Picture

This haunting piece by Russian painter Ilya Repin in 1885 portrays an elderly Ivan the Terrible (Ivan IV), in a state of remorse and shock, clutching his dead son, Ivan, who was murdered in a fit of rage by the tsar after a heated confrontation. Ivan's son was well on his way in being groomed to succeed Ivan IV's place on the Imperial Russian throne.

​The biographical Ivan the Terrible by Sergei F. Platonov covers many aspects of Muscovite Russia, including the stifling bureaucratic administrative governments and the influence the 'Boyer' nobility class had within the Russian Palace, and consequently, on the Tsar's political decisions over Russia.

Most of all, the Ivan the Terrible explores Ivan's life from childhood until his death at the end of his reign.

In the 1986 publication of Platonov's Ivan the Terrible, two featured contributing historians, Richard Hellie and Joseph L. Wieczynski, provide their own insight into Ivan IV and the Muscovite era of Russia.

Hellie draws on an accumulated historiography of Russia from those before him and cites additional 19th century-era Russian historians, mainly that of Vasily O. Kliuchevsky, by challenging long-held beliefs about Ivan the Terrible's reign.

The primary author of Ivan the Terrible, Sergei F. Platonov, was an iconic pre-revolutionary Russian historian, and it nearly goes without saying that his works regarding Muscovite Russia - including his famous 1899 publication Times of Troubles - are highly valuable to historians who study Russian history.

In keeping with his straightforward assessment of Ivan IV, Platonov discards what he believes is the myth that the Muscovite ruler was mentally unstable, and instead makes a practical assessment of the tsar that, upon first glance, seems to veer into apologist territory before ultimately settling into plain old political centrism. 

Much of the value of Ivan the Terrible is found in the way that Platonov presents his research and claims through a  “scientific” approach to historical evaluation that is based purely on the concrete facts of what is known, rather than guessing or asserting about bigger picture themes and theories.
​
This template for historical evaluation is said by Wieczynski to be a product of Platonov’s authentic education received from St. Petersburg school of Russian historiography.

​Students of the school “refused to fill factual lacunae with guesses, and abstained from elaboration of grandiose historical schemes,” Wieczynski adds (Platonov, Wieczynski, 10).

Picture

Ivan the Terrible by Viktor Vasnetsov, 1897

The biographical Ivan the Terrible covers many aspects of Muscovite Russia, including the stifling bureaucratic administrative governments and the influence of the 'Boyer' nobility had within the Russian Palace on the Tsar's decisions.

Most of all, the biography explores Ivan's life from childhood until his death at the end of his reign.

​Hellie claims that the idea of a toxic, conniving presence of the Boyar Duma noble council within the Russian Palace is little more than a "figment of the imagination of the nineteenth-century historians," like Kliuchevsky, and a "myth still being perpetuated."
​
Hellie also argues that much of Ivan’s paranoia with the upper classes was unfounded, and claims that the princes were preoccupied with their inherently lustful entitlement for status and power within the cumbersome Mestnichestvo system to even bother hatching a plot against Ivan’s authority.

This claim even collides against Platonov’s belief that Ivan IV was not insane by boldly asserting that Ivan was, in fact, mentally ill. “ Ivan was suspicious, he surrendered to fear and suspicion, and struck out at all who seemed hostile and dangerous” (Platonov, 22). ​

Picture

"Your Grasping, Scheming V.I.P.s," by Anne Bobroff-Hajal

This is but one example of the complexity and disagreement in the historical atmosphere surrounding what little is known about Ivan and his immediate time of reign.

While there is ample documentation that outlines the basic, and sometimes specific, elements of Muscovite Russia, it is clear that not all Russian historians agree about the same things.

Ivan IV is considered one of the more enigmatic figures in history. Little is known about his life and Platonov makes this abundantly known to the reader.

Despite the secondary sources and anecdotal rumors, Platonov dryly asserts with little doubt that Ivan did not have a discernible mental condition and thus was not insane (Platonov, 22).

Hellie points out that Platonov’s criteria was likely based on an outdated definition of insanity used in the era when the author wrote his thesis on Ivan.

This strict definition involves “a state of derangement in which the afflicted foams at the mouth and his perpetually violent.”

The modern view of psychology, Hellie describes, would assert his condition as being one that is paranoid, “whatever threat can be conceived is to be believed” (Platonov, Hellie, 23).

The major theme in Ivan the Terrible is that of the ruler’s rationality being evident in his decision-making and the sovereign legacy of his reign in Russian history (Platonov, 12).

As stressed in the preface, there is an unfortunate lack of information about the reign of Ivan IV.

Other textbooks that peruse Russian History like The History of Russia by Charles E. Ziegler frequently cite Riasnovsky’s work A History of Russia.

However, when discussing Ivan's reign, Zeigler seems unable to resist the temptation to indulge the popular characterization of Ivan the Terrible as an tyrannical sadist who unleashes wild bears out cages onto crowds of Russian civilians.

Another story tells of Ivan forcing his political enemies to dance to their death in a giant man-made “skillet” in Red Square designed to torture and kill at the same time.

These rumors of his behavior may actually be true, but they are impossible to verify, especially with the possibility hinted at historians like Hellie that some of the writings about Ivan IV may be forged or slanderous to further tarnish his already troublesome reputation.

Platonov’s thesis essentially declares that Ivan was not insane, basing his assertion on a laughably outdated Soviet psychiatric metric - one that requires 'foaming at the mouth' and random lashing as pre-requisites for mental illness.

We know mental illness takes ore forms than that. Unfortunately, we also don't have concrete evidence of Ivan's sadism. Worth noting that Ivan was successful in expanding the Russian Empire dramatically.

It's possible enemies from within and without during Muscovite Russia's expansion resulted in propaganda or slandered accounts. This would certainly explain Ivan's persistent paranoia during his reign. In either case, this is a model example of "lost history."