Because the original JM Barrie is really dark, violent, and not suitable for children.
I think the people who liked Peter Pan because of Disney’s 1953 cartoon, and the people who despised it because the original was too scary.
Peter Pan the boy who never grew up
Peter Pan is a 12-year-old boy who can fly and always seeks fun and enjoyment in life. That's why he refuses to grow up and tries to deny the concept of maturity.
One day, while having a great time, Peter Pan accidentally encounters Wendy, a charming girl from London. He develops special feelings for her and invites her to join him in Neverland. Together, they embark on a series of captivating adventures, with Wendy serving as the catalyst that exposes Peter Pan to a realm he has never before ventured into.
Peter Pan is afraid of growing up and becoming a man, so he decides to hide and remain a boy forever.
In the Disney version, Peter Pan is portrayed as softer, innocent, mischievous, and cheerful with adventures. The Disney version focuses on Peter Pan and Wendy, showcasing their lightheartedness and innocence, while presenting the theme of choosing between adulthood and childhood.
In J.M. Barrie's version, the book delves into darker themes compared to the Disney movie. The children engage in battles, taking lives without experiencing any remorse. Peter Pan displays arrogance and prioritizes the well-being of others only if it enhances his heroic image. The children readily abandon those who love them, exhibiting no sense of shame in doing so.
Peter embodies an exaggerated stereotype of a boastful and carefree boy. He carries a nonchalant and devil-may-care attitude, fearlessly displaying arrogance when faced with danger. According to Barrie's writing, when Peter believed he would perish on Marooners' Rock, he experienced a sense of fear, albeit only a single shudder. Nevertheless, with a carefree demeanor, he expressed that "To die will be an awfully big adventure."
The darker elements of Peter Pan's story are not directly present in the narrative itself but rather originate from J.M. Barrie's personal experiences. In 1867, Barrie's older brother David died tragically in an ice skating accident, which deeply impacted him at the age of 6. Throughout his life, Barrie frequently reflected on his brother's death and explored the idea of the sacredness of childhood. Barrie also experienced the loss of two infant siblings, which further influenced his perspective on death. Despite his fascination with eternal youth, Barrie himself never had children. Instead, he formed close relationships with Jack and George Davies in the late 1890s and early 1900s, who were four and five years old respectively when they met the author.
The story of Peter Pan and JM Barrie is not over yet, you can see more here:




Comments