The Battle of Muye was a major event in the history of the Shang and Zhou dynasties. It ended the Shang dynasty for more than 500 years and opened the rule of the Western Zhou dynasty.

Due to the long history and inconsistent literature records, people still have many differences in understanding of this war that has affected the course of China's history.

For example: the time and location of the war, the route of the Zhou army, the strength and deployment of the two sides, the reason for the victory of the Zhou army, and so on.

The most unbelievable thing is that the coalition forces of King Zhou Wu defeated a merchant army with much more force than its own in just a few hours, captured the Shangdu Dynasty Song, and forced King Shang Zhou (Di Xin) to set himself on fire. dead.

This is not only documentary records, but also confirmed by unearthed cultural relics.

In 1976, a batch of bronze wares were discovered in Lintong Lingkou Commune, Shaanxi, among which the most valuable was "Ligui" ——

Gui is an ancient food utensil with a round mouth and two ears. The creator was named "Li" . He joined the King Wu to participate in the battle of destroying business. After victory, he was rewarded. This bronze vessel was cast to remember his merits and used to pay tribute to ancestors. .

This is the earliest Western Zhou bronze ware that can be known so far.

"Successfully conquers business, but Jiazi Dynasty, Sui Ding, overcomes faintness and has business."

(Scholars have yet to reach a consensus on the textual research and interpretation of the inscriptions. This is just an example of sentence interpretation.) and so on.

Battle of Muye: Why did King Wu of Zhou destroy King Shang Zhou in just a few hours?

It is not difficult to see that although the interpretation of this inscription is not the same, it is consistent on one point, that is, this decisive battle between Shang and Zhou went very quickly, and it ended within a few hours within a day.

And this is basically consistent with the records of historical documents.

According to "Shang Shu·Mudan Oath", "Historical Records · Zhou Benji" and other records, Zhou Wu's army came to Shangjiao Muye at "Jiazi Meishuang (Dawn)" to hold the oath; after that, it fought against Shang Zhou's army. The merchant army was quickly defeated, King Zhou fled back to Chaoge City, and died on self-immolation that night.

Battle of Muye: Why did King Wu of Zhou destroy King Shang Zhou in just a few hours?

Why did the Battle of Makino end so quickly? Shang Zhou's army-according to the "Historical Records", there were 700,000 people, and later generations thought it was 170,000 people-why is the combat effectiveness so low?

The orthodox explanation in the past was: King Zhou was unscrupulous, tyrannical, deprived of people's hearts, and betrayed by the people; while King Wu is the teacher of benevolence and righteousness, and the common people look forward to it. In this case, as the "Historical Records" said: "Although there are many masters, they have no desire to fight, and they want to enter the king." Therefore, when the two armies clash, the merchants are defeated, and they retreat on the battlefield, assisting Zhou attacking merchants. , So that King Zhou was defeated.

However, the business force was far better than the Zhou army, and it was still waiting for work, but the result was a big defeat, and even a reversal. During this period, it was strange and intriguing. It seems a bit simplistic to explain that King Zhou loses people's hearts and King Wu wins people's hearts.

The ancients put forward some opinions about this. For example, in "Huayang Guozhi·Bazhi", it says: "The king of Zhou Wu defeated him, and he was the master of Bashu, and he was the author of "Shangshu." Ba Shi Yongrui, singing and dancing to Ling Yin, the former It's only to go to war . Therefore, it is called "the king of Wu cuts down, before singing and dancing afterwards"."

This means that the coalition led by King Zhou Wu has the Bashu army. They are very brave and "sing and dance with the Yin people" in front of the battle. This is probably a kind of witchcraft, which caused the defiance of the merchants.

From what we see today, this kind of combat method of the Pakistani people must have never been seen by the merchants living in the east, so it can play a role in disrupting the minds of the merchants to a certain extent. But this is unlikely to be the main reason for the rapid defeat of the merchant army.

Battle of Muye: Why did King Wu of Zhou destroy King Shang Zhou in just a few hours?

Modern and contemporary scholars have combined historical documents and archaeological evidence to provide multiple explanations for this.

For example , Mr. Guo Moruo believed that Zhou Neng's destruction of Shang was "not because of how tyrannical King Yin and Zhou lost the popular support, but because of another historical origin. The truth of this ancient history is also due to the discovery of the (oracle bones) inscriptions. It's just to be known to the world."

In Mr. Guo's view, Shang Zhou's notoriety was mostly attributed to Zhou people. In fact, Emperor Xin (King Zhou) "was a very talented person." During the two generations of him and his father, Di Yi, there was a long-term war with Dongnan Yi.

"According to the inscriptions, Emperor Yi repeatedly conquered the barbarian in ten and twenty years.... In the generation of Emperor Xin, "Zuo Zhuan" also repeatedly said that he'searched for Li and betrayed by Dongyi', Said that he'Kidongyi killed his body', said that he was'a hundred grams without a dying.' It can be seen that Emperor Xin inherited his father's business, repeatedly used troops, and finally razed the southeast, so he could have '100 million trillions of people. 'Be his minister'-a slave."

"Captives can have billions of trillions. The war can be seen to be fierce, and the losses of the soldiers of Yin are not necessarily in the minority. Under such circumstances, the Zhou people took advantage of the void and the king of Yin Chou used the captured soldiers to confront the enemy, causing the'predecessors to despise'. It was a failure. This is the reality of the so-called condemnation during the Yin and Zhou Dynasties."

In other words, King Shang Zhou used heavy troops to conquer Dongyi, which gave King Wu Zhou the opportunity to attack Shang, and finally failed to set himself on fire, which is what the "Zuo Zhuan" said "to kill the Dongyi". .

Battle of Muye: Why did King Wu of Zhou destroy King Shang Zhou in just a few hours?

Many scholars also analyzed the battle between Shang and Zhou from the perspective of strategy or strategy .

In the view of some scholars, the victory of the Zhou people in the Muye battle was not accidental. It was the result of several generations of Zhou people's long-term planning and implementation, especially the vigorous efforts of Zhou Wen and Zhou Wu to promote the strategy of destroying business.

For example, two years before the Battle of Muye, King Wu of Zhou had watched his troops in Mengjin, and the "eight hundred princes" came to assist in the fight, saying that it was time to cut down, but King Wu withdrew his troops on the grounds that "fate was out of time." In fact, this was not only a troop dispatch to test the reaction of the Shang court, but also a real combat exercise against businessmen.

After waiting until two years later, the Shang Dynasty's ruling clique was severely divided. King Zhou's elder brother, the trio, left, his uncle Bigan was killed, and his uncle Jizi pretended to be crazy because of fear. He was also imprisoned by King Zhou. He picked up his musical instrument and fled from Shangdu, and defected to King Wu of Zhou... Only then did King Wu seize the favorable opportunity, gather the coalition forces, and send troops again.

Battle of Muye: Why did King Wu of Zhou destroy King Shang Zhou in just a few hours?

And from the specific process of King Wu's defeating Zhou, it was also full of superb strategy.

Many commentators believe that King Wu's use of a surprise attack was similar to the German "blitzkrieg" in World War II. Its elite troops traveled day and night, and went deep into Wang Ji with lightning speed, and defeated the merchant army in one fell swoop and captured the capital of Shang Dynasty.

Some commentators believe that Zhou Jun's victory so quickly was largely due to the success of the espionage war .

In fact, as early as in "The Art of War by Sun Tzu", it was pointed out: "In the past, Yin was prospered, and Yi Zhi was in Xia; Zhou was also prosperous, and Lv Ya was in Yin. Therefore, it is only the emperor and the wise general who can achieve great achievements in the above-mentioned wisdom. ".

Sun Tzu believes that the espionage activities of the two great heroes Yi Zhi (Yi Yin) and Lu Ya (Jiang Shang) played an extremely important role in the process of the destruction of Xia during the Shang Dynasty and the destruction of Shang during the Zhou Dynasty .

Jiang Shang had been active in the Shangdu in his early years, and he knew the Shang Ting very well, and he should have collected a lot of information. However, as the first adviser when King Wu defeated Zhou, it was impossible for him to preside over the spy work in Chaoge himself.

Many commentators believe that the spies arranged by King Zhou Wu and Jiang Shang to be with King Shang Zhou are Jiao Kun .

"Guoyu" once listed him and Daji as the sinners of the dead businessmen: "In the Yin Xin Dynasty, there was Su, there was Su Yida and her daughter Yan, and Daji had a favor, so he died in Yin compared with Jiao Li."

In other documents, Jiao Ku has a virtuous name, and he is not favored by King Zhou like Fei Zhong and Elai. Therefore, it is said that he "dead Yin" is probably because he was a spy for Zhou people.

Battle of Muye: Why did King Wu of Zhou destroy King Shang Zhou in just a few hours?

Regarding this, there is a very interesting story recorded in "Lu Shi Chun Qiu · Gui Yin":

It was said that King Wu led the army to Tuna Shui, and the Shang Ting sent Jiaoqi to ask King Wu where he was going. King Wu also told the truth and said to go to the Shangdu. I asked when I would arrive, saying Jiaziri . Jiao Li reported back to Shang Ting on this date.

It was raining and the march was difficult. The counselor suggested to stop and rest, but King Wu ordered to keep walking day and night. The reason is that if it fails to arrive on time on Jiazi Day, Jiaoqi may be killed by King Zhou for providing wrong information.

In order to save the rubber, King Wu rushed all the way and arrived in Yinjiao Muye as scheduled. At this time, the commercial army was ready. But in the end, King Wu defeated King Zhou.

"Lu Shi Chun Qiu" attributed the victory of King Wu to "righteousness". But this is probably a whitewash for posterity.

It is very likely that it was Jiao Ku who planned the "defection of the former disciples" of the merchant army. He first secretly contacted the Dongyi prisoners, and then asked King Zhou to use the Dongyi prisoners as the forwards of the merchant army. The Pakistani singing and dancing in front of the army might be them. The promised reversal signal.

With Jiao Li's strong internal response, although Zhou Jun's strength is not as good as the commercial army, it is not too difficult to seize the opportunity to win with a surprise weapon and conquer the commercial capital in one fell swoop.

Battle of Muye: Why did King Wu of Zhou destroy King Shang Zhou in just a few hours?

What do you think of the above analysis? What do you think was the main reason why King Zhou Wu quickly defeated King Shang Zhou?