Chetan Sehgal of Franklin Templeton's Emerging Markets Fund has sounded the alarm: China's massive production surplus is set to export deflation worldwide, without a doubt, with Vietnam as its primary victim.
This overcapacity crisis is rapidly transforming global economies, particularly in Vietnam, where local markets are now drowning in cheap Chinese imports that undercut domestic businesses. These developments prompt critical questions about economic stability and the adequacy of current regulations to counteract such aggressive market strategies. As Chinese firms implement a calculated invasion of Vietnam's markets, the implications for local jobs and prices loom large. Will Vietnam's economy withstand this tidal wave of challenges?
Let's dive into a detailed analysis from NTDVN, based on insights from logistics managers and domestic economic experts, to understand the situation precisely.
Surplus Goods – Chinese Consumers Retract
The collapse of the real estate market is one part of a larger crisis where China faces a significant goods surplus. Mr. P.H, an experienced logistics manager in Vietnam, believes the surplus is more acute than what is reported in China. He has observed overflowing warehouses in coastal Chinese cities during his trips and through discussions with Chinese partners.
During an NTDVN interview, Mr. P.H mentioned, “China has been facing a goods surplus for a while, but it appears now to be at its most critical point.” He added that the situation worsened after three years of COVID-19 lockdowns. According to him, many in China are shifting from middle to lower income levels, while the affluent are hoarding cash due to fears about the digital yuan and potential governmental confiscation. This has led to reduced consumer spending and attempts to move wealth abroad.
This excess inventory and downturn in consumer sentiment reflect psychological effects economists associate with economies entering deflationary and recessionary phases. As real estate prices plummet, losing a third of their value, asset values decline rapidly, eroding confidence in the economy's future stability. This results in reduced consumer spending and investment. To mitigate losses as prices continue to fall, businesses cut back on production.
Furthermore, the factors triggering China's deflationary period include those often mentioned in economic theories:
- An ongoing surplus of goods.
- Declining confidence among consumers and businesses.
- An increase in bad debts.
- A bursting of the long-speculated bubble in the asset market, especially real estate.
These dynamics have led to a more severe reaction from Chinese consumers and businesses than what was observed in Japan during the 1990s. Trust in the government has fallen sharply due to actions against private enterprises, efforts to convert private assets to public ownership through "shared prosperity" programs, and attempts to increase control by embedding party branches in companies.
Mr. P.H also pointed out that the Chinese middle class and wealthy are reducing their spending, with many preferring to keep their money in cash at home, choosing foreign currency and gold over bank deposits. They view the digital yuan with suspicion, seeing it as a potential trap for their assets.
A pressing issue remains: How will Chinese companies offload surplus inventories that the domestic market can't absorb? Their strategy to enter new markets in developed economies and compete for these export opportunities seems to be their only viable survival plan at the moment. Evidently, Vietnam has become a key 'prey' for these surplus inventories.
E-commerce Dominance In The Domestic Market
By the close of 2022, a report from Finance China highlighted by CafeF, a Vietnamese financial news outlet, indicated that 80 billion parcels had been dispatched across China and abroad within the initial nine months of the year. This statistic implies that daily, one out of every five people in China either sends or receives a parcel. On popular e-commerce platforms such as Taobao, Shopee, and Lazada, parcels are delivered within one to five days,
Vietnam's consumer goods market is especially susceptible to Chinese e-commerce due to very competitive shipping rates and the low cost of overproduced goods. Additionally, aggressive digital marketing strategies on platforms like TikTok and Facebook have outperformed local products.
The dominance over Vietnam’s consumer market is likely to worsen as Chinese investors, potentially using entities from countries like Singapore or Thailand as fronts, could gain ownership of local e-commerce platforms. This might result in the sidelining of Vietnamese products through strategic discounting and algorithmic biases that favor Chinese goods, making them more visible and accessible.
Vietnamese companies struggle to maintain domestic market share due to the absence of protective tariffs and non-tariff barriers.
Exploiting The Export Market Through ‘Dirty’ FDI
Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) is vital for evaluating economic growth potential and significantly influences GDP through job creation and technology transfer. However, ‘dirty’ FDI, which neither shares knowledge nor creates employment and instead exploits fiscal and land benefits while disadvantaging local exporters, remains a major concern. This sort of unethical investment from China into Vietnam is becoming increasingly sophisticated.
Mr. P.H told NTDVN that Chinese firms are carefully assessing Vietnam's leading export sectors, such as wood processing, seafood, and agriculture, and are aligning their investments accordingly. Initially, they use a Vietnamese Certificate of Origin to offer unsustainable low prices on exports, driving local businesses out of the market.
How are Chinese companies able to implement predatory pricing against Vietnamese goods so effectively? The answer lies in the multiple trade agreements Vietnam has entered into, which allow importing countries to recognize a Vietnamese Certificate of Origin (CO) if the product has at least 30% domestic value-added content, according to Vietnam's Ministry of Industry and Trade. This requirement is significantly lower than Switzerland's 60% and the USA's 50%.
This lenient standard attracts FDI that seeks to evade taxes and bypass sanctions, aiming to dominate Vietnam’s export market through manipulation of origin certificates. With a significant portion of production and technology remaining in China, Vietnamese products struggle to compete on price, allowing Chinese FDI firms to buy cheaply and offer lower prices.
The pressing issue here is whether Vietnam can effectively curb ‘dirty’ FDI.
In theory, there are many strategies available for identifying, verifying, auditing, and excluding unethical foreign direct investment. However, in practice, this proves to be a formidable challenge. Vietnamese provinces, driven by the goal of achieving annual GDP growth, encounter substantial obstacles. The political dynamics and ambitions of local leaders create fierce competition for FDI funds, which paves the way for the infiltration of corrupt FDI into various industrial zones nationwide. According to Vietnamese regulations, local authorities possess the authority to approve most FDI proposals.
Ms. H, an economist speaking with NTDVN, identified a major shortfall: although local governments have the power to approve FDI, there lacks a robust national legal framework to eliminate harmful or unscrupulous FDI. There is also a deficiency in oversight, auditing, and accountability mechanisms. As a result, driven by the pursuit of growth and sometimes by corrupt practices, provinces are prone to approve FDI indiscriminately without thorough assessment.
Source: NTDVN



Comments