The Ultimate Grilled Cheese Recipe – We Tested the World's Best to Build the Perfect Sandwich**
What actually makes the perfect grilled cheese?
To find out, we travelled from London to Paris, tasted some of the world's most iconic grilled cheese sandwiches, dug into the surprising history of the dish, and stole the very best techniques from each one.
Along the way, we discovered:
🇺🇸 The classic American grilled cheese 🇬🇧 The original English grilled cheese from Mrs Beeton 🇫🇷 Luxurious French Croque Monsieur variations The science behind the perfect cheese pull How to get an ultra-crispy golden crust Why mayonnaise beats butter for browning The secret to a rich, gooey cheese filling using béchamel, Red Leicester and Gruyère The cooking method that creates the ultimate texture
After dozens of tests, we've combined everything we've learned into what we genuinely believe is the best grilled cheese recipe on Earth.
Ultimate Grilled Cheese Recipe
Ingredients: 1 large white tin loaf 100g clarified butter 30g flour 30g butter 300ml whole milk 150g Red Leicester 100g Gruyere 30g Mayonnaise
Recipe: 1. With a sharp serrated knife, start by thinly slicing the crust off all sides of the loaf (if super soft, put the loaf in the freezer for 30 minutes) 2. Position the loaf lengthways along the edge of your worktop 3. Place a thin chopping board (around 1cm thick) along the edge of the loaf furthest away from you. 4. Lie your serrated knife at one end of the loaf with the tip on the chopping board and start to slice horizontally, ensuring that the end of the knife stays in contact with the board at all times 5. Set aside the bottom slice and continue to slice the bread in this way until you’re left with 6 slices 6. Spread these out on a baking tray and bake on 160C for 10 minutes until just crisp 7. For the bechamel, on a medium heat, melt the butter and the flour in a saucepan, whisking continuously for one minute until you have a golden roux 8. Take the pan off the heat and slowly whisk in the milk until fully incorporated. 9. Return to the heat and continue to whisk until the bechamel has thickened and has volcanic bubbles on the surface 10. Take the thick bechamel off the heat and add the grated red leicester 11. Whisk until you're left with a silky, full homogenised cheese sauce. 12. Season with salt, transfer to a tray and put in the fridge to chill 13. Once the bechamel has cooled down, use a spatula to scrape the contents into a mixing bowl before whisking vigorously until it loosens slightly and looks smooth. 14. Fold through the grated Gruyere 15. To assemble the grilled cheese, lay out your toasted pieces of bread and spread 50g of the bechamel mix on all but one of the pieces. 16. Stack the slices one on top of the other, topping with the final slice without bechamel. 17. Trim all the sides before portioning width-ways into 4 18. Brush all the sides of each portion with mayo 19. Heat a pan to medium heat and add 2 tablespoons of clarified butter 20. Carefully place the first portion into the pan and fry for a minute or so until golden brown. 21. Carefully flip over and then repeat on the other 3 sides. If the pan starts to look dry, add another couple of tablespoons of clarified butter 22. Transfer to a baking tray, brush with more clarified butter and bake in the oven for 10 mins or until the cheese has started to run out 23. Remove from the oven, allow to sit for a couple of minutes and enjoy!
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The creator embarks on a global quest to engineer the \"ultimate\" grilled cheese by combining elements from American, English, and French traditions. By analyzing the strengths of various versions—from the gooey melt of American cheese to the luxury of a Croque Monsieur—they develop a multi-layered, bechamel-based masterpiece.
This is the best grilled cheese on earth.
How do I know?
Because I took the best parts from some of the greatest grilled cheese.
So you brought me all the way to France for a toasted cheese sandwich.
I hunted down the biggest cheese pull, the crispiest crust.
Super crispy.
And the richest flavor.
I feel like a genuine wolf about 10 hours.
And after all this testing I've combined everything I've learned into one epic grilled cheese.
We've now crafted what we feel is the best version of the grilled cheese
and it starts with a bechamel.
Butter goes in, melt it down, equal parts flour.
We just want to bring it together and we want this to be quite thick.
We want to use a bechamel base with a little bit of red lester in.
I feel like it definitely has more body and structure when you use a proper cheese.
You still get that sort of gooey ooziness that you really, really want from a grilled cheese.
It mimics the American cheese but it just has way, way, way more flavor.
Whilst that cooks out I'm going to start with our red lester cheese.
In the UK we call this red lester.
Semi-hard cheese like cheddar but it's just got that beautiful red tinge to it.
Brew base is just cooked out.
We're going to start adding in some milk.
Okay, so really beating the bechamel.
We want it to be nice and thick but we don't want it to catch in any way.
You still want to cook all of that flour out.
We want this perfect glossy smooth consistency.
Add a touch of seasoning now and then take the heat off
and then melt in all of this beautiful red lester.
So we want to be nice and thick so it spreads on the bread and holds it all together.
So we've got this beautiful bechamel now.
This is recreating that goo that you get that everybody loves from an American cheese.
I think generally speaking when you think about a simple thing like a grilled cheese
but when you actually start to dissect why it actually works it does become pretty complex.
I think we didn't understand the gravity of the challenge before taking on this recipe.
So in order to start our quest for the perfect grilled cheese
we're going to do the most consumed version of a grilled cheese in America
which is white bread, butter on the inside, the almighty American cheese,
some mayo goes on the outside of our bread.
It's ready.
It's coming out.
Staple for a reason.
Easy.
Cheap.
Let's see if it's delicious.
So what you're looking for the classic grilled cheese is this
and this is why you use, I mean I don't even know what American cheese is
but just look at the state of that.
Depth of flavour not quite there.
Cheese pull definitely there.
Has to be cheap white bread and has to be mayo on the outside
because it really helps get that golden caramelization.
But I wanted to know from here where a grilled cheese actually came from
therefore I went down a little bit of a rabbit hole which revealed something shocking.
The grilled cheese is actually an English invention.
Beaton's book of household management
and this is actually where the first ever reference to a grilled cheese comes from.
It isn't actually grilled at all.
Slices of brown bread, thin slices of cheese.
She specifies you need a nice fat Cheshire.
Time 10 minutes in a brisk oven.
The bread's gone quite dry.
Obviously because there's absolutely no fat there.
Cheese and bread, that's exactly what it tastes like.
So running it through the oven, bread is really nice and soft inside.
So that's really the only thing I'm going to be taking away from Mrs Beaton's.
Obviously the English invented the grilled cheese
but I think it's fair to say we left it too plain.
What I want from a grilled cheese is a bit of luxury,
I know a little bit of decadence
and to be honest I think the best place to go next is to look to the French.
They always know how to richen things up.
So we've come here to Les Gargaux in Soho
in the hope that we might find the most luxurious version
of the classic grilled cheese, the croque monsieur.
Bread, toasted and clarified butter, compte cheese, beautiful ham.
There's definitely a good amount of bechamel in there,
adds this layer of richness.
The flavours and the luxuriousness are top notch.
If I was going to take one element away from this, it would be the gruyere.
I think it gives the elite cheese pull.
In order to get the cheesiness and the sort of meltiness and the cheese pull,
we're actually going to add in some extra cheese to it after this has cooled down.
The next stage is just take the cheese sauce,
put it onto a nice sheet tray and you just want to bring it just to room temp
before we fold in our gruyere cheese.
Gruyere is going to give you the perfect consistency for that all-important cheese pull.
Whilst that chills down we can start slicing our bread.
On our whistle-stop tour of croque monsieurs,
we also found out there was a new version.
Something special was brewing in Paris.
This is the Grand Boulevard, the home of the croque monsieur.
This restaurant is doing it a little bit differently.
You brought me all the way to France for a toasted cheese sandwich.
Well, I think it's more than a toasted cheese sandwich.
It's a part of French identity.
I must admit, it's never something I normally order.
This is going to blow your mind.
Look at all those layers.
It's very interesting they've kept the bread relatively soft.
The flavour changes every now and then.
At the moment it's cheese with pesto.
Look at all those layers.
Absolutely delightful.
The bread itself was incredibly soft.
I like the subtle, the subtle cheesiness.
I've never had a croque monsieur like that but it was delicious.
Banging right?
I think we can make it better though.
So after the mind-blowing version of the croque monsieur from Constance Restaurant,
we've come up with our own technique.
Get a good loaf of white bread
and then I'm just going to top and tailor it and take all the sides off.
So this is a closed tin white loaf.
I know Mrs Beaton's was originally a brown bread
but I do think it has to be a white bread.
I think for me what I'm looking for and what I loved about the Constance one
was that you've got this pillowy softness
which comes from it being cooked in clarified butter on one side
and then cooked in the oven.
So we're going to slowly take slices out.
Now traditionally if I was going to cut my grilled cheese
you would go like that, boom, boom.
But what we're going to do to get this perfect shape
and all these multiple layers is take it down the other way.
Probably like half an inch thick.
If you don't have the confidence to do this in one go to get that even slice
just take a narrow chopping board and then use that as a guide.
Okay, so we've got our bread.
This is our cheese sauce.
Add a little bit of Gruyere on a nice fine grater setting
and then we're going to fold it into our cheese base
and then this is going to be our spread.
Lay out these layers of bread
and we're just going to lightly run them through the oven.
The idea being it's the first layer just a little bit dried out.
We almost felt that the one in Brasserie Constant
almost had no structural integrity whatsoever
and it's quite nice poetic that it always goes back to Mrs Beeton
and the original grilled cheese.
So 160 for 10 minutes should be perfect.
You'll notice it's got absolutely no colour at all on the bread
but all you've done is it's taken out that surface layer of moisture.
Stack it up and I'm going to go on with our first layer of this cheese mix that we've got.
So you're looking for around about 50 grams per sheet.
So not too thick.
You can kind of see those little tiny strands of Gruyere
are going to be the thing that make that sort of satisfying cheese pull.
I think although the Constance one was incredible in terms of like innovation
it didn't give you that sort of decadent cheesiness that you wanted.
Same with like Mrs Beeton.
So I think the ratio here is quite crucial
and you want to go all the way out to the edges as well.
One thing that was really nice from the grilled cheese in Paris
was you get this really beautiful caramelised edge
and it was the same in Les Cargots.
The caramelised cheese is delicious.
That crispy cheese flavour and texture
is pretty much the best thing about a grilled cheese.
Okay so now time to stack it up
and then basically all you want to do now is just trim them up slightly
because you want a really nice even edge
and then you can make your first sandwich.
So we still want it to be nice and pillowy soft in the middle.
So I'm going for a fairly large slice.
Look at all those beautiful layers of cheese.
We're just going to brush a little bit of light mayo on the outside.
Going back to where we started
and then we're going to start cooking in clarified butter.
Normal butter would just make it slightly burn.
Clarified it'll have a higher smoking point.
Like at Constance we want to get a really nice crust on this first layer.
So face down into a nice hot pan
and then we're going to cook it on fairly low heat.
So you can see here the cheese escaping
and starting to crisp up on the bottom which we want
and then now we're going to flip it over.
Oh look at that.
That is outrageous.
Add a touch more butter if you feel like it needs it.
Then we're just going to colour up the other side lightly
just working this around the pan.
This helps get a really nice even layer of goldenness on the bread.
So once you've got colour all over
this is going to go in the oven for around about eight minutes at 160 degrees.
It's been around about six minutes.
Not quite as long as eight.
So now this is optional but just put a tiny bit more clarified butter on.
Touch of flaky salt.
Very gently take it off.
All these layers of cheese coming out.
Then cooking it in the oven like as opposed to a normal grilled cheese
which is 100% sort of contact heat.
We know that the inside of this is going to be sort of molten.
Very, very soft bread.
Just look at those layers as well.
You know I'm going to get the absolute ultimate cheese pull.
That is banging.
Between these layers you get so much of that sort of like
delicious softness that you get from a croque monsieur.
But it gives you all the satisfying sort of crisp with more flavour
than the classic American grilled cheese.
There's a little bit extra work.
Well, it's a lot extra work.
This is the elite grilled cheese.
Need to try and make it next.
you