Zhou Yu was very close to the royalty of Wu. He was a childhood friend of Sun Ce, and joined him by his side immediately after he started his conquest of Jiangdong.
Zhou Yu’s loyalty to Sun Ce was comparable to Guan Yu to Liu Bei.
They were also related by marriage to Da Qiao and Xiao Qiao, so they were brothers-in-law.
Purely on the thought of pragmatism, there would’ve been a possible time where Zhou Yu “might have” taken leadership of Wu himself, and that would have been immediately after Sun Ce’s death. Sun Quan was young and inexperienced, the future of Wu was uncertain, if Zhou Yu wanted control of Wu he could try to take over at that time.
Like Zhao Kuangyin (first emperor of Song) did.
(Zhao Kuangyin claimed he was loyal to Chai Rong, the late Emperor that he served, and it was his followers who “forced” him to take the throne rather than the young son of Chai Rong.)
Zhou Yu had never considered this. He always showed his loyalty to the Sun family. Sun Quan’s mother told him: “Zhou Yu was like a second son of mine. Now that your brother (Sun Ce) is gone, you must listen to and respect his advice as if he was your brother.” Zhou Yu also never overstepped the border and always formally established that he was a loyal servant of the Sun family.
Also realistically, he couldn’t have successfully taken the throne for himself.
There was a faction of Wu that would have stopped him: the old people.
There were three generals who served the Sun family before even Sun Ce was born, when they were generals of Sun Jian. After Sun Jian’s sudden and relatively young death, they continued to serve Sun Ce.
There had been times where the elders showed some disrespect to Zhou Yu. Cheng Pu was the official second-in-command during the Battle of Chibi, but he was initially insulting towards Zhou Yu. Yet Zhou Yu kindly discussed things with him, and he ultimately accepted Zhou Yu as his superior.
Huang Gai, obviously he insulted Zhou Yu and claimed he was an arrogant inexperienced whippersnapper, but that was for their false surrender plot.
Han Dang, I wasn’t sure if he had arguments with Zhou Yu. But he definitely did with Lu Xun during the Battle of Yiling.
However, suppose if Zhou Yu did show any signs of disrespect towards the Sun family, then they would most definitely stand together to declare his act as treason.
Technically, Zhou Yu was also political rival to Lu Su (over whether to ally with Liu Bei). However, the two had a very close personal friendship; when Zhou Yu needed supplies, Lu Su offered him his entire depot of food, and Zhou Yu recommended him to serve Wu.
But Lu Su was known for being an extremely honourable person. If Zhou Yu truly betrayed the Sun family, Lu Su would’ve definitely lost all respect for him.



Comments