It's time to determine the ultimate champion among the pirates of the Caribbean series! You and I will meticulously assess all five cinematic treasures within the Disney franchise, delving from the depths of the seafloor to the pinnacle of the highest tide.
We start with the Certified Fresh Curse of the Black Pearl that catapulted Johnny Depp from cult darling to international star. That’s followed up with the rest of the original trilogy featuring Orlando Bloom and Keira Knightley, and then franchise extenders On Stranger Tides and Dead Men Tell No Tales.
Note: The ranking was based on Rotten Tomatoes
#1 - PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN: THE CURSE OF THE BLACK PEARL (2003)
Tomatometer: 80%
Audience score: 86%
In the tumultuous tides of the Pirates of the Caribbean movies, "The Curse of the Black Pearl", produced in 2003, directed by Gore Verbinski, with a screenplay by Ted Elliott and Terry Rossio, is definitely the best movie. The film was a resounding success upon its release, grossing over $654 million worldwide, making it the third-highest-grossing film of 2003.
It has stunned audiences in the best possible way. The cast has portrayed some of the best characters that have now carved a place in our hearts. Johnny Depp’s rock star sensibility enlivens Jack Sparrow, and scored him an Oscar nomination for Best Actor, as well as a win at SAG. Disney stepped out of their comfort zone like never before with this one, releasing their first PG-13 rating under their family-friendly banner. These risks paid off with one of the year’s biggest blockbusters, surprising many with its imaginative action, sharp comedy, and compelling romance.
The film tells the story of Will Turner, a young blacksmith, who is in love with Elizabeth Swann, the daughter of Governor James Norrington. Elizabeth is rescued from a shipwreck by the notorious pirate captain Jack Sparrow. Will and Elizabeth discover that the Black Pearl, a cursed ghost ship, has returned and is terrorizing merchant vessels throughout the Caribbean. Governor Norrington tasks Will with capturing Jack Sparrow in exchange for Elizabeth's freedom. Will and Jack are forced to collaborate to find a way to break the curse of the Black Pearl.
#2 - PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN: DEAD MAN'S CHEST (2006)
Tomatometer: 53%
Audience score: 72%
Released in the US in 2006, "Dead Man's Chest" made waves in the film industry. Breaking numerous records, it soared to the top of the box office, amassing an impressive $136 million during its opening weekend in the US alone and, the fastest film to gross over $1 billion at the worldwide box office (63 days). Notably, it became the highest-grossing film of 2006, the 3rd highest-grossing film of all time at the time of its release. Additionally, it held the distinction of being Disney's highest-grossing film until it was surpassed by "Toy Story 3" in 2010. The film received four nominations at the 79th Academy Awards (winning Best Visual Effects).
Comparable to the franchise's "Temple of Doom," "Dead Man's Chest" faced mixed critical reception upon its debut, with some critics expressing reservations about its ability to match the excellence of its predecessor. However, the film proved to be a thrilling ride, packed with exhilarating action sequences that kept audiences on the edge of their seats. Between the escape from a cannibal island, the three-way sword fight for the chest’s key, and the spectacular final battle, the film is a rollicking rollercoaster that rarely stops to catch a breath. Amidst the action, moments of character development added depth to the narrative, such as the poignant reunion between Will and his father.
“Dead Man’s Chest” also introduces two of the franchise’s most visually astounding creations: the towering Kraken and Bill Nighy as Davy Jones. The latter in particular set a new standard for motion capture villains. The production team even picked up 04 nominations at the 79th Academy Awards (winning Best Visual Effects).
While it may not have retained the freshness of its predecessor, "Dead Man's Chest" distinguished itself with a darker tone, juxtaposed with moments of lighthearted comedy reminiscent of Chaplin's style. The rum was far from gone.
#3 - PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN: AT WORLD'S END (2007)
Tomatometer: 44%
Audience score: 72%
In 2007, Buena Vista Pictures Distribution brought forth "At World's End" to the US audience, stirring up a mixture of reviews from critics. While performances and visual effects garnered praise, the film faced criticism for its convoluted plot, uneven pacing, and lengthy runtime. Nonetheless, it emerged as the highest-grossing film of 2007, amassing over $963 million worldwide. It was nominated at the 80th Academy Awards for Best Makeup and Best Visual Effects, and won Favorite Movie Actor for Johnny Depp at the 2008 Kids' Choice Awards.
While not hailed as the franchise's pinnacle, "At World's End" unfolds as a grandiose spectacle, unmatched in scale (With a production budget of nearly US$300 million, it was, at time of production, the most expensive film ever made). Within its narrative, breathtaking imagery unfolds, from daring voyages over colossal waterfalls to the climactic showdown amidst swirling maelstroms.
The final act brims with some of the series' most memorable moments: Jack Sparrow engaging in a fierce duel with Davy Jones, Will and Elizabeth have an impromptu wedding, and although there is a happy resolution, it doesn’t come without some sacrifice. Yet, amidst these crescendos, audiences must endure stretches of bewildering exposition and eccentric scenes that could have been excised. Despite these detours, the film's gripping action sequences and fulfilling resolutions compensate for its meandering sections.
At the time, many assumed that this would be the last “Pirates” movie and there is a sense of finality to all the character arcs. Occasionally the story can become a tad too self-serious, but we ultimately feel the gravitas that the filmmakers aim for.
#4 - PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN: ON STRANGER TIDES (2011)
Tomatometer: 33%
Audience score: 54%
When “On Stranger Tides” was announced, a lot of people had the same reaction: really, a fourth one? Nonetheless, the film soared past a billion dollars in global box office, indicating a continued fervor for the franchise.
Returning with Captain Jack and Barbossa, "On Stranger Tides" goes on a fresh journey under the helm of a new director, Rob Marshall, and introduces a slew of new characters. Despite potential, the newcomers failed to fully shine. Penélope Cruz's portrayal of Angelica exuded charisma, yet her dynamic with Jack lacked depth. Ian McShane's casting as Blackbeard appeared promising, yet the villain fell short of being captivating or fearsome.
The plot unnecessarily tangled itself, deviating from a straightforward pursuit of the Fountain of Youth. Instead of simplicity, the quest involved additional elements like chalices and mermaid tears, seemingly inserted to prolong the runtime. Amidst the convolution, moments of enjoyment emerged, particularly in the chemistry between Johnny Depp and Geoffrey Rush, creating a hick for the film.
#5 - PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN: DEAD MEN TELL NO TALES (2017)

Tomatometer: 30%
Audience score: 60%
The filmmakers cited the series' first installment, The Curse of the Black Pearl (2003), as inspiration for the script and tone of the film, with critics describing the film as a "requel". Pre-production for the film started shortly before On Stranger Tides was released in early 2011. Dead Men Tell No Tales premiered in Shanghai on May 11, 2017, and was released in the United States on May 26. The film received generally negative reviews from critics and grossed $796 million worldwide against a production budget of $230–320 million.
Despite its impressive visuals, "Dead Men Tell No Tales" falls short in terms of plot and character development. While there are moments of humor and nostalgia, they are overshadowed by a sense of déjà vu. They do find some success in the swashbuckler set pieces, with the highlights being an inventive bank robbery and an execution escape. While Johnny Depp continues to charm as the eccentric Captain Jack, the rest of the cast, including newcomers Brenton Thwaites and Kaya Scodelario, struggle to leave a lasting impression. Javier Bardem's portrayal of Captain Salazar adds a menacing presence, but his character lacks depth compared to past villains in the series.
Although the film is visually interesting and the divided sea climax is a creative one, it felt like the franchise needed to either sail off into the sunset or take things in an entirely new direction going forward.








Comments