This is a reissue of a film we released a couple of years ago, originally called the Science and Psychology of Polarisation, which we are re-releasing now as it is even more relevant now than it was then.
It is part of our new "State of Sensemaking" series of films, check out the other films released over the next couple of weeks. We will be holding a big free event at the end of September also called the State of Sensemaking, with a few special guests, to register for it, go here: https://rebelwisdom.co.uk/state-of-sensemaking
Original text for the Science and Psychology of Polarisation film was: "How can we even begin to solve many of society's problems if our conversations keep breaking down? Polarisation has been growing for decades, and supercharged by social media filter bubbles.
This is the first in a series of films from Rebel Wisdom looking at the science and psychology of polarisation.
We speak to Alex Evans, a former government adviser now looking at the roots of division through the Collective Psychology Project: https://www.collectivepsychology.org/
Also to superstar trauma specialists Dr Stephen Porges, Peter Levine, Gina Ross and Steve Haines about how our nervous system is intimately involved in assessing safety and threat, and how that underlies all conflict and polarisation."
Hey everyone, so we're putting out some pieces from before the pandemic that we think are
particularly relevant now as the polarisation and the struggle to make sense of the world has only
increased in the time since we made them. If you're a long time fan you've maybe already seen these
but maybe they're worth watching again. This film was called The Science and Psychology of
Polarisation but we're putting it out now called The Science and Psychology of Difficult Conversations.
If you go to our website we've arranged all of our films into categories
and there's one for this category. Also on our website you can add your email address
and you'll get our newsletter which is a deep dive we put out every two weeks
and we also give access to extra films for mailing list subscribers. So hope you enjoy the film.
Hey guys, this is the first of a series of films about The Science and Psychology of Polarisation
and it's something that we've been working on for quite a while. I got some really interesting
interviews with Peter Levine, Stephen Porges and with Alex Evans and it's kind of a topic that
we've been talking about for quite a while, generative dialogue conversation. This is kind
of delving a little bit more deeply into that as a subject. In this introduction we're going to try
and sort of tie together the whole series, give a sort of briefing of why we think all these pieces
fit together and also to say what's really interesting and there seem to be a lot of
people who are zeroing in on this kind of area at the moment. What's exciting for me about this is
that this is something we've been talking about since the beginning of the channel and part of
the reason that the Intellectual Dark Web was so interesting. People getting together from
different sides of the political spectrum or with different cultural values sitting to have a long
form conversation over maybe two or three hours and the promise of that was that this was a way
to really overcome polarisation and to find a new synthesis. One level is to be able to sit down
with someone and have the conversation without attacking each other, let's say, to put it in
an extreme. The other level is for that conversation to go to some new territory and I think that for
me is the really interesting thing and so this is one missing piece. It's almost like the foundations.
Yes, exactly. You mentioned psychological safety. There's that and there's also a lot of other
elements that come into it and I think this is exciting because this is one of those absolutely
key elements without which I don't think, without understanding the biology and the psychology of
these conversations, I don't think they can be done. It's not like a nice to have. I think it's
absolutely essential. I'm just going to play a quick clip from Stephen Porges that I wasn't
going to play until a bit later but I'm going to play it now because I think it fits this perfectly
because he talks about better living through neurobiology. As we understand the neurobiology
of what it is to be a human being, when that becomes our guide then culture and life becomes
better. I put on one of my slides a couple of days ago a kind of modification of what DuPont,
the chemical company used to say, used to advertise better living through chemistry. That was their
slogan and what I was saying was maybe better living through understanding neurobiology.
I think it's also worth noting this isn't just about having difficult kind of political or
cultural conversations. This is about life. This is about how do we have conversations with each
other, how do we have conversations with our partners. There's that classic phrase of if you
think you're enlightened, go and spend a weekend with your parents. It's about how we stay in our
centeredness and have conversations in general. As we've talked about, this kind of understanding
I think is the foundation but what's really important is building from that foundation
and then what's the real world impact. That's why it's really exciting to have an interview
with Alex Evans. I'm going to play a short clip from him now. He was a government advisor for
many years. He was involved in a lot of summits around climate change and big government policy
and became quite dispirited because what he realized was all of the work of government
was talking about the externals and it was almost never talking about the internals.
So he went on a bit of a journey around sort of understanding polarization and learning more and
more about psychology and now he's launching something called the Collective Psychology
Project. One of the ideas at the heart of the report that we've just produced is the idea that
the inner and outer crises that we see in the world and inside us are two sides of the same
coin. On the one hand you have this sort of pile of crises out there in the world like climate
breakdown and hyper inequality and mass extinction and so on and then over here you've got this pile
of mental health crises like suicide and self-harm and anxiety and depression and addiction and so
on and so on. What I'm arguing in the report is that at the moment these two sets of crises are
fueling each other. We feel messed up inside partly because we feel like the world is messed
up out there and when we feel messed up inside when we're kind of triggered we act out in ways
that worsen the state of the world. So again it's another example of a feedback loop. Now you look
at mainstream politics as it is today or for that matter the kind of campaigning that you get from
big global NGOs, it only talks about the outer stuff. It's all about issues in the world
out there and it's just silent on the question of the states of mind of the citizens who are voting
or the policy makers who are making the decision. They're just completely separate.
So one of the things I find particularly interesting not just about what Alex was saying
but about this entire topic is that there's lots of different levels to it. So Alex is talking about
government tends to look at the systems level but needs to also look at the individual level and
those two things are as he says two sides of the same coin and then there's the biological level
of understanding where my biology is while I'm doing it. So there's all these different layers
to it and I think what seems to be happening right now is lots of people are coming in from
different angles and hopefully and what's very interesting is what does the synthesis look like
and how do we take that synthesis and use it practically in our day-to-day lives.
So it was really fascinating to see the journey that Alex had been on from a completely different
starting point the starting point of like politics and systems change. When I was chatting with him
he had exactly the same reference points that we're familiar with from our counselling training
polyvagal theory, somatic experiencing, Peter Levine, Stephen Porges, all of this stuff
and they were they're like in a way sort of like superstars in the counselling and
in particular in the trauma world because they were the ones that really understood
how the body stores emotions and how the body metabolises experience and this kind of work is
just I think absolutely crucial to bring into the mainstream, bring into the sort of political and
the conflict world and understanding that especially now and more and more under the
influence of social media and under the influence of kind of ever expanding and ever increasing pace
of life we're all in some sort of low level overwhelm a lot of the time or a lot of us are
so this kind of work becomes essential to navigating those kind of spaces and we were
lucky enough to get an interview with Peter Levine when we were out in America recently.
If you're talking to two people who are in the hyper vigilant state, the sympathetic adrenal
state or the shutdown state even more so, you can't engage with them because you perceive them
either as threat or as mortal threat because your nervous system is stuck in that groove and so
there's no way you can really listen to another person and express yourself so they want to
listen to you. While you're in one of these stuck states you have to be able to come into the social
engagement system. Could you talk about like the physiology of this like what is actually going on
when we're in these conflicts with each other and when because what I also understand is that we
stopped listening to each other at a certain point. The polyvagal theory gives us a very clear
map of exactly how that works and what it looks like. You can see the facial expression when
somebody's in fight or flight they're mobilized in the jaw and the neck is tight. When somebody's in
a state of social engagement the eyes are relaxed and open. This part of the face is
the one that's more active or the one more engaged. So when you're feeling like this
you will not be able to feel like this. So again we read signals from each other's faces, from each
other's postures and if we subconsciously all the time we all do it. We may not be aware that
we're doing it, we're all doing it. And referencing back to something that a lot of the sort of more
avid fans of the channel will be aware of Jordan Greenhalgh and his kind of concept of broadcast
versus digital and discernment. What that does is it puts a huge amount of impact on the individual
which is why individual sort of regulation and our own psychology and our own biology
become so much more important. And you notice how much of a burden is placed on the individual now.
It's not like the broadcast modality where most of your agency is limited to a very narrow band
and you're really relying on the causal structure that you're embedded in to do almost all the work.
In the decentralized collective intelligence for it to actually work almost all of the agency
is actually on the individuals. You have to have really really effective responsible
individuals. And by responsible what I mean is they're able to respond to the environment in
the way that I'm talking about. They are not reacting. So I think one important thing to
add to that is that while it starts with the individual it doesn't stop with the individual.
So you know Jordan Hall talks about this concept of sovereignty and you know what you were just
ascribing kind of coming into our own agency and our own discernment so we can start making sense
of the world but we have to make sense of the world with one another. So we have to find a way
not only to be sovereign in ourselves but to be open and contactful with one another and to figure
out OK how together can we be in a mode where we're starting to make sense of the world better
than one of us could by ourselves. To come back to Alex Evans and the collective psychology project
a lot of his work he did in Israel. He went to live in Israel for a while and just saw
how in Israel in particular everyone is in a state of kind of low level hyper vigilance
at all times on both the Palestinian side and the Israeli side and how that affects politics there
and how it makes things very very difficult because if you're in a hyper vigilant state
it's very difficult not to see to be in a sort of fight or flight response and see the other
as an enemy. It's almost impossible and he then draws parallels with what's been happening in the
in the UK and the US. I'll play another quick clip from his interview. I took a sabbatical
for six months and went to live in Jerusalem with my family for that period and obviously
the political polarisation there is even more extreme and at one level that was incredibly
depressing and I could see the kind of similarities with Brexit or with Trump's America.
I mean obviously it's more extreme in Israel and Palestine but nevertheless I felt like it was on
the same spectrum in some sense but what was hopeful when I was there was finding the work
of a few psychologists people like Gina Ross who are arguing that really to understand
polarisation there you can't divorce it from its mental health context particularly the fact that
continuous traumatic stress which is a bit like post-traumatic stress disorder when it's not
post when it's just an everyday ongoing reality that of course that catalyzes polarisation because
the classic symptoms of continuous traumatic stress are things like anxiety and hypervigilance
and especially othering kind of projecting everyone onto some idealised shadowy other
and when enough individuals display these symptoms of course they start to manifest politically too
and you know of course that the other reality there is that people live in this constant low
level state of threat perception I mean Israelis are constantly at some level perceiving threats
of terrorism or of rocket attacks or even of invasion and then Palestinians are constantly
perceiving the threat of arbitrary arrest or of their house being the next to be demolished or
of just living in kind of conditions of more or less total surveillance so everyone's triggered
all of the time and then you know I mean at another level you look at that and you think
well I can see how this plays out in a kind of conflict zone like this but actually is it
is it overreaching a bit to say that this is also relevant to Brexit or to Trump and of course I'm
not saying that you know most voters in Britain or the States are traumatised in the strict
medical sense but the threat perception absolutely shows up when you look at opinion polling
of why did people vote Trump one of the strongest predictors for that was this sense that
the American way of life is threatened and it was the same with leave voters in the UK
many of whom clear majority of whom agreed like you know Britain increasingly feels like a foreign
country and that makes me feel uncomfortable so there's threat perception on that side and then
of course as soon as you've had the presidential election in 2016 or the Brexit referendum
all the kind of liberal cosmopolitan internationalist type people also wake up
feeling like they're living in a foreign country and that makes them feel very uncomfortable now
you know how it feels right almost and so the threat perception is contagious and this is
the big risk that it becomes a kind of self-amplifying feedback loop and so one of the
questions right at the heart of the collective psychology project is well how would we reverse
the polarity of that feedback loop so instead of you know these kind of mutually reinforcing
you know threat perceptions across the political spectrum we have a kind of mutual reinforcing
process of sort of healing and coming back together to a sense of empathy for each other
and respect for each other's experiences and how we reach the values that we've got and so on
I mean my only concern with that narrative is that it can seem almost condescending because
you're sort of saying and when we talk about these things when we talk about Trump we talk
about Brexit as being only a product of sort of fear it can sound like more of the liberal elite
kind of thinking well we know better than you what why you've done something how do you avoid
that in the narrative around this kind of conversation well I think I mean as I say I
think the issue of threat perception is by no means confined to one side of the political spectrum I
think on the contrary it's something that's sort of cropping up here there and everywhere but I
mean of course you know you can look at for instance membership of the European Union and
make a completely trenchant critique of the EU on very solid rational bases that has nothing to do
with threat perception or fear or anything like that and I would as it happens by a lot of that
critique myself there's much about the EU that needs reforming but I think when you look at the
state of our political debate and how much kind of triggering there is and how much just heat
and you know projection there is in the discourse there's something deeper going on here as well
yeah he mentions Gina Ross who's an expert in this field and has been working particularly
with conflict for a long time who I caught up with the other day so when you think about it
people are approaching the resolution of conflict in a very rational reasonable manner but where
is the attention to the emotional foundation and these are the aspects that are not being
addressed when people are trying to come up with very rational intelligent cogent
solutions for problems but the emotions don't care about that if I don't feel safe I don't care how
reasonable your solution seems to be that's not going to affect me so what I then saw that was
very very important was to really marry the two fields together so I developed a protocol actually
that combines the two on an ongoing basis the whole time so one of the key words for me is
curiosity and it's a it's a really interesting word because it means when when we're curious
we accept the idea that we don't know the answer but there's a there's a there's a kind of natural
ability to be open when we're curious and one of the light bulb moments on a recent course that
was actually a breathwork course where they were talking about polyvagal theory and somatic
experiencing was where they started using that word curious and were saying that it's impossible
to be curious and defensive at the same time which is a really important thing and that I think fits
into the nature of like any kind of generative conversation is about curiosity you can't be
curious and traumatized at the same time the physiology that doesn't allow them to both be
there so if you can get the client enlist the client in being curious about their sensations
and and and and images and feelings then you've gotten halfway there I think there's a useful link
from the world of kind of meditation research here as well there's a there's a woman called
Shauna Shapiro who's done a lot of studies on meditation she talks about its three elements
its attitude attention and intention I think it applies very closely to staying curious you know
it's it's very easy to be knocked off into thinking I know or I disagree with that I'm just
waiting for this person to shut up so I can jump in and put my point across often in meditation
is called a kind of a soft alertness and that's a that's a skill to cultivate because it doesn't
just come naturally to any of us to any human being and you know you have to kind of literally
engage your prefrontal cortex so that you can stay present and stay with it so it's a it's kind
of a for me it's kind of a dance between psychology and biology that's that's a constant process and
you get better and better at it the more you practice it the other interview we've got with
one of the pioneers in this field is with Stephen Porges and Stephen Porges came up with polyvagal
theory independently of Peter Levine but when Peter Levine and Stephen Porges met they immediately
connected because polyvagal theory validated and explained what Peter Levine was seeing in his
practice so Peter Levine was having these understandings and realizations about how
emotion and trauma was stored in the body and realizing that a lot of the time the body
was intimately connected with what we normally consider psychology and polyvagal theory basically
grounded that in neurobiology and it works primarily on the vagus nerve the vagus nerve is
the longest nerve in the body it comes from the brain and goes to all of the major organs
it also goes to the face and what polyvagal theory explains is firstly how we're constantly
getting information from our um from our gut and from our heart and our heart is actually connected
to our face and we're also then connected to other people through that so we're constantly
regulating our nervous system in relation to other people and in relation to what's going on inside
polyvagal theory has several features and we're going to go through a few of them
the important the first important one is that it gives us a way of organizing our own bodily
reactions and it really emphasizes that the neural which really means the brain regulation of the
autonomic nervous system the neural system that regulates the the organs within our body
followed an evolutionary tradition trajectory so we had a very primitive autonomic system
that really was about maintaining metabolic resources so it was very much oriented in
if there wasn't enough oxygen enough food it just kind of shut us down then with evolution from
these ancient vertebrates that had only one a very ancient old vagal circuit and that old vagal
circuit was unmyelinated and myelination is really the fatty substance that coats a nerve
and if it's myelinated it can actually convey these signals more efficiently and more specifically
but in the very ancient vertebrates they only had this older dorsal vagal system
but we still have it it's the primary system that still goes to our gut and the major defense
response that the autonomic nervous system for these ancient vertebrates was basically shutting
down immobilizing death feigning through evolution a sympathetic nervous system came on board and
that one was a spinal sympathetics that came on with the bony fish and you can see them moving
and even stopping so now you have an autonomic balance of mobilization through the sympathetic
nervous system and immobilization that old vagus and then what you have with mammals and this is
the interesting part of polyvagal theory is something strange and something miraculous that
occurs with the transition from the ancient extinct reptiles to mammals and that is you have
a newer vagal circuit that's myelinated that helps calm or coordinate these the older vagal circuit
to support homeostasis and to enable sympathetics to work without getting you into fight or flight
but the other miraculous part is that the area of the brain that regulates that pathway of the vagus
is not the same that regulates the old vagus going to the gut it's linked to the nerves in the area
of the brainstem is linked to the part that regulates the nerves that regulate your face
the muscles of your face and head it regulates your social engagement system your ingestive
system the way you touch and connect with the world so it's really this kind of remarkable
transition where our heart became connected in a normal way to the the nerves that regulate
our voice the intonation of our voice our facial expressions and even our ability to extract
information by listening so there are muscles in our middle ear our facial expressivity and
intonation of a voice so now we project our our heart in our voice and people know that
intuitively they respond that way we project our feelings in our face so these become the
important parts of how we make connections with others but the bi-directionality so that we're
in a sense of a person is in a physiological destabilized way their voice is very different
and we often if we're good therapists or good human beings or good parents or good teachers
we know that and we calm them and how do we calm them it's not the words that are powerful
it's how we use the words it's the intonation of our voice so polyvagal theory emphasizes these
evolutionary stages but also emphasizes that under challenge under demands that could be illness or
threat our autonomic nervous system shifts state it moves from this social engagement safe state
where we are connected with others it moves to defensive states and how we're also then
transmitting our own internal state through our voice and through our face to other people and
how important that is for what they call co-regulation so regulating ourselves in relation
to other people and how does this theory or theoretical framework apply to say conflict
and mediation well it defines conflict doesn't it in terms of that conflict so people feel that
there is a threat or their bodies feel there's a threat to have remediation you have to provide
sufficient cues of safety so that you now get into a dialogue now a dialogue by nature of being the
word implies some reciprocity in the interaction and when you do rest when you have reciprocity
in the action you have a listening component as well as expressive component so you have a
witnessing component so it part of i think the major issue of conflict is that people don't
listen to each other so they're not witnessing and people don't listen to you when you try to
talk express something or let's say you're even a child and you're not being listened to what
happens to your physiological state you become very uncomfortable you become frustrated and as
you get older with those same feelings you become angry and belligerent and so we have to understand
that being listened to being witnessed not necessarily being agreed with but being witnessed
and appreciated for what you're saying is really part of our birthright it's something that we
scream to to have and polarization is occurs when people aren't listened to they're not witnessed
and they feel marginalized just to join that together with the polyvagal and kind of real or
genuine conversation is because what polyvagal theory shows is that either we're in an open
frame of mind we're in what they call the ventral vagal circuit where we're we're able to connect
with others we're able to take in new information we're able to be curious or we're in a defensive
frame of mind and when we're in a defensive frame of mind we're we're pretty much unavailable
and that shift can happen quite quickly that shift can happen very quickly even in a conversation where
and developing that awareness of when we're slipping into a defensive frame of mind and when
we're slipping into and when we're more open and then hacking that neurology or hacking that
physiology is going to be an important or essential thing for us to learn to have these conversations
and i think a key point here is that these are skills and let's say a way of being that we have
to practice and cultivate rather than something that we can decide on the intellectual level okay
i'm going to drop into the having that next time i have a conversation with with my partner or
someone i disagree with on facebook i'm going to just drop into this no that's that's not how it
works we need to really cultivate these skills and i think someone who's been doing that extensively
and with with success is jamie wheel who we've put out a few interviews with and had one quite
recently on the channel as well and i think it's very interesting to hear him talk about what
actually happens when you're getting people into groups and getting people into flow what are some
of the things some of the practical techniques we can use to actually uh you know practice these
skills because we're in a culture at the moment where the conversation just keeps seeming to break
down again and again and again and this kind of understanding like the neurophysiology of
coherence or the neurophysiology of connection seems really vital in that do you what's your
take on that yeah i mean i would almost um i mean short answer is yes because there's no there's no
opportunity for tribal primates to be in coherence without that also having a you know showing up in
the kind of stack of our bodies and brains for sure so for what we want is the ability to have
a nice conversation together the ability for us to have that nice conversation sits on the
foundation right of bodies and brains and hearts and minds in attunement and whether that's simple
things like mirror neurons or it's more complicated things like overall neurophysic neurophysiological
resonance um that is for sure um another lever for us to play with so you know the the business
school isare in spain um that we i wrote about in the stealing fire the idea that they took
a strategic business problem and had a bunch of mba students try and solve it together you know
with one-way mirrors and biometrics tracking them on all this kind of stuff and they figured
out who are the emergent leaders in this group and and they backed out statistically you know
how much people talked how loudly people talked the words they used even what they actually had
to say about solving the problem none of that stuff was statistically as significant as the
fact that that those leaders those emergent leaders could regulate their own nervous systems
and do it in a way that entrained other people into their states so it's a little bit like that
old story of you know galileo entering the watchmaker's shop and seeing you know all the
all the clocks on the wall swinging in time with the one with the longest pendulum
so that idea of the longest pendulum entrains all the others into that field that to me has
been my inquiry really on the sort of biohacking spaces what's the longest pendulums in our bodies
if we had to pick i mean there's a gajillion things we can map track measure from brain waves
to heart rate to heart rate variability to neurochemistry to posture to respiration to
affect you know all sorts but what are the one or two or three that if you get those right the entire
rest of our bodies and brains cascades into coherence and then that's a strong signal that's
now that's lengthened our pendulum and now we are far more likely to bring others into that coherent
state and so before we get to kind of what you know you might call communitas or like a highly
coherent group presencing something greater than the sum of the parts if you find yourself
in an attempt to have a coherent conversation meaning we're trying to do something that
none of us know what's going to come of this but if we play it right something better than any one
of us separately could have thought of and let's say that's the kind of a version of the game we're
playing and things start to go sideways right somebody gets hijacked somebody starts engaging
an older less functional pattern you feel triggered you want to react you know that's
that right there the first moment is you know this this is man's search for meaning right it's
the it's the stimulus and the response and the space between what's happening and my reaction
to it therein lies freedom and redemption so a couple of things and this is you know
grainy wisdom 101 which is if you're about to get angry or say something off the cuff
take a deep breath and actually take several deep breaths and specifically engage in you know what
free divers call vagal tone breathing which is just the idea of x like a 10 second exhale with
a two second hold so exhale fully empty your lungs once your lungs are completely empty hold them for
two seconds and then just fill your lungs and you can do that at a table you don't need to announce
it you can just actually use that and just take five of those and you will match and in fact if
you do it a friend of ours um as a neuroscientist at Stanford his name's Andrew Huberman and he's
done fascinating research where if you combine eye gaze so if you kind of go soft focus meaning that
you're focusing your eyes to the outside of your frame and you do that vagal nerve breathing so
the super slow exhales a whole with inhale and you do it through your nose you completely
draw your physiological threat response you just chill the **** out super fast and so that would
be the simplest and people might think you've just kind of spaced out or you're not there but
yeah if you can just go soft soft eye focus so you're not laser focused and you're not focused
on something immediately in front of you and you do nitrogen basically nasal exhales um then that
will really calm you down further the next would be and part of the reason for the nose breathing
the Karolinska Institute in Sweden has done some fascinating research on nitric oxide and that
correlates with some research at Harvard that basically said nitric oxide is a neurotransmitter
and it's a gaseous molecule and it takes stress response stuff out of our brain it shunts it all
the way and it brings in feelings of you know bliss even call it the bliss molecule right so
basically anything you can do in your body to increase nitric oxide is usually a good thing
for stress response and resilience right so that was the Harvard research then the Karolinska
Institute has found that nasal breathing increases it three to five times and that if you really want
to get freaky vibrating your nasal cavity as you breathe out through your nose so something like
that or if you were playing a didgeridoo or playing a clarinet or a trombone that actually
increases nitric oxide production 15 times so if you slam all these together you're like okay
i'm going to breathe i'm going to exhale slowly through my nose with visual focus to the periphery
and i might depending on my social situation at my comfort level even hum as i do it that is
actually going to calm me down and give me a reset so that's a true straight up kind of biohack i
don't need to think anything to do it just do it and it will have some positive effect the next is
what's the bridge between neurophysiology and psychology and then even higher level judo would
be i'm not trying to fix it change it shape it at all i'm simply going to notice it and name it
and with a little bit of practice i can speak that truth into the shared conversation and quite often
you'll find a you'll find it the whole thing can drop to the level where oh me too or oh thank you
for saying that and then we're back to that level of resonance and coherence not from follow me i'm
super stoked this is all amazing and i'm going to be this bright light it's more like actually
let's actually orient around what is happening right now now what are the truths we can explore
if we can stay in this place together without judgment without naming the emotion without then
creating the narrative without enacting triggered drama responses around it and that actually is
arguably an even more magic place for us to get together to forge coherence which is
wherever the hell we actually are versus some effort to escape it fix it mend it transcend it
my sense i think is that this is still quite cutting edge maybe marginal but it's definitely
the conversation is definitely moving in that direction and that's where i'm really interested
personally that's where i'm always interested like where is the mainstream conversation and
where is something that's just on the fringe of it but it looks very promising psychedelics for
example for the last six or seven years i've been looking at journalistically and thinking okay that
it will shift there will be mainstream interest in this and it has i mean we're now in what we
call kind of the new psychedelic renaissance there's definitely mainstream interest and i
think mainstream interest in the site the sort of collective psychology and therefore the kind
of neurobiology of all of this stuff is coming i mean this sort of so it's interesting to look at
what what has kept this out of the mainstream conversation for so long i think there's a few
different factors i think a lot of it is based in this kind of cartesian dualism descartes classic
sort of split in the 16th 17th century of splitting mind and matter and that's had a huge
impact ever since of seeing all of these things as separate but there's a there's a new holism
and there's a new kind of understanding of how these things fit together how the body is in
intrinsically involved in in the mind for example which is what all of this work is is bringing back
and then also then psychology being intimately involved in in the in the political world and in
any kind of policy changes yeah i think that that for me is one of the big things is that
that cartesian dualism and the way it plays out in culture and the way that
just through our education through even our language we are much more comfortable with
what we know than what we don't know and much more comfortable being in this kind of disembodied
intellectual space often than in the more liminal flowing let's say chaotic space um
ian mcgill christ is got a really great model of this for anyone who's interested we've got a few
interviews in the channel with him you know he's done great work around looking at the left brain
and the right brain which is a lot more complex than just left brain logical and right brain kind
of creative as people used to think but ironically there is actually some truth in that as well and
so he argues in part that we're in a very left brain dominant society so it's very much the left
brain is focused in part on what we know what we know we know whereas the right brain is focused
in part on what we don't know and so that you know we've talked quite a few times on the channel
around having conversations that are more liminal so that means that they're more in a space of not
knowing and again that concept of curiosity comes up you know curiosity inherent in the idea of
curiosity is i don't know because if you knew you wouldn't be curious and so there is a biologic
again a biological aspect to it there's a cognitive aspect to it and there's a cultural aspect to it
and there is a shift happening in that and i think all these speakers are part of that shift so yeah
on that subject of how this has been sort of kind of not included in the mainstream perspective for
so long i spoke to a guy called steve haynes who i've experienced i've done a couple of his courses
really really interesting body worker who knows this stuff really inside out our ability to feel
is fundamental to how our mind works so cognition memory and emotion are rooted in a readout of our
physiological state and i'm offering here through the most of this interview is that our physiological
state it's primarily am i safe and if i'm not safe i go fight or flight or freeze so if that's
happening my feelings that inform my mental state of cognition my memory and my emotional state
will be colored by the fact i've got this danger physiology running inside me so to embrace that
means embracing the messiness of what was historically hysterical emotional states in
the body that weren't our dr spock fantasy of a rational human being who would analyze and
analyze and work out what we're really doing is sort of feeling and attaching to things that feel
right so an idea is valid because it's elegant and somehow it tastes right or it smells right or
my body can ease into that state because those numbers fit together in an elegant way
so feeling is the root of rationality rather than rationality mind and pure thought being this
separate sort of special entity that was the purview of a psychiatrist it's a much messier
embodied place and feelings are central to the whole process of consciousness yeah and it's
really interesting and exciting that quite a few of the people from very different backgrounds
have the sense that things are moving in this direction and it might be an idea whose time has
come but what we're not seeing is that synthesis of recognizing that you know our mental health our
state of mind matter for the state of the world and vice versa but i think that's partly because
this isn't an idea that's really surfaced much until recently and now it feels like a lot of
people are converging onto this territory i mean i don't feel at all like the collective psychology
project's the only player in this space i think a ton of people are sort of converging on this
space which gives me a lot of hope it feels like this is something that's kind of ripe that's ready
to you know mature and take root in the world and i think therefore like you know i don't see this as
like expecting massive pushback from people who work in politics on this stuff i think that it's
just a question of we have to figure out how to start seeding it so it can take root and sprout
we are a connected species and if we don't appreciate that we are in a sense injuring
the species and we have to take on the responsibility the bottom line is i think
there are going to be more and more people having this understanding because now you have with
polyvagal theory and neurobiology that supports the philosophy philosophical and for many people
even a spiritual religious view so you have a convergence of different orientations all ending
up in the same point this is really embryonic work we have no idea what's actually going to fly what
are going to be the interventions that can really have a transformational impact and go to scale i
think the larger question is how do we create systems and platforms for lots of little experiments
many of them very small scale or very local and for making sure we share the learning from those
experiments among a kind of involving community of people who feel like they are practitioners
of collective psychology so that when we fail we do it quickly and we make sure that as many people
as possible have access to the lessons from that failure so hopefully this film has kind of tied
the topic together made sense of it and also made you want to go and watch the other films
the whole films so we're going to release them over the next couple of weeks if you want to get
early access to see them all now you can become a supporter and they're in the members area of the
website so subscribe also sign up for notifications just click the bell button below if you want to
make sure that you get notified when those go online and also we're going to be running events
in london over the autumn yeah we're going to be doing something a little bit different this autumn
so we're going to have a series of events where we're really trialing and growing let's say a
protocol of how do we actually get into these conversations and how do we do it sustainably
in a way that could be replicated potentially in different cities so we're it's quite exciting you
know so we're going to be announcing that soon it's going to be quite a few they're going to
be focused on different practices techniques and we're hoping to build a core group of people who
really want to kind of go to the edge i guess and then kind of level up in a new way our ability
to make sense of the world is breaking down we're making more and more consequential choices with
worse and worse sense making to inform those choices which is kind of running increasingly fast
through the woods increasingly blind over the last two years rebel wisdom has interviewed some of the
now we've brought them together for an eight-week online course sense making 101
with daniel schmachtenberger diane musho hamilton john vivecki doshin roshi and more
improve your sense making develop your sovereignty and join a wider community looking to do the same