College planning is full of well-meaning advice — but not all of it actually helps families make better financial decisions. In this episode, I break down some of the most common statements families hear from financial advisors and explain why many of them reveal a limited understanding of how college funding and financial aid actually work.
From misconceptions about 529 plans and life insurance to oversimplified advice about community college transfers or merit scholarships, I walk through the phrases that should make you pause. The goal isn’t to criticize advisors — it’s to help families recognize the difference between generic financial advice and guidance that truly understands the realities of college costs and aid formulas.
Recognizing Misleading College Funding Advice
Many families assume that a financial advisor who understands retirement planning also understands college funding, but the rules governing financial aid are far more specialized. Statements like “you can borrow for college but not for retirement” may sound responsible, yet they often oversimplify how student loans and long-term finances interact. Advice involving annuities, life insurance, or other asset shifts can also miss key differences between FAFSA and CSS Profile calculations.
Other common suggestions — such as relying on community college transfers for guaranteed savings or assuming strong grades automatically lead to merit scholarships — often ignore the nuances of admissions, transfer success rates, and institutional aid strategies. Understanding these distinctions helps families recognize when advice reflects real expertise versus recycled talking points.
The Advice That Reveals a Lack of Specialization
The college funding process contains layers of rules, formulas, and institutional policies that many general financial advisors simply don’t study in depth.
(00:09:29) Financial Aid Mistakes to Avoid (00:12:27) Community College Transfer Challenges (00:16:06) College Admissions: Test Scores Explained (00:17:16) College Admission Factors Beyond Scores (00:23:29) 529 Plans and Financial Aid (00:28:38) Misguided College Aid Advice
Understanding how aid formulas, asset treatment, and school policies interact can prevent families from relying on advice that sounds logical but doesn’t hold up in practice.
Looking Beyond Simplified College Advice
Families often assume that certain strategies automatically increase financial aid, but the reality is more complex. Multiple children in college no longer increase aid under FAFSA the way many people expect, and income appeals don’t always produce meaningful changes in aid packages. Even tools like 529 plans are frequently misunderstood in how they affect financial aid calculations.
The key takeaway is simple: college funding requires its own specialized knowledge. When families understand the difference between broad financial advice and true college funding expertise, they can make more confident decisions about affordability, financial aid, and long-term debt.
Thank you for watching Smart College Buyer where you'll find videos on: College Financial Aid Financial Aid Strategies College Expenses Admissions process Financial Guidance for College Student Loans College Financial Aid Help College Admissions Success Financial Planning for College
Show your support for this content by hitting the Subscribe button and clicking the bell. It's free and simply allows YouTube to notify you when I've posted a new video.
My content is for educational purposes only and should not be construed as advice or any kind of solicitation to buy or sell anything. As always, consult your own financial or tax professional for your own specific situation. Your mileage may vary. Batteries not included.
Connect with Jack Wang: / thejackwang *be sure to send a connection request with a message saying Hello!
www.smartcollegebuyer.com
Comments are disabled for this video.
How to tell if your financial advisor or if that college funding advisor you think about hiring
actually knows anything about how college financial aid college funding works.
If your advisor keeps telling you, oh yeah just be in the top 25 percent,
they don't really know what they're talking about.
Welcome to the Smart College Buyer Podcast.
My mission is to help high school families pay for college without taking on a truckload of debt.
Each episode I'll share insights into college admissions,
financial aid, payment strategies, and more often with expert guests.
I'm Jack Wang, your host.
I started helping families after struggling to navigate the process myself for my sons.
If I needed help, I knew others did too.
Let's dive in.
Welcome back to this episode of the Smart College Buyer Podcast.
As always, I'm your host, Jack Wang.
And I've been tempted to record this episode for a while,
but the topic's been kind of brewing around in the back of my head for a while,
and I never really got around to it until recently.
I had several experiences where I've had conversations with other financial advisors
about this whole college planning, college funding process.
And what they told me kind of led me to say to myself, yeah, it's time to record this.
So today's topic is going to be all about how to tell if your financial advisor
or if that college funding advisor you think about hiring
actually knows anything about how college financial aid, college funding works.
Now, to be fair, most advisors don't specialize in this area.
So the extent of their college funding or college savings knowledge is they say something like,
just put however much money you have into a 529 or similar vehicle, and that's it, right?
And with 529 savings plans being one of the more popular savings options out there for college,
it's probably not an unreasonable recommendation for most families.
But as I've discussed in other episodes of this podcast,
it's by far not the only option or way to save for college.
So for most advisors, they don't know, they acknowledge they don't really know,
good for them.
And I'm actually kind of thankful that they're honest about it.
They say, you know, 529s and that's it, because they don't really know.
The people I'm really talking about are the ones who really position themselves
as a college funding advisor, someone who says they know how this works, but really doesn't.
Again, there are some really great people, some friends who I know who have designations or
whatever, who have done the coursework, who truly do know.
But there are many, unfortunately, many, many others who say they do, but they really don't.
But as the consumer, how are you supposed to be able to tell whether or not they know or don't
know?
Well, I'm going to go over some of the common things they say that will
essentially indicate that they don't know.
And we start with the first one.
I hear this phrase all the time, and it drives me absolutely bananas.
And that is if they say you can borrow for college, but not for retirement.
And now that's not technically an incorrect statement.
Okay, you can borrow for college, but not so much for retirement.
Although for retirement, you could do things like reverse mortgages or bargain the equity
of your house to supplement your retirement savings.
But the statement is basically true.
However, the reason it drives me bananas is because if you don't use strategies to try and
lower the cost of college, instead you just borrow, well, eventually you're going to have
to borrow that money back.
Or I'm sorry, not borrow, pay that money back.
And by virtue of having to pay it back, it's going to impact your ability to save for retirement.
But also the origin of the statement back then was to have the students borrow so that
the parents didn't, so that the parents can continue to save for retirement while the
student borrowed.
And then later on, the parent could help the student pay off the loan or something.
But it's very much the whole oxygen mask falling down out of the ceiling of the airplane.
They always say, put your own mask on first before you help someone else put their mask
on.
And that's very much the basis of the statement.
But today, of course, students are not able to borrow themselves, or not very much anyway.
And if a family were to need to borrow for college, it's going to be on the parents,
and it's going to influence their ability to save for retirement.
And I've talked about this issue before.
I mean, this one statement can take up a whole episode by itself.
But I hear this all the time from advisors who really don't know.
And part of why they say this is because they want to quickly shift the discussion to retirement
versus helping solve the paying for college problem.
An example of this, so several years ago, I actually had a conversation with a fairly
well-known college funding advisor.
And actually, this person had founded an organization to help other advisors sort of help
with college.
But their whole strategy was really to have the conversation with you, the family, and
quickly turn it to a retirement planning discussion versus actually helping you with college.
And so as I was having a conversation with this particular individual, he was giving
me an example of a case study that his folks had helped a family with.
And I'll share the details in just a moment with the second statement.
But suffice it to say that the solution they came up with was helpful to the advisor because
the advisor got a nice sale out of it and a nice commission check and supposedly helped
the client with their retirement readiness but did absolutely nothing to help them lower
the cost of college or sort of figure out how to pay for it.
So when he told me that solution, I actually asked that, like I sort of pushed back, like,
so how did that solution help the problem of paying for college?
And he hemmed and hawed and stuff.
And at that point, I'm like, you know what?
I'm done with you.
And so that's not an uncommon thing.
So I hear that a lot.
I hear that from advisors who say they do college, but really what they're doing is
they're trying to shift the conversation away from college to retirement to do that and
sort of go on the whole like, well, but you can borrow for college.
You can't borrow for retirement.
The second statement that I hear often is that life insurance and annuities are always
exempt from FAFSA or exempt from financial aid, I should say.
And that actually is a true statement on the FAFSA.
The money inside the cash value inside the life insurance policy and annuities or what
are called non-qualified annuities, those are exempt from reporting on the FAFSA.
But that is not true in the case of the CSS form.
Life insurance is exempt, but annuities, non-qualified annuities are not.
They are still reportable.
And so that example I was just giving was the solution was they had their client put
a bunch of money into a non-qualified annuity, annuities can be pensions or whatever, so
that can help with retirement.
But then the kid ended up going to a CSS school, which meant that the value of the annuity
still had to be reported.
And the family did not benefit at all from that transaction from a financial aid perspective.
It had no impact because the money was sitting in their checking account.
They moved into annuity.
If it stayed in the checking account, it would have counted.
Once it moved to annuity, it still counted.
So it basically did nothing from a college standpoint, but supposedly helped the family
from a retirement readiness standpoint.
And that was the issue that I had was that, hey, he didn't do anything for the cause.
Now, maybe that family was very concerned about retirement.
And that could have been true.
I don't know.
I wasn't part of the conversation.
But if you're hiring someone to help you figure out the college problem, they should
probably help you figure out the college problem.
The other thing is that a lot of advisors, especially those that really focus on life
insurance annuities, again, not bad solutions in the right circumstances.
They can work very well.
But in the CSS world, life insurance can still count sometimes.
Either A, the school, through supplemental questions, can ask about life insurance values.
So you have to disclose.
Or B, schools that use the CSS profile can do what's called projecting assets.
And what I mean by that is, let's say they see on your tax return, they have $1,000 of
interest income.
But then you move the money from your checking account to a life insurance policy, so you
don't have to report it.
Well, when they get that information, they'll see, well, but where does that $1,000 of interest
income come from then?
So they can impute back and say, well, something had to generate that interest income.
And if you're not reporting any assets, the school can estimate the amount of assets that
it would have taken to generate that interest income.
So effectively, they add back the value that you were trying to hide to begin with.
So a lot of times in the CSS world, by moving that money into life insurance policy, it
doesn't do anything for financial aid anyway.
Of course, the advisor got a nice sale out of it, a nice big fat commission check, but
it didn't actually help anything with the college financial aid.
So I hear those a ton.
The third, I hear all of these all the time.
I should just say, I keep saying I hear this all the time, because I hear all of these
all the time.
That's why I'm talking about it.
But I also hear, go to community college, then transfer to a four-year school.
Now, this can be a tremendous cost-saving move.
And here in the state of Massachusetts, community college is essentially free, and we actually
have a very generous what we call A to B or mass transfer program, going from get your
associates and then going on to a four-year public college or university.
But here's why this doesn't generate the savings that you might expect.
So according to the National Student Clearinghouse Research Center, which is an organization
that gathers all the enrollment data and stuff, and they do a lot of research on sort
of where kids go and transfer rates and things like that, roughly a third of all community
college enrollment are students who go to community college, and then they intend to
then transfer on to four-year school.
So about 33% of students that intend to transfer.
But of that 33%, roughly only half actually get their bachelor's within six years.
So in other words, of all the students who go to community college with the intention
of transferring to four-year schools, most of them don't, or they do, but then don't
finish within a six-year time frame.
So effectively, what they do is they either get their bachelor's degree, and then they
decide not to go on, or they end up dropping out.
Now, the research doesn't really get into why they're not finishing, but it does clearly
state that they're not finishing.
So if they're not finishing, then are you really saving any money by going to community
college first if the intention was to get a four-year degree?
Yeah, you pay less, but you didn't get the degree, so I would argue that you really didn't
save any money to begin with.
Now, I have my theories as to why they may not have finished.
I don't know if it's true or not, it's my own opinions.
But the reality is that only one in six of all community college students end up going
on to the four-year and actually then getting a bachelor's degree within six years of when
they even started, like when they graduated high school, which is a really low percentage
if you think about it.
Now, the other thing that you have to watch out for going to community college first is
many private schools, or many of the private schools I've actually visited and talked to,
they now do what some schools call an upside-down curriculum.
The whole point of going to community college first was you theoretically get your English
lit 101, and your math 101, and your political science 101, your history 101, all the basic
freshman courses out of the way, so you pay lower community college prices versus having
to take those same exact courses at the four-year university.
But many public schools, as I mentioned, use an upside-down curriculum.
So what that means is they will start kids in their classes for their major as early
as freshman year to make sure that kids either want that major or they figure out pretty
early that's not for them.
So kids aren't taking their English lit or math 101 freshman year.
But also, many of the schools now have an integrated curriculum, and what I mean by
that is law schools now don't have the basic math class, right?
That math class is embedded in some other topic.
That math class is embedded in the history class, and the writing class is embedded in
social studies class, and the science class is embedded in something else, right?
So a lot of colleges, there just isn't that math 101, English 101, history 101.
Those classes don't exist.
So what that means is if you go to community college first and you take the math 101 or
the English lit 101, those classes might not transfer to the four-year school.
So you're going to end up having to take those sort of integrated classes again anyway.
So it didn't save you any time by taking it at community college, right?
You essentially had to retake all those classes just in a different form.
It still took you four years, or it might shave off a little bit, but it doesn't shave
off as much time as most people think.
So going to community college, community college can be a great option.
If you know that you're going for community college and then that same state's four-year
public, that could probably be pretty good, okay?
Assuming your kid is one of those 16% who makes it all the way through.
But again, it doesn't really get you the result and it doesn't save you the money
that most people think they do.
Yet I hear advisors all the time tell the client, oh, just have your kid go to community
college and save a bunch of money.
Not really the case.
Another is on how to maximize merit scholarships.
And what I hear from particularly a lot of the college funding advisors is, oh, just
have your student be in the top 25%, the applicant pool, okay?
Now, again, it's not wrong, but it's not really as easy as they make it out to be.
I hear this from a lot of the people, a lot of the advisors who specialize in college
funding.
And so I did a whole episode on this, the topic of enrollment management.
The episode, I believe, is called how college aid actually works or really works.
And you can go back and listen.
But yes, being in the top 25% can help, but sometimes it takes more than that.
At some schools, you have to be in the top 10% to 15% or even higher.
At some schools, it doesn't matter because they don't give out merit scholarships anyway,
looking at you, Ivy League and most top-tier private schools.
But the reason they talk about top 25% is because colleges publicize the standardized
test scores of the kids who submit, right?
And they do what's called the middle 50 range, right?
So 75th percentile or the top 25% down to the 25th percentile or say where the bottom
25% cutoff is.
And because standardized test scores are standardized, it's very easy for software and for
data to figure out, oh, well, if the top 25% cutoff is the score on your SAT, you just
have to be above that number.
You would know that you're in the top 25%.
Well, that's where software has its limitations.
That's where data has its limitations.
Because number one, not all students submit test scores, especially at your test-optional
colleges, which there are many of these days.
Number two, test scores aren't the be-all and end-all, okay?
And colleges don't just look at test scores because they consider other factors, as I
talked about in the other episode, like what your major is, where you're from sort of
geographically, and whether you're a boy or girl or any number of other factors get
considered.
But a lot of the software that's used by these college funding advisors, it's hard to
figure out, right, like the weighting on some of this stuff.
So they go with the easy thing.
The only thing that software can figure out, which is, hey, we know exactly where the top
25% SAT or ACT scores are.
We're just going to go on that.
So if your advisor keeps telling you, oh, yeah, just be in the top 25%, they don't really
know what they're talking about.
Also, by the way, it doesn't work the same for GPA because some schools, different high
schools use different scales, right?
Some it's a 5-point scale, 4.5 scale, or 100-point scale.
Some colleges strip out all the weightings.
Some colleges keep the weightings in.
So colleges do generally publish the average GPA of the students who got in, but it's almost
meaningless because every college does something different with that number.
And quite frankly, GPA today doesn't mean nearly as much as it used to.
Schools are now looking more at the academic rigor, like did your kid take a lot of dual
enrollment or advanced placement classes and things like that.
But so it is well beyond just being the top 25%.
I hear this too.
Well, you know what?
Just go to an in-state public university.
Now, nothing wrong with this.
There are great in-state public universities, and by virtue of being in-state, you're going
to pay a lot less than being out-of-state.
So it's not a bad strategy to get costs down to begin with.
However, if there are private schools out there that will give you a lot of aid, if
they really want you, again, go back to the episode on how aid really works, where you
can get the cost down to even below, either equal to or even below the cost of the in-state
university.
So yes, going to an in-state university is a great start, but price-wise, you might be
able to do better.
But also for a lot of states, the in-state flagship, so here in my home state, University
of Massachusetts Amherst, or University of New Hampshire, or like a Penn State, or University
of North Carolina Chapel Hill, or University of Virginia Charlottesville, or University
of Texas at Austin, my alma mater, those are huge schools.
And huge schools aren't right for every kid.
So yeah, you can just go to the in-state university, but if you want to go to the flagship,
that might not be the right environment for your student.
Your student may thrive in a much smaller school setting.
Not saying that they can't be successful in a large school, but going to a large school,
like I went to University of Texas, I think it was like 40,000, 50,000 kids at the time.
I think it's still around that now.
That's a lot of kids, right?
It's a lot of kids.
And by the way, being surrounded by 50,000 other students can actually still be a really
lonely place.
So it takes a certain personality to go that type of thing.
Just like, you know, not every kid's going to thrive in a small school, right?
But you're far better off finding the right environment for your student versus just saying,
well, you're going to go to in-state because it's cheaper.
Well, that might not actually even be true.
One thing I still hear often, even though this isn't really true anymore, particularly
for FAFSA schools, is you'll get more aid if you have multiple kids in college simultaneously.
So this was a rule, or part of the financial aid formula for FAFSA schools,
that if you had multiple kids in college simultaneously, the schools would split,
if you will, what was then called EFC, Expected Family Contribution, now called SAI,
Student Aid Index.
They would split among the number of students.
So for example, if colleges calculated that your EFC at that time was $50,000, meaning
they thought you could afford about $50,000 per year, but you had two kids in college
simultaneously, then you would take that $50,000, divide it by the two, and each kid
would get allocated $25,000, and then each school would then calculate aid eligibility
based on that.
Well, that divided by the number of kids in the FAFSA, that rule's gone away.
They don't do that anymore.
That still exists in some forms in the CSS school formula, okay?
That does exist, and schools have tremendous leeway in terms of how they calculate multiple
kids in college, like sort of how they split up a family contribution.
So it's not a straight divide by two, never was.
So they do it a little bit differently.
But even when you have multiple kids in college, that didn't necessarily lead to more aid per
kid, because number one, your family EFC could have been so high that even if you divided by
two or divided by three, you still weren't eligible for need-based aid anyway, or your
kid got so much in merit aid that even if your income was lower, you still didn't qualify
for need-based financial aid, because most of the aid that you got was in merit, and
it covered most of what we call your need anyway, right?
So it didn't matter whether you had multiple kids in school or not.
So it wasn't always a guarantee that if you had kids overlap for college, that you were
going to get more aid.
That was never true.
And even today, by the way, this will be a totally different episode.
But even the FAFSA world, even though the splitting of the SAI is not a thing anymore,
there is still a potential way to get something like that.
But again, that gets a little bit technical.
So that'll have to be saved for another episode.
So there is kind of a way to still do it sometimes.
But again, another episode.
529s count heavily against you.
This definitely comes from the insurance set.
Again, nothing against insurance.
I will often do insurance if it fits a particular situation.
But advisors will say, well, if you have money in a 529, it hurts you more than if you had
it in your checking account, let's say.
So from a formula standpoint, that's actually not true, right?
Whether you have it in your checking account or you have it in a 529 for that student,
the formula treats them exactly the same.
And quite frankly, on the FAFSA and on the CSS, when you list out how much you have in
assets, you don't distinguish between how much is in your bank account versus a 529
or investment account versus 529.
The school doesn't know based on that disclosure.
Now, in the CSS world, there can be supplemental questions where the schools can ask, hey,
of the asset values that you sort of disclose, how much that comes from 529s, right?
But that would be the only instance ahead of time where schools would know if you have
a 529 versus not.
So in the formula, it doesn't treat these things any differently.
Now, once they know CSS schools, but also any schools, they can apply their own formula
to it, right?
Because remember, the bulk of aid comes from the college's own money, okay?
So when people say like, oh, the FAFSA says this or the formula says that or whatever,
they treat it almost as if it's very black and white, right?
And for federal aid and state aid, it really is, right?
So for things like the Pell Grant, you either qualify or you don't, right?
There's no gray area.
The numbers are there or they're not.
But when it comes to institutional aid, which is aid directly from the college's own pockets,
the colleges are able to set whatever rule that they want.
So there are some rumors out there that for institutional aid, sometimes 529s do count
more heavily towards you, but that's only if the college asks for more disclosure or
they somehow otherwise found out, which is certainly not when your kid's a high school
senior filling out these forms ahead of time.
Because the FAFSA form doesn't ask you to split out how much is your 529, and the CSS
certainly doesn't either unless there are supplemental questions, which not all schools
use.
So again, I hear this a lot, not really that true.
Last couple, so if your income dropped and you appeal, you will be successful in getting
more aid.
That is definitely not true.
I mean, it obviously could be true, but it's not a guarantee depending on whether your
income drop was temporary or not, or if it's more permanent, but also by how much it drops
and things like that.
The way that the formula works is when your income goes down, the impact on SAI actually
starts to go down, right?
So one of the things in the financial aid world on the school side is sometimes they
end up having to explain to families like, yeah, your income dropped by 100 grand a year,
but we can't give you any more aid because the math didn't work out that way.
Again, that's because as income goes down, the impact on the SAI goes down.
Conversely, as your income goes up, the impact on SAI increases also.
And also schools will often use banding.
So they'll say, well, if your SAI is between this range or if we rank your kid based on
other factors in this range or this range, and your income goes down but doesn't get
you to the next lower range, then you don't get more aid anyway.
So having your income drop does not automatically get you more aid, just like having your income
go up does not automatically take aid away either.
It goes both ways on that.
And lastly, I hear this all the time, you don't need to fill out the FAFSA, right?
You're not going to qualify for any aid anyway, so why bother filling out the FAFSA?
Well, I get asked this question quite a bit.
Here's my take on it.
If you don't fill out the financial aid form, whether it's FAFSA or CSS,
you're basically telling the school that you don't need the money.
And there are a number of colleges out there where your student will not even
qualify for a merit scholarship if you don't fill out the FAFSA or the CSS,
because again, you're telling the school that you don't need the money.
Now, if that's true, good for you, right?
Like, rock on.
But for most families I talk to, even the high-income ones are like,
yeah, you know, college is expensive, we really need some aid.
In that case, you're filling out the FAFSA, even if on paper it doesn't look like you
qualify for need-based aid, because you don't want to tell the school that you don't need the money.
So I always tell my families, we're always filling out the FAFSA.
But also, by the way, by virtue of filling out the FAFSA,
your student can take out the federal student loans anyway, which is a great way,
a low-cost way for your student to have some skin in the game
and builds their credit down the road as well.
And those are good things.
Again, the point of all of these is that most of these statements,
most, not all, but most of these statements aren't wrong on the surface,
but it's not usually quite as simple as most people make out to be.
But what I have found in my experience and the conversations I've had
is if a college funding advisor or financial advisor says any one of these things I've outlined,
they don't really know that much about how college aid works or paying for college.
Yes, they might say, well, we should do this or we should do a 529 or some tax strategy.
Well, yeah, yeah, yeah.
But if they don't really understand the nuances of how aid works,
kind of like the example where they had the family move a bunch of money
from the checking account to an annuity, these advisors will tell you like,
oh, yeah, yeah, this really helps.
But if they don't really understand how this stuff works,
it often doesn't actually help.
Or I should say, it doesn't actually help you,
but it usually helps them because it helps them
charge you a fee or get a commission on something or whatever.
And again, I'm not against commission if it's done for the right reasons and in the right way.
Okay, we all have to get paid.
But the point is, in that particular example that I gave earlier,
head of that organization told me, that's why I pushed back like,
yeah, okay, yeah, you had your family do this, but how did it actually help?
And he knew from his hemming and hawing that he knew,
like he knew that I knew and I basically caught him, right?
So that's not what I want to have happen to you.
I want you to be armed with good information.
You know, look, whether you hire me or not is sort of besides the point,
but I want you to be armed with good information
so that you know what actually matters and what doesn't actually matter.
And in this case, I hope now you know how to identify
people who say they know when they really don't know.
And when you are armed with this knowledge, that allows you to be a smart college buyer.
As always, thank you so much for spending this time with me
and listening or watching this episode.
Stay safe, stay healthy, and I'll see you next time.
Thanks for listening to the Smart College Buyer Podcast.
I hope you found the information useful for your family.
Follow me on LinkedIn for more episodes, videos, and tips.
The link is in the show notes.
Remember, you can spend time now to plan and strategize,
or you can spend more money later.
Success in college admissions and financial aid isn't about luck.
It's about being intentional.
I'm here to help you every step of the way.