see him as despotic, monarchical,” Gonzalez Jacob said. “I don’t think any musicians would stand me screaming at them the whole rehearsal, the whole day.” But then, he wasn’t Barenboim. “I’ve learned more in a week of watching than I have in my last five masterclasses.”

That Tuesday, the session concluded three-and-a-half hours later with the warning: “I’m afraid you won’t be ready in time.” Musicians headed back to their hotel for a short rest, before another long rehearsal in the afternoon. Barenboim now had to endure a Guardian interview. On learning I was of Bengali origin, the lifelong friend of Mumbai’s Zubin Mehta regaled me with his headwaggling Indian accent. “Kul-kutta. Vot are you saying?” He has somehow a reputation as a skilled mimic, but this was Peter Sellers. Then came another voice: “Waare’s me boonch of flaars?” This, he assured me, was “the North Coon-try” accent of opera singer Dame Janet Baker.

In the five-minute walk between theatre and restaurant, the classical musician was stopped four times by strangers who wanted to shake his hand, touch his arm, thank him. One woman strode up, clapping loudly. “Muy bueno! Muy BUE-no! Felicitaciones.”

It was near here that Barenboim’s own performing career began. On Fridays, he would play chamber concerts at a businessman’s house. “I loved to go mostly because his wife made the best apple strudel.” There, aged seven, he met an eight-year-old Argerich. “We used to play under the piano.”

Both parents were piano teachers, and would take him to see the great musicians touring Buenos Aires. The young Barenboim saw Furtwängler, violinist Adolf Busch and virtuoso pianist Arthur Rubinstein. “You used to queue for three days and two nights for tickets for Rubinstein. People stayed in the queue for the whole day.” The child prodigy enjoyed a “double life. I would go to school, come home and play football, then give a concert.”

As Julien and the cellists would be glad to hear, he also committed plenty of his own gaffes. Take his first-ever recital in Britain, in Bournemouth. The name was rolled around his mouth, like a glug of Malbec: Bawn-mouf. He was into the final strait of a Mozart concerto in E-flat and the “last movements of Mozart concertos are sometimes quite similar in rhythm and speed. Even the melodies.” All of a sudden, “I mistakenly landed in another concerto, this time in B-flat.” Luckily, his conductor had all Barenboim’s humour and none of his temper. “He said, ‘It’s OK – as long as you don’t charge double for playing two different pieces.’”

Having picked the restaurant – a barbecue with a giant firepit in the front window and a corrugated-iron ceiling – Barenboim was now ordering platters of meat, pumpkin and chips. Even as he did so, waiters kept bringing complimentary dishes: metal trays of grilled pork and empanadas. While forking food towards me and his chief executive, Tabaré Perlas, the conductor discussed the members of the Divan Orchestra. He and Perlas could name all 100 of them, from more than 10 countries. They told me where X lived, whether Y was clever. Barenboim works with four orchestras regularly, but it is the Divan musicians that he calls “my people”. While touring, they live in “The Sovereign Independent Republic of the West-Eastern Divan”.

Source: The Guardian
Article: "Daniel Barenboim on ageing, mistakes and why Israel and Iran are twin brothers" (2016)